Press Alt + R to read the document text or Alt + P to download or print.
This document contains no pages.
2017 Feb 07 - CC PACKET AGENDA
- EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL
COUNCIL CHAMBERS - 350 Main Street
The City Council, with certain statutory exceptions, can only take action upon properly posted and listed
agenda items. Any writings or documents given to a majority of the City Council regarding any matter on
this agenda that the City received after issuing the agenda packet are available for public inspection in
the City Clerk's office during normal business hours. Such Documents may also be posted on the City's
website at www.elsegundo.org and additional copies will be available at the City Council meeting.
Unless otherwise noted in the Agenda, the Public can only comment on City-related business that is
within the jurisdiction of the City Council and/or items listed on the Agenda during the Public
Communications portions of the Meeting. Additionally, the Public can comment on any Public Hearing
item on the Agenda during the Public Hearing portion of such item. The time limit for comments is five (5)
minutes per person.
Before speaking to the City Council, please come to the podium and state: Your name and residence
and the organization you represent, if desired. Please respect the time limits.
Members of the Public may place items on the Agenda by submitting a Written Request to the City Clerk
or City Manager's Office at least six days prior to the City Council Meeting (by 2:00 p.m. the prior
Tuesday). The request must include a brief general description of the business to be transacted or
discussed at the meeting. Playing of video tapes or use of visual aids may be permitted during meetings if
they are submitted to the City Clerk two (2) working days prior to the meeting and they do not exceed five
(5) minutes in length.
In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to
participate in this meeting, please contact City Clerk, 524-2305. Notification 48 hours prior to the
meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this
meeting.
MEETING OF THE EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 7, 2017 — 5:00 PM
5:00 P.M. SESSION
CALL TO ORDER
ROLL CALL
PUBLIC COMMUNICATION — (Related to Citv Business Only — 5 minute limit per
person, 30 minute limit total) Individuals who have received value of$50 or more to communicate
to the City Council on behalf of another, and employees speaking on behalf of their employer, must so
identify themselves prior to addressing the City Council. Failure to do so shall be a misdemeanor and
punishable by a fine of$250.
1
1
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS:
CLOSED SESSION:
The City Council may move into a closed session pursuant to applicable law, including
the Brown Act (Government Code Section §54960, et seq.) for the purposes of
conferring with the City's Real Property Negotiator; and/or conferring with the City
Attorney on potential and/or existing litigation; and/or discussing matters covered under
Government Code Section §54957 (Personnel); and/or conferring with the City's Labor
Negotiators; as follows:
CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL — EXISTING LITIGATION (Gov't Code
§54956.9(d)(1): -0- matters
CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL — ANTICIPATED LITIGATION
Significant exposure to litigation pursuant to Government Code §54956.9(d)(2): -0-
matters.
Initiation of litigation pursuant to Government Code §54956.9 (d)(4): -1- matters.
DISCUSSION OF PERSONNEL MATTERS (Gov't Code §54957): -2- matters
1. Public Employee Performance Evaluation
Title: City Manager
2. Public Employee Performance Evaluation
Title: City Attorney
APPOINTMENT OF PUBLIC EMPLOYEE (Gov't. Code § 54957): -0- matter
PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT (Gov't Code § 54957) -0- matter
2
2
CONFERENCE WITH CITY'S LABOR NEGOTIATOR (Gov't Code §54957.6): -8-
matters
1. Employee Organizations: Police Management Association; Police Officers
Association; Police Support Services Employees Association; Fire Fighters
Association; Supervisory, Professional Employees Association; City Employee
Association and Executive and Management/Confidential Employees.
Agency Designated Representative: Steve Filarsky and City Manager, Greg
Carpenter
CONFERENCE WITH REAL PROPERTY NEGOTIATOR (Gov't Code §54956.8): -0-
matters
3
3
AGENDA
u EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL
COUNCIL CHAMBERS - 350 Main Street
The City Council, with certain statutory exceptions, can only take action upon properly posted and listed
agenda items. Any writings or documents given to a majority of the City Council regarding any matter on
this agenda that the City received after issuing the agenda packet, are available for public inspection in
the City Clerk's office during normal business hours. Such Documents may also be posted on the City's
website at www.elsegundo.org and additional copies will be available at the City Council meeting.
Unless otherwise noted in the Agenda, the Public can only comment on City-related business that is
within the jurisdiction of the City Council and/or items listed on the Agenda during the Public
Communications portions of the Meeting. Additionally, the Public can comment on any Public Hearing
item on the Agenda during the Public Hearing portion of such item. The time limit for comments is five (5)
minutes per person.
Before speaking to the City Council, please come to the podium and state: Your name and residence
and the organization you represent, if desired. Please respect the time limits.
Members of the Public may place items on the Agenda by submitting a Written Request to the City Clerk
or City Manager's Office at least six days prior to the City Council Meeting (by 2:00 p.m. the prior
Tuesday). The request must include a brief general description of the business to be transacted or
discussed at the meeting. Playing of video tapes or use of visual aids may be permitted during meetings if
they are submitted to the City Clerk two (2)working days prior to the meeting and they do not exceed five
(5) minutes in length.
In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to
participate in this meeting, please contact City Clerk, 524-2305. Notification 48 hours prior to the
meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this
meeting.
REGULAR MEETING OF THE EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 7, 2017 - 7:00 P.M.
7:00 P.M. SESSION
CALL TO ORDER
INVOCATION — Pastor George Lopez, The Bridge
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE — Council Member Dugan
4
4
PRESENTATIONS
a) Presentation — Recognition of Centennial Ball Sponsors
b) Presentation —The 2016 Holiday Parade Winners
c) Proclamation — School Choice Week, January 22-28, 2017
d) Presentation — Treasury Department's Quarterly Investment Portfolio Report
ROLL CALL
PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS — (Related to Citv Business Onlv — 5 minute limit per
person, 30 minute limit total) Individuals who have received value of$50 or more to communicate
to the City Council on behalf of another, and employees speaking on behalf of their employer, must so
identify themselves prior to addressing the City Council. Failure to do so shall be a misdemeanor and
punishable by a fine of$250. While all comments are welcome, the Brown Act does not allow Council to
take action on any item not on the agenda. The Council will respond to comments after Public
Communications is closed.
CITY COUNCIL COMMENTS — (Related .to Public Communications)
A. PROCEDURAL MOTIONS
Consideration of a motion to read all ordinances and resolutions on the
Agenda by title only.
Recommendation — Approval.
B. SPECIAL ORDERS OF BUSINESS (PUBLIC HEARING)
1. Consideration and possible action regarding approval of Environmental
Assessment No. EA-1064 and Zone Text Amendment No. ZTA 14-01 to
amend the development standards regarding two-story homes and second
story additions in the City's R-1, single-family residential zone; create new
definitions and amend certain existing definitions contained in the El
Segundo Municipal Code; and amend the parking requirements for single-
family residences.
(Fiscal Impact: None with this action.)
5
5
The proposed project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the
California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to 14 California
Code Regulations § 15301 as a Class 1 (existing facilities), § 15303 as a
Class 3 (new construction or conversion of small structures), and § 15304
as a Class 4 (minor alteration to land) categorical exemptions.
Recommendation — 1) Conduct a public hearing; 2) Take testimony and other
evidence as presented; 3) Introduce an Ordinance (Zone Text Amendment No.
ZTA 14-01) amending the development standards regarding two-story homes
and second story additions in the City's R-1, single-family residential zone,
creating new definitions and amending certain existing definitions contained in
the El Segundo Municipal Code, and amending the parking requirements for
single-family residences; 4) Schedule second reading and adoption of the
Ordinance for February 21, 2017; and/or, 5) Alternatively, discuss and take other
possible action related to this item.
2. Consideration and possible action regarding Environmental Assessment
No. EA-1158 and Precise Plan Amendment No. PPA 16-01 regarding the
proposed conversion of an existing single lane restaurant drive-thru to a
double lane drive-thru at 101 South Sepulveda Boulevard in the Heavy
Industrial (M-2) Zone. Applicant: McDonald's Corporation. The proposed
project is exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental
Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to 14 California Code of Regulations §15301
which identifies the project as a Class 1 exemption (Existing Facilities) and
§ 15304 as a Class 4 categorical exemption (Minor Alterations to Land).
(Fiscal Impact: N/A)
Recommendation — 1) Open public hearing and take testimony; 2) Close public
hearing and discuss item; 3) Adopt Resolution No. approving
Environmental Assessment No. 1158 and Precise Plan Amendment No. PPA 16-
01; and/or 4) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this
item.
C. UNFINISHED BUSINESS
3. Consideration and possible action to review and approve the three-year
strategic plan (FY 2016-17 through FY 2018-19).
(Fiscal Impact: $0)
Recommendation — 1) City Council review and approve the three-year Strategic
Plan (FY 2016-17 through FY 2018-19); and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss and
take other possible action related to this item.
6
6
4. Consideration and possible action to determine how to proceed with
Paolucci Selling & Martin Communications Art ("PSM") and the City's
business marketing program in light of the delayed decision from the Fair
Political Practices Commission ("FPPC") regarding whether the City can
continue to contract with PSM.
(Fiscal Impact: To be Determined)
Recommendation — 1) Wait for the FPPC to issue an opinion re PSM before
making a decision as to whether to amend its contract; or, 2) Proceed with a
process to select a new business marketing consultant and potentially terminate
PSM's contract; and/or, 3) Authorize the City Manager in amount not to exceed
$25,000 to procure business marketing services until a decision has been made
regarding PSM or until a new business marketing consultant is under contract;
and/or, 4) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this
item.
5. Consideration and possible regarding introduction and first reading of an
Ordinance amending Title 8 of the El Segundo Municipal Code to regulate
parking of oversized vehicles, recreational vehicles, and trailers; establish
a registration/permit process; and prohibit the placement of electrical
cords, cables and similar items between such vehicles and nearby
property.
(Fiscal Impact: Not to exceed $4,000.00)
Recommendation — 1) Conduct a public hearing; 2) Take public testimony and
other evidence as presented; 3) Introduce the proposed Ordinance amending the
El Segundo Municipal Code Title 8; 4) Provide direction to City staff regarding
possible cost-recovery fees for one-time vehicle registration, permits and/or
annual handicapped permits issued under the ordinance; and/or, 5) Alternatively,
discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
D. REPORTS OF COMMITTEES, COMMISSIONS AND BOARDS
6. Consideration and possible action to receive and file the El Segundo
Senior Housing Board Corporation (Park Vista) proposed annual budget for
2017.
(Fiscal Impact: None to the General Fund)
Recommendation — 1) Approve the 2017 Park Vista Annual Budget; and/or, 2)
Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
7. Consideration and possible action to announce the appointments to the
Arts and Culture Advisory Committee.
(Fiscal Impact: None)
Recommendation — 1) Announce the appointees to the Arts and Culture Advisory
Committee; and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action
related to this item.
7
7
E. CONSENT AGENDA
All items listed are to be adopted by one motion without discussion and passed unanimously. If a call for
discussion of an item is made, the item(s) will be considered individually under the next heading of
business.
8. Warrant Numbers 3014763 through 3015090 on Register No. 8 the total
amount of $1,666,676.10 and Wire Transfers from 01/09/17 through 01/29/17
in the total amount of $3,159,843.65.
Recommendation — Approve Warrant Demand Register and authorize staff to
release. Ratify Payroll and Employee Benefit checks; checks released early due
to contracts or agreement; emergency disbursements and/or adjustments; and
wire transfers.
9. Special Meeting (Strategic Planning Workshop 3) Minutes of November 7,
2016.
Recommendation —Approval
10.Consideration and possible action to award a standard Public Works
Contract to Ayus and Co., Inc. for the Fire Station 1 Men's Bathroom
Improvements, Project No. PW 17-08.
(Fiscal Impact: $57,805)
Recommendation — 1) Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public
Works Contract in a form approved by the City Attorney with Ayus and Co., Inc.
in the amount of $52,550.00, and authorize an additional $5,255.00 for
construction related contingencies; 2) Authorize to transfer $40,000 from account
#301-400-8208-8706 (Seismic Early Warning System) to account #301-400-
8201-8707 (Fire Department Upgrades); and/or, 3) Alternatively, discuss and
take other possible action related to this item.
11.Consideration and possible action to award a standard Public Works
Contract to Ayus and Co., Inc. for the Fire Station 1 Kitchen Improvements,
Project No. PW 17-06.
(Fiscal Impact: $138,270.00)
Recommendation — 1) Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public
Works Contract in a form approved by the City Attorney with Ayus and Co., Inc.
in the amount of $125,700.00 and authorize an additional $12,570.00 for
construction related contingencies; and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss and take
other possible action related to this item.
8
8
12.Consideration and possible action to accept as complete the Water Main
Improvement Project on Center St., Walnut Ave. and Maple Ave., Project
No. PW16-02.
(Fiscal Impact: $1,527,796.80)
Recommendation — 1) Accept the Water Main Improvement Project work for
Project No.16-02 as complete; 2) Authorize the City Clerk to file Notice of
Completion in the County Recorder's office; and/or, 3) Alternatively, discuss and
take other possible action related to this item.
13.Consideration and possible action to 1) award a standard Public Works
Contract to Stephen Doreck Equipment Rentals, Inc. for the Water Main
Improvement on Mariposa Avenue, Project No. PW17-03; and, 2) award a
standard Public Works Professional Services Agreement to AKM
Consulting Engineers for construction inspection services.
(Fiscal Impact: $750,386.13)
Recommendation — 1) Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public
Works Contract, in a form approved by the City Attorney, with Stephen Doreck
Equipment Rentals, Inc., in the amount of $579,657.50 and approve an additional
$86,948.63 for construction-related contingencies; 2) Authorize the City Manager
to execute a standard Public Works Professional Services Agreement in a form
as approved by the City Attorney with AKM Consulting Engineers in the amount
of $73,780 for construction inspection and geotechnical (compaction) oversight
and testing, and approve an additional $10,000 for related contingencies; and/or
3) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
14.Consideration and possible action to approve energy efficiency products
from Southern California Edison's Direct Install Program and installation of
energy efficient replacement equipment at the Library and Water Plant and
authorize the City Manager to execute the Southern California Edison
Direct Install Program Agreement.
(Fiscal Impact: $)
Recommendation — 1) Approve the installation of energy efficiency products from
Southern California Edison's Direct Install Program at the Library and Water
Plant, and authorize the City Manager to sign the Direct Install Program Partner
Authorization Forms; and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible
action related to this item.
9
9
15.Consideration and possible action regarding a request for two new ABC
Licenses (Type 21 for the sale of beer, wine and distilled spirits for off-site
consumption and Type 86 for instructional tasting) within the existing Cost
Plus World Market located at Plaza El Segundo at 720 South Sepulveda
Boulevard in the Commercial Center (C-4) Zone. EA No. 1170 and AUP No.
16-13. Applicant: Cost Plus World Market c/o Jane Baughman.
(Fiscal Impact: N/A)
Recommendation — 1) Receive and file this report without objecting to the
issuance of the alcohol licenses; and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss and take other
possible action related to this item.
16.Consideration and possible action regarding authorization for the Police
Department to purchase thirty-five (35) sets of Level III+ rifle body-armor
protective plates with related carriers using Asset Forfeiture Funds.
(Fiscal Impact: $37,075)
Recommendation — 1) Authorize the Police Department to purchase thirty-five
(35) sets of Level III+ rifle body armor protective plates with related carriers from
Galls; and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to
this item.
17.Consideration and possible action regarding the expansion of alcohol
service to include instructional tasting of beer, wine and distilled spirits
(Type 86 ABC License) at a :grocery store at 500 North Sepulveda
Boulevard, EA No. 1169, AUP No. 16-12. The project is categorically exempt
from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA)
pursuant to 14 California Code of Regulations § 15301 as a Class 1
categorical exemption (Existing Facilities). Applicant: Ralphs Grocery
Company.
(Fiscal Impact: N/A)
Recommendation — 1) Receive and file this report for the instructional tasting of
beer, wine and distilled spirits at an existing grocery store at 500 North
Sepulveda Boulevard; and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible
action related to this item.
18.Consideration and possible action regarding 1) Approval of Examination
Plan for Records Technician.
(Fiscal Impact: N/A)
Recommendation — 1) Approval of Examination Plan for Records Technician;
and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this
item.
10
10
19.Consideration and possible action regarding a request for the expansion of
alcohol service (Type 47 ABC License) for a new Kona Grill restaurant
located at "The Atrium at Continental Park," at 2321 East Rosecrans
Avenue, Suite 1225. Applicant: Kona Grill Inc.)
(Fiscal Impact: N/A)
Recommendation — 1) Receive and file this report without objecting to the
issuance of an alcohol license for the on-site sale of beer, wine and distilled
spirits for on-site consumption at a new restaurant 2321 East Rosecrans Avenue,
Suite 1225; and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action
related to this item.
20.Consideration and possible action to award a standard Public Works
Contract to Cinbad Industry Inc., in a form approved by the City Attorney,
for construction of the Police Department Kitchen Remodel, Project No. PW
17-07 (Fiscal Impact: $38,148.00)
Recommendation — 1) Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public
Works Contract in a form approved by the City Attorney with Cinbad Industry Inc.
in the amount of $34,680.00 and authorize an additional $3,468 for construction
related contingencies; and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible
action related to this item.
21.Consideration and possible action to receive and file an informational
report on the Transient Occupancy Tax (T.O.T.) revenue to the City and the
impact of Measure B.
(Fiscal Impact: $0)
Recommendation — 1) Receive and file an informational report on the Transient
Occupancy Tax (T.O.T.) revenue to the City and the impact of Measure B; and/or
2) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
22.Consideration and possible action to award a standard Public Works
Contract to Corral Construction & Development Inc., in a form approved by
the City Attorney, for construction of the Police Department Men's Locker
Room Improvements, Project No. PW 15-10.
(Fiscal Impact: $64,898.00)
Recommendation — 1) Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public
Works Contract in a form approved by the City Attorney with Corral Construction
& Development Inc. in the amount of $58,998.00 and authorize an additional
$5,900.00 for construction related contingencies; and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss
and take other possible action related to this item.
11
11
23.Consideration and possible action authorizing the City Manager to execute
an amendment to the Professional Services Agreement with NCM
Engineering Corp. for preliminary roadway and railroad design work for the
Park Place Extension Project.
(Fiscal Impact: $0 to General Fund; Reimbursement Grant up to $735,000
and Property Owner Deposit of $150,000)
Recommendation — 1) Authorize the City Manager to execute an amendment to
the Professional Services Agreement with NCM Engineering Corp. in a form
approved by the City Attorney in the amount of $49,146.00; and/or, 2)
Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
F. NEW BUSINESS
24.Consideration and possible action to adopt a resolution to implement the
honorary memorialization of Lairport Street as Carl Jacobson Drive.
(Fiscal Impact: None)
Recommendation — 1) Adopt the attached Resolution implementing the honorary
memorialization of Lairport Street as "Carl Jacobson Drive" effective April 3,
2017; and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to
this item.
25.Consideration and possible action to receive and file an informational
report on the fiscal impact to the City from the change to the CalPERS
discount rate.
(Fiscal Impact: $0 for FY 2016-17)
Recommendation — 1) Receive and file information regarding the reduction to the
CalPERS discount rate and the resulting fiscal impact to the City; and/or, 2)
Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
26.Consideration and possible action to direct staff to carry out the necessary
actions to change the name of Sepulveda Blvd. to Pacific Coast Highway in
the City of El Segundo.
(Fiscal Impact: None)
Recommendation — 1) Direct staff to carry out the necessary actions to change
the name of Sepulveda Blvd. to Pacific Coast Highway in the City of El Segundo;
and/or, 2) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this
item.
G. REPORTS — CITY MANAGER
H. REPORTS — CITY ATTORNEY
12
12
I. REPORTS — CITY CLERK
J. REPORTS — CITY TREASURER
K. REPORTS — CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
Council Member Brann —
Council Member Pirsztuk—
Council Member Dugan —
Mayor Pro Tern Boyles —
Mayor Fuentes —
PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS — (Related to City Business Only — 5 minute limit per
person, 30 minute limit total) Individuals who have receive value of$50 or more to communicate
to the City Council on behalf of another, and employees speaking on behalf of their employer, must so
identify themselves prior to addressing the City Council. Failure to do so shall be a misdemeanor and
punishable by a fine of$250. While all comments are welcome, the Brown Act does not allow Council to
take action on any item not on the agenda. The Council will respond to comments after Public
Communications is closed.
MEMORIALS —
CLOSED SESSION
The City Council may move into a closed session pursuant to applicable law, including the Brown Act
(Government Code Section §54960, at sue.) for the purposes of conferring with the City's Real Property
Negotiator, and/or conferring with the City Attorney on potential and/or existing litigation; and/or
discussing matters covered under Government Code Section §54957 (Personnel); and/or conferring with
the City's Labor Negotiators.
REPORT OF ACTION TAKEN IN CLOSED SESSION (if required)
13
13
ADJOURNMENT
POSTED:
DATE:
TIME: DUp /ate
NAME:
14
14
Presentation
Recognition of Centennial Ball Sponsors
15
Presentation
The 2016 Holiday Parade Winners
16
roclamatt" On Cite of (El *eguubo, California
WHEREAS, all children in El Segundo should have access to the highest-quality education
possible; and
WHEREAS, El Segundo recognizes the important role that an effective education plays in
preparing all students in E1 Segundo to be successful adults; and
WHEREAS, quality education is critically important to the economic vitality of El Segundo;and
WHEREAS, El Segundo is home to a variety of high quality public and nonpublic schools from
which parents can choose for their children, in addition to families who educate
their children in the home; and
WHEREAS, educational variety not only helps to diversify our economy,but also enhances the
vibrancy of our community; and
WHEREAS, El Segundo has man high-quality teaching professionals in all types of school
settings who are committed to educating our children; and
WHEREAS, School Choice Week is celebrated across the country by millions of students,
parents, educators, schools and organizations to raise awareness of the need for
effective educational options.
NOW,THEREFORE,the Mayor and Member of the City Council of the City of El Segundo,California,
hereby recognize January 22-28,2017 as El Segundo School Choice Week,and call this observance
to the attention of all of our citizens.
RUGUN. 0
CENij �/ NIAL•
�■ '•fa
AlayorSuzanne Fuentes
,14ayor Pro gem Drew Boyles Council914ember_14licfiaelOugan
CounciC-14ember Card Pirsztuk Council9lem6er loon Brann
17
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Presentation
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Presentation of Investment Portfolio Report
(Fiscal Impact: None)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Receive and File
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
Investment Portfolio Report—December, 2016
FISCAL IMPACT: None
Amount Budgeted: N/A
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): N/A
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 5 Champion Economic Development & Fiscal Sustainability
Objective: 3 The City will maintain a stable, efficient, and transparent financial
environment
ORIGINATED BY: Dino Marsocci,Deputy City Treasurer II
REVIEWED BY: Crista Binder,Treasurer
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter,,City ManageryL
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
The Treasury Department presents the December, 2016 Investment Portfolio Report which
provides a status of Treasury Investment activities and related economic indicators.
This report will be created and submitted to Council on a quarterly basis. The report will also be
posted to the City's web site under the Treasury Department.
18
ggslu,Nli-�10
f-'G R 04 T,it N Pq RIK.
....o..r alp� a swvw�
GF
tllpe i�(Me 6ty J'wajaww
Date: February 7, 2017
From: Office of the City Treasurer
To: El Segundo City Council
RE: Investment Portfolio Report—As of December 31, 2016
Introduction:
This report will serve as a summary for the City of El Segundo's Treasury Department investment reporting,
compliance, investment environment and future plans; as well as subsidiary schedules which will support the
Portfolio Summary and provide additional analysis of our investments.
Investment Summarv:
The investments as of December 31, 2016 are as follows:
December Portfolio Summary
Market
Securitv Tvpe Cost Market value % of Total
Government 23,980,461.50 23,850,218.90 31.75%
Corp. Bonds 3,527,200.00 3,483,730.00 4.64%
CD's 8,862,938.75 8,891,337.03 11.84%
Union Bank Trust 36,370,600.25 36,225,285.93 48.22%
Plaza Bank CBD 5,000,000.00 5,000,000.00 6.66%
LAIF Immediate 11,725,517.31 11,725,517.31 15.61%
LAIF Sr. Housing 1,093,337.55 1,093,337.55 1.46%
LAIF - LAWA 10,609,087.08 10,609,087.08 14.12%
LAIF Subtotal 23,427,941.94 23,427,941.94 31.19%
Total Invested 64,798,542.19 64,653,227.87 86.06%
Trust Acct. Cash 10,146.53 10,146.53 0.01%
Chase Bank- Cash 10,458,743.76 10,458,743.76 13.92%
Total Portfolio 75,267,432.48 75,122,118.16 100.00%
Page 1
19
The portfolio Breakdown by Short Term (< 1 year) and Long Term is:
Short Term Long Term Total
Portfolio Value (Market) $ 38,943,838 $ 25,719,536 $ 64,663,374
Effective Yield 0.786% 1.520% 1.078%
Average Wtd. Maturity 71 Days 2.98 Years 1.30 Years
Benchmark Yield 0.51% 1.47% 0.851
Benchmark value is the Interpolated Treasury Yield to the Portfolio's Avg.Weighted Maturity
The interest income received during the period was:
Month Invested Cost Interest Received %Yield
October 68,048,087 84,176.39 1.48%
November 66,946,787 48,736.57 0.87%
December 64,798,542 54,229.76 1.00%
Avg/Total * 66,597,806 187,142.72 1.12%
'Note:the monthly fluctuation is because interest on most bonds is paid semi-annually,with LAT paid quarterly,and some investments paid monthly.
Compliance:
It is the intention of the City Treasurer's office to ensure that our investments are in compliance with the maturity
time limits and percentage allocation limits with all of our investments. The City is currently in compliance as
demonstrated below:
Partial List of Allowable Investment Instruments for Local Agencies
Ma)dmum City of El In
Ma�dmum Minimum Quality
Investment Type Maturity Specified % of Requirements Segundo Compliance
Portfolio Investments Y/N
Local Agency 5 years None None 0.00% Y
Bonds
U. S Treasury 5 years None None 0.00% Y
Obligations 111
US Agency
Obligations 5 years None None 31.75% Y
Negotiable
Certificates of 5 years 30% None 11.84% Y
Deposit
Medium Term 5 years 15% "A" Rating 4.64% Y
Notes
Collateralized 5 years None None 6.66% Y
Bank Deposits
Local Agency
Investment Fund N/A None None 31.19% Y
(LAI F)
Investment Type: Medium Term Notes-As of:December, 2016
Mabmum Minimum City of El In
InvestmentType Issuer Specified% of Quality Actual g VALUE
Segundo Compliance MARKET
Portfolio Requirements Rating Investments YIN
Medium Term Notes TOTAL 15% "A" Rating 4.64% Y 3.483.730
Medium Term Notes HSBC USA, INC. 3% "A" Rating A 0.65% Y 485,635
Medium Term Notes WELLS FARGO&CO. 3% "A"Rating A 0.67% Y 501,415
Medium Term Notes CATERPILLAR FINANCIAL SVCS 3% "A" Rating A 0.66% Y 498,810
Medium Term Notes GENERAL ELECTRIC CAP CORP 3% "A" Rating AA- 0.67% Y 501,335
Medium Term Notes TOYOTA 3% "A" Rating AA- 0.66% Y 493,950
Medium Term Notes WALT DISNEY CO 3% "A" Rating A 0.67% Y 499,570
Medium Term Notes BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON 3% "A"Rating A 0.67% Y 503,015 1
Page 12
20
City of El Segundo- Treasury Department
Continuing Education Tracking -As of December 31, 2016
Requirement YTD Hours Excess/(Deficit)- Notes
f Treasurer 5.00 11.50 6.50 GIOA Conference - March, 2016
Deputy City Treasurer 11 5.00 11.50 6.50 GIOA Conference- March, 2016
Deputy City Treasurer 1 5.00 10.00 5.00 CMTA Training - January, 2016
Investment Environment:
During the fourth quarter of 2016, rates increased significantly, ending much higher than they were at the beginning
of the quarter. While the highest rates in years were seen right after the FOMC meeting in the middle of December,
the good news is that as of January 25th the rates have increased to above where they were at December 31". Based
upon the projected 2017 Federal Funds Rate from the December meeting, it appears that the Fed may raise rates one
to three times during 2017.The current expectation is for gradual increases, but this could change depending on the
policies of the new Presidential Administration.
The graphs and charts below show some of the key interest rates on items we invest in. As rates are expected to rise
over the next few years, we want to time our investments to take advantage of the increases as they occur.
US Treasury Bonds Yield Curve as of 12/30/16
2.50
2.00 1.93 i
1.50 1.47
25
1 1"2 1.14
c _
1.00 -
0.8 0.88
_ ,59
0.50 0.44 5
9
0.2
0.00
1 Mo 3 Mo 6 Mo 1 Yr 2 Yr 3 Yr 5 Yr
9/30/2016 •12/30/2016
Page 13
21
Composite Bond Rates (as of 1/3/17)
US Treasury Bonds
Maturity Yield Yesterday Last Week Last Month
3 Month 0.47 0.47 0.49 0.44
_ I
6 Month 0.59 0.59 0.60 0.57
2 Year 1.18 1.15 1.20 1.07
3 Year 1.48 1.43 1.54 1.36
5 Year 1.94 1.89 2.03 1.80
Municipal Bonds
Maturity Yield Yesterday Last Week Last Month
2yr AA 1.15 1.16 1.18 1.17
2yr AAA 1.09 1.01 1.09 1.09
2yr A
1.17 1.00 1.26 1.25
5yr AAA 1.62 1.76 1.79 1.85
5yr AA 1.7 1.92 1.87 1.84
5yr A 1.96 2.12 2.06 2.11
Corporate Bonds
Maturity Yield _� Yesterday I Last Week Last Month
2yr AA 1.34 1.32 1.42 1.34
2yr A 1.43 1.39 1.50 1.41
5yr AAA 2.11 2.06 2.21 2.05
5yr AA 2.17 2.12 2.32 2.17
5yr A I 2.35 2.28 2.46 2.28
Data provided by VaIuBond.
Source: http://finance.vahoo.com/bonds/comoosite bond rates
Cash Flow Analvsis:
The chart below shows the historical cash flow for the last 12 months. We can see that the majority of our funds are
received in the second quarter of the fiscal year,January thru March, primarily due to Business License Renewals and
the annual Chevron Payment. We also receive Sales and UUT taxes during the first few months of the year as well.
Our investments will be purchased with the liquidity relative to our cash flow needs.
Page 14
22
Rolling 12 Month Cash Flow Analysis Total Receipts
16,000,000 ',Total Disbursements
14,000,000
12,000,000 -
10,000,000 --
c —_
8,000,000 _ - -- -
6,000,000
4,000,000 - --
2,000,000
0
(0 � (0 ti(0 ti� \tip ti(0 ti(0 �ti� ,tip Gti�
CP
This chart shows the net change in Cash as related to the Cash Flow Analysis above. Some of the larger
disbursements occur in the third and fourth quarters of the fiscal year. During Q-3, March to June, we have
a significant payment to CalPERS for our Other Post-Employment Benefits, and in Q-4,July- September, a
payment to ICRIVIA for our citywide insurance premiums, and a large infrastructure payment for roadwork
which was completed several years ago. We have added the prior year to highlight the changes that have
occurred this year.
/2016
Rolling 12 Month Net Change in Cash FY-2015
-FY-2015/2016
8,000,000 —
6,000,000
4,000,000
2,000,000
0
(2,000,000)
(4,000,000) —
(6,000,000)
JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC
Page 15
23
Additional Economic Indicators:.
Economic Pro ectfons from 5entember Meetina
The Economic Indicators presented below are key items that the Federal Reserve will look at in deciding
whether or not to change interest rates going forward.
The GDP, or Gross Domestic Product, represents the market value of all goods and services produced by
the economy during the period measured, including personal consumption, government purchases, private
inventories, paid-in construction costs and the foreign trade balance (exports are added, imports are
subtracted). This is a key indicator the Federal Reserve will look at when deciding on interest rate changes.
The target level for GDP is in the 2.5%to 3.5% range.
The Unemployment Rate shows the percentage of the labor force that is unemployed but seeking work.
The target level for Unemployment is around 5.6%.
The PCE Inflation is the Personal Consumption Expenditures rate of inflation. This index is essentially a
measure of goods and services targeted toward individuals and consumed by individuals. The long term
inflation target is around 2% per year. Core PCE Inflation excludes items such as food and energy due to
the nature of their potential price swings.
Fed Economic Projections (central tendencies as of December 2016)
Variable 2016 2017 2018 2019
Change in real GDP 1.8-1.9 1.9-2.3 1.8-2.2 1.8-2.0
September projection 1.7- 1.9 1.9-2.2 1.8-2.1 1.7-2.0
Unemployment rate 4.7-4.8 4.5-4.6 4.3 -4.7 4.3-4.8
September projection 4.7-4.9 4.5-4.7 4.4-4.7 4.4-4.8
PCE inflation 1.5 1.7-2.0 1.9-2.0 2.0-2.1
September projection 1.2 - 1.4 1.7 - 1.9 1.8-2.0 1.9 -2.0
Core PCE inflation 1.7-1.8 1.8- 1.9 1.9-2.0 2
September projection 1.6- 1.8 1.7-1.9 1.9-2.0 2
Memo: Projected
appropriate policy path
Federal funds rate 0.6 1.1-1.6 1.9-2.6 2.4-3.3
September projection 0.6-0.9 1.1-1.8 1.9-2.8 2.4-3.0
Page 6
24
Unemployment
5.5
5-
4.5 t
01115 03/15 05115 07115 09115 11115 01116 03116 05116 07116 09116 11116
Month
Source: http://data.bis.goy/cgi-bin/surveymost?bls
Inflation.
Inflation Rates by Month -0 2015
-�-�2016;
2.5
2.0
1.5 —
% 1.0
0.5 -
(0.5)
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug 5ep Oct Nov Dec
Page ( 7
25
Average Inflation Rates by Year
4.5
4.0 — — — - - - - -- -
3.5 - - - — -
3.0 -
2.5 --- �_ — - - -- - - -
2.0 - - — - -- - - -- - - --- ,_
1.5
1.0 _ —
0.5 -- - -- — -- - -
(0.5)
(1.0)
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Source: http://www.usinflationcaIcuIator.com/inflation/current-inflation-rates/
Retail Trade & Food Services, ex Auto, US Total 2015 2016
375,000 Seasonally Adjusted Sales (Millions of$)
370,000
365,000 - -
360,000
355,000 -
i
350,000
345,000
340,000
335,000
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Source: United States Census Bureau - http://www.census.gov/retail/index.html
Page 18
26
Investment Strategy,
It is the City and City Treasurer's policy to invest funds in accordance with the Investment Policy and to meet all legal
requirements regarding the safeguarding of funds.
In the past we maintained a higher cash balance at the bank in order to offset our bank fees since our Earnings Credit
rate was higher than the LAIF rate. Now that the LAIF interest rate exceeds our Earnings Credit rate we have lowered
our bank balance and invested more short term funds in LAIF. We will now pay bank fees but earn more interest
income, and will continue to monitor our cash flow needs in order to determine which investments will maximize
return while providing the proper level of liquidity.
The Liquidity Schedule provides an overview of when our current investments are due to mature. We will plan our
future investments to coordinate with these maturities in order to ensure a liquidity balance to our portfolio. The
Investments by Security Type schedule provides an additional breakdown of how our funds are presently allocated.
The Portfolio Summary for the month is included as an attachment to this report.
Additional Notes:
The City has funds of$1,093,337.55 which belong to the El Segundo Senior Citizens Housing Fund and is now shown
as its own LAIF balance. There are also LAWA RSI (Los Angeles World Airports Residential Sound Insulation)funds of
$10,609,087.08 included in the City's LAIF balances. The applicable interest for these accounts is posted quarterly in
the same manner as the regular City LAIF interest posting.
In October we deposited $5,000,000 into a Collateralized Bank Deposits account at Plaza Bank. This is a special
account structure set up for Government funds and backed by a Federal Home Loan Bank of San Francisco
Irrevocable Letter of Credit. The interest rate is above that of LAIF, and the funds, while intended for a 1 year
deposit, are available if needed.
Page 19
27
City of El Segundo
Investrnent Advisory Committee
Liquidity Schedule
As of: December 31. 2016
Cumulative
% of Total % of Total
Item Availabilitv Par Value Cumulative Balances Assets Assets
Cash in Bank
Chase Immediate 10,458,743.76
Union Bank-Trust Account Immediate 10,146.53
Cash in Bank-Total $10,468,890.29 $10,468,890.29 13.90% 13.90%
L A I F. (State of California) LAIF Immediate $11,725,517,31 $22,194,407.60 29-48% 15.57%
Cash Immediate $22,194,407.60
L.A.I.F. - Senior Housing Fund LAIF Immediate 1,093,337.55 $23,287,745.15 30.93% 1.45%
L.A.I.F. - LAWA(Restricted) LAIF Immediate 10,609,087.08 $33,896,832.23 45.02% 14.09%
Plaza Bank CBD 5,000,000.00 $38,896,832.23 51.66% 6.64%
Portfolio Investments: <30 Days $0.00 $38,896,832.23 51.66% 0.00%
31 to 90 Days $500,000.00 $39,396,832 23 52.32% 0.66%
91 to 180 Days $1,850,000.00 $41,246,832.23 54.78% 2.46%
181 to 365 Days $8,153,000.00 $49,399,832 23 65.61% 10.83%
1 to 2 Years $7,735,000.00 $57,134,832.23 7588% 10.27%
2 to 3 Years $6,855,000.00 $63,989,832-23 84.99% 9.10%
3 to 4 Years $6,455,000.00 $70,444,832.23 93.56% 8.57%
4 to 5 Years $4,850,000.00 $75,294,832.23 100.00% 6.44%
Subtotal $53,100,424.63
Grand Total $75,294,832.23 100.00%
Investment Portfolio subtotal $64,836,088.47
Investments by Maturity Date Market Value
$14,000,000.00
$12,000,000.00
$10,000,000.00 --- -- --� -- - - --.. - -
$8,000,000.00
$6,000,000.00 e - - ---- - ---
i
$4,000,000.00 -
$2,000,000.00 - -
$0.00 -_
�a�� 6J> � C�O p��yy �a�+ �gaAa+ ��� °k&' �a4�
*¢` ` X01 10'r 1� w0
Lim ) ^! t:10
i
�N
Page 10
28
City of El Segundo
Investment Advisory Committee
Investments by Security Type
As of: December 31, 2016
Cumulative
% of Total % of Total
Item Availabilitv Market Value CurnuiatIve Balances Assets Assets
Cash in Bank
Chase Immediate 10,458,743.76
Union Bank- Trust Account Immediate 10,146.53
Cash in Bank- Total $10,468,890.29 $10,468,890.29 13.94% 13.94%
L.A.I.F. (State of California) LAIF Immediate $11,725,517.31 $22,194,407.60 29.54% 15.61%
Cash Immediate $22,194,407.60
L.A.I.F. - Senior Housing Fund LAIF Immediate 1,093,337.55 $23,287,745.15 31.00% 1.46%
L.A.I.F. - LAWA(Restricted) LAIF Immediate 10,609,087.08 $33,896,832.23 45.12% 14.12%
Plaza Bank CBD 5,000,000.00 $38,896,832.23 51.78% 6.66%
Portfolio Investments: CD's 8,891,337.03 $47,788,169.26 63.61% 11.84%
Gov`t Obligations 23,850,218.90 $71,638,388.16 95.36% 31.75%
Bonds 3,483,730.00 $75,122,118.16 100.00% 4.64%
Subtotal $52,927,710.56
Grand Total $75,122,118.16 100.00%
Investment Portfolio subtotal $64,663,374.40
Investments by Security Type
$3,483,730.00
$10,468;890.29
Cash Immediate
LAIF Immediate
LAIF.-Senior Housing
$23,85 0,218.90 S11,725.,527.31� ■ LAIF-LAWA
■ Plaza Bank CBD
'Ab; J
E CD's
1,093,337.55 Gov't Obligations
10,609,087.08 ;
Bonds
$8,891,337-03
5,000,000.00
Page 11
29
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Public Hearing
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action regarding approval of Environmental Assessment No. EA-1064
and Zone Text Amendment No. ZTA 14-01 to amend the development standards regarding two-
story homes and second story additions in the City's R-1, single-family residential zone; create
new definitions and amend certain existing definitions contained in the El Segundo Municipal
Code; and amend the parking requirements for single-family residences.
(Fiscal Impact: None with this action.)
The proposed project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California
Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to 14 California Code Regulations § 15301 as a
Class 1 (existing facilities), § 15303 as a Class 3 (new construction or conversion of small
structures), and § 15304 as a Class 4 (minor alteration to land) categorical exemptions.
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Conduct a public hearing;
2. Take testimony and other evidence as presented;
3. Introduce an Ordinance (Zone Text Amendment No. ZTA 14-01) amending the
development standards regarding two-story homes and second story additions in the
City's R-1, single-family residential zone, creating new definitions and amending
certain existing definitions contained in the El Segundo Municipal Code,and amending
the parking requirements for single-family residences;
4. Schedule second reading and adoption of the Ordinance for February 21, 2017;
5. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
1. Proposed Ordinance (strike-out/underline version)
2. Planning Commission Resolution No. 2810
FISCAL IMPACT:None.
Amount Budgeted: N/A
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): N/A
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: Enhance customer service and engagement
Objective: City services are convenient, efficient and user-friendly for all residents
and businesses.
PREPARED BY: Eduardo Schonbom, AICP, Principal Planner
REVIEWED BY: Gregg McClain, Planning Manager
Sam Lee, Planning and Building Safety irector
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager `
30
INTRODUCTION:
In 2016, the City Council directed Staff to prepare a zoning code amendment that would clean-up
the R-1 Zone development standards and improve or eliminate the existing modulation
requirements. An R-1 Subcommittee was formed which was tasked with exploring alternatives to
the current modulation standards that regulate second stories in the R-1 zone, and to propose
alternatives. The Subcommittee made its recommendations and the proposed amendments were
reviewed by the Planning Commission on November 10, 2016 and January 12, 2017. At the
January 12 meeting, the Planning Commission adopted a resolution recommending that the City
Council approve the amendments, which include deleting the modulation requirements in ESMC
§15-4A-6, and replacing them with a formula based on floor area ratio (FAR); increasing the
allowable FAR; and a general cleanup of article 154A to eliminate redundancies and provide
clarity.
BACKGROUND:
The City Council adopted Ordinance No. 1401 amending the development standards of the Single-
Family Residential (R-1) Zone and other sections of the El Segundo Municipal Code in 2006.
Generally, the amendments were intended to minimize bulk and mass of two-story homes,
encourage architectural elements and features in accordance with the goals and policies of the
City's General Plan.
Most notable of the 2006 amendments was the inclusion of a new building wall modulation
requirement along the sides of second stories, whereby a portion of the second story is required to
be set back from the first story by a minimum of 4-feet and up to a maximum of 6-feet. The
following standards and requirements were adopted and codified(ESMC Section 15-4A-6(D)(2),
attached)to implement the modulation requirements for second stories:
"Side Yard: Structures must maintain a minimum setback on each side of the lot of ten
percent(10%) of the width of the lot, but can never be less than three feet(3) and need
not be more than six feet (6). Side yard setbacks need not be more than five feet (5)
for any single story additions, or for a second story addition that does not add more
than five hundred(500)square feet to the existing structure. Side yard setbacks for new
dwellings, second floor additions to dwellings, or additions to dwellings that add more
than five hundred (500) square feet in area to the existing structure must comply with
the following additional requirements if located on a lot greater than forty feet (40)
wide:
a. Modulation of the second floor exterior perimeter walls must occur on the
second floor of the dwelling that is equal to a minimum of fifteen percent
(1501o) of the building area (including garages and carports) on the ground
floor, but not less than two hundred (200) square feet of area.
b. Modulation of the second floor exterior perimeter walls must occur on the
side of the structure that faces the side yards.
c. The total area required to be modulated must be divided equally between both
sides of the building facing the side yards.
d. Modulation must be a minimum of four feet (4) in depth and must be a
maximum of six feet (6) in depth.
e. No additional modulation is required if the exterior walls of the second floor
facing each side yard is set back an amount that is equal to the ten percent
31
(1001o) of the lot width and an additional four feet (4) in depth.
f. If a portion of the second floor facing a side yard is set back an amount that is
equal to ten percent (10016) of the lot width plus an additional four feet (4) to
six feet (6) in depth, that portion may count towards the total required area of
modulation as required in subsection D2a of this section. "
Since adoption of the 2006 amendments, the Staff consistently receives regular complaints from
the public, developers and architects, about the modulation requirements. They express frustration
and dissatisfaction with how to implement the regulations. Additionally, Staff is told that the
modulation standards are confusing and onerous to property owners in that they lead to difficulties
in designing and increased construction costs. In response, on April 5, 2016, the City Council
directed Staff to prepare a zoning code amendment that will clean-up the R-1 zone standards and
improve or eliminate the modulation requirements.
In accordance with the Council's direction, on August 25, 2016, Staff took an item to the Planning
Commission regarding modulation in the R-1 zone. At the meeting Staff presented various
alternatives to the current modulation requirements, and sought public input and Planning
Commission direction. Alternatives included: limiting the size of second floors; establishing a
setback encroachment plane; requiring second stories to be set back from the first story facade;
and, requiring additional setback from the property lines.
After discussing the alternatives presented to them, the Planning Commission felt that additional
information was needed and that a subcommittee should be formed to study the matter and to
present their recommendation to the Commission. With authorization and support from the City
Council, the Planning Commission formed the R-1 Subcommittee comprised of seven members
consisting of various community stakeholders, including a member from the Council, two
members of the Planning Commission, local residents and architects. The subcommittee was
tasked with exploring alternatives to the current modulation standards, and to propose alternatives
to the standards or the language of the regulations contained in the zoning code.
DISCUSSION:
Based upon the Subcommittee's recommendation, the Planning Commission suggests changes to
the development standards that regulate lot coverage, structure size and setbacks for second stories,
which the Commission believes achieves the desired goals and simplifies the process for residents,
architects and developers.
Modulation and Structure Size:
The current zoning code requires modulation of the second floor along the side yards as illustrated
above. The modulation requirements dictate the square footage of modulated areas and require
that such modulated areas be equally distributed along the sides of second floors in an attempt to
minimize bulk and mass of second floors. The current zoning code also regulates structure size
by establishing a total gross floor area of 0.53 FAR. However, the proposed Zone Text
Amendment removes the modulation requirements, increases the overall FAR to a maximum of
0.6, and limits second stories to 0.25 FAR.
Although FAR would increase to 0.6, it important to note that certain areas that are not currently
calculated into FAR would now constitute floor area for purposes of FAR. For example,rotundas
and spaces with high vaulted ceilings currently count towards the FAR calculation on one floor;
32
however, the amendments would specify that such areas would be counted on both the first and
second stories for FAR calculation if the height is 14-feet or more. Further, the entire garage is
currently exempt from the FAR calculation; however, the amendments would allow up to a 500
square foot exemption, with anything above that counting as floor area. One last example is that
the amendments would include second floor balconies and decks that are covered into the FAR
calculation. Thus, although FAR would increase, additional areas would now constitute FAR.
As part of increasing the overall FAR to a maximum of 0.6, second stories would be limited to
0.25 FAR. This will ensure that most second stories are smaller than the first story. Additionally,
when designing a house, as the second story increases in area, the first floor would necessarily
decrease to ensure that the overall FAR does not exceed 0.6. For example, should a second story
be designed to the maximum FAR(0.25),the first floor would be limited to 0.35 (0.60 minus 0.25).
The Subcommittee,Planning Commission and Staff believe that limiting the size of a second floor
through Floor Area Ratio (FAR) will produce similarly attractive houses, create a simpler process
and allow architectural design flexibility while meeting the needs of homeowners. Further, this is
a far superior alternative to the current modulation requirement as it simplifies the regulations,
results in standards that are easier to understand and implement, and will result in designs that are
very much in line with the intent and purpose that modulation was intended to achieve. In
particular, the new regulations will result in smaller second floors than currently permitted, which
will have a positive impact on light, shadows and air circulation.
Lot Coverage:
The proposed amendment removes the multiple lot coverage standards since they are not necessary
for the purpose of regulating building size when FAR and setbacks are applied. Removal of the
lot coverage regulations greatly simplifies the process without losing any degree of control.
Parking Requirements for Single-Family Residences:
During the Subcommittee's meetings, there was discussion regarding the Code's current
requirement for an additional (third) garage parking space. The current zoning code requires two
spaces for each unit and one additional space for dwelling units exceeding 3,000 square feet. The
Subcommittee believed this to be stringent and burdensome, and felt that increasing the threshold
is necessary since additional parking is typically available on the driveway in front of garages.
Further, to accommodate a third space, garages are typically widened. This results in a negative
impact, especially when the garage is at the front. In these cases, the garage becomes the focal
point of a house; it practically eliminates opportunities for porches, verandas and other
architectural elements that are of human-scale; over time it will change the character of the
neighborhood; and significantly increases the bulk and massing of the first floor. Thus, for these
reasons, the proposed code amendment includes increasing the threshold for requiring a third
garage space from 3,000 square feet, to 3,500 square feet.
Definitions:
During the process of this code amendment, Staff reviewed the current definitions that apply to
residential properties, uses, and structures, and found that certain definitions are ambiguous and
difficult to follow. Further, there are also terms that are used throughout the code or in the
proposed amendment that need a definition. Thus, definitions have been updated, modified or
created as necessary.
33
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW:
The proposed project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California
Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) because it consists only of minor revisions and clarifications
to existing zoning regulations and procedures related thereto and will not have the effect of
substantially changing any regulatory standards or findings. The proposed Ordinance is an action
that does not have the potential to cause significant effects on the environment,but rather will help
reduce the impact of new construction in residential zone property on the environment. As such,
the proposed Ordinance constitutes a Class 1 (existing facilities), Class 3 (new construction or
conversion of small structures), and Class 4 (minor alteration to land) categorical exemptions.
RECOMMENDATION:
Planning Staff recommends that the Council:
1. Conduct a public hearing;
2. Take testimony and other evidence as presented;
3. Introduce an Ordinance (Zone Text Amendment No. ZTA 14-01) amending the
development standards regarding two-story homes and second story additions in the City's
R-1,single-family residential zone,creating new definitions and amending certain existing
definitions contained in the El Segundo Municipal Code, and amending the parking
requirements for single-family residences; and,
4. Schedule second reading and adoption of the Ordinance for February 21, 2017.
34
ORDINANCE NO.
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE 15 OF THE EL SEGUNDO
MUNICIPAL CODE REGARDING REGULATIONS FOR
PROPERTIES IN THE SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL (R-1)
ZONE, DEFINITIONS AND THE PARKING REQUIREMENTS FOR
SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES.
The City Council of the City of El Segundo does ordain as follows:
SECTION 1: The City Council finds and declares as follows;
A. On April 5, 2016, the City Council directed Staff to prepare a Zoning Code
Amendment that would clean up the R-1 Zone development standards and
improve/eliminate modulation requirements for the Planning Commission's
and City Council's consideration;
B. On September 22, 2016, the Planning Commission formed the R1
Modulation Subcommittee comprised of seven members, including
members from the Council, Planning Commission, local residents and
architects. The subcommittee was tasked with exploring alternatives to the
current modulation standards that regulate second stories in the R1, Single-
Family residential zone, and to propose alternatives to the concept or the
language of the regulations contained in the City's Zoning Code.
C. The R1 Subcommittee formulated draft regulations to address second story
residential structures.
D. On November 10, 2016, the Planning Commission conducted a public
forum to review the Subcommittee's draft development standards for two-
story homes and second story additions in the R1 zone, and provide staff
with feedback on the draft regulations.
E. The City reviewed the project's environmental impacts under the California
Environmental Quality Act (California Public Resources Code §§ 21000, et
seq., "CEQA") and the regulations promulgated thereunder (14 California
Code of Regulations §§ 15000, et seq., the "CEQA Guidelines"), and the
City's Environmental Guidelines (City Council Resolution No. 3805,
adopted March 16, 1993);
F. On January 12, 2017, the Planning Commission held a public hearing to
receive public testimony and other evidence regarding the proposed
amendments, including, without limitation, information provided to the
Planning Commission by City staff and public testimony;
G. On January 12, 2017, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No.
2810 recommending the City Council approve Environmental Assessment
No. EA-1064 and Zone Text Amendment No. ZTA 14-01;
Page 1
35
J. On February 7, 2017, the City Council held a public hearing and considered
the information provided by City staff and public testimony regarding this
Ordinance; and
K. This Ordinance and its findings are made based upon the entire
administrative record including, without limitation, testimony and evidence
presented to the City Council at its February 7, 2017 hearing and the staff
report submitted by the Planning and Building Safety Department.
SECTION 2: Environmental Assessment. Pursuant to the provisions of the California
Environmental Quality Act, Public Resources Code Sections 21000 et. seq. ("CEQA"),
the State's CEQA Guidelines, California Code of Regulation, Title 14, Section 15000 et
seq., and the City's Local CEQA Guidelines, the proposed project is categorically exempt
from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to 14
California Code of Regulations § 15301 because it consists only of minor revisions and
clarifications to existing zoning regulations and procedures related thereto and will not
have the effect of substantially changing any regulatory standards or findings required
therefor. The proposed Ordinance is an action that does not have the potential to cause
significant effects on the environment, but rather will help reduce the impact of new
construction in residential zone property on the environment. Accordingly, the proposed
Ordinance constitutes a Class 1 (existing facilities), Class 3 (new construction or
conversion of small structures), and Class 4 (minor alteration to land) categorical
exemptions. In addition, this ordinance constitutes a component of the ESMC which the
Planning Commission determined to be consistent with the General Plan FEIR. Further,
any environmental impacts associated with this ordinance are adequately addressed in
the General Plan FEIR. Consequently, no further environmental review is required.
SECTION 3: Factual Findings and Conclusions. The City Council finds, without
limitation, that the proposed ordinance to amend ESMC §154A regulating the single-
family residential (R-1) zone would result in the following:
A. The proposed amendment to the ESMC modifies ESMC Chapters 154A
regulating Single-Family Residential (R-1) Zone Site Development Standards; 15-
1 Definitions; and 15-15-6A, parking requirements for single-family residences.
B. The General Plan Land Use designation for the affected properties in the Single-
Family Residential (R-1) Zone is Single-Family Residential.
C. It replaces an inaccurate setback diagram for parcels 25 feet or less in width.
D. Deletes the modulation requirements, and deletes the building wall modulation
using architectural features requirements for lots 40-feet wide or wider.
E. Creates a maximum floor area ratio (FAR) for lots 40-feet wide or wider, with
standards that include a maximum FAR, limits the size of second stories, and
defines the areas that constitute floor area in on R1 zoned properties.
Page 2 36
F. It deletes redundant language by expressing numbers as digits, rather than a
combination of using digits and writing out the number in words.
G. It increases the threshold for requiring a 3rd parking space, from 3,000 square feet
of floor area to 3,500 square feet of floor area
H. It updates certain existing definitions, and creates new definitions for residential
areas, features, structures or improvements found in the R1 zone standards.
I. The proposed amendment to the ESMC that modifies Chapters 154A regulating
Single-Family Residential (R-1) Zone Site Development Standards; 15-1
Definitions; and 15-15-6A parking requirements for single-family residential relate
only to the new construction of a single-family residence in the City's R-1 Zone,
an urbanized area; alterations and additions to existing residential structures in the
R-1 Zone that involve negligible expansion of an existing use; repair and
maintenance of existing residential structures in the City's R-1 Zone that involve
no expansion beyond what is permitted in the R-1 Zone; and new construction of
accessory structures including garages, carports and patios in the City's R-1 Zone.
SECTION 4: General Plan Findings. As required under Government Code § 65860 the
ESMC amendments proposed by the Ordinance are consistent with the El Segundo
General Plan as follows:
A. The amendment conforms with the Land Use Element Goals, Objectives and
Policies. Specifically, the amendment is consistent with Goal LU1, Objective LU1-
1, Goal LU3, in that the amendment as a comprehensive whole create polices,
design standards, and helps create a sense of place for the entire City; preserves
and maintains the City's low-medium density residential nature, with low building
height profile and character, and minimum development standards; adopting the
amendment ensures the preservation, protection and extension of existing single-
family residential uses; and promotes the health, safety, and wellbeing of the
people of El Segundo by adopting standards for the proper balance, relationship,
and distribution of the residential land uses at all times in accordance with
applicable law.
B. The proposed text amendment to the Single-Family (R-1) Zone Site Development
Standards, Definitions, Open Space Encroachments and Off-Street Parking
Requirements conforms with the General Plan. The proposed changes do not
modify or increase the maximum density of dwelling units per acre currently
allowed in the Single-Family Residential Land Use designation. As a result, the
proposed Zone Text Amendment conforms to the Land Use Element of the
General Plan.
C. The amendment conforms to the Land Use Element Goals, Objectives and
Policies. Specifically, the amendment is consistent with Goal LU1 and Objectives
LU1-1 and LU3-2, in that the minor code changes make corrections to existing
exhibits and code language and clarifies the Single-Family Residential (R-1) Zone
Page 3 37
regulations. The R-1 Zone establishes comprehensive regulations to preserve
and maintain the City's low-medium density residential nature, with low building
height profile and character. Large portions of the City are zoned R-1 and
maintaining the character of these areas is essential to the continuation of El
Segundo's "small town" atmosphere.
D. The text amendment complies with Objective LU 1-5.6 in that the changes to the
existing language to clarify and update regulations and correct errors in the R-1
regulations will make it easier for projects to demonstrate consistency with the
City's Zoning Ordinance.
E. The text amendment is consistent with the Single-Family (R-1) Residential Land
Use designation in that the proposed changes do not modify or increase the
maximum density of dwelling units per acre currently allowed by the R-1
designation.
SECTION 5: Zone Text Amendment Findings. In accordance with ESMC § 154A and
based on the findings set forth in Section 3, the proposed Zone Text Amendment is
consistent with the goals, policies, and objectives of the General Plan as follows:
A. It is consistent with the purpose of the ESMC, which is to serve the public health,
safety, and general welfare and to provide the economic and social advantages
resulting from an orderly planned use of land resources.
B. It is necessary to facilitate the development process and ensure the orderly
development of single-family residences since the proposed amendment corrects
errors and clarifies the standards contained in the zoning regulations for the Single-
Family (R-1) Residential Zone.
SECTION 6: El Segundo Municipal Code (ESMC) §15-1-6 "Definitions" is amended to
add, amend or delete the follow definitions (6trikethro u rYh is language deleted, and
underlined is language added):
"15-1-6: DEFINITIONS:
ACCESSORY: A building, �:� cf a "avild+ng-or otruoture;er ucc which io oubG4[Rate4cs
a ,d tho uoo of which is inGidental to, that of-ft main biuitding, struoturo or use on the
sarne lot-.
ACCESSORY BUILDING OR STRUCTURE: A building or structure that is r)hvsicallu
detached from. on the same lot as, and incidental and subordinate to the r)rincinal build inq
or structure. "Accessory building or structure" includes. but is not limited to. accessory
dwelling units, garages,gazebos, greenhouses. olavhouses. storaae and tool sheds. and
workshous.
Page 4
38
ACCESSORY USE: A use of a portion of land or building that is customarily and clearly
incidental and subordinate to the principal use of the land or buildioa. is located on the
same lot as the principal use and is dependent upon the principal use for the maiority of
its utilization or activity_ . Accessory uses typically are very small in proportion to the
principal use.
ATTACHED: Havina a wall or roof in common with another structure. when referrirja to
dwelling units or aaraaes.
ATTIC: The sp ace aroa located between the ceiling joists of the top floor or story and the
roof of a building. An attic may nWDc '.load --3 habitstle "per
BALCONY: A covered or uncovered platform that can be used as a walking surface,
proiectina outward from the vertical surface/facade of a building or structure. and which
is directly accessible from floor area located on the same level as the balconv.
BASEMENT: Any floor level below the first story in a building that is more than 4-feet
below"grade"for more than 50-Dercent of the total perimeter, or is more than 8-feet below
"grade"at anv point., 34c>']W that a floor lovol in a buildiwng-havinS only me flccr 4evoi ohall
E;;-- ' ;fied ac s: 1--momont vniess sucn-fTQOr-IRvol q,"alifioo as a "first otcry" ac defined
hhrreFei ..
the roof level is r as fit
tawerrwA whoon the It�,ar
Wro ft an 4 leM WOW Vr6d*Nar
mQr�1h�r+s�paroart d t
Porlmatar ar t
bolow grade pdr L -- ~—
Singly Lavol Building
Page 5 39
Fksl Ipwer door I I will
be clankil d as thu bat4meM
If gtid lire"lavel la:
W more them Stool abvrel
^�
�
grodo forM Itut$O aetcoml
. ; x s ; at thA oettnwrtw and does rwi
ti �� s araeed 12 aborre If R'.fv at
x -
Ono Story and Bls rnotd Building
BUILDING AREA: See "Floor Area (Gross)".
CEILING: The upper interior surface of a room. opposite and directly above, the finish
floor or walking surface.
DECK: An outdoor epen, unroofed n F- ^F platform that can be used as a walking
surface and outdoor aatherin-o/activity area. tvpically extending outward from a house,
structure, or other building.
DETACHED: Not havina a wall or roof in common with another structure. when referring
to dwellina units or aaraaes.
DWELLING: Any building" r-portion thef:Wch ctintnins not rnoro than twG42+4weWmg
UR its.
DWELLING UNIT, ACCESSORY: An attached or a detached residential dwelling
unit which provides complete independent livinq facilities for one or more
persons. It shall include permanent provisions for living. sleeping, eating
cooking. and sanitation on the same parcel as the sinale-family dwellina is
situated. An accessory dwellina unit also includes the followina:
(A) An efficiencv unit. as defined in Section 17958.1 of Health and Safety
Cod-g,
Page 6
40
(B) A manufactured home. as defined in Section 18007 of the Health and
Safetv Code.
DWELLING, MULTIPLE-FAMILY: A building or portion of a building containing
three or more dwelling units. the*eef designed or arran ecd for occupancy by three
Wor more households fames living independently in which they may or may not
share common entrances and/or other spaces. Individual dwelling units may be
owned as condominiums, or offered for rent.
DWELLING. PRIMARY for MAIN STRUCTURE): The Drincipal dwelling on a
residential lot. which existed ,prior to the establishment of a secondary ("second
unit") or accessory dwellina unit.
DWELLING, SINGLE-FAMILY: A building containing no more than one dwellina
unit, de€aGhed-dweMng unit with enly or,-- kitohoR-, designed for occupancy by not
more than one household. one family, This defirAien family
dwellings.
DWELLING, TWO-FAMILY: A building containing no more than two dwellina units.
designed or arranged for occupancv by to--bo 000upled b two households (2)
families living independently-,4ae stFurt6fFe having only-two (2) dr•&4W4 w*
DWELLING UNIT: Any building or portion thereof that is used as a complete
independent livina facility for one or more Dersons containing r)ermanerlt
provisions for livina. sleeping. eating. cookina. and sanitation. as required by the
California Building Code..Arhirh contains living faGili+ies G!wding_ PFOViciOno fCW
sleeping, eating, ^^^king and-Sanitstion, as by the coda, met
+4xe than one family.
SAVE: The overhanainj lower edge of a roof plane that extends uo to 18-inches bevond
the facade of a wall attached to said roof plane.
FLOOR: The aeximntvly horizontal,level base surface stye of a room.
FLOOR AREA (GROSS): The total horizontal area on all floors. stories or levels. as
measured to the interior of a building's Derimeter walls, lnsluded within the 3urroundirvg
exteFiOF c of a building or potion thoroaf, including all floors. stories or levels of the
primary dwellina. attached and detached accessory dwellina units. habitable attic space.
and accessory buildinas. See Section 15-4A-6.F for additional details when calculating
"floor area". mwluoivo of gafarc-3, vcRt-s#afto and oourto. Thule^r aFea of-a building or
portion thore af, not pFayi.-1 d ,arith O4:.rrcundi% exterior waII6 chill be tho uooble area
under the heFizoRtal nrGiertion of the rc-# v-r floor ab01,3.
Page 7
41
Property
wx
w ":ti} ti� • t �r�je
One - F.A.R. = 2,200 sf
T tory - FAR, = 4.440 sf
Building
FLOOR AREA(NET): The total horjzpntal area of all floors. stories or levels. as measured
to the inferior of a buildina's perimeter walls. in >aed within the hor ourroundir.,g
wa4ls of a builri ng or otruo4ure.The tGta -Rna„a—eVVt" #c high or mo rra-- y lats, is
the M 1 zone only, may b_ multi-lie h vter r'f deteFrnine the net floor ea..
Space devoted to the following shall not be included when determining the total net floor
area within a building or structure:
A. Elevator shafts.
B. Stairwells and stairwav enclosures.
C. Courts or atriums u GGv red env.' QRSR#$4}e-asky.
D. Rooms exclusively holding building operating equipment.
E. Parking spaces at or above grade and access thereto; provided, that in
commercial and manufacturing zones:
1. Not less than the front 50-percent fiff fGen;t (I Q%) of the
ground floor is devoted to commercial/manufacturing use; and
2. At least one full level of parking below grade is provided.
F. Structures devoted exclusively to parking.
G. Restrooms in common areas of nonresidential buildings.
In the M-1 Zone only, the total space devoted to high or medium bav labs may be
multiplied by a factor of 0.5 to determirle the net floor area.
FLOOR AREA RATIO: The floor area or net floor area of all building_ s on a lot. divided by
the lot area.
Page 8 42
HABITABLE AREA: As defined by the California Buildina Code.
PORCH: An GGYer latfnrm that is an exterior appendage to a building, usually hayIR
cof from the# ilding,that r 'HRgs—an4A*--4+pyeF4Rg ooIumnc,%vh4Gh
forms forming a covered aoroach eptra-ese or vestibule to a doorway. The covering may
have a separate roof from the buildina, and mav have railings and/or surmortina columns.
!Sometimes referred to as a "Veranda".
ROTUNDA: A round, domed feature, building or portion thereof containing high interior
vertical space between the floor and cklina above.
STORY: That portion of building included between the surface of any floor and the
surface of the next floor above it: or, if there is no floor above, then the space between
such floor and the ceilina above, groper s urfare of any floor Ynd the sI�ce of-t-►e
ff99H4� e,except thwt th- te`"-I''^N�^°t tap —Aall by that pvrticn ef�iu-ilding ino!�ed
d feen the pr+n 4aGe-94he+epmc>ot floe coiling or roof abevo. If the finished
floor level directly above a usable or unused underfloor space is more than 6-feet sit feet
(6} above "grade" as defined herein for more than 50-perceiij fifty ^ r ent (59-%) of the
total perimeter, or is more than 12-feet twelvo foot (12') above "grade" as defined herein
at any point, such usable or unused underfloor space shall be considered as. a "story".
Floor lava k clasalf iad W V*
Fl rat M"
Man 60 i
laW prods at i
Sim is Lf lf� �[tt� lfl
Page 9
43
S�eond S lo�Y no iawor Hoar UY&I Is
dAmwod as 1h Ilea slop+ d the
Ww*vat Wme kr
r'{t5i f ,; ti•,r:. o MCKO than a I"Gwyn grJu"
,. ?. i+x t titan S4araont o4 tha
WW VW"ioto W WW*than 12
Two Sjoq Building
STORY, FIRST: The lowest story in a building which qualifies as a "story", as defined
herein. In , eXGept f",f }eof4evet ice a building having only one floor level. said floor
level shall be classified as the a-first storyW ded-sash floor 13.x' is not m khan four
feat (') below "g da", as dofinod- e�n, for more-fhan fifty porGent (50%) of the total
perimeter, or not rnere than eight feet (8') below "grade", as defined 118FeiR, at aRy peint.
TRELLIS: A system of horizontal latticework supported on posts, designed to support
growing vines and plants, or to provide partial shade for outdoor gatherina/activity areas.
(Also referred to as a "Pergola").
VERANDA: A tarp, opera porch, usually roofed and partly enclosed—, as by a railing, which
extends often a)rtonding across the front and sides of a house.
SECTION 7: ESMC §15-4A-2 "Permitted Uses" is amended to read as follows
(stFikethFough is language deleted, and underlined is language added):
"15-4A-2: PERMITTED USES:
Only the followina uses and develoaments may be conducted or constructed Tie
faltewing ano3 aro pormittled in the R-1 zone:
Page 10
44
A. Single-family dwellings; provided, that where a dwelling containing e&ian hundrad
{700) square feet or less exists on the rear portion of the lot and was placed
thereon prior to, or for which a building permit was issued prior to December 26,
1947, in conformance to the requirements of ordinance 293 of the city, a second
one-family dwelling may be erected on the front portion of the lot, whereupon the
dwelling on the rear portion of the lot shall assume the status of a nonconforming
use as defined herein, but may be expanded to a maximum of 700)
square feet.
B. Parks, playgrounds, recreational areas (publicly owned and operated) but
excluding ballparks, bleachers, swimming pools or other types of facilities where
racing or contests are conducted or public amusement devices are for hire.
C. The renting of not more than twe42) rooms to not more than few(4) persons per
dwelling unit.
D. The keeping of animals and pets in accordance with title 6, chapter 2 of this code.
E. A state authorized, certified or licensed family care home, foster family home, or
group home serving six (6) or fewer children.
F. A state authorized, certified or licensed residential facility, residential care facility,
residential care facility for the elderly, intermediate care facility, developmentally
disabled habilitative or nursing, or congregate living health facility, serving six {6)
or fewer persons.
G. Home occupations.
H. Small family daycare homes.
I. Large family daycare homes pursuant to section 15-4A-4 of this article.
!. S"-v-nd4we#ieg snit, when +hes stile 4et4n9 form-a-Gammor. b",nda.
or loto :s9nod for Pte,a I?S, C 2, C 3, CO, or XJ. in nO GaDo oha;4he-propert
used for the ser--n-nd 11' it Consist 0 re- than Gne jot or bo more than
fiferf,� ( 0')iA„�a+.�.� —Prd. 1216, 2 C ' 9913,. rte. ON, 1391, 2 15 205)
J.� One mobile or manufactured home subject to the following:
1. The mobile or manufactured home shall nct 1>9 porrni{tcd ur1le has been
certified pursuant to the national manufactured housing construction and safety
standards act of 1974, and has not been altered in violation of applicable codes;
and
2. The mobile or manufactured home must swafl be installed on a permanent
foundation in compliance with all applicable building regulations and division 13,
Page 11 45
part 2 (commencing with section 18000) of the California Health and Safety
Code.
K.L-. Other similar uses approved by the dirootor Of GOMmunity, eGOROMiG and
deve4opm per ++ces Director, as provided by chapter 22 of this title."
SECTION 8: ESMC §15-4A-3 "Permitted Accessory Uses" is amended to read as follows
(strikethr,,u h is language deleted, and Underlined is language added):
"15-4A-3: PERMITTED ACCESSORY USES:
A. Any use customarily incidental to a permitted use.
B. Detached accessory buildings and structures, including private garages.
C. Play structures mss.
D. Accessow dwelling unit. pursuant to Article 15-4E (Accessory DweUina Units) of
this title.
E.D-. Other similar uses approved by the dirootor of Gommunity, eGonemic Mnc
devetepmont oorVises Director, as provided by chapter 22 of this title."
SECTION 9: ESMC §15-4A-4 "Large Family Daycare Facilities" is amended to read as
follows (stFikethFo gh is language deleted, and underlined is language added):
"15-4A-4: LARGE FAMILY DAYCARE FACILITIES:
All large family daycare facilities must comply with the following provisions for a large
family daycare permit:
A. Apply For Po tAW.Plication: Applications for large family daycare permits sly
must be submitted to the dirootor of oommun;ty, oeonomis-and-developmept
viGeS, Director by a property owner or an applicant with the consent of the
owner(s).
B. Notice To Adjacent Property Owners: At least tern--(10) days prior to the date on
which the d-irwtar of oommunity, oocnomi -e),e1opm3nt wrvices Director will
make a decision on the application, the department of Goo-rn�inity, coonomio and
development sewie es Plannina and Buildina Safety shall give written notice of the
proposed use by mail or delivery to all owners shown on the last equalized
assessment roll as owning real property, and all residents within a 500 fi d-red
foot (500' radius of the exterior boundaries of the proposed facility, the owner of
the subject property and the project applicant.
Page 12
46
C. Request f=for Hearing: No public hearing shaft will be held before a decision is
made on the application unless a hearing before the planning commission is
requested by the applicant or a property owner or resident within the NO five
hundFed foot{500} notification radius. If a hearing is requested, it shall be provided
in accordance with section 15-27-5 of this title, except, both the owners and all
residents within a 500'�We-hundrod foot ¢60$4 radius are required to be notified of
the hearing. The applicant shall be is required to pay an additional fee for the cost
of the hearing.
D. Findings: Before a large family daycare permit may be granted, the diFesteFef
GGmmuRity, e-oongmb cnd de i—ab Ges Director or planning commission
shaft must make the following findings that the proposed facility:
1. Provides one off street parking space for each employee who drives to the
facility and who requires a parking space.
2. Provides drop off facilities as necessary to avoid interference with traffic and to
promote the safety of children.
3. Is not located within three h- (300) linear feet of an existing large family
daycare facility; provided, however, that the dir--Qt3r of s3mmunity, co3n3mis
rand 4cvclepmnt torvioes Director or planning commission shall disregard this
requirement where the applicant can demonstrate that:
a. The existing large family daycare facility is operating at full capacity; or
b. The proposed facility meets the need for a particular service not provided by
the existing large family daycare facility.
4. Complies with the noise element of the city's general plan.
5. Has been or will be licensed for such use by the state.
6. Complies with all state fire marshal requirements for large family daycare
facilities, and with all local building and fire codes which apply to single-family
residences.
E. Appeal: The decision of the d rotor of oommunity, omnc;,•r►is--an4-developrnent
GeWiGes Director may be appealed to the planning commission, and shall be
processed as provided by chapter 25 of this title."
SECTION 10: ESMC §15-4A-5 "Uses Subject to Conditional Use Permit" is
amended to read as follows (stFikethre u nh is language deleted, and underlined is
language added):
"15-4A-5: USES SUBJECT TO CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT:
The following uses are Dermitted. shall be allowed subject to obtaining a conditional use
permit, as provided by chapter 23 of this title.
Page 13
47
A. Mobile home parks, subject to all applicable building regulations and division 13,
part 2 (commencing with section 18000) of the California Health and Safety Code.
B. Other similar uses approved by the d4rester cf ccomm4r+ity, atincmia vznd
development ooriioes Director, as provided by chapter 22 of this title."
SECTION 11: ESMC §15-4A-6 "Site Development Standards for Lots Wider than
Twenty Five Feet" is amended to read as follows (strikethr^„^" is language deleted, and
underlined is language added):
"15-4A-6: SITE DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR LOTS WIDER THAN TWENTY
FIVE FEET:
All uses on lots that are wider than 25 +w +fie feet {2,54 within the R-1 zone must
comply with the development standards contained in this section.
A. General Provisions:
1. As provided by chapter 2 of this title.
2. New dwelling units must be internally integrated and connected.
3. An addition to, or extension of, a dwelling unit, except a garage or an accessory
dwellinc unit, must share a common wall and be internally integrated and
connected to the existing dwelling unit.
B. Height: The height of all buildings must not exceed 26 feet and 2 stories. dwelling
units t G®s xGeed tvArenty aix oa: (25') and hva (2) @torioc, o)toopt as provided in
sub000tion N cf thic-se-Gt4en. Tho ho ght of all other one story buildings and
detaoh ed—l"-csoacry Oructuros, inoluding-detaGhed-garegoa, Baannot www-Z4
fou ften fcc� (14'y
v rage of-
Highest Gable
Accessory Dwelling Unit
Structure
weight of ell other two Flory build11°c`"i°Iti--detaohad awcc&sarny ctn;oturoc, inGluding
detaahed-garcgca, oannot mint not ewn; e ' the he 4t0ro primary-dwetl pg
Page 14
48
-dftw -,2- Average of
Hf h ;-Gable
26'Max I!
...
Structure
Height shall be measured from the finish grade or natural grade adjacent to the
building or structure. whichever is lower.
C. Lot Area: A minimum of fivo thout)&nd (5,000) square feet.
D. Setbacks:
1. Front Aand Rear Yards: The combined total of setbacks for the front and rear
yards must be at least 30 ##icy feet , with no front yard setback less than
22 mo w$feet(22')and no rear yard setback less than 5 five feet(-5!. Front
yard setbacks for two-(2)-car and three (3)=-car garages located in the front half
of a lot must comely with the standards contained bo ac de oribad in the
plaGement of �04Rgs nd otruoture-- roquirements in subsection G of this
section.
a. Permitted Front Yard Setback Encroachments:
(1) Porches or verandas in a front yard setback not fully enclosed on three
(3) sides (railings and/or columns permitted) may encroach into the
front setback a maximum of 6 six feet (W) in cloth;
(2) The first floor front yard setback facing exterior wall of a dwelling may
encroach up to 2 two feet (2' for a width not exceeding 30 t" feet
(304 when a first floor porch or veranda, not fully enclosed on three 04
sides, is also projecting into the front yard setback. The total amount of
encroachment may not exceed 6 six feet(64 in depth combined for both
the dwelling structure and a porch or veranda, for a maximum 50-fifty
percent(50%) of the building width not to exceed 30 thirty feet(30-;
(3) Courtyards (with walls not exceeding 42 inches in height) may encroach
into the front yard setback a maximum of 6six feet (6'} and 504i#y
percent(50%) of the building width not to exceed 20 tweMy feet(204;
(4) Raised decks not greater than 24 twenty fGuF inches (24") above
adiacent qrade constructed in conjunction with a lattice deck cover not
greater than 10 tern feet (4-0' above adiacent grade may encroach into
Page 15 49
the front yard setback a maximum of 6 sjx feet(64 in depth and 50--firfty
percent(50°x) of the building width not to exceed 20 twer#v feet(2-04;
(5) Lattice patio covers not greater than 10 tea feet (444 above adjacent
grade may encroach into the front yard setback a maximum of 6 s+x feet
(64 in depth and 50 fifty percent (50%) of the building width not to
exceed 2C? twenty feet(204;
(6) Architectural elements such as towers or turrets not greater than 8 eight
feet(8!yin diameter may encroach into the front setback a maximum of
4 fear feet(4);
(7) Pergolas not greater than 10 tea feet ODD in overall height as
measured from lowest grade adjacent to the pergola, to the hiahest
point of the taeraola) that are attached to the dwelling may encroach
into the front setback a maximum of 6 sjx feet (6) in depth and 50-fifty
percent(50°x) of the width not to exceed 20 twenty feet Q-G0 in width;
(8) An arbor or trellis, not exceeding 8 eight feet (8') in overall height Lq=s
measured from lowest grade adjacent to the arbor or trellis. to the
highest point of the arbor or trellis and 8 eight feet (8-) in width may
encroach into the front yard setback.
2. Side Yard: Structures must maintain a minimum setback on each side of the lot
of 10-tea percent(10%)of the width of the lot, but can never be less than 3 three
feet(34 and than not be more than 6 six feet (64. Silo }nrd ootbaGk „eery "^+
hu-a more than five feet (6') fog a
an_��_si,�gle cte-, additions, or f r s uoocnd ttzrj
addition-the &-vim-add moro than five--h4ndrod (500) cq ect,�,q to the
e;(iotir,g otruoturo. Sid° -eetba r�lia k for new a ingt, (000nd * additions
to dwellings, or additiens te dwelliRg6 that add mere than five hundined (500)
squa foot in erex to the exist, -Vuetwo M Gernply with tho Blew
a4d tine eRtS if;002 on a lot grea or then feity#oo} (10" 1
a--Moduli tiGn -GGeYe_eRd floor exterior nerimete, , is must ocG ur on the
seGend floor of the-dwe" that ho equal to a minimum of fifteen per en}
(16%) of tho rq oso bUilding aFea (inGlu&Rc_ Taira^ems ands the
gr3und floor, but rrat lee s_th n4vio hundred (200) 3q:a--re first of area
b. KI^_ lalatjer,-efhe-seso►d-floe exterer perimcfor wa4smuste^ r e
oido of the--struots;ro that f=oa the side_yard
G. The total area FeqwiFed te be modulated must be divided.- _'Iy between
ho nes -f the r~Wdj.ng f=hg tho oide
d—Medel,ati mlest be ^ minim,em of four foot (4') fir, depth and mutt be--a
Mcnimum depth.
Page 16 50
e: la add ition31 medal 4Gn io rogs;iFed if thri ox4er4or-��f tho coscn444
facing cr...oh oido yard iw plc an smeont thrt is-eq�jsl to tho ten-pefseRt
f. If a p9#iee-e44h° ,,eGevnnd -F faRi..9 a side and is sot haG- an a—u-)uP 4hat
is oqual to ton porsont (19%) cf tho le idth-piw,ae-additional four foot (9')
to-sk4eet (6') in depth, that port+an may oount t3 wardo the--tots' require
arc^ of mod ula-tien-a�i in ujbces#ien�2a� ofth�,T
3. Setbacks for Detached Accessory Structures:
Detached accessory structures, including garages, must maintain a
minimum setback on each side of the lot of 10-tee percent (10%) of the
width of the lot, but may not saapaet-be less than 3 three feet (34 and need
not be more than 6 s�x feet (6'} on the first floor=
b) The second floor of a detached accessory structure. includina D'araaes,
must maintain -and a minimum setback on each side of the lot of 10-teR
percent(1Q%) of the width of the lot plus an additional setback of 2_Wwe--feet
(2-4, but may not Gannet be less than 5 five feet (5} and need not be more
than 8 eight feet(--on th© se,,.,n Moor
c)--Detached accessory structures, including garages, that are only one story
in height and are located in the rear or a-third Oa) of the lot, must maintain
a minimum side setback of 2 two feet(2}.
d)—Detached accessory structures that are 2 t stories high, and located
in the rear eRe-third 03) of the lot, must maintain a minimum side setback
of 2 two feet (2'} on the first floor and a minimum 5 five feet (won the
second floor. Mached ^ ges Yenty five-foot (25) Mdo loto only;
o roar oro third (1 3)-ewe Ic., cro al#owed zoro rotbaok-Gn-eRe
intorjor side lot lines'
e) Detached accessory structures must maintain a minimum setback of 3 feet
from the rear ❑ropertv line on the first floor and must maintain a minimum
setback of 5 feet from the rear orooerty Fine on the second floor.
f)--Rooftop decks with required goa-rdrailings are permitted on either single-
story accessory structures and on top of the single-story portions of two-
story accessory structures. Rooftop decks are not permitted on top of two-
story accessory structures. Rooftop decks must maintain a minimum
setback on each side of the lot of 10-ten percent (10%) of the width of the
lot, plus an additional setback of 2 two feet (2'} but can never be less than
5 We feet, (5� as measured from the ofQuerty line to the required railina of
the rooftop deck.
4. Side Yard, Reversed Corner: Reversed corner lots must have the following side
yard with a triangular area described as follows: One angle must be formed by
Page 17 51
the rear and street side property lines, and the sides of this angle must be 15
#+Been feet 0-&- in length, measured along the rear and street side property
lines. The third side of this triangle must be a straight line connecting the two-423
other lines at their endpoints. This triangular side yard setback area is in addition
to the other side yard setback requirements described in subsection D2 of this
section.
5. Rear Yard: Structures must maintain a minimum setback of 5 five feet (&} on
the first and second floors. Detaohed ooacoor�"&tr-wGtu6m Not ma nta%n a
minimum WbQck cf t*cr fcrot (3) from tho raw prsporty lino on tho first flee
aPA4nvot rr&itain a m4nimum cotbook of five feot (V) fr,om the��P��*4 e
en-the ei:.
Front
-V 06 COM-Nned S-W-baok
Front + Raar _ Combined
25` + 6 ,
51000 sf Mih. _
Lot. Size
YY
MI Min,
S& Mitt. �
at Rear of
Prom Ywd
6. Exceptions: Notwithstanding the provisions of this subsection D, the west side
yard of 618 W. Oak Avenue, more particularly described as the north 142.5 feet
of the south 285 feet of the east 50.265 feet of Lot 14, Block 9, Tract No. 1685,
commencing 63 feet south of the front lot line and continuing south a distance
of 30 feet, must be 3 three inches k3l} in width so long as that certain structure
located along that 30 t" foot (304 distance which existed on January 11,
1973, remains in existence. Upon the removal or destruction of said building,
this property is no longer exempt from this subsection D.
Notwithstanding the provisions of this subsection D, the south side yard of 724
Penn Street, more particularly described as the south 55 feet of the north 110
feet of Lot 8, Block 92, El Segundo Sheet No. 4, commencing 84 feet east of
the front lot line and continuing east a distance of 20 feet, must be 3 three feet
(34 in width so long as that certain structure located along that 20 twenty foot
(29'} distance which existed on January 11, 1973, remains in existence. Upon
Page 18
52
the removal or destruction of said building, this property is no longer exempt
from this subsection D.
E. Lot Width: Every lot created after the effective date hereof must maintain a width
of not less than §.Ofifty feet (504 at the rear line of+h° required front yard setback
line. However, any lot or parcel of land of record on May 14, 1954, having a street
frontage not exceeding 200 two-hundred feet 200 , may be subdivided into twe
(2) or more parcels having a width of not less than the average width of the
narrowest 20 twent-y percent (20%) of the lots fronting on its block. The "block" is
defined as the area on both sides of the street between the nearest intersecting
streets. Each parcel must have an area of not less than five th ' sand45,000)
square feet.
F. Floor Area Ratio.-__,l Zing Ara: !ie minimum Tr° enient-Tho total gr000 fluter
aroo of all- WFs g3, ac dcfine� in oc�icn IF 1 5-cf thin titlo, on any-pa rGel OF 1
forty feat('10`) -r wider in`vidth oannot eax000d tho total squaFe footage of tho parool
Gr- ar a multiplied by 0.6Z, th8Feby giving ° floor area ratio °f 0.62 to stye
(3.52:1). Tho floor aros � query footage Of GeGG d
ding unitis and Ooon^entiS where at least (90%) of the o)ctcriof
perimeter walls of the ser.ond wging unit or basemntc arc fuV.y bolew--natural
gr
1. The maximum total buildina area on the lot shall not exceed an overall Floor
Area Ratio (FAR) of 0.60. There is no minimum buildina size.
2. The maximum FAR for the second floor of the primary structure shall not exceed
0.25.
3. In calculating the overall FAR, floor area is measured to the interior of a
building's perimeter wails and shall include all floors of the r)rimary dwelling
(i.e.. main structure), attached and detached accessory dwellina units,
habitable attic space, accesso-w buildings. and balconies. decks. verandas and
porches.
4. Areas where the vertical measurement between the floor and ceiling directly
above is 14-feet or more shall be counted on both the first and second stories
for FAR calculations (areas such as rotundas, spaces with vaulted ceilings. and
other similar areas with volume).
5. Stairs and elevators are counted once and are aDDlied to the first floor.
6. For aurr)oses of calculating floor area. the following are not included:
a. Basements as defined in Section 15-1-6,
b. Ur) to 500 square feet of interior floor area of an attached or detached
garage
Page 19
53
c. Detached accessory structures measuring not more than 120 sauare feet„
d. Up to 500 square feet cumulative of first floor decks. verandas and porches.
covered or uncovered. attached or detached. and not more than 4 feet in
height (as measured from adiacent Grade to the walking surface). provided
that the deck, veranda or porch is at least 50 Dercent open on the sides.
e. Second floor balconies and decks that are not covered.
f. Ur) to 12 sauare feet of second floor decks and balconies that are covered
by roof. lattice or trellis.
a. The area of decks. balconies. va(andas or porches covered by eave
proiections up to 18 inches
7. In cases of uncertainty or ambia_ulty. the Director will determine whether an area
is counted toward FAR.
G. Placement Of of,Buildings and And Structures:
1. AT-he minimum distance of 3 feet must be maintained between buildings-is
regulated by tho California Bu Iding Code;
2. A detached single-story accessory structure in the rear eRe-third of the lot
may be located as described in the requirements for setbacks in subsection D
of this section, unless one of the following conditions exists:
a. Where the lot abuts rears upon an alley and the vehicular entrance to the
detached accessory structure is from the alley, such detached accessory
structure must be set back a distance measured from the opposite side of the
alley that will provide a turning radius as follows:
90 degrees - 25 feet
75 degrees - 21 feet
60 degrees - 18 feet
45 degrees - 15 feet
b. On the rear third of a reversed corner lot a single-story detached accessory
structure may be built to the interior lot side line, but no building may Rat be
erected closer than 5 five feet{5}to the property line of any abutting lot to the
rear. However, if an alley intervenes and the vehicular entrance to the
detached accessory building is directly from the street side, a detached
accessory building may be built to the rear lot line.
3. A garage that is attached to a dwelling that is located in the front half of the lot
facing the front property line must be set back a minimum of 24 twentyfouf feet
{24'} from the front property line unless the building has a porch, veranda,
Page 20
54
courtyard or deck at least 8_6ght feet (&' in width by 4,-few feet (4'} in depth,
then a minimum front setback of 22_twenty-twe feet (2,14 is permitted.
4. An attached three 3=) car garage located in the front half of the lot that faces
the front property line where one of the stalls is not tandem, must have at least
tw&42) individual car door openings. The following garage designs are
encouraged) car garages located on the front of a dwelling face toward the side
property lines.
a.Three-(3}-car garages constructed as attached or detached structures at the
rear of a lot.
b.Tandem paFkiRg for parking provided in excess of a twG42=) car garage.
c. Attached three X3_3 car garages located on the front of a dwelling face toward
the side property lines.
5. Accessory outdoor showers attached to a building wall are permitted, but panne
must not encroach in a required setback and Gannet must not be roofed. They
may be enclosed with walls on three (3) sides and a shower door on one side.
buildings rump#c.� eighteen-feet en fee '
'--',. Lot ���erago. /111 awit , than G-�-�,--�-�t (1 Q) is
s�ot=hod asoosse ry hL rtgc, canna seue-r-mvre than thirty five porcnnt (2(-%) of
the lot area. Thit coerrcgo msy bo inoroasod to aimY n° 0%) if all
on the tot arc siaglc otol, and do not 1 Q') ir: hc�5ht, If the
bsdidings loalsd an the lat vrc a ocn4gfetion of cne en4-4wo (2) otorie s where
Gix* erGent total area dGe r, not eXGe ed eighteen feet (184
in he ght, the I!\ Ceyg ege-muot not be--riofe than forty thm p°Y^°n# fA 101�
repeF oo that ar"ermitted t4-h. - - sec n -'�g snit sa.A44at oovor more
tlan forty PeFGeRt cf the lot aroa if thcr �uildingo 9ver eighteen fee#
(18') in he ght an the PFepe irro that am permitted to have a SeGend-dwe
unit mnnn#a+n�ee�r rnRrn than Bart--sevfie 4472%) cif thv lot aroc if a\I tmildi-ngs
er+4h° lot of exeod o�Shteen foot (18') in height. �;ave porohoo and m.,e-s
Page 21
55
.. ......................
■..................
....... ......
.............. ..............
A+13 A+13 :560% if A+ 3% if no
bl ight is bldg. height is more t IYO of
r 18' single-story bldg B is ov
in height
a.-�'ding-Wal4--Modulation-.—A4:GhitectLirciI butilding fleatures, On confbr-imanGe-with4he
def4nition-of-�rGhiteGtL4ra4-Wlding4,eatufe'L- secfi,g,. 15 1 this-tits&,-mA4st-be
inG4udad to modulsto tho one: story o.ttorior buildhg-waI"i4bjeGt-to th-_ approval
of tho dirootar of planning &n� building �fxt"nd fcr two c;kipry atruGtu-r-es-as
�ppL-cifilL,d in .),Ataeobon D, of this-se'CA' ieR-.
H.J-. Detached Accessory Buildings. not including detached accessory dwellinq nj s
as defined in Section 15-1-6:
1. Any detached accessory building or combination of accessory buildings, except
the garage, may not uonnot be larger in gross floor area than six hundred 4600}
square feet;
2. Detached accessory buildings are limited to two (2) stories, and may include an
attic, which may be used for storage purposes only, provided that-access to the
attic is not from permanently fixed stairs (pull down type stairs are permitted),
no plumbing is permitted, and electrical fixtures are limited to the minimum
required by the California Building Code (GBG) and natienal California
Eelectrical CGode (NEC);
Page 22 56
3. Unless permitted as an accessory dwelling unit.Gdetached accessory buildings
may not Ganflet contain a kitchen or kitchen facilities, a bathtub or shower and
cannot be used for sleeping purposes or as an "R" occupancy, as defined by
the California Building Code (Gl3G), except that they may contain a sink and a
toilet;
4. Detached accessory buildings Est-mav not be rented or used as a separate
dwelling unit; and,
5. Before the city issues a building permit for a detached accessory structure,
except a garage, the Director dire#-p4n.Ring and build�nS oafs y-will t
require that a covenant running with the land must be recorded stating that the
accessory structure samnef--ma_v not be used as a dwelling unit or used in
violation of this section."
SECTION 12: ESMC §15-4A-6-1 "Site Development Standards for Lots twenty Five Feet
Wide or Less" is amended to read as follows (stFikethro g-h is language deleted, and
underlined. is language added):
"15-4A-6-1: SITE DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR LOTS TWENTY FIVE FEET
WIDE OR LESS:
All uses on lots 25 twenty five feet{2-5'}wide or less within the R-1 zone must comply with
the development standards contained in this section.
A. General Provisions:
1. As provided by chapter 2 of this title.
2. New dwelling units must be internally integrated and connected.
3. An addition to, or extension of, a dwelling unit, except a garage or an accessory
dwellinq=Un.it, must share a common wall and be internally integrated and
connected to the existing dwelling unit.
B. Height: The height of all dwelling units cannot may not exceed twenty-six feet (26')
and two (2) stories, e,.rept as previde in a"", cstlen H of thin uect+en. The height
of all other buildings and detached accessory structures, including detached
garages, oannot-may no exceed 14#eerteen feet-(444 .
Page 23
57
Aver of
Highest Gavle
Dwelling Unit l
Structure
Height shall be measured from the finish grade or natural grade adiacent to the
building or structure. whichever is lower.
C. Lot Area: A minimum of fkm- thoucand (5,000) square feet.
D. Setbacks:
1. Front And Rear Yard: The combined total of setbacks for the front and rear yard
must beat least 30 thirty feet{39'), with no front yard setback less than 22�t-y
two feet R-2-� and no rear yard setback less than 5 five feet(54.
2. Side Yard: Structures must maintain a minimum setback on each side of the lot
of 10 te-R percent (IQ%) of the width of the lot, but can never be less than three
feet (3') and need not be more than 5 five feet {54.
3. Detached Accessory Structures and Garages: Detached accessory structures
and attached aaraaes are allowed alonV the Dror)ertv line on one interior side
lot line. provided that the detached accessory structure or attached aaraae is
located in the rear one-third ('/s) of the lot, aro allowad zors ootbaok on e
i#orior oide`!eg4no. Attsohud gcragoo on twenty_fivo foot (26") wide-9ta-GP
looatod csn the roar ano third (1h) of ±ho 13#;-afe a IS allowed zoro ootbaolc on
ono int-Nor sides let l Rea
4. Side Yard, Reversed Corner: Reversed corner lots must have the following side
yard with a triangular area described as follows: One angle must be formed by
the rear and street side property lines, and the sides of this angle must be 15
fifteen feet {1-54 in length, measured along the rear and street side property
lines. The third side of this triangle must be a straight line connecting the two (2)
other lines at their endpoints. This triangular side yard setback area is in addition
to the other side yard setback requirements described in subsection D2 of this
section.
5. Rear Yard: Structures must maintain a minimum setback of 5 fife feet}.
Detached accessory structures are allowed zero setback on the rear property
line.
Page 24
58
Front t ood Eck Exei
' Front+ Rear = rood
2' + - 3Q'
317
5.01M tf Alin, �
Lot Situ ,
Min ,
rry 4-
i Min.
81 hear at
FrOM Yard
Front
Combined setback example:
c
Front+rear=combined
22'+0'=30'
c5 25'+5'=30'
N
r
Y
10%of lot width;3-ft 10%of lot width;3-ft
min.5-ft max min.5-ft max
d
E
rn
25-Foot max.
[ it
6. EAHOOPW G.—Net ithstanding tho p5evisiona of this sub 3s�ion D, the-west-side
}urd of '.'. 001 Ava nue mcro porti=i rly doacribo a he ^^rth 112,2-foot
of the s sqh 'WiQ5 foss of the east 5Q.-165 foot of Lot 11, QIOGk , Traot No—. I &,
GomrnellGiAg E2 foot ✓auth of the front lot lino and oorlt4uinS ceuth a, distanre
of 30 feat, mutt bo thrro94n (3") in width oo 1sng so thot seftain 3trw1,'%',re
IOGated along that 39 thi"et4W) d iota nc\ A*" eh atoll on January 11,
4-973, roma'm in 3idoWnm �.Ipon tho rern3val or d�efl of maid buildi n�
tl#o prone y rc\hall no Ionyer be excvrlpt from thio oubseGtks�.
Page 25 59
l stwrwFthotandiog the provi,s,,�f thia oiubceGtion D, the erjuth oide-yar--e#-x-24
Penn Str ot, mo�ire�f cloaoribod sc the gout -55 #mot of the r/-,Fth 4 1�9
foot of Lot P,, BIGG --82, El Segundo :. eet--Nc. 4, commonoing V font ocst-of
tie-frotnt lot lino end continuing oaot a diatonoe cf 29-foot, must bo ?thFee feet
�Idth co long-asAhat oortain ornruoturo looQtc� along that ?g-twe�BBt
(20') Aista oe w IGh �a�/xi&t�.� �,ey Jcviva''py 1072, samainc in and n✓o. Upon
tho romo�f°' e-stR"on of o&id bu4d4ng, this property � er- hL 6fY1pt
,� is no ron�_. �.:_...�..
fpGM44 f'.+ ouboost44A4 :
E. Lot Width: Every lot created after the effective date hereof must maintain a width
of not less than fifty feet (50') at the rear line of the required front yard. However,
any lot or parcel of land of record on May 14, 1954, having a street frontage not
exceeding two hundred feet (200'), may be subdivided into two (2) or more parcels
having a width of not less than the average width of the narrowest twenty percent
(20%) of the lots fronting on its block. The "block" is defined as the area on both
sides of the street between the nearest intersecting streets. Each parcel must have
an area of not less than five thousand (5,000) square feet.
F. Building Area: No minimum requirement.
G. Placement of Of Buildings and ARd Structures:
1. The distance between buildings is regulated by the California Building Code;
2. A detached accessory structure in the rear one third {443} of the lot may be
located on the rear and one interior side lot line, unless one of the following
conditions exists:
a. Where the lot rears upon an alley and the vehicular entrance to the
detached accessory structure is from the alley, such detached accessory
structure must be set back a distance measured from the opposite side of
the alley that will provide a turning radius as follows:
90 degrees - 25 feet
75 degrees - 21 feet
60 degrees - 18 feet
45 degrees - 15 feet
b. On the rear third of a reversed corner lot a detached accessory structure may
be built to the interior lot side line, but no building must be erected closer than
5 f+ve feet 454 to the property line of any abutting lot to the rear. However, if
an alley intervenes and the vehicular entrance to the detached accessory
building is directly from the street side, a detached accessory building may
be built to the rear lot line.
H. Lot Coverage: All buildings, including detached accessory buildings, shall not
cover more than :j=04erty percent (40%) of the lot area. This coverage may be
increased to 47 forty oovon percent(4 7%) if the height of all the structures is limited
Page 26
60
to 18 eighteen feet 494. If a building exceeds 105 18 . We4aR feet 0-8'} in height, the
="
lot coverage shall not exceed 440-" percent (40%) under any circumstances.
......................:3
......................................
A+B —<40% if A+B 547% if
bldg. height is bldg. height is
over 18'. 18' or under.
1, Building Wall Modulation: Architectural building features, in conformance with the
definition of "architectural building feature" in section 15-1-6 of this title, must be
included to modulate the one-story exterior building walls subject to the approval
of the Director, diFeGteF of plan g-apd-bt&.4�y and for two-story structures
as specified in subsection D, "Setbacks", of this section.
J. Detached Accessory Buildings, not including_ detached accessory dwellina units as
defined in Section 15-1-6::
1. Any detached accessory building or combination of accessory buildings, except
the garage, GaRf4G•mav not be larger in gross floor area than six hundred (600)
square feet;
2. Detached accessory buildings are limited to one floor, but may include an attic,
which may be used for storage purposes only, provided access to the attic is
not from permanently fixed stairs (pull down type stairs are permitted), no
plumbing is permitted, and electrical fixtures are limited to the minimum required
by the California building code (CBC) and national electrical code (NEC);
3. Detached accessory buildings --\-.nnot maw not contain- a kitchen or kitchen
facilities, a bathtub or shower and GaR-notmav not be used for sleeping purposes
or as an R occupancy, as defined by the California building code (CBC), except
that they may contain a sink and a toilet;
Page 27 61
4. Detached accessory buildings Gannot may not be rented or used as a separate
dwelling unit; and
5. Before the city issues a building permit for a detached accessory structure,
except a garage, the director of planning and building safety must require that a
covenant running with the land be recorded stating that the accessory structure
met may not be used as a dwelling unit or used in violation of this section."
SECTION 13: ESMC §15-4A-7 "Landscaping" is amended to read as follows
(6tFikethr^„^" is language deleted, and underlined is language added):
"15-4A-7: LANDSCAPING:
Landscaping and irrigation must be provided within the front and street side setback
areas. Those setback areas fronting upon a public street must incorporate a combination
of soft (plantings) and hard (rock, brick, concrete) landscape materials, except for those
portions devoted to vehicular parking.
A. A minimum of 25-twenty-five percent " , of the front yard setback area must be
maintained with permanent landscaping that contains a combination of lawn, trees,
vines, bushes and ground covers, and does not include hard landscape materials
for lots less than 50fa#y feet (504 in width.
B. A minimum of 35 thirty fide percent (35%) of the front yard setback area must be
maintained with permanent landscaping that contains a combination of lawn, trees,
vines, bushes and ground covers, and does not include hard landscape materials
for lots that are 50fafty feet{504 or greater in width."
SECTION 14: ESMC §15-4A-8 "Off Street Parking and Loading Spaces" is amended to
read as follows (StFikethF^„n" is language deleted, and underlined is language added):
"15-4A-8: OFF STREET PARKING AND LOADING SPACES:
Off street parking must be provided as required by chapter 15 of this title but in no case
can a driveway or curb cut be less than 10te-R feet 40' in width. Where the driveway
access and curb cut is to a 2 twe(2) car or larger garage which exits directly onto the
front street, the driveway and curb cut sanRG may not be less than 16 sixteen feet
in width. Driveway entrances and exit locations including curb cuts must be provided in
conformance with subsection 15-15-50 of this title."
SECTION 15: ESMC §15-4A-9 "Signs" is amended to read as follows (strikethFou h is
language deleted, and underlined is language added):
"15-4A-9: SIGNS:
Page 28 62
Signs in the R-1 zone &I} must comply with the requirements of chapter 18 of this title."
SECTION 16: ESMC §15-4A-10 "Vehicular Access" is amended to read as follows
(6tFikethr^„^" is language deleted, and underlined is language added):
"15-4A-10: VEHICULAR ACCESS:
Where an R-1 lot abuts an alley, vehicular access to the lot must be from the alley, except
when 80-ekjht-y percent (80%) or more of the properties on the block have existing
vehicular access from the street. For the purposes of this section, the "block" is defined
as the properties on the same side of the street between the nearest intersecting streets.
Carte auto and driv ,f b/o insta4ed4n vonformanc/_� atjen 16 1A 8 of this
arltiolo and "s ^*�,n k 15 5I' of this t),t!e-."
SECTION 17: Subsection A of ESMC §15-15-6 "Required Parking Spaces" is amended
to read as follows (strikethroug-14 is language deleted, and underlined is language added):
"A. Automobile Spaces Required:
Use Number Of Parking Spaces Required
Accessory dwelling units Refer to SSMC 154E
Single-family and two-family 2 spaces for each dwelling unit and 1 additional
dwellings space for dwelling units exceeding 3,500 3,998
square feet of ids floor area
x
SECTION 18: CONSTRUCTION. This Ordinance must be broadly construed in order to
achieve the purposes stated in this Ordinance. It is the City Council's intent that the
provisions of this Ordinance be interpreted or implemented by the City and others in a
manner that facilitates the purposes set forth in this Ordinance.
SECTION 19: ENFORCEABILITY. Repeal of any provision of the ESMC does not affect
any penalty, forfeiture, or liability incurred before, or preclude prosecution and imposition
of penalties for any violation occurring before this Ordinance's effective date. Any such
repealed part will remain in full force and effect for sustaining action or prosecuting
violations occurring before the effective date of this Ordinance.
Page 29
63
SECTION 20: VALIDITY OF PREVIOUS CODE SECTIONS. If this entire Ordinance or
its application is deemed invalid by a court of competent jurisdiction, any repeal or
amendment of the ESMC or other city ordinance by this Ordinance will be rendered void
and cause such previous ESMC provision or other the city ordinance to remain in full
force and effect for all purposes.
SECTION 21: SEVERABILITY. If any part of this Ordinance or its application is deemed
invalid by a court of competent jurisdiction, the City Council intends that such invalidity
will not affect the effectiveness of the remaining provisions or applications and, to this
end, the provisions of this Ordinance are severable.
SECTION 22: The City Clerk is directed to certify the passage and adoption of this
Ordinance; cause it to be entered into the City of El Segundo's book of original
ordinances; make a note of the passage and adoption in the records of this meeting; and,
within fifteen (15) days after the passage and adoption of this Ordinance, cause it to be
published or posted in accordance with California law.
SECTION 23: This Ordinance will go into effect and be in full force and effect on the
thirty-first (31st) day after its passage and adoption. Upon the effective date of the
Ordinance, the Ordinance will apply to building plans submitted to the City of El Segundo
for plan check for construction, reconstruction or remodeling of structures within the R-1
Zone. Building plans that have been submitted to the City of El Segundo for plan check
for construction, reconstruction or remodeling of structures within the R-1 Zone prior to
the Effective Date are exempt from the regulations contained within this Ordinance, even
if such projects have not yet obtained a permit to commence construction.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this day of 2017.
Suzanne Fuentes, Mayor
ATTEST:
STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ) SS
CITY OF EL SEGUNDO )
I, Tracy Weaver, City Clerk of the City of El Segundo, California, do hereby certify that
the whole number of members of the City Council of said City is five; that the foregoing
Ordinance No. was duly introduced by said City Council at a regular meeting held
on the day of , 2017, and was duly passed and adopted by said City
Council, approved and signed by the Mayor, and attested to by the City Clerk, all at a
regular meeting of said Council held on the day of 2017, and the same
was so passed and adopted by the following vote:
Page 30
64
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
Tracy Weaver, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Mark D. Hensley, City Attorney
Page 31
65
RESOLUTION NO. 2810
A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
EL SEGUNDO RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL ADOPT AN
ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE 15 OF THE EL SEGUNDO MUNICIPAL
CODE REGARDING REGULATIONS FOR PROPERTIES IN THE
SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL (R-1) ZONE, DEFINITIONS AND THE
PARKING REQUIREMENTS FOR SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES.
(EA NO. 1064 and ZTA NO. 14-01)
The Planning Commission of the City of El Segundo does resolve as follows:
SECTION 1: The Planning Commission finds and declares that:
A. On April 5, 2016, the City Council directed Staff to prepare a Zoning Code
Amendment that would clean up the R-1 Zone development standards
and improve/eliminate modulation requirements for the Planning
Commission's and City Council's consideration;
B. On September 22, 2016, the Planning Commission formed the R1
Modulation Subcommittee comprised of seven members, including
members from the Council, Planning Commission, local residents and
architects. The subcommittee was tasked with exploring alternatives to
the current modulation standards that regulate second stories in the R1,
Single-Family residential zone, and to propose alternatives to the concept
or the language of the regulations contained in the City's Zoning Code.
C. The R1 Subcommittee met weekly during October, and formulated draft
regulations to address second story residential structures.
D. On November 10, 2016, the Planning Commission conducted a public
forum to review the Subcommittee's draft development standards for two-
story homes and second story additions in the R1 zone, and provide staff
with feedback on the draft regulations.
E. The City reviewed the project's environmental impacts under the
California Environmental Quality Act (California Public Resources Code
§§ 21000, et seq., "CEQA") and the regulations promulgated thereunder
(14 California Code of Regulations §§ 15000, et seq., the "CEQA
Guidelines"), and the City's Environmental Guidelines (City Council
Resolution No. 3805, adopted March 16, 1993);
F. On January 12, 2017, the Planning Commission held a public hearing to
receive public testimony and other evidence regarding the proposed
1
66
amendments, including, without limitation, information provided to the
Planning Commission by City staff and public testimony; and,
G. This Resolution and its findings are made based upon the evidence
presented to the Commission at its January 12, 2017, hearing including,
without limitation, the staff report submitted by the Planning and Building
Safety Department.
SECTION 2: Factual Findings and Conclusions. The Planning Commission finds,
without limitation, that the proposed ordinance to amend ESMC §15-4A regulating the
single-family residential (R-1) zone would result in the following:
A. The proposed amendment to the ESMC modifies ESMC Chapters 15-4A
regulating Single-Family Residential (R-1) Zone Site Development
Standards; 15-1 Definitions; and 15-15-6A, parking requirements for single-
family residences.
B. The General Plan Land Use designation for the affected properties in the
Single-Family Residential (R-1) Zone is Single-Family Residential.
C. It replaces an inaccurate setback diagram for parcels 25 feet or less in
width.
D. Deletes the modulation requirements, and deletes the building wall
modulation using architectural features requirements for lots 40-feet wide
or wider.
E. Creates a maximum floor area ratio (FAR) for lots 40-feet wide or wider,
with standards that include a maximum FAR, limits the size of second
stories, and defines the areas that constitute floor area in on R1 zoned
properties.
F. It deletes redundant language by expressing numbers as digits, rather than
a combination of using digits and writing out the number in words.
G. It increases the threshold for requiring a 3rd parking space, from 3,000
square feet of floor area to 3,500 square feet of floor area
H. It updates certain existing definitions, and creates new definitions for
residential areas, features, structures or improvements found in the R1 zone
standards.
I. The proposed amendment to the ESMC that modifies Chapters 15-4A
regulating Single-Family Residential (R-1) Zone Site Development
Standards; 15-1 Definitions; and 15-15-6A parking requirements for single-
family residential relate only to the new construction of a single-family
2
67
residence in the City's R-1 Zone, an urbanized area; alterations and
additions to existing residential structures in the R-1 Zone that involve
negligible expansion of an existing use; repair and maintenance of existing
residential structures in the City's R-1 Zone that involve no expansion
beyond what is permitted in the R-1 Zone; and new construction of
accessory structures including garages, carports and patios in the City's R-
1 Zone.
SECTION 3: Environmental Assessment. Based upon the facts set forth in Section 2,
the proposed zone text amendment is exempt from further review under the California
Environmental Quality Act (California Public Resources Code §§ 21000, et seq., "CEQA")
and the regulations promulgated thereunder(14 California Code of Regulations§§ 15000,
et seq., the "CEQA Guidelines") because it consists only of minor revisions and
clarifications to existing zoning regulations and procedures related thereto and will not
have the effect of substantially changing any regulatory standards or findings required
therefor. The proposed Ordinance is an action that does not have the potential to cause
significant effects on the environment, but rather will help reduce the impact of new
construction in residential zone property on the environment. Accordingly, the proposed
Ordinance constitutes a Class 1 (existing facilities), Class 3 (new construction or
conversion of small structures), and Class 4 (minor alteration to land) categorical
exemptions. In addition, this ordinance constitutes a component of the ESMC which the
Planning Commission determined to be consistent with the General Plan FEIR. Further,
any environmental impacts associated with this ordinance are adequately addressed in
the General Plan FEIR. Consequently, no further environmental review is required.
SECTION 4: General Plan Findings. As required under Government Code § 65860 the
ESMC amendments proposed by the Ordinance are consistent with the El Segundo
General Plan as follows:
A. The amendment conforms with the Land Use Element Goals, Objectives and
Policies. Specifically, the amendment is consistent with Goal LU1, Objective LU1-
1, Goal LU3, in that the amendment as a comprehensive whole create polices,
design standards, and helps create a sense of place for the entire City; preserves
and maintains the City's low-medium density residential nature, with low building
height profile and character, and minimum development standards; adopting the
amendment ensures the preservation, protection and extension of existing single-
family residential uses; and promotes the health, safety, and well being of the
people of El Segundo by adopting standards for the proper balance, relationship,
and distribution of the residential land uses at all times in accordance with
applicable law.
B. The proposed text amendment to the Single-Family (R-1) Zone Site Development
Standards, Definitions, Open Space Encroachments and Off-Street Parking
Requirements conforms with the General Plan. The proposed changes do not
modify or increase the maximum density of dwelling units per acre currently
allowed in the Single-Family Residential Land Use designation. As a result, the
3
68
proposed Zone Text Amendment conforms to the Land Use Element of the
General Plan.
C. The amendment conforms to the Land Use Element Goals, Objectives and
Policies. Specifically, the amendment is consistent with Goal LU1 and Objectives
LU1-1 and LU3-2, in that the minor code changes make corrections to existing
exhibits and code language and clarifies the Single-Family Residential (R-1) Zone
regulations. The R-1 Zone establishes comprehensive regulations to preserve
and maintain the City's low-medium density residential nature, with low building
height profile and character. Large portions of the City are zoned R-1 and
maintaining the character of these areas is essential to the continuation of El
Segundo's "small town" atmosphere.
D. The text amendment complies with Objective LU 1-5.6 in that the changes to the
existing language to clarify and update regulations and correct errors in the R-1
regulations will make it easier for projects to demonstrate consistency with the
City's Zoning Ordinance.
E. The text amendment is consistent with the Single-Family (R-1) Residential Land
Use designation in that the proposed changes do not modify or increase the
maximum density of dwelling units per acre currently allowed by the R-1
designation.
SECTION 5: Zone Text Amendment Findings. In accordance with ESMC § 15-4A and
based on the findings set forth in Section 2, the proposed Zone Text Amendment is
consistent with the goals, policies, and objectives of the General Plan as follows:
A. It is consistent with the purpose of the ESMC, which is to serve the public
health, safety, and general welfare and to provide the economic and social
advantages resulting from an orderly planned use of land resources.
B. It is necessary to facilitate the development process and ensure the orderly
development of single-family residences since the proposed amendment
corrects errors and clarifies the standards contained in the zoning
regulations for the Single-Family (R-1) Residential Zone.
SECTION 6: Recommendations. The Planning Commission recommends that the City
Council adopt an Ordinance amending ESMC Sections 15-1-6 (Definitions), 15-4A
(Single-Family Residential), and 15-15-6A (Automobile Spaces Required), which is set
forth in the attached Exhibit "A" (Draft Ordinance) and incorporated into this resolution by
reference.
SECTION 7: Reliance On Record. Each and every one of the findings and determination
in this Resolution are based on the competent and substantial evidence, both oral and
written, contained in the entire record relating to the project. The findings and
determinations constitute the independent findings and determinations of the Planning
4
69
Commission in all respects and are fully and completely supported by substantial
evidence in the record as a whole.
SECTION 8: Limitations. The Planning Commission's analysis and evaluation of the
project is based on the best information currently available. It is inevitable that in
evaluating a project that absolute and perfect knowledge of all possible aspects of the
project will not exist. One of the major limitations on analysis of the project is the Planning
Commission's lack of knowledge of future events. In all instances, best efforts have been
made to form accurate assumptions. Somewhat related to this are the limitations on the
city's ability to solve what are in effect regional, state, and national problems and issues.
The City must work within the political framework within which it exists and with the
limitations inherent in that framework.
SECTION 9: This Resolution will remain effective until superseded by a subsequent
resolution.
SECTION 10: The Commission secretary is directed to mail a copy of this Resolution to
any person requesting a copy.
SECTION 11: This Resolution may be appealed within ten (10) calendar days after its
adoption. All appeals must be in writing and filed with the City Clerk within this time
period. Failure to file a timely written appeal will constitute a waiver of any right of appeal.
5
70
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 12th day of January, 2017.
Ryan Baldino, Chairperson
City of El Segundo Planning Commission
ATTEST:
Sam Lee, Secretary
Baldino
Newman -
Nicol -
Nisley -
Wingate
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Mark D. Hensley, City Attorney
By:
David King, Assistant City Attorney
6
71
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Public Hearing
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action regarding Environmental Assessment No. EA-1158 and Precise
Plan Amendment No. PPA 16-01 regarding the proposed conversion of an existing single lane
restaurant drive-thru to a double lane drive-thru at 101 South Sepulveda Boulevard in the Heavy
Industrial (M-2) Zone. Applicant: McDonald's Corporation. (Fiscal Impact: N/A)
The proposed project is exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality
Act(CEQA)pursuant to 14 California Code of Regulations §15301 which identifies the project as
a Class 1 exemption (Existing Facilities) and § 15304 as a Class 4 categorical exemption (Minor
Alterations to Land)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Open public hearing and take testimony;
2. Close public hearing and discuss item;
3. Adopt Resolution No. approving Environmental Assessment No. 1158 and
Precise Plan Amendment No. PPA 16-01; and/or,
4. Alternatively, discuss and take other action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
1. Planning Commission Resolution No. 2808, adopted on December 8, 2016.
2. Draft Planning Commission Minutes (December 8, 2016)
3. Project Plans
4. Draft City Council Resolution No.
5. Resolution No. 2372, adopted by the City Council on March 8, 1971, adopting
Precise (Specific) Plan No. 8
6. Resolution No. 4028, adopted by City Council on August 5, 1997, which approved
EA-394 and Precise Plan Amendment No. PP 97-2
FISCAL IMPACT: None
Amount Budgeted: N/A
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): N/A
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: N/A
Objective: N/A
ORIGINATED BY: Gregg McClain, Planning Manager tlpm
REVIEWED BY: Sam Lee, Planning and Building Direct
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager �_
2
72
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
I. Background
On December 8, 2016, the Planning Commission considered the request and recommended City
Council approval. The City Council considered the project at its January 17, 2016 meeting,
however, the public was not properly noticed of the hearing. To give the public proper notice, a
new hearing was advertised for February 7, 2017.
In 1971, a Precise Plan for the subject property, PP-8 (later renumbered Precise Plan 71-2 and 71-
3) was adopted by the City Council. The Precise Plan allowed for the redevelopment of an older
service station, a cashier kiosk, and the construction of a training center adjacent to the service
station. The Precise Plan was amended on August 5, 1997 (EA-394 and PP 97-2) which allowed
for the construction of a fast food restaurant with a single-lane drive-thru and a food mart that was
integrated into the restaurant building.
The project site is currently developed with a 12 pump Chevron service station, a 3,342 square
foot McDonald's restaurant, and a 1,736 square foot Chevron food mart integrated into the
restaurant building.
On August 17, 2016, the Planning and Building Safety Department received an application for an
environmental assessment (EA-1158) for the second amendment to Precise Plan 71-2/71-3
(originally referred to as Precise Plan 8) to allow the conversion of an existing single lane
restaurant drive-thru to a double lane drive-thru at 101 Sepulveda Boulevard. The present action
would amend the precise plan to allow the proposed double lane drive-thru.
II. Discussion
The 1997 Amendment specified that"[t]he development standards for Precise Plan 8 are those set
forth in the plans for the proposed project," which depicted a single-lane drive-thru. Because a
double-lane drive thru is now being proposed,a Second Amendment to the Precise Plan is required.
Due to the legislative nature of precise plan amendments, staff recommends that this amendment
be approved by the City Council.
The term "precise plan" is commonly used to refer to a plan for a specific project for a particular
area within the city, which is to be developed with specific development standards. The adoption
(and amendment) of a precise plan is a legislative act by the City Council. Therefore, there are no
specific required findings that must be made for the uses or development standards, other than the
facts and findings as to why the precise plan is necessary to implement the General Plan within a
particular area.
The proposed modification to the drive-through and other exterior site modifications are intended
to alleviate congestion in the drive-through lane and improve on-site circulation. On December 8,
2016, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing, reviewed the facts and required
findings related to the precise plan amendment. A complete background, discussion, and
73
justification for the proposed project is contained in the staff report presented to the Planning
Commission at its December 8, 2016 meeting. (Attachment 1)
At the December 8, 2016 Planning Commission public hearing, the Commission raised concerns
about the project with respect to the improved efficiency of the proposed double lane drive-
through. While the project proceeded through the development review process, the restaurant
initiated the use of a drive-through attendant who takes food orders when cars start to back-up at
the drive-through entrance. The Commission questioned if the double lane drive-through would
be sufficient to alleviate congestion without the continued use of a drive-through attendant.
The applicant affirmed that other fast food restaurants that have implemented the use of a double
lane drive-through experienced an increased efficiency of 20% with regard to speed of service.
The double lane drive-through has also resulted in increased volume of business as more customers
are able to be served. The double lane drive-through is effective at improving on-site circulation
for restaurants that implemented a similar design. The applicant also clarified that the drive-
through has two points of contact after food orders are placed: the first where orders are confirmed
and cash is taken, and the second when food orders are presented to customers. The Planning
Commission was satisfied by the restaurant proactively providing a solution to issues related to
on-site circulation. No conditions other than those in the draft resolution were recommended.
Accordingly,the Commission unanimously adopted Resolution No. 2808, recommending the City
Council approve the project.
III. Environmental Review
The proposed project is exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality
Act(CEQA)pursuant to 14 California Code of Regulations §15301 which identifies the project as
a Class 1 exemption (Existing Facilities) and § 15304 as a Class 4 categorical exemption (Minor
Alterations to Land). The project consists of the reconfiguration of an existing drive-thru. The
project also includes minor alterations to the parking lot, resulting in a reduction of 6 parking
spaces, installation of additional landscaping and other exterior site modifications to comply with
the Americans with Disabilities Act. The proposed project would result in negligible expansion
of the existing use and includes minor alterations to landscaping that do not involve removal of
healthy,mature, and/or scenic trees. Furthermore,the site has no value as a habitat for endangered,
rare, of threatened species. There are adequate utilities and public services to serve the project.
The project is consistent with the City's General Plan and Zoning Code, and is not anticipated to
have any significant impacts with regard to traffic, noise, air quality, or water quality.
IV. Conclusion
Staff recommends that the Council adopt Resolution No. , approving Environmental
Assessment No. 1158, adopting Precise Plan Amendment No. PPA 16-01.
PAPlanning&Building Safety\_Planning\Projects\1151-1175\EA-1 158\City Council\EA 1158 PP 16-01 CC Staff Report-2017-01-17-
Draft.docx
74
RESOLUTION NO. 2808
A RESOLUTION RECOMMENDING THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVE
ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT NO. EA-1158 AND ADOPT PRECISE
PLAN AMENDMENT NO. PPA 16-01 TO AMEND PRECISE PLAN 71-2
AND 71-3 TO ALLOW A "SIDE-BY-SIDE"/DOUBLE LANE DRIVE-
THROUGH AT A DRIVE-THROUGH RESTAURANT LOCATED AT 101
SOUTH SEPULVEDA BOULEVARD IN THE HEAVY INDUSTRIAL (M-2)
ZONE.
The Planning Commission of the City of El Segundo does resolve as follows..
SECTION 1. The Planning Commission finds and declares that:
A. On August 17, 2016, McDonald's Corporation filed an application for
Environmental Assessment No. EA-1158 and Precise Plan Amendment No.
PP 16-01 for a second amendment to Precise Plan 8 (later renumbered as
Precise Plan 71-2 and 71-3) to allow the conversion of an existing single
lane drive-through to a "side-by-side"/double lane drive-through at a
McDonald's fast food restaurant within the Heavy Industrial (M-2) Zone
located at 101 South Sepulveda Boulevard.
B. The application was reviewed by the City's Planning and Building Safety
Department for, in part, consistency with the General Plan and conformity
with the El Segundo Municipal Code ("ESMC");
C. In addition, the City reviewed the project's environmental impacts under the
California Environmental Quality Act (Public Resources Code §§ 21000, et
seq., "CEQA"), the regulations promulgated thereunder (14 Cal. Code of
Regulations §§15000, et seq., the "CEQA Guidelines"), and the City's
Environmental Guidelines (City Council Resolution No. 3805, adopted
March 16, 1993);
D. The Planning and Building Safety Department completed its review and
scheduled a public hearing regarding the application before this
Commission for December 8, 2016;
E. On December 8, 2016, the Commission held a public hearing to receive
public testimony and other evidence regarding the application including,
without limitation, information provided to the Commission by
representatives of McDonald's Corporation and Chevron USA Inc.; and
F. The Commission considered the information provided by City staff, public
testimony, and representatives of McDonald's Corporation and Chevron
EXHIBIT 1 75
USA Inc. This Resolution and its findings are made based upon the
evidence presented to the Commission at its December 8, 2016 hearing
including, without limitation, the staff report submitted by the Planning and
Building Safety Department.
SECTION 2: Factual Findings. The Commission finds that the following facts exist:
A. The subject site is located in the Heavy Industrial (M-2) Zone on a 1.27-acre
portion of a larger 625.24-acre section of the Chevron Oil Refinery located
at 101 South Sepulveda Boulevard.
B. The surrounding land uses consist of a three-story office/research and
development building across El Segundo Boulevard to the northwest, the
22 story Pacific Corporate Towers, containing approximately 1,683,056
square feet of office uses, to the northeast, a single-story commercial
shopping center across Sepulveda Boulevard to the east, and the
surrounding area to the west and south is developed as the Chevron Oil
Refinery, with an employee park and fitness center adjacent to the project.
C. The existing development and uses were approved in 1971 under Precise
Plan 71-2 and 71-3 and an amendment in 1997 (EA-394 and PP 97-2).
D. The subject site is developed with a 12-pump Chevron service station, a
3,341.5-square foot McDonald's fast food restaurant with a single lane
drive-through, and a 1,735.5-square foot Chevron foodmart integrated into
the restaurant building.
E. Vehicular access for the project site is provided by three existing driveways
on Sepulveda Boulevard and one existing driveway on El Segundo
Boulevard. A 13' x 50' loading zone will is located on the east side of the
building. A previously approved parking demand study determined 45
parking spaces would be required for the restaurant and foodmart. The
project will provide 62 parking spaces, including 59 standard parking spaces
and 3 accessible parking spaces.
F. The proposed project would amend the existing Precise Plan to allow a
"side-by-side"/double lane drive-through at drive-through restaurants,
including new menu boards, customer ordering display, directional signage,
and additional landscaping.
-2-
76
SECTION 3: Environmental Assessment. Based upon the facts identified in Section 2 of
this Resolution and the evidence presented to the Planning Commission at its December
8, 2016 hearing, the proposed project is exempt from the requirements of the California
Environmental Quality Act(CEQA) pursuant to 14 California Code of Regulations §15301
which identifies the project as a Class 1 exemption (Existing Facilities) and § 15304 as a
Class 4 categorical exemption (Minor Alterations to Land). The project consists of a
Precise Plan Amendment that will allow the conversion of an existing single lane drive-
through to a "side-by-side"/double lane drive-through at drive-through restaurants,
including new menu boards, customer ordering display, directional signage, and
additional landscaping. in the Heavy Industrial (M-2) Zone. The proposed project would
result in negligible expansion of the existing use and includes minor alterations to
landscaping that do not involve removal of healthy, mature, and/or scenic trees.
Furthermore, the site has no value as a habitat for
endangered, rare, of threatened species. There are adequate utilities and public services
to serve the project. The project is consistent with the City's General Plan and Zoning
Code, and is not anticipated to have any significant impacts with regard to traffic, noise,
air quality, or water quality.
SECTION 4: General Plan and Zoning. The proposed project conforms with the City's
General Plan or the zoning regulations in the ESMC as follows:
A. The General Plan Land Use Designation of the project site is Heavy
Industrial. The proposed project is consistent with the following General
Plan Economic Development objectives and policies: Objective ED1-1 and
Policies ED1-2.1 and ED 1-2.3, which relate to the maintenance and
expansion of El Segundo's economic base.
B. The proposed project is consistent with the following General Plan Land Use
policies: LU 1-5.6, LU 4-1.1, and LU 4-1.2, which relate to conformance with
City zoning standards and guidelines for the implementation of CEQA,
requiring landscaping and its maintenance for commercial projects, and
compliance with Health and Safety Code requirements.
C. The proposed project is consistent with the following General Plan Circulation
goals, objectives, and policies: C 1-2 and C 2-1, C 3-1, Goal C-1, and Policy
C 3-2.1, which relate to the provision of a circulation system to ensure safety
of residents, workers, and visitors of El Segundo and the consideration of
circulation impacts.
D. The proposed project is consistent with the General Plan Air Quality
Objective AQ-10-1 which relates to the control of particulate emissions.
E. The site is zoned Heavy Industrial (M-2), which permits drive-through
restaurants, service stations, and foodmarts with the approval of a
-3-
77 `�
Conditional Use Permit (CUP). However, because Precise Plan
Amendment 97-2 established a drive-through restaurant as a permitted use
by right, an amendment to the Precise Plan is required to modify the
previously approved development.
SECTION 5: Recommendation. The Planning Commission hereby recommends the City
Council adopt the following amendments to Precise Plan 8 subject to the attached
Conditions of Approval:
A. To convert the existing single lane drive-through to a"side-by-side"/double lane
drive-through. Precise Plan 97-2 established a fast food drive-through
restaurant as a permitted use by right at the project site. SSMC § 15-5-5(Q)
allows drive-through lanes to encroach into required landscaped setbacks up
to a maximum of 50% of the required setback. Drive-through lanes must not
interfere with on-site and off-site circulation and must maintain a minimum
continuous length of 150 feet for an eating and drinking establishment. The
proposed modification to the existing single-lane drive-through is consistent
with these standards.
SECTION G: This Resolution will remain effective until superseded by a subsequent
resolution.
SECTION 7: The Commission Secretary is directed to mail a copy of this Resolution to
Chevron USA, Inc., McDonalds' Corporation, and to any other person requesting a copy.
-4-
78 0
SECTION 8; Except as provided in Section 6, this Resolution is the Planning
Commission's final decision and will become effective immediately upon adoption.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 8th day of December 2016.
Ryan Baldino, Chairperson
City of El Segundo Planning Commission
ATTEST:
Sam Lee, Secretary
Baldino -
Newman -
Nicol -
Nisley -
Wingate -
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Mark D. Hensley, City Attorney
By:
David King, Assistant City Attorney
-5-
79,
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 2808
Exhibit A
CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
In addition to all applicable provisions of the El Segundo Municipal Code ("ESMC"),
McDonald's Corporation and Chevron USA Inc. agree to comply with the following
provisions as conditions for the City of El Segundo's approval of Environmental
Assessment No. EA-1158 and Precise Plan Amendment No. PP 16-01, ("Project
Conditions"):
Planning Division Conditions
1. Before the City issues a building permit, the applicant must submit plans
which show that the Project substantially complies with plans and conditions
approved and on file with the Planning and Building Safety Department. Any
subsequent modification to the approved Project must be referred to the
Planning and Building Safety Director to determine whether Planning
Commission approval is required for the proposed modification.
2. Any subsequent modification to the project as approved must be referred to
the Director of Planning and Building Safety for approval and a determination
regarding the need for Planning Commission review of the proposed
modification.
3. A complete Landscape Plan and Irrigation Plan must be submitted for the
review and approval of the Director of Planning and Building Safety. The
Landscape and Irrigation Plan must have a planting schedule and description
of the proposed irrigation system. The proposed Landscape and Irrigation
Plan must meet the requirements of ESMC §§ 15-4C-6 and 15-4C-5(I)
regarding Open Space and Landscaping. The Landscape Plan and Irrigation
Plan must also meet the Water Conservation in Landscaping requirements in
ESMC §§15-1-6, 15-2-14, and 15-15A (Ordinance No. 1515).
4. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the applicant must submit
a Master Sign Program to ensure compatibility with the surrounding area and
the aesthetic objectives of the General Plan, as well as ensure sign do not
impede traffic or pedestrian safety. The Master Sign Program is subject to
approval of the Director of Planning and Building Safety, or their designee.
5. All conditions of approval contain in Resolution No. 4028, adopted by the City
Council on July 24, 1997, will remain in effect.
-6-
80'.
Buiidinp Safety Division Conditions
6. The applicant must comply with the ESMC, the applicable State Water
Conservation requirements, the 2013 edition of the California Building Code
(CBC), as amended by the City of El Segundo, the California Residential
Code, California Electrical Code, California Mechanical Code, California
Plumbing Code, California Green Building Standards and Building Energy
Efficiency Standards.
7. Before the City issues building permits, the applicant must submit plans
stamped by a State-licensed architect or engineer to the Planning and
Building Safety Division for review and approval. Building Safety Division staff
will determine if the plans must include demolition, complete structural
calculations, details, notes and material specifications.
Fire Department Conditions
8. The applicant must comply with the applicable requirements of the 2013
California Building and Fire Codes and the 2013 International Fire Code as
adopted by the City of El Segundo and El Segundo Fire Department
Regulations. On January 1, 2017, the City will be adopting the 2016
California Building Standards. For projects submitted for plan review after
January 1, 2017, the 2016 California Editions apply.
Construction Conditions
9. The applicant must keep soil stockpiled for two days or more covered, moist,
or treated with soil binders to prevent dust generation.
10. The applicant must cover or maintain two feet of free board on any stock pile
of debris, dirt or rusty materials on-site.
11. All haul trucks hauling soil, sand, and other loose materials must either be
covered or maintain two feet of freeboard.
12. The owner or contractor must conduct daily street sweeping and truck wheel
cleaning to prevent dirt in the storm drain system.
13. All diesel equipment must be operated with closed engine doors and must be
equipped with factory-recommended mufflers.
14. The applicant must provide a telephone number for local residents to call to
submit complaints associated with the construction noise. The number must
-7-
81
be posted on the project site and must be easily viewed from adjacent public
areas.
15. All construction-related parking must be accommodated on-site. No
construction related parking is permitted off-site.
Miscellaneous Conditions
16. McDonald's Corporation c/o Lorraine Fortelka, Senior Counsel, and Chevron
USA Inc. c/o Jacqueline McGinnis, Real Property Officer, agree to indemnify
and hold the City harmless from and against any claim, action, damages,
costs (including, without limitation, attorney's fees), injuries, or liability, arising
from the City's approval of Environmental Assessment No. EA-1158 and
Precise Plan Amendment No. PP 16-01. Should the City be named in any
suit, or should any claim be brought against it by suit or otherwise, whether
the same be groundless or not, arising out of the City approval of
Environmental Assessment No. EA-1158 and Precise Plan Amendment No.
PP 16-01, McDonald's Corporation clo Lorraine Fortelka, Senior Counsel,
and Chevron USA Inc. clo Jacqueline McGinnis, Real Property Officer agree
to defend the City (at the City's request and with counsel satisfactory to the
City) and will indemnify the City for any judgment rendered against it or any
sums paid out in settlement or otherwise. For purposes of this section "the
City" includes the City of El Segundo's elected officials, appointed officials,
officers, and employees.
By signing this document, McDonald's Corporation c/o Lorraine Fortelka, Senior Counsel,
and Chevron USA Inc. c/o Jacqueline McGinnis, Real Property Officer certify that they
have read, understood, and agrees to the Project Conditions listed in this document.
McDonald's Corporation c/o Lorraine Fortelka, Senior Counsel
Chevron USA Inc. c/o Jacqueline McGinnis, Real Property Officer
{If Corporation or similar entity, needs two officer signatures or evidence that one
signature binds the company}
-8-
82
MINUTES OF THE MEETING
OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION
OF THE CITY OF EL SEGUNDO, CALIFORNIA
December 08, 2016
Chair Baldino called the El Segundo Planning Commission meeting to order at CALL TO ORDER
5:30 p.m. in the El Segundo City Hall's Council Chambers, 350 Main Street, El
Segundo, California.
Commissioner Wingate led the Pledge of Allegiance. PLEDGE TO FLAG
PRESENT: NICOL, NEWMAN, BALDINO, NISLEY, WINGATE ROLL CALL
None. PUBLIC
COMMUNICATIONS
Chair Baldino presented the Consent Calendar, CONSENT
CALENDAR
None. CALL ITEMS FROM
CONSENT
Ms. Wingate moved, seconded by Commissioner Newman, for the Planning MOTION
Commission to approve the September 22, 2016 and October 13, 2016 minutes.
Motion carried (5-0).
WRITTEN
None. COMMUNICATIONS
Chair Baldino presented Agenda Item H-3, Environmental Assessment No. EA- NEW BUSSINESS for
1158 and Precise Plan Amendment No. PP 16-01. Address: 101 South Sepulveda EA-1158; PPA 16-01
Boulevard. Property Owner Chevron USA Inc. c/o Jacqueline McGinnis, Real
Property Officer. Applicant: McDonald's Corporation c/o Lorraine Fortelka, Senior
Counsel.
Assistant Planner Raneika Brooks presented presentation of the staff report.
Zorah 'Mariano, Stantec Architecture, applicant
Mr. Baldino asked Ms. Mariano if the proposed additional drive-through lane would
resolve the issue.
Mrs. Mariano stated that she believed that it would. She said that past projects
show that adding a lane improves efficiency by 20%. She added that technological
improvements also help the line move quicker.
Mr. Baldino stated that since the overflow is into their own property, rather than
into the street, they have the incentive to address such issues on their own.
Ms. Wingate moved, seconded by Commissioner Nicol, for the Planning MOTION
Commission to approve Environmental Assessment No. EA-1158 and Precise
Plan Amendment No. PP 16-01. Motion carried (5-0).
PAPlanning&Building Safety\_Planning\Planning Comm ission\Minutes\2016\2016 12-08 Min docx
age 1
None. PUBLIC HEARING-
CONTINUED
BUSINESS
Chair Baldino presented Agenda Item J-4, Scoping Meeting for the proposed Park OTHER BUSSINESS
Place Extension.
Alan Ashimine of Michael Baker International gave a brief overview of the project
options and the environmental documents that his firm would be preparing.
Mr. Baldino asked if the Environmental Impact Report would look at all of the
presented options, and asked who ultimately chooses which option will be taken.
Principal Planner Paul Samaras stated that the document would analyze the
impacts of all options. He also stated that the City Council makes the final decision.
Commissioner Newman asked why some of the options take the street right into
the Arc Light Cinemas property rather than going straight through.
Mr. Samaras responded that since this project directly impacts access to their
property. The said configuration of the street is a way to make up for that.
Mr. Baldino questioned whether a future southward leg to Rosecrans Avenue
would need a separate EIR.
Mr. Nicol asked why the City would pay for two EIRs rather than include the present
and future projects into the one being prepared now.
Mr. Samaras said that our application for grant funding states that we will use the
money for the City to complete its road network as outlined in the Circulation
Element of the General Plan. A street connecting S. Allied Way to E. Rosecrans
Avenue is not proposed in the General Plan.
Mr. Newman asked if we could amend the General Plan.
Mr. Samaras stated that we could, but that it is not the project before the
Commission at present.
Ms. Wingate asked if the railroad companies would be willing to move their tracks.
Mr. Ashimine stated that they have only had preliminary meetings with the
companies, and that they have not made any statements about moving their
tracks. He said that they will be in contact with them throughout the CEQA
process.
Ms. Wingate asked if the railroad companies are unwilling to move their tracks, the
City's only option would be subgrade roads.
Mr. Hishinish stated that to get them to move their tracks would require a significant
amount of coordination between the companies.
Allan Mackenzie, Rosecrans Sepulveda Partners
Mr. Mackenzie stated that it is their intention to eventually continue S. Allied way
south.
PAPlanning&Building Safety\_Planning\Planning Commission\Minutes\2016\2016 12-08 Minu�%.docx
Page 2
Mr. Baldino asked for an explanation as to why such a connection cannot be
included in the current EIR.
City Attorney David King stated that this could be done, but that General Plan
Amendment would have to first be approved, and the current project would have
to start over, since the project description would have to be modified.
Ms. Wingate asked how long a General Plan Amendment would take.
Mr. King replied that it would take several months.
Mr. Mackenzie counseled that staff continue current project without amending the
General Plan.
Ken Berkman, Interim Public Work Director
Mr. Berkman stated that the project is partially funded by Measure R, and that
stopping to amend the General Plan in order that a future addition to the project
be included in the current EIR may impact funding.
Rod Spackman, Manager of Govt. Affairs for Chevron in the South Bav
Mr. Spackman said that Chevron is not opposed to the reconfiguration of the
railroads, but said that they are also interested in their ability to continue to operate
as they do today. He stated that much of the crude oil that comes into the refinery
for processing comes through a pipeline infrastructure that would have to be
reconfigured along with the railroads. An interruption of this flow for such a
reconfiguration would constitute a significant impact that would have to be
addressed in the EIR.
He stated that the ideal choice from Chevron's perspective would be the option
with grade separation at each track, which requires no reconfiguration of the tracks
or pipelines, thus allowing them to continue to operate normally.
He added that at-grade rail crossings for the new streets are a "non-starter", and
that he did not believe them to be workable or safe, and that they would raise safety
and security concerns that they would rather not have.
Michael Strahs, Federal Realtv Investment Trust
Mr. Strauss expressed support for the project, stating that it would increase
connectivity and reduce traffic congestion. He stated that the element of the
project that his company is most concerned about is: if there is a grade separation
at the railroad tracks, whether the road will rise to street grade again in time for
cars to conveniently get into The Point's parking lot.
Planning & Building Safety Director Sam Lee gave a brief overview of the progress REPORT FROM
that the Department has made over the last year and the goals for 2017. He PLANNING AND
thanked the Commission and staff for a wonderful year and for everyone's hard BUILDING SAFETY
work. DIRECTOR
Mr. Nicol asked why the R-1 update was not on the agenda, and if staff was behind
schedule.
P:\Planning&Building Safety\_Planning\Planning Commission\Minutes\2016\2016 12-08 Minu¢ .docx
"Wage 3
PLANNING
Planning Manager Gregg McClain stated that staff found it necessary to make COMMISSIONERS
changes to the Definitions section of the Code in tandem with the R-1 changes. COMMENTS
He stated that this has caused a slight delay, but that staff is still on schedule and
that the item will be before the Commission for the next meeting.
Chair Baldino adjourned the meeting.
The meeting adjourned at 6:41 p.m. ADJOURNMENT
PASSED AND APPROVED ON THIS 8TH DAY OF DECEMBER 2016,
Sam Lee, Secretary of Ryan Baldino, Chairman
the Planning Commission Planning Commission
and Director of the City of El Segundo, California
Planning and Building Safety Department
PAPlanning&Building Safety\_Planning\Planning Commission\Minutes\2016\2016 12-08 MinuMdocx
Ptige 4
EL SEGUNDO PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING DATE: December 8, 2016
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA BEADING: New Business
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action regarding Environmental Assessment No.EA-1158 and Precise
Plan Amendment No. PPA 16-01 amending Precise Plan 8 to allow a"side-by-side"/double lane
drive-thru, including new menu boards, customer ordering display, and directional signage, at a
drive-thru restaurant. The project site is located at 101 South Sepulveda Boulevard in the Heavy
Industrial (M-2)Zone. Applicant: McDonald's Corporation.
RECOMMENDED PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION:
It is recommended that the Planning Commission open the public hearing, receive testimony,
consider the evidence, and then adopt Resolution No. 2808 recommending the City Council
approve Environmental Assessment No. EA-1158 and adopt Precise Plan Amendment No. PPA
16-01.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
1. Draft Planning Commission Resolution No. 2808
2. Resolution No. 2372, adopted by the City Council on March 8, 1971, adopting Precise
(Specific)Plan No. 8
3. Resolution No. 4028, adopted by City Council on August 5, 1997,which approved EA-
394 and Precise Plan Amendment No. PP 97-2
4. Plans
ORIGINATED BY: Raneika Brooks, Assistant Planner
REVIEWED BY: Paul Samaras, Principal Planner
REVIEWED BY: Gregg McClain, Planning Manager )
APPROVED BY: Sam Lee,Director ofPlarirxng and Building Safety
I. INTRODUCTION:
The Planning and Building Safety Department received an application for an environmental
assessment (EA-1158) for a second amendment to Precise Plan No. 8 (later renumbered Precise
Plan 71-2 and 71-3) to allow the conversion of an existing single lane drive-thru to a "side-by-
side"/double lane drive-ffim, including new menu boards, customer ordering display, and
directional signage. The project site is located at 101 South Sepulveda Boulevard.
3
87
II. BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
Background
The project site is located in the Heavy Industrial(M-2)Zone on the block bounded by El Segundo
Boulevard to the north,Rosecrans Avenue to the south,Vista Del Mar to the west, and Sepulveda
Boulevard to the east.
SURROUNDING LAND USES
Direction Land Use ;done
North Office/Industrial Medium Manufacturing(MM)
Commercial/Parking/ General Commercial(C-3)
East Recreation
South Oil Refinery Heavy Industrial (M-2)
West
Oil Refinery Heavy Industrial (M-2)
Discussion
Site Description
The subject property is a 1.27-acre portion of a larger 625.24-acre section of the Chevron Oil
Refinery at the southwest corner of Sepulveda Boulevard (State Highway 1) and El Segundo
Boulevard. The project site is currently developed with a 12 pump Chevron service station, a
3,341.5-square foot McDonald's fast food restaurant with a single-lane drive thru, and a 1,735.5-
square foot Chevron foodmart integrated into the restaurant building.
Proiect Description
The applicant seeks a second amendment to Precise Plan 71-2 and 71-3 that would allow for the
conversion of an existing single lane drive-thru to a "side-by-side"/double lane drive-thru,
including new menu boards, customer ordering display, and directional signage. The proposed
modification to the drive-thru and other exterior site modifications are intended to alleviate
existing drive-thru congestion in the drive-thru lane and improve on-site circulation.
Precise Plan
Adopted in 1971, the Precise Plan for the subject property, PP-8 (later renumbered Precise Plan
71-2 and 71-3) allowed for the redevelopment of an older service station and the construction of
new 240-square foot cashier kiosk and training center adjacent to the service station. The training
center building was used as a fitness center by Chevron employees and was located directly west
of the parking lot at the south end of the project site.
2
88
The adoption(and amendment)of a Precise Plan is a legislative act by the City Council. Therefore,
there are no specific required findings that must be made for the uses or development standards,
other than the facts and findings as to why the Precise Plan is necessary to carry out the general
purpose of the Zoning Code.
The Precise Plan was amended on August 5, 1997 (EA-394 and PP 97-2) which allowed for the
construction of 3,341.5-square foot McDonald's fast food restaurant with a single-lane drive-thru
and a 1,795.5-square foot Chevron food mart that was integrated into the restaurant building. The
Amendment specified that "[t]he development standards for Precise Plan 8 are those set forth in
the plans for the proposed project," which depicted a single-lane drive-thru. Because a double-
lane drive thru is now being proposed, a Second Amendment to the Precise Plan is required.
Although the 1997 Amendment does allow the Director of Planning and Building Safety authority
to approve modifications to the project as approved in 1997 (Section 3, Condition#1), due to the
legislative nature of precise plan amendments,staff recommends that this amendment be approved
by the City Council.
General Plan and Zoning Consistencv
The General Plan Land Use designation for the site is Heavy Industrial. This designation allows
heavy manufacturing uses such as construction yards,factories,generation stations, and refineries
at a maximum floor area ration(FAR) of 0.6. The project is consistent with the goals, objectives,
and policies of the General Plan,which are discussed in detail in the attached resolution.
The site is zoned Heavy Industrial (M-2), which permits drive-thru restaurants, service stations,
and foodmarts with the approval of a Conditional Use Permit (CUP). However, because Precise
Plan Amendment 97-2 made drive-thru restaurants and retail sales permitted uses, a CUP is no
longer required. Instead, because the amendment to the Precise Plan established development
standards in the form of the 1997 plans submitted to the City,an amendment is required to modify
the previously-approved development. The Precise Plan Amendment requires a public hearing by
the Planning Commission. Conditions of approval may be imposed through the Precise Plan
Amendment process in order to minimize potential impacts to noise,traffic, lighting, etc.
The proposed conversion of the single-lane drive-thru to a"side-by-side"/double lane drive-thru
and other site modifications are consistent with the zoning standards for drive-thru lane
dimensions. The project does not propose a change to the FAR of the existing building nor does
it result in a reduction of required parking spaces.
III. Inter-Departmental Comments
The project application and plans were circulated to all departments for review and comment. Staff
incorporated those comments that have a legal nexus as conditions of approval.
IV. Environmental Review
The proposed project is exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality
Act(CEQA)pursuant to 14 California Code of Regulations §15301 which identifies the project as
3
89
a Class 1 exemption (Existing Facilities) and § 15304 as a Class 4 categorical exemption(Minor
Alterations to Land). The project consists of the conversion of an existing single lane drive-thru
to a"side-by-side"/double lane drive-thru,including new menu boards,customer ordering display,
and directional signage. The proposed project would result in negligible expansion of the existing
use and includes minor alterations to landscaping that do not involve removal of healthy, mature,
and/or scenic trees. Furthermore, the site has no value as a habitat for endangered, rare, of
threatened species. There are adequate utilities and public services to serve the project. The
project is consistent with the City's General Plan and Zoning Code, and is not anticipated to have
any significant impacts with regard to traffic, noise, air quality, or water quality.
V. Recommendation
Planning staff recommends that the Planning Commission review the facts as contained within this
report and adopt Resolution No. 2808 recommending City Council approval of Environmental
Assessment No. EA-1158 and adoption of Precise Plan Amendment No. PPA 16-01.
4
90
vZ61'6Y6•°fl OOC 7rMK Pi9Z6 tl]
xJAWO A 1E*W 19
"a
'�' I:C6irEY fi46'Nl Ua Ue w % C r S4 ZO6 tlJ•oUN0935
pAl9 V03A1f1d35 I01 O
N s,xnvm Hanna ✓Ixn ��/' I I$ � „�*.nMr• ��� 'y,'���� OL
aumr star Y�
304ue:JS 'ill`;sn s,Pleuoaowow . - NVId MIS NoLLnoh330 I
gC g �•99N 8 � � V Y.R �.. ,� � Y + Y
b
YEF y{X ea .9 $ a e Yo= ¢ o u y a o f r{r{ 3{E?I
Z Yi o E Yf Yb Y Y 4' o �, "' ;; S s'a ? Z DDD N L' r;°.l E:•
k d �i-� s i W b tl
O D v o. L Y e¢ .�"`� C3.4. . Y..
z' y :: Eti.plE:il
tl.Y Ya 1d Y' � ¢ .N Y••J W l
' 5 0000000000000000000 Y " '
w a r 211 Ltd EA
0
a °5 � a ..dam'°:.
_IIf =
{�u 0
I I s
r
I
I
I
I R
y a
I
a
1 I r,1
1 - L--------_--- -_
i
Art f-,�e�'��,°tt• et,:�.. - I
_ � u
S V` l 43 SIR' -Iqr � 7
co 0
G V � 1 111666- .
1
LU
ac, U �l U U n Ilg Fs� C
0.
n
L
a d
a
a
o
0 10 as la
«Nn, Itl4'CZ6'a1r^q ml DiG �� �3 SbZ06 tlJ OON003S l3
y ux..m wna.r� � � dOd9 StFWd MY ]PILCIy +'�' ° �� _ .1.1 3A1Od35.1
l rFFM.n Fr+F+r.r +-✓.ln..a..«°r..«r,� 1i�� � ENkr rtiW � r:
33 1.1L''�.� -��"rts�s"p�euopapyjuf " Nvid1 HIS
�
IY �+'
is i g3 a
biib Z u iY!ul
k k ke'
Y
o
^ p t � �E o f c y E ��M �°.i'S, �•N X 0_ W .. ¢ �.4
5 a4_ s " �e s of x g ; o "e Q e " F get ' Y a
'1£ #� f ;f Slb �� 3 k 3 A �{�.� � � 3 y Y A 1 F A i x e r a
a s a psxxyp `4 Y € a e r ¢ u a c c o g� 'G J ag
b� 9I uit 1 Z i r S F g p � O � O O Ftl m N � a O 3
€ d�a S a x' 3 z °s Y N���¢q r N K Y ��. 4
I r k ea# Y Wire S i � o ° r'�1 Y - s - � e � Y s2 gY ? u 8 z � 8 .Y z st 'iY ° u �`7W 10 e$ybbt I � i
a'e$a� r z iii a 3 s Y ra . Y. - u 1 o o .'�Y. sdqu. yyI
e g esats§Y� Y z y ¢ y eE"...Y 1 7 •i]�� O 0000OOOO�9a8aA880B8 _ .
eAqg
�=
I �. a€Ao�sasa,_ ,.ss
WE
I ���sHaRg3�W-
F
l
I _
--
I l
14 4} i
11 1 il
f./m,
�' 9 R
Go
LLI
Ia �
I , t
�f►,14IMJ3S Q
S-
4 a�,
r
a
0
[w•r 5 esxa w'1.xi<x�,1�°a co,rxri az:.u"i1""yw w>,w ra tr sro�s�.-�s.•,,v��i,.+,nr�eub oon°�'�N[�5r
wwaaM wo�'Y.I '.�xI 913[6 r3'Ttl .,. N' y,. pw ° a +w�nusw° nm n•.rnl .n,e.aasu Y
..
Idl9 C�66W r,1l MI 11115'NH}.71Yl�ildK
0009 Caw N71 021uels �.x+�, I 54 OA1 VJ 3Ain`3S l3
OAIB V03/,lfld35 101
✓'a Ve '.,.:r':�r...:r...^ +,.�..""""""-w... I urar.
�S oll`vsn s.Pleuoa3w W s 'a+ NV16 'Dual V 3dvDsaNVI
N
MIN
IN
9g.
lo ERR
-
3
N
°
_ .
°
I� .
g gq
$�a
a.. ts � aoa<bak€aA g ��e. s �yssraag% e. g.°° e a o s Vie=x a= s
c :u dsY <a4 °° .g ad., Wg; "pi d° ojga k=k € _� s .eg m Ue as ;.
rq, lx g g a y a° g €g a ° ¢ee.kes"s�gr Sck�4 - geFugej a k NA k ab N 0 6 8 � r "=j4: a �y€ a€
i ..9, orIMP,°sag= xzs °afix'"� "=°„n n ===:ygisQ amY o ee€ka s "Yd. d� �€ Fsn x -
z
Iii r R" m� $=a gs.�°, Hip a �"go==_-h° Fs`"°�
°� gj €=e � '" �; _ Y£` � y_�=k s ��°ash Frig& I
Wiw x xa s° o :J $ ,-€Yx <4cci„£ �°Y g g'g„C d= n �,;j T-- "uge ar xeie;^-a k a w'; g a
°E-'{2g-� c ■. k. C"=K°' rd6Y�•° ==a° °g xyk°..° _ kAd,gk`�,`. Yg`� oYb. 6 sy° p ' IEoA .t
cd =6 °3^@__:b kid ! gq� =�y
�'x'fa gae 'ga aa� iag�msa„"=sg°sa-o�Aa- ,k€age° ` a�i4. �..Y� e.00 :ss;�x'�
v 33 �� =5yaa$ £g �K "=<a; K $sags °" & � oeoY° Yo:og9 ,%sYoe °�"4�e` iz,"�esge Wsy=ss°I �3
g..s° . " =<y ggc i£;s„ g s ° g” =F' .s _°: '�°u- s ,g. g gg° gr esa" y°
= se„€sdggca°s °^�„ sg,; �g°si am<i„=='s:k r �aa'=k ° g�=A-.4 " g _ a
�i 4 ad :3°mg s c=�g'�a. ° guky.= -"'ems `g ° .a
"tl i a `° B `J i °' Y'° °a"° q- un Y`fl �3V7 gC' oY gs
Y°-Hz'H g$. og �" -iq
° ° `€ ds=a. ° Aa=x` Boa t x i ¢saes= mg^ff -=� s
.^.b i €icis' � stsa=lsa€ r : aua osa :€ es< � sssse°
K.`
Ms A
gd " a •J
-d3 SH- I
1 f
m ----_ �
sus ar e� � e z' 3 W I'i I� I '.. 'fdss' � �b
0.
a A
g 3�Yx $ gs ao e` N f a sYr� sa Yg 'f
=a�x�
o i apps r. r k 8 a
e 1 C Q
-y 6 z a
� 3g ❑n4 IG©�tt�t(t99s"t3 r��4� a•
,.eY.W+.-«n,�w�+.�sNw _.VMSn ..sa'01 +/vinxewx.ia e�•nwsiNxN.rlr� ee. µl.,"i�w.iao'w xp���
p.°..�:,ea,.siw«.o�•z: ...;ti,ad '+ n...°, o�� m+.o�o���w.-r.,.,.,yawn ,.�..., ��ff
r wo>>aluols NYM 919261' 'IMAHI at - unaaM�vn x.?�>•vn! �vmum
IZ l9'CZ6"666''J-1]llf5'N"A Ayl—'l BF
.e wVA f"Ij a. �e1S A o� W SbZ06 tl0'OONf1035 13 N
,u n+w�+naoww wrVia IyI 0009 CZ6'6Y611 ;'„ '. p•w w, -
Os'^.2. >f N,IB tl03AlA0d r0" /L
- :)04ue:tS o-ri'vsnPSaPleuoa3w'W ..moo . SNVId 3115 0308V1N3 (n !
t .., u• 8
Lj
.¢ o
K : F
0 q
° 1i
� �
<
�• 1I � d € 4k d a I�■9g S l�; f _�� ga Y r � 9r S
4Y�
/
! ,j T + >
ri...... 1 /
I, �•v
,a
00 0
400 0
i R
IZI9 V46,0f+1 001]lily'NMO A'16CCMd1p 6C I`
K sn►n's� ` •salt.I 11101 tl0 OONf1035 11 •b'
wG 9909'C(h'tlfh al aaluel5 - QAIB tl03/,llld35 l01
0 :)04ue4S ,i'dsn s�Pleuo w'w
.a o
�� �; oz ��� ��oo, e�=`ate= ow � - �C"�Rd•
u o N zm� g o= gN59 a9
q og w g�_ �-
Z
U,VI_ 3e `� vaN 3 eo po oe oo
�yj - }Er<iYgtle =48 9 "', -,
.YM .Yaa
n
= oy © ©�.
� w � � � �oo � g° g�° v� I ��yp• �� I�� I I
n Ps
oo s° s i< ° Wo so °gW; as :affi J"7 uJ I l �I
° 3 Nei
a
Tli
GG.Yi 910x.-f0-so ANA¢'I=ln:l�\s]lViAnll\nna bntlAlx3\la-,v,i_I�9.oz\Ib ld>niso nNni-�vHa\oSems\l�v\w
95
,racwae
� ttI&111.W;'al .ructg ill att IIR"klA A71X 4" s 'j° \�•
6W •SbL06 VJ i�3s a13�
Ml9 V0a4nd35 101
j S
'd5l1 s,PleuvpDVy w silvlaa CIS � 3
d
$ °l g
gob
a
6 x
j C7 �._ zll fq�al b
O
d77
V, }��•1 to - ��.r }r. o ���Y +[
e A
°S3; W e sa
oCJ 64Y qe kxa'+atl
'r, s
650
0
FK
M.
AU
S ii` � �H5 � •m
.Qg q 1 a
i� I� I �
e a
N ppy:`
a! x O
�gm
4 O O
V N
H F F
2 r 2
*a,�m" w».e s.w,w.•,n.*,aY o�,.-,wvmw.rt+ual.o.aonw�,.�.
rn .,i .
.x•Y,m9s IJMlY. ubs'sYluols xYx ww A:h�°YaYdl .•w M�,r ura�zw m.�s
x, f� ,yxy WpN IZ l9'C266b6''YJ 001]llf6'YJxA A7°1iW1S['K W
$v SbZOfi VO'OONf10..l3 711
0009 CZ66Y6 Nl
x•�xssnxL ,aNMn 7�C�lS w xfa.i M19 V0wnd35 lOL
�a�ue�S Yogi aysn'., Pi a w W y,« p CO
s euo � „�,y SlIV134 AtlM31tl`J w
rid B 1'tf
jq -a' r ' 3r )t
i�i1f r r�rl�iRtfrF�l � {•� 6 .m° �ts� _l�„� 2
Z w cp
• V
s f 1f 1gik iy l}•�} v ;�S5 cl�
41 15$ t5,i ti Gr
t J2
C)
r3�y r
Lj
4JJ--4--- rr--4--4 � fY
rr�rf�l 'Is ggyy
flak Mosi RAW
o
� ro �
�y til� A•d ilk ,�y �y "• b`p Q 3
IVY]
q w
g:
~tea alJf
W
J 9fC
' .
i
z
LL
[ i A
g v
x .a_srt Arur,rY fa»n5)�wsxra_Y?Arx,�r�f„amoYrrasu,q W ssimx>t, xsrY„r�sdwCir:ulasi, • .a mT�iV'YU%M,'.Vf c�?ahoeaY,tii�\�W[�X
_,. w..wx .m .oa xiw�s.o� eiez6 w7-FMAbI �,�•.�.,,`;Y",,,,�^.�.nn."R. v !�w...n. ..aw.x.
I
nron I;i4 FZ6'666'vo,6p131X6'lAllq AA»Gb/f N "vJ ',"."p1+vr• v� f S4Z06 tl�'00Nf103S l3' ,
4�w6l ufa+4 MRYN 69Y7SZ6'66fi Pl 3%Y9t§ �.�w°" '�;;,'°�w m��u�`»1w !{S �..
_ _ "°ir ,�_r � 0A19 tl03/,1Nd35�lYl Q
�a�ue�S »"�ll'bSfl s,pleuoQaW°w iiviK aavmdod find (n I
x.v--1-i sn ;�� sMy ONV AdONtl�.p y`M
' T!
13 i1"
}y # q y n,
i {e
n,y1ll FeFti gR i�` p i s li�1�f;s� r E a � wo
LLJ
r# !s iitEls���;f3 0 I — w
I. o d
III�s tiil� l €�i�' gl�l�g s s�Fii
o
qra° { 1f;
° o
_�
LLJ
cn
LLJ
eii riF+f!} i,x ,ter
5tx s j F ppF � FFttttFFFrrr Fj]
u
l! r-- _h t �« K a w
4y ° j F i €Fiaa — —I.I.1 �_ i
i yy it aS i3salgr IR I 1=={a I: w
it I I
i
°�u LL m an O Uy��pJ�� �LLU�J�e ZUi'LL w c a�3u�Dm.ae�J 8S¢pp°w�y¢
ZZmin A a,w mi w y g
zj Z kw
o6 e 0 o al = W s j_U y mo 0
oz..O, I ¢
zz
¢- H M�. o ¢
w,�OJJ¢J.f
�N 4 a
7 i
Ji�
9 1 n r
sag R�
�0
y c �
i
r
4
s� Ic
I
A r,i.
sa�e wn_sam�o�,won vni:_sa 1,�Poevv.3wv,�m mr.°oxr xon anu„su ego ouwwe,vu_�.w h,ureuH31 n.r.we,m�:�mxra'-am.g�il�n'w.11���:i•�i:�'wo�w�'avtti»n•�+ticos.niwn':vi��<AMYI
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF EL
SEGUNDO, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING ENVIRONMENTAL
ASSESSMENT NO. EA-1158 AND ADOPTING PRECISE PLAN
AMENDMENT NO. PPA 16-01 TO AMEND PRECISE PLAN 71-2 AND 71-
3 TO ALLOW A DOUBLE LANE DRIVE-THROUGH AT 101 SOUTH
SEPULVEDA BOULEVARD IN THE HEAVY INDUSTRIAL (M-2) ZONE.
PETITIONED BY MCDONALD'S CORPORATION.
The City Council of the City of El Segundo does resolve as follows:
SECTION 1: The City Council finds and declares that:
A. On August 17, 2016, McDonald's Corporation filed an application for
Environmental Assessment No. EA-1158 and Precise Plan Amendment No.
PPA 16-01 for a second amendment to Precise Plan 71-2/71-3 (originally
referred to as Precise Plan 8) to allow the conversion of an existing single
lane drive-through to a double lane drive-through at a McDonald's
restaurant within the Heavy Industrial (M-2) Zone located at 101 South
Sepulveda Boulevard.
B. The application was reviewed by the City's Planning and Building Safety
Department for consistency with the General Plan and conformity with the
El Segundo Municipal Code ("ESMC");
C. In addition, the City reviewed the project's environmental impacts under the
California Environmental Quality Act (Public Resources Code §§ 21000, et
seq., "CEQA"), the regulations promulgated thereunder (14 Cal. Code of
Regulations §§15000, et seq., the "CEQA Guidelines"), and the City's
Environmental Guidelines (City Council Resolution No. 3805, adopted
March 16, 1993);
D. On December 8, 2016, the Commission held a public hearing to receive
public testimony and other evidence regarding the application including,
without limitation, information provided to the Commission by City staff and
public testimony, and representatives of McDonald's Corporation.
Following the public hearing, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution
No. 2808 recommending that the City Council approve the project;
E. On February 7, 2017, the City Council held a duly advertised public hearing
to receive public testimony and other evidence regarding the application
including, without limitation, information provided to the City Council by City
Staff and public testimony;
-1-
99
F. The City Council considered the information provided by City Staff and
public testimony. This Resolution, and its findings, are made based upon
the evidence presented at the Planning Commission at its February 7, 2017
hearing including the staff reports submitted by the Planning and Building
Safety Department.
SECTION 2: Factual Findings and Conclusions. The City Council finds that the following
facts exist:
A. The subject site is located in the Heavy Industrial (M-2) Zone on a 1.27-acre
portion of a larger 625.24-acre section of the Chevron Oil Refinery located
at 101 South Sepulveda Boulevard.
B. The surrounding land uses consist of a three-story office/research and
development building across El Segundo Boulevard to the northwest, the
22 story Pacific Corporate Towers, containing approximately 1,683,056
square feet of office uses, to the northeast, a single-story commercial
shopping center across Sepulveda Boulevard to the east, and the
surrounding area to the west and south is developed as the Chevron Oil
Refinery, with an employee park and fitness center adjacent to the project.
C_ The existing development and uses were approved in 1971 under Precise
Plan 71-2 and 71-3 and an amendment in 1997 (EA-394 and PP 97-2). The
1997 Amendment specified that "[t]he development standards for Precise
Plan 8 are those set forth in the plans for the proposed project," which
depicted a single-lane drive-through.
D. The subject site is developed with a 12-pump Chevron service station, a
3,342-square foot McDonald's fast food restaurant with a single lane drive-
through, and a 1,736-square foot Chevron foodmart integrated into the
restaurant building.
E. Vehicular access for the project site is provided by three existing driveways
on Sepulveda Boulevard and one existing driveway on El Segundo
Boulevard. A previously approved parking demand study determined 45
parking spaces would be required for the restaurant and foodmart. The
project will provide 62 parking spaces, including 59 standard and 3
accessible spaces.
F. The proposed project would amend the existing Precise Plan to allow a
double lane drive-through.
-2-
100
SECTION 3: Environmental Assessment. Based upon the facts identified in Section 2 of
this Resolution and the evidence presented, the City Council finds that the proposed
project is exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act
(CEQA) pursuant to 14 California Code of Regulations §15301 which identifies the project
as a Class 1 exemption (Existing Facilities) and § 15304 as a Class 4 categorical
exemption (Minor Alterations to Land). The project consists of a Precise Plan
Amendment that will allow the conversion of an existing single lane drive-through to a
double lane drive-through at drive-through restaurants in the Heavy Industrial (M-2) Zone.
The proposed project would result in negligible expansion of the existing use and includes
minor alterations to landscaping that do not involve removal of healthy, mature, and/or
scenic trees. Furthermore, the site has no value as a habitat for endangered, rare, of
threatened species. There are adequate utilities and public services to serve the project.
The project is consistent with the City's General Plan and Zoning Code, and is not
anticipated to have any significant impacts with regard to traffic, noise, air quality, or water
quality.
SECTION 4: General Plan and Zoning. The proposed project conforms with the City's
General Plan and the zoning regulations in the ESMC as follows;
A. The General Plan Land Use Designation of the project site is Heavy
Industrial. The proposed project is consistent with the following General
Plan Economic Development objectives and policies: Objective ED1-1 and
Policies ED1-2.1 and ED 1-2.3, which relate to the maintenance and
expansion of El Segundo's economic base.
B. The proposed project is consistent with the following General Plan Land Use
policies: LU 1-5.6, LU 4-1.1, and LU 4-1.2, which relate to conformance with
City zoning standards and guidelines for the implementation of CEQA,
requiring landscaping and its maintenance for commercial projects, and
compliance with Health and Safety Code requirements.
C. The proposed project is consistent with the following General Plan Circulation
goals, objectives, and policies: C 1-2 and C 2-1, C 3-1, Goal C-1, and Policy
C 3-2.1, which relate to the provision of a circulation system to ensure safety
of residents, workers, and visitors of El Segundo and the consideration of
circulation impacts.
D. The proposed project is consistent with the General Plan Air Quality
Objective AQ-10-1 which relates to the control of particulate emissions.
E. The site is zoned Heavy Industrial (M-2), which permits drive-through
restaurants, service stations, and foodmarts with the approval of a
Conditional Use Permit (CUP). However, because the 1997 Amendment to
the Precise Plan specified that "[t]he development standards for Precise
-3-
101
Plan 8 are those set forth in the plans for the proposed project," which
depicted a single-lane drive-through, an amendment to the precise plan is
required.
SECTION 5: Approval. The City Council hereby approves and adopts the following
amendments to Precise Plan 8 subject to the attached Conditions of Approval:
That double lane drive-throughs are permitted under the Precise Plan. Any
proposed modification to the existing single-lane drive through must comply
with ESMC § 15-15-5(Q) which (1) allows drive-through lanes to encroach into
required landscaped setbacks up to a maximum of 50% of the required
setback; (2) provides that drive-through lanes must not interfere with on-site
and off-site circulation and (3) requires drive-throughs maintain a minimum
continuous length of 150 feet for an eating and drinking establishment.
SECTION 6: Reliance on Record. Each and every one of the findings and determinations
in this Resolution are based on the competent and substantial evidence, both oral and
written, contained in the entire record relating to the project. The findings and
determinations constitute the independent findings and determinations of the City Council
in all respects and are fully and completely supported by substantial evidence in the
record as a whole.
SECTION 7: Summaries of Information. All summaries of information in the findings
which precede this section, are based on the substantial evidence in the record. The
absence of any particular fact from such summary is not an indication that a particular
finding, is not based in part on that fact.
SECTION 8: This Resolution will become effective immediately upon adoption and will
remain effective until superseded by a subsequent resolution.
SECTION 9: A copy of this Resolution must be mailed to McDonald's Corporation and
Chevron USA Inc., and to any other person requesting a copy.
-4-
102
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this _ day of February, 2017.
Suzanne Fuentes, Mayor
ATTEST:
STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ) SS
CITY OF EL SEGUNDO )
I, Tracy Weaver, City Clerk of the City of El Segundo, California, do hereby certify that
the whole number of members of the City Council of said City is five; that the foregoing
Resolution No. was duly passed, approved and adopted by said City Council at a
regular meeting held on the day of February, 2017, approved and signed by the
Mayor, and attested to by the City Clerk, by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
Tracy Weaver, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Mark D. Hensley, City Attorney
-5-
103
CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO.
Exhibit A
CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
In addition to all applicable provisions of the El Segundo Municipal Code ("ESMC"),
McDonald's Corporation and Chevron USA Inc. agree to comply with the following
provisions as conditions for the City of El Segundo's approval of Environmental
Assessment No. EA-1158 and Precise Plan Amendment No. PPA 16-01, ("Project
Conditions"):
Planninq Division Conditions
1. Before the City issues a building permit, the applicant must submit plans
which show that the Project substantially complies with plans and conditions
approved and on file with the Planning and Building Safety Department. Any
subsequent modification to the approved Project must be referred to the
Planning and Building Safety Director to determine whether Planning
Commission approval is required for the proposed modification.
2. Any subsequent modification to the project as approved must be referred to
the Director of Planning and Building Safety for approval and a determination
regarding the need for Planning Commission review of the proposed
modification.
3. A complete Landscape Plan and Irrigation Plan must be submitted for the
review and approval of the Director of Planning and Building Safety. The
Landscape and Irrigation Plan must have a planting schedule and description
of the proposed irrigation system. The proposed Landscape and Irrigation
Plan must meet the requirements of ESMC §§ 15-4C-6 and 15-4C-5(I)
regarding Open Space and Landscaping. The Landscape Plan and Irrigation
Plan must also meet the Water Conservation in Landscaping requirements in
ESMC §§15-1-6, 15-2-14, and 15-15A (Ordinance No. 1515).
4. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the applicant must submit
a Master Sign Program to ensure compatibility with the surrounding area and
the aesthetic objectives of the General Plan, as well as ensure sign do not
impede traffic or pedestrian safety. The Master Sign Program is subject to
approval of the Director of Planning and Building Safety, or their designee.
5. All conditions of approval contain in Resolution No. 4028, adopted by the City
Council on July 24, 1997, will remain in effect.
-6-
104
Buildinq Safetv Division Conditions
6. The applicant must comply with the ESMC, the applicable State Water
Conservation requirements, the 2013 edition of the California Building Code
(CBC), as amended by the City of El Segundo, the California Residential
Code, California Electrical Code, California Mechanical Code, California
Plumbing Code, California Green Building Standards and Building Energy
Efficiency Standards.
7. Before the City issues building permits, the applicant must submit plans
stamped by a State-licensed architect or engineer to the Planning and
Building Safety Division for review and approval. Building Safety Division staff
will determine if the plans must include demolition, complete structural
calculations, details, notes and material specifications.
Fire Department Conditions
8. The applicant must comply with the applicable requirements of the 2013
California Building and Fire Codes and the 2013 International Fire Code as
adopted by the City of El Segundo and El Segundo Fire Department
Regulations. On January 1, 2017, the City will be adopting the 2016
California Building Standards. For projects submitted for plan review after
January 1, 2017, the 2016 California Editions apply.
Construction Conditions
9. The applicant must keep soil stockpiled for two days or more covered, moist,
or treated with soil binders to prevent dust generation.
10. The applicant must cover or maintain two feet of free board on any stock pile
of debris, dirt or rusty materials on-site.
11. All haul trucks hauling soil, sand, and other loose materials must either be
covered or maintain two feet of freeboard.
12. The owner or contractor must conduct daily street sweeping and truck wheel
cleaning to prevent dirt in the storm drain system.
13. All diesel equipment must be operated with closed engine doors and must be
equipped with factory-recommended mufflers.
14. The applicant must provide a telephone number for local residents to call to
submit complaints associated with the construction noise. The number must
_7_
105
be posted on the project site and must be easily viewed from adjacent public
areas.
15. All construction-related parking must be accommodated on-site. No
construction related parking is permitted off-site.
Miscellaneous Conditions
16. McDonald's Corporation c/o Lorraine Fortelka, Senior Counsel, and Chevron
USA Inc. c/o Jacqueline McGinnis, Real Property Officer, agree to indemnify
and hold the City harmless from and against any claim, action, damages,
costs (including, without limitation, attorney's fees), injuries, or liability, arising
from the City's approval of Environmental Assessment No. EA-1158 and
Precise Plan Amendment No. PPA 16-01. Should the City be named in any
suit, or should any claim be brought against it by suit or otherwise, whether
the same be groundless or not, arising out of the City approval of
Environmental Assessment No. EA-1158 and Precise Plan Amendment No.
PPA 16-01, McDonald's Corporation c/o Lorraine Fortelka, Senior Counsel,
and Chevron USA Inc. c/o Jacqueline McGinnis, Real Property Officer agree
to defend the City (at the City's request and with counsel satisfactory to the
City) and will indemnify the City for any judgment rendered against it or any
sums paid out in settlement or otherwise. For purposes of this section "the
City" includes the City of El Segundo's elected officials, appointed officials,
officers, and employees.
By signing this document, McDonald's Corporation c/o Lorraine Fortelka, Senior Counsel,
and Chevron USA Inc. c/o Jacqueline McGinnis, Real Property Officer certify that they
have read, understood, and agrees to the Project Conditions listed in this document.
McDonald's Corporation c/o Lorraine Fortelka, Senior Counsel
Chevron USA Inc. c/o Jacqueline McGinnis, Real Property Officer
{If Corporation or similar entity, needs two officer signatures or evidence that one
signature binds the company)
-8-
106
RESOLUTION NO. 2372
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE
CITY OF EL SEGUNDO, CALIFORNIA, ADOPTING
WITH CERTAIN CONDITIONS SPECIFIC (PRECISE)
PLAN NO. 8. (SERVICE STATION)
WHEREAS, under the provisions of Title 20 (The Comprehen-
sive Zoning Ordinance) of the "El Segundo Municipal Code" and the laws of
the State of California, applicable to such matters, Standard Oil Company of
California, Western Operations, Inc., has filed its petition for the adoption
of Specific (Precise) Plan No. 8; and
WHEREAS, said Plan is for property located in the City of
El Segundo, County of Los Angeles, State of California, more particularly
described as follows:
A portion of Lot 3, Tract No. 1314, in the City of El Segundo as
recorded in Book 20, Page 81 of Maps, Records of Los Angeles
County, California, described as follows:
BEGINNING at the Northeast corner of said Lot 3 said
point also being the Northeast corner of Section 13,
Township 3 South, Range 15 West, S.B.B. & M.; thence
due West along the northerly line of said Lot 3 a distance
of 225.00 feet to a point; thence South 0° Oil 00" East
along a line parallel with and 225 feet westerly of the
easterly line of said Lot 3 a distance of 50 feet to the
true point of beginning; thence continuing South 00 Olt
00" East along said parallel line a distance of 200 feet
to a point; thence North 8,90 59' 30" East slong a line a
distance of 217 feet to a point in a line parallel with and
8.00 feet westerly of the easterly line of said Lot 3;
thence North 01' 01' 00"West along said parallel line a
distance of 160.01 feet to a point of tangency with a cir-
cular curve concave to the Southwest with central angle
of 89' 59' 00" and radius of 40 feet; thence along an arc
of said curve a distance of 62.82 feet to a point of tan-
gency with a line parallel with and 50 feet southerly of
the said northerly line of Lot 3; thence due West along,
said parallel line a distance of 177.01 feet to the point
of beginning;
and said Plan was submitted to the Planning Commission of the City of
El Segundo, and after a hearing duly and regularly held, was approved and
recommended for adoption by the City Council; and
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of El Segundo has duly
and regularly held a public hearing on said Plan; and
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of El Segundo has now
acquired jurisdiction to adopt this resolution;
EXHIBIT 2 107
i I Oq
NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
EL SEGUNDO, CALIFORNIA, DOES HEREBY RESOLVE, DECLARE, DETER-
MINE AND ORDER AS FOLLOWS:
SECTION 1. That said Specific (Precise) Plan No. 8 herein-
above referred to as approved by the Planning Commission of the City of
El Segundo in its Resolution No. 730, be and the same is hereby approved
and adopted upon the following conditions:
(1) That Alameda brick veneer shall be added to the main build-
ing as indicated on the right and left elevations on the drawing as submitted.
(2) That the exterior trash storage area shall be screened from
view regardless of the location of the storage area.
(3) That a sidewalk shall be constructed to City specifications
from the South property line to the North property line paralleling Sepulveda
Boulevard.
(4) That street trees shall be planted and maintained between
the driveways on Sepulveda Boulevard in accordance with the City's master
plan of street trees.
(5) That all utilities providing services to the new building nor-
mally placed above ground, including without limitation electrical service
lines and telephone service lines, shall be placed underground, except that
if it is not possible to place said lines underground, overhead services may
be approved by the City Council.
(6) That signs shall not be permitted to overhang the street right-
of-way.
(7) That plants shall not exceed 24 inches in height and the park-
ing of automobiles, and the placement of sign poles, or lighting standards, shall
not be permitted in the 15 foot corner vision clearance triangle (Section 20.58.Of10
of the "El Segundo Municipal Code").
(8) That the roof line as indicated on the elevation sheet be
changed to a suburban style station wLth a low pitch roof.
(9) That no building or structure shall be constructed that will
interfere with the use of the existing free right turn until the right turn at
-2-
108
I (iS..
El Segundo and Sepulveda Boulevards is completed.
(10) That construction shall commence within one year from
March B, 1971; this request becomes null and void if construction has not
commenced within said time.
SECTION 2. That the applicant is informed that the City Council
does not, by this action, intend to impair its authority to modify the traffic
and circulation restrictions in the neighborhood of applicant's property if the
need arises to make such modification.
SECTION S. That the City Clerk is hereby authorized and
directed to endorse the said plan as hereby approved and adopted by the City
Council. Said plan is on file in the office of the City Clerk for public inspec-
tion and by this reference incorporated in this resolution and made a part
hereof.
SECTION 4. That this resolution shall become effective upon
adoption.
SECTION 5. That the City Clerk shall certify to the passage
and adoption of this resolution; shall enter the same in the book of original
resolutions of said City, and shall make a minute of the passage and adoption
thereof in the records of the proceedings of the City Council of said City, in
the minutes of the meeting at which the same is passed and adopted.
PASSED, APPROVED and ADOPTED this Sth day of March
1971.
ayor o thT z of,E;I egund California.
ATTEST, (�
City Clerk
(SEAL)
-3-
109 ,
STATE OF CALIFORNIA, )
)
COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES, ) SS
CITY OF EL SEGUNDO. )
I, JANE D. HOUGH, , City Clerk of the
City of El Segundo, California, DO HEREBY CERTIFY that the
whole number of members of the City Council of the said City
is five; that the foregoing Resolution, being Resolution No. 2372
was duly passed and adopted by the said City Council, approved
and signed by the Mayor of said City, and attested by the City
Clerk of said City, all at a regular meeting of the said Council
held on the 8th day of Alp rrth . 197_}__
and that the same was so passed and adopted by the following vote:
AYES: Councilmen Frederick, McGill, Nadel and Mavor
Stephens;
NOES: Councilmen None;
ABS ENT: Councilmen None;
ABSTAINING: Councilman Balmer
WITNESS my hand and the official seal of said City
this 15th day of _ MAr . 197_1
�...�� r
y C:lerlc of the Lity 1 Segundo
California
(SEAL)
c
110
RESOLUTION NO. 4028
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CT 11Y OF EL SEGUNDO,
CALIFORNIA, APPROVING PRECISE PLAN AMENDMENT 97-2 TO
AMEND PRECISE PLAN 8, CERTIFYING A MITIGATED NEGATIVE
DECLARATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS FOR F.NWRONMENrAL
ASSESSMENT EA-394 AND ADOPTING A MITIGATION MONITORING
PROGRAK TO ALLOW A MCDONALD'S DRIVE THRU RESTAURANT,A
REBUILT CHL'VItON SERVICE STATION AND A FOODMART AT 101
SOUTH SMYMVEDA BOULEVARD. PFITIIONED BY CHEVRON USA
i
PRODUCTS COMPANY.
I
R
WEREAS, an application, has beer' received from Chevron USA Products Company,
requesting approval of an Environmental Assessment and an Amendment to a Precise Plan to
allow the development of a.McDonald's drive-thru restaurant, a Chevron Service station with 12
fueling positions, and a Chevron foodmart on 1.27 acres located at 101 South Sepulveda
Boulevard in the Heavy Industrial(M-2) Zone; and
WT tFAS, an Environmental Assessment (EA-394), including a Draft Initial Study and
Mitigated Negative Declaration of Environmental Impacts for the propo sed use,has been prepared
and circulated to all Interested parties, staff, and affected public agencies for review and
comment in the tirne and manner prescribed by law; and
W 4EREAS,the Planning Commission has reviewed the application and supporting evidence
with the authority and criteria contained in the California Environmental Quality Act, State CEQA
Guidelines and the City of E1 Segundo Guidelines for the Implementation of the California
Environmental Quality Act (Resolution No. 3805); and
WlffftEAS, a Traffic Impact Study was conducted to evaluate all transportation and
circulation impacts associated with the project and submitted with the application; and
WHEREAS, a Parking Demand Analysis was conducted to evaluate all parking impacts
associated with the project and submitted with the application; and
WHITLFAS, an Air Quality Assessment was conducted to estimate the air pollution
emissions which will be generated by the project to evaluate any potential air quality impacts
associated with the construction and operation of the facility and submitted with the application;
and
SEAS, a Fiscal Impact Analysis to evaluate the project costs versus project revenues
and the project's impact on City services was conducted by City Staff; and
WITM , and Environmental Site Investigation was submitted by the applicant, which
examined potential subsurface soil contamination on the property; and
WIIEREAS, on July 24, 1997, the Planning Commission did hold, pursuant to law, a duly
advertised public hearing on such matter in the Council Chamber of the City Hall, 350 Main
Street,and notice of the public hearing was given in the time,form and manner prescribed by law;
the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 2397, recommending approval of the Precise
Plan Amendment and Environmental Assessment; and
1
EXHIBIT 3
'Wl-T1 RW,on August 5, 1997,the City Council did hold,pursuant to law,a duly advertised
public hearing on such matter in the Council Chamber of the City Hall, 350 Main Street, and
notice of the public hearing was given in the time, form and manner prescribed by law;and
WXEERFAS,opportunity was given to all persons present to speak for or against the findings
of Environmental Assessment EA-394 and Precise Plan Amendment 97-2; and
WIIEREAS, at said hearing the following facts were established:
1. The applicant is proposing to construct a new 3,341 square foot McDonald's drive-thru
restaurant, a 1,795.5 square foot Chevron Foodmart, and Chevron Service Station with 12
fueling positions at 101 South Sepulveda Boulevard.No outdoor dining or alcohol sales are
proposed. The restaurant is proposed to operate from 5.010 am to 12:00 am (midnight)
Sunday through Thursday and 5:00 am to 1:00 am on Friday and Saturday. The drive-thru
is proposed to operate twenty-four(24)hours a day, seven.(7)days a week.While there are
three windows deigned to allow"face-to-face"ordering payment and pick-up,ordering will
usually take place from menu board/speaker box located west side of the building with the
drive-thru queue on the west and south side, and pick-up window on the south side of the
building. The building is one story and 22 feet maximum in height.
2. The lot currently has a Chevron Service Station with 14 fueling positions, a four-bay
automobile service center,and a 240 square foot cashier kiosk.The existing structures will
be demolished.
03. Access to the site would be provided by two existing driveways on Sepulveda Boulevard,
one existing driveway on El Segundo Boulevard and one new 37 foot wide driveway on
Sepulveda Boulevard. Additionally, a 30 foot wide existing driveway on El Segundo
Boulevard closest to Sepulveda Boulevard would be eliminated. A 13 foot wide by 50 foot
long loading zone is proposed on the east side of the building and 45 total parking spaces
would be provided, including 43 standard spaces and 2 handicapped spaces.
4. No new fences or walls are proposed;the existing 6 foot high chain link fence on the south
and west sides of the property are proposed to remain. The total site landscaping would
be approximately 11,110 square feet in area, covering 2096 of the total site.
5. A total of sixty (60) to seventy (70) employees would occupy the site; with a total of ten -
(10)to twenty(20) employees per shift.
6. The proposed BAR would be 0.09,well below the 0.6 FAR limit. All development standards
required by the Heavy Industrial(M-2)Zone would be met with the exception of the width _
of the new parking lot driveway, the number of parking spaces provided, and the number
of trees in the Vehicular Use Area and street side setbacks. The proposed development is
on a 1.27 acre portion of a larger 625.24 acre section of the Chevron Oil Refinery, The -
property would be leased to the operators of the McDonald's/Chevron.No division of land
is proposed or required by the Subdivision Map Act. i
7. The surrounding area to the west and south is developed as the Chevron Oil Refinery,with
an employee park and a fitness center adjacent to the project. A landscape strip
approximately five(5)feet to nine(9)feet in width would then separate the project parking
lot from adjacent portions of the Chevron Oil Refinery. To the east is a single-story
2
112
commercial shopping center across Sepulveda Boulevard,and there is a vacant three story
office, research and development building across El Segundo Boulevard to the north. To
the northeast are the 22 story Pacific Corporate Towers,containing 1,683,056 square feet
of office uses.The properties to the north across El Segundo Boulevard are zoned Medium
Manufacturing(MM), Public Facilities(PF), and General Commercial(C-3), to the south and
west is zoned Heavy Industrial (M-2), to the east across Sepulveda Boulevard is zoned
Open Space (OS), Parking (P), and General Commercial (C-3), and to the northeast across
El Segundo and Sepulveda Boulevards is zoned Corporate Office (CO).
8. The project site is Iocated within the southwest portion of the City of El Segundo,
approximately one mile west of the San Diego (1-405)Freeway and two miles south of the
1 Glenn Anderson (1-105) Freeway and Los Angeles International Airport (LAX). The Metro
J Green Line Light Rail and the closest station at El Segundo Boulevard and Nash Street is
located approximately one-half mile to the east of the project site.
9. The existing buildings, uses and development standards were approved under a Precise
f Plan (PP-8) in 1971, later renumbered as Precise Plan 71-12 and 71-13 for the
redevelopment of an older service station and the construction of a training center
adjacent to the service station. The training center building is currently used as a fitness
center by Chevron employees and is located directly west of the proposed parking lot at
the south end of the project.
10. The proposed project is subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA.). in
accordance with State guidelines and local requirements,a Draft Initial Study and Mitigated
Negative Declaration was prepared and circulated for interdepartmental and affected
agency review.No significant adverse impacts were identified which could not be mitigated
to an insignificant level,including impacts to traffic/circulation, risk of upset,air quality
and public services.
11. The Fiscal Impact Analysis, utilizing the City's Fiscal Impact Model, indicates that the
project will generate a fiscal surplus for the City of approximately$375,400 during its first
five years, after consideration of City service costs.
SECTION 1. AFTER CONSIDERING THE ABOVE FACTS, TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE PRESENTED
AT THE HEARING, AND STUDY OF PROPOSED ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT EA-
394 AND PRECISE PLAN AMENDMENT 97-2, THE CITY COUNCIL MAKES THE
FOLLOWING FINDINGS FOR THE PROPOSED PROJECT AND AMENDMENT TO
PRECISE PLAN 8: -
BONNE,WAL ASSESSMINT
1. The Draft Initial Study was made available to all local and affected agencies and for public
review and comment in the time and manner prescribed by law. The Initial Study -
concluded that the proposed project will not have a significant, adverse effect on the
environment, and a Mitigated Negative Declaration of Environmental Impact will be
prepared pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA); and
2. That when considering the whole record,there is no evidence that the project will have the -
potential for an adverse effect on wildlife resources or the habitat nn which the wildlife
depends, because the project is in a built-out urban environment; and
3
3. That the City Council authorizes and directs the Director of Planning and Building Safety
to file with the appropriate agencies a Certificate of Fee Exemption and de minimus finding
pursuant to AB 3158 and the California Code of Regulations. Within ten(10)days of the
approval of the Mitigated Negative Declaration of Envirbnmental Impacts, the applicant
shall submit to the City of El Segundo a fee of 525.00 required by the County of Los
Angeles for the filing of this certificate along with the required Notice of Determination.
As approved in AB 3158, the statutory requirements of CEQA will not be met and no
vesting shall occur until this condition is met and the required notices and fees are filed
with the County.
PRECLSE PLAN
1. That the proposed location of the project is in accord with the purposes of the zone in
which the site is located. The proposed project is consistent with the intent of the Heavy
Industrial (M-2) Zone which refining, construction yards, factories, and heavy
manufacturing uses. The proposed project adds restaurants with drive-thru operations,
and retail sales to the permitted uses stated in Precise flan 8 (PP 71-12 & 71-13).
2. Precise Plan 8 (PP 71-12 &71-13),which established the design of the existing facilities and
the placement of essential related facilities such as parking,traffic circulation,and loading,
is not significantly altered by the proposed amendment.The traffic will still access the site
from three of the four original locations with an additional driveway at the south end of
the project site,
03. The amendment to allow the proposed restaurant and foodmart to provide 45 parking
spaces instead of 51 parking spaces as required by the current Zoning code,based on the
submitted Parking Demand Analysis, the amendment to allow the placement of 7 trees in
the 36,218 square foot Vehicular Use Area (VUA) instead of the 12 trees required by the
Zoning Code, the amendment to provide 5 and 8 trees in the in the£l Segundo Boulevard
and Sepulveda Boulevard street side setbacks,respectively,instead of 7 and 11 trees in the
respective setbacks, and the amendment to allow the new driveway to exceed the required
30 foot maximum width by 7 feet are consistent with the purposes of a Precise Plan which,
like a Specific Plan or a Planned Residential Development,provides the flexibility to allow
for deviation from specific site development standards to achieve the overall design for
the site.
GENERAL PL4N CONSISTENCY
1. That the proposed use is consistent with the following General Plan Economic
Development objectives and policies: ETA 1-1.1, ED 1-2.1, ED 1-2.2, and ED 1-2.3, which -
relate to prioritizing economic development, diversification of an economic base,
expanding the retail and commercial base, targeting industries that balance economic -
development and quality of life goals, and balancing development with resource and
Infrastructure capacity.
2. That the proposed use is consistent with the following General flan Land Use Goals,
Policies and objectives: LU 1-5.6, LU 1-5.7, LU 3-2.3, LU 4-1, LU 4-1.1, LU 4-1.2, LU 4-1.4, -
LU 7-1.2 and LU 7-2.3. These issues relate to providing a stable tax, Lase, providing
landscaping, providing high quality retail facilities in proximity to employment centers,
insuring seismic safety,providing good accessibility to transportation routes,encouraging
4
alternative transportation modes,and requiring adequate public facilities and underground
utilities.
3. The proposed use is consistent with the .following General Plan Goals, Policies and
Objectives related to circulation: C-1, C 1-2, C 1.1.8, C 1-1.13, C 1-1.15, C 1-1.16, C 2-1, C
2-1.6, C 2-2.2, C 3-1.1, C 3-1.2, C 3-1.5, C 3-1.7, C 3-2.1, and C 4-1.2. These issues identify
the need for full examination the providing for the present and future circulation needs
of the City, implementation of Master Plan roadway improvements, evaluation of project
impacts, protecting right-of-way to accommodate future growth, upgrading substandard
streets,provide a safe and convenient pedestrian circulation system,encouraging facilities
designed for easy pedestrian access,bicycle facilities, full mitigation of all project-related
circulation impacts, requiring developers to pay for mitigation measures, integration of
transportation with land uses and surrounding environments, adequate pedestrian, and
bicycle access, adequate parking, evaluation of project impacts on CMP routes, and
evaluation of circulation system impacts.
6
4. The proposed use is consistent with the following General Plan Goals, Policies and
Objectives related to air quality:AQ 6-1.1,AQ 10-1,AQ 10-1.2, and AQ 10-1.3,which relate
to truck delivery schedules,paving parking lots, encouraging energy conservation features
in- the design, of new projects, and requiring conformance with the SCAQMD PM10
standards..
SECTION 2. THE CITY COUNCIL HEREBY APPROVES AND ADOPTS THE FOLLOWING
AMENDMENTS TO PRECISE PLAN 8 SUBJECT TO THE CONDITIONS SET FORTH IN
SECTION 3 OF THIS RESOLUTION.
1. Drive-thru restaurants and retail sales are permitted uses under Precise Plan 8.
2. The development standards for Precise Plan 8 are those set forth in the plans for the
proposed project, dated July 1, 1997, including any revisions to said plans pursuant to
Condition 1 of Section 3 of this Resolution. In particular, there shall be a minimum. of 7
trees in the Vehicular Use Area and a minimum of S and 8 trees in the El Segundo
Boulevard and Sepulveda Boulevard stree side yard setbacks, respectively.
3. The design of the existing facilities and the placement of essential facilities such as
parking, traffic circulation and loading are as set forth in said plans and pursuant to
Condition No. 9 of Section 3 of this Resolution.In particular, the required parking for the
Precise Plan includes reduced parking,based on a Parking Demand Analysis, as set forth
in Condition No. 23 of Section 3 of this Resolution. The width of the proposed driveway
at the south end of the proposed parking lot maybe maximum of 3 7 feet wide, as set forth
in Condition No. 23 of Section 4 of this Resolution.
SECTION 3. THE CITY COUNCIL HEREBY APPROVES ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT EA-394,
AND ADOPTS AND CERTIFIES A MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION OF THE
PROPOSED PROJECT SUBJECT TO TIME FOLLOWING CONDITIONS AND MITIGATION
MEASURES:
1. Prior to approval of the building plans, the applicant shall develop plans which indicate
that the project is in substantial conformance with plans approved and on file with the
Department of Planning and Building Safety. Any subsequent modification to the project
as approved shall be referred to the Director of Planning and Building Safety for a _
S
determination regarding the need for Planning Commission review of the proposed
modification.
2. Prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the applicant shall pay a one-time library
services mitigation fee of $0.03 per gross square foot of building floor area for each
building.
3. Prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the applicant shall pay a one-time Fire
Services Mitigation Fee of $0.14 per gross square foot of building floor area for each
building.
4. Prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the applicant shall pay a one-time Police
Services Mitigation Fee of $0.11 per gross square foot of building floor area for each
building.
5. Prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the applicant shall pay a Traffic Impact
Mitigation Fee,pursuant to City Council Resolution No.3969,to the Department of Public
Works,.
6. Prior to approval of the building plans,the applicant shall submit a Security Plan,including
a complete exterior lighting plan, to the Police Department for review and approval. The
security measures shall be installed prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy or
Implemented prior to operation, as appropriate.
7. A Landscaping and Irrigation Flan shall be submitted by the applicant to the Directors of
Planning and Building Safety and Recreation and Parks and the Police Chief prior to
approval of the building plans. All landscaped areas shall be provided with a permanent
automatic watering or irrigation system and shall be permanently n iaintained in a neat and
clean manner.The Landscape Plans shall be revised to include 1 shade tree for every 5,174
square feet of 'V'ehicular Use Area (VUA). A minimum of 5 shade trees must be located
along the El Segundo Boulevard street frontage and 8 shade trees must be located along
the Sepulveda Boulevard street frontage. The applicant, if feasible, shall incorporate
provisions for the use of reclaimed water in the landscaping and Irrigation Plan.The Plan
shall be reviewed and approved by the Director of Planning and Building Safety and
Director of Recreation and Parks and installed per the approved plans by the applicant
Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy.
8. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy,the applicant shall submit a Master Sign
Plan to ensure compatibility with the surrounding area and the aesthetic objectives of the
General Plan,as well as to ensure that signs do not Impede traffic or pedestrian safety.The
Master Sign Plan shall be subject to the approval of the Director of Planning and Building
Safety and all signs shall be installed per the approved plan prior to issuance of a
Certificate of Occupancy. -
9. The applicant shall submit a Circulation Plan, prior to approval of the building plans, to
be reviewed and approved by the Directors of Public Works and Planning and Building
Safety which contains, but is not limited to,the following provisions;
A. The eastern most driveway on the El Segundo Boulevard side of the property shall
be removed and replaced with sidewalk, curb and gutter;
6
4P
11F
B. Signs which limit .)eft,-tarn ingress to the project from westbound El Segundo
Boulevard and left-turn egress onto westbound El Segundo Boulevard from the
existing driveway at the west end of the site shall be prohibited from 6:00 a.m. to
6:00 p.m. Monday through Friday, excluding Holidays shall be installed;
C. The area in front of the drive-thru, within the 25 foot wide drive aisle, shall be
striped and labeled as"keep clear"to prevent vehicles from blocking the area which
could create a traffic safety hazard; and,
D. Caltrans approval for all work to be performed in the Sepulveda Boulevard (State
Route 1)right-of-way.
All required Circulation Plan elements shall be installed prior to issuance of a Certificate
of Occupancy.
10. 'A circulation and traffic review will be required a minimum of six (6) months to a
maximum of twelve(12)months after the issuance of the Certificate of Occupancy for the
site. The definition of a "review" involves the preparation of a study for the actual
operating restaurant, foodmart, and service station identical to that performed for the
development of the site.Additionally, the review shall include reporting of any accidents
or other vehicular conflicts related to the fuel delivery operations and/or any other on-site
circulation problems.The findings shall be submitted to the Departments of Planning and
Building Safety, Public Works, .Police and Fire for review and approval. If necessary, the
drive-thrn and other operations will be modified to maintain clear circulation and access
at all times or other mitigation that the City deems appropriate will be required.
11. During construction, the entire project site shall be enclosed by a six-foot high chain link
fence. Oates for site fencing shall be located at driveways and shall not open over
sidewalk/public right-of-way. A fencing plan shall be submitted by the applicant and
reviewed and approved by the Director of Planning and Building safety prior to installation.
12. All work within.the City public right-of-way shall be in accordance with the latest edition
of the Standard Specifications for Public Works {Construction and City of El Segundo
Standard Specifications. No work shall be performed in the public right-of-way without
first obtaining a Public Works permit.
13. Prior to approval of the building plans,plans shall indicate that all existing and proposed
utilities shall be placed underground to the satisfaction of the City Engineer.The applicant
shall assume the costs for the relocation of all utilities, Including but not limited to, light
poles, electrical vaults, and fire hydrants which are affected by the proposed project.
14. Encroachment permits must be obtained from the Engineering Division Public Works
Department for demolition haul-tiff.Permit must be obtained at the same time the permit
for demolition is issued.An encroachment permit for grading is also required when import
or export of dirt exceeds fifty(50) cubic yards. Demolition and grading may be listed on
one encroachment permit.
15. If new sewer laterals are required and constructed in the public right-of-way they shall be
a minimum of six (6) inches inside diameter. Material shall be "vitreous clay pipe". Each
lateral shall have a six(6)inch clean-out brought to grade at the property line and securely
I
7
117
capped. A B9 size box shall be placed around the C.O.for protection. The box shall have
a cover emblazoned with the word "sewer". If in a traffic area, cover shall be traffic
approved. All planned sewer connections shall be checked for elevation prior to starting
construction. Existing sewer laterals shall be plugged at the sewer mainline and capped at
the property line. Existing six (6) inch wyes may be reused if approved by the Director of
Public Works.
16. No material storage is allowed in the public right-of-way except by permit issued by the
! Engineering Division of the Public Works Department.If material storage is allowed in the
public right-of-way it shall be confined to parkway areas and street parking areas, as long
as safe and adequate pedestrian and vehicular passage is maintained at all times.Storage
beyond these areas in the public right-of-way requires prior approval of the Public Works
Department and shall be limited to a maximum period of 24 hours.
17. Prior to Certificate of Occupancy, new curbs, sidewalk, driveway approaches, wheelchair
ramps and.A.C.pavement,including alleys,shall be constructed/reconstructed as required:
by the Director of Public Works. Existing driveways and ether concrete work not to be
incorporated into the construction shall be removed and replaced with standard curb and
sidewalk.
18. The applicant shall submit the appropriate documentation to show conformance with or
exemption from the state Water Quality Control Board's National Pollution Discharge
Elimination System (NPDES) Permit for construction related stormwater run-off to the
Director of Public Works prior to the approval of the building plans.
19. The applicant shall develop the property pursuant to applicable provisions of the City's
Water Conservation Ordinance.
20. The removal and relocation of any underground storage tanks (UST's)shall be required to
comply with all applicable State and Federal requirements for UST's, which will include
additional soil sampling around the existing tanks-and associated piping to the dispensing
islands. If additional soil contamination is discovered, remediation may be required.
21. Should any previously un-recorded archeological or cultural resources be encountered
during construction of the project, all work will be stopped and the Department of
Planning and Building Safety will be notified immediately. At the owner's expense a
qualified archeologist will be consulted to determine the potential significance of the find,
and his findings shall be submitted to the Director of Planning and Building Safety prior
to the commencement of work
22. During construction dust control measures shall be required in accordance with the City's
Dust Control Ordinance. Grading will be discontinued during first-stage smog alerts and
suspended during periods of high wind (i.e. over 15 miles per hour). All hauling trucks
shall have loads covered or wetted and loaded below the sideboards to minimize dust.
23. The proposed restaurant and foodmart shall be allowed to have a minimum of 45 parking
spaces, based on a total floor area of 5,137 square feet.
24. The proposed driveway at the south end of the proposed parking lot shall be a
width of 37 feet. maximum
8
25. The applicant shall indemnify,defend,protect, and hold harmless the City,its elected and
appointed officials, officers, agents and employees from and against any and all claims,
actions, causes of action,proceedings or suits which challenge or attack the validity of the
City's approval of Environmental Assessment EA-394 and Precise Plan.Amendment 97-2.
SECTION 4: The City Clerk shall certify to the passage and adoption of this Resolution, shall
entered the same in the book of original resolutions of said city; and shall make a
minute of the passage and adoption thereof in the records of the proceedings of the
City Council of said City, in the minutes of the meeting which the same is passed
and adopted.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this Sth day of August 1997.
Sandra Jaco . yor
of the City f E Segundo,
California
ATTESTED:
! Cindy Mortesen, City Clerk
(SEAL)
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
zl�
Mark D. Hensley, City Attorn
iAA394-cc.res
9
�J
I
I
CERTIFICATION
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ]
COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ] SS
CITY OF EL SEGUNDO ]
I, Lora Freeman, Deputy City Clerk of the City of El Segundo, California, DO
HEREBY CERTIFY that the whole number of members of the City Council of the said
City is five; that the foregoing resolution, being RESOLUTION NO. 4028 was duly passed
and adopted by the said City Council, approved and signed by the Mayor or said City,
and attested by the City Clerk of said City, all at a regular meeting of the said Council
held on the Sth day of August, 1997, and the same was so passed and adopted by the
following vote:
AYES: Mayor Jacobs, Mayor ProTem Wernick, Councilwoman
Fnedkin, Councilman Weston, and Councilman Gordon
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTENTION: None
NOT PARTICIPATING: None
WITNESS MY HAND THE OFFICIAL SEAL OF SAID CITY this 7th day of August,
1997.
ora Freeman, Deputy City Clerk
of the City of El Segundo,
California
(SEAL)
n
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7,2017
AGENDA ITEM STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Unfinished Business
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Review and approve the three-year strategic plan (FY 2016-17 through FY 2018-19). (Fiscal Impact
$0)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. City Council review and approve the three-year Strategic Plan(FY 2016-17 through FY
2018-19).
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
1. Proposed Strategic Plan
2. Example of Community Survey
FISCAL IMPACT:
Amount Budgeted: N/A
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): N/A
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 5(b) Champion Economic Development and Fiscal Sustainability:
El Segundo approaches its work in a financially disciplined and responsible way
Objective: 2 The City will maintain a stable, efficient, and transparent financial environment
PREPARED BY: Joseph Lillio, Director of Finance
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
BACKGROUND & DISCUSSION:
The City started the strategic planning process by holding its first Strategic Planning session on June 22,
2016. A second meeting was held on August 3, 2016. The community and staff were encouraged to
attend and participate in the sessions. During these open sessions, City Council and staff discussed the
City's strengths and weaknesses as well as opportunities and threats(SWOT analysis). This analysis was
used to help identify the City's vision and goals. Based on decisions at these planning sessions,the goals,
objectives and activities were developed and incorporated into the draft strategic planning document.
On November 7, 2016, a third Strategic Planning session was held. This meeting focused on further
developing the objectives and activities, as well as introducing the metrics. Also, during the November
7th meeting, City Council asked staff to provide an example of a citizen and/or business survey. Staff
has developed a draft survey for Council's review. 3
121
On January 17th, Council was presented the revised draft strategic plan and customer satisfaction survey.
Council provided feedback to develop the customer satisfaction survey to align the survey with the
concept of the Net Promoter Score (NPS). The NPS provides the core measurement for customer
experience. In order to calculate your NPS, the survey will use the answer to a key question, using a 0-
10 scale: i.e. How likely is it that you would recommend [brand] to a friend or colleague?
Respondents are grouped as follows:
• Promoters (score 9-10) are loyal enthusiasts who will keep engaging and refer others, fueling possible
growth.
• Passives (score 7-8) are satisfied but unenthusiastic customers who are vulnerable to alternative
offerings.
• Detractors (score 0-6) are unhappy customers who can damage your brand and impede growth
through negative word-of-mouth.
Subtracting the percentage of Detractors from the percentage of Promoters yields the Net Promoter
Score, which can range from a low of-100 (if every customer is a Detractor)to a high of 100 (if every
customer is a Promoter).
Not at all likely Neutral Extremely likely
Detmct.oi Promoter
PROMOTERS - % DETRACTORS = NPS (NET PROMOTER SCORE)
Also, an employee satisfaction survey and questionnaire are in the process of being developed and will
be presented to City Council at a future Council meeting.
The attached proposed strategic plan incorporates the direction City Council provided to staff during the
November 7th and January 17th meetings. The strategic plan begins with a message from the City
Manager and includes the following sections:
• Executive Summary
• Mission, Vision& Values
• Strategic Direction
• Goals, Objectives, Activities & Key Performance Indicators
• Appendix: Work Plan for FY 2016-2019
122
The Goals are general topics that are likely to involve multiple departments and encompass many
objectives. Combining objectives within goals helps to ensure that activities covering similar areas are
aligned to produce effective and efficient results.
The Objectives are multi-year in nature. The timeframe for achieving an objective is typically three to
five years, although some may take longer to accomplish.
The Activities are the means to achieve the goals. The timeframe for implementing activities can be
within a single budget year and may span several years depending on the specific program or projects
undertaken.
The Mayor and City Council, the City Manager, and staff worked diligently to develop a three-year
Strategic Plan. The mission, "Provide a great place to live, work and visit," serves as the foundation for
the City's five major goals. These goals are:
1. Enhance Customer Service and Engagement;
2. Support Community Safety and Preparedness;
3. Develop as a Choice Employer and Workforce;
4. Develop Quality Infrastructure and Technology; and
5. Champion Economic Development and Fiscal Sustainability.
Identifying these goals will enable the City to align its efforts and resources to accomplish the goals and
achieve positive progress for the community of El Segundo. This plan sets the course for the City of El
Segundo to ensure the City's mission is accomplished.
The three-year Strategic Plan is a living document and should not be considered static by any means.
The strategic plan features a framework that can be adjusted based on the current needs of the
community. The goals, objectives, activities, and key performance indicators (KPIs) will be reviewed
annually and Council can modify these if necessary. Also, on a quarterly basis the City will provide
updates on the progress and performance of the work plan and monthly updates on the KPIs. As such,
the plan may be modified to ensure that stated goals are aligned with the needs of the community.
The City's quarterly updates will include a status column that delineates whether there is compliance
with each activity.
Green Current compliance with stated activity: City has fully implemented the stated
activity.
Yellow : .Current non-compliance with stated activity: City activity is not fully
implemented as identified in the Strategic Plan but the estimated date to achieve
full implementation is deliniated in"Next Steps to Compliance".
Red : Current non-compliance and cannot comply with stated activity: City activity
is not currently attainable as identified in the Strategic Plan and staff recommends
suspending attempts to pursue implementation at this time. This may necessitate a
change in the activity in the future.
Since assumptions, community needs, the economy, legislation and other factors upon which this plan
is based continue to change, it is necessary that this be considered as the beginning, rather than an end,
to managing the organization and serving El Segundo's community. Furthermore, with the adoption of
123
the 3-year strategic plan, the strategic planning and budgeting process are now linked to assure that the
City's budget reflects City Council and community priorities. Also, the City's staff report template has
been modified to include a reference to a strategic goal and objective with the associated agenda
description. All staff reports that appear on the City Council agenda packet will have this reference.
With the development and implementation of the strategic plan, the City of El Segundo reaffirms its
commitment to continue to provide exceptional services and programs to its community.
124
{{
CITY OF EL SEGUN ❑Q CALIFORNIA
-
Strategic Planning f = =
F Y 2 0 1 6 - 2 0 1 9
i
r �d
Y
As
CITY OF EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
350 Main Street El Segundo, California (310) 524-2302
Suzanne Fuentes
Mayor
sfuentes @elsegundo.org
b
$ Drew Boyles
Mayor Pro Tern
dboyles @elsegundo.org
r'
Michael Dugan
Council Member
mdugan @elsegundo.org
Aft
Dr. Don Brann
Council Member
dbrann @elsegundo.org
* ' Carol Pirsztuk
-A Council Member
cpirsztuk @elsegundo.org
ti
Strategic Plan
2016-2019
Table of Contents
Message from the City Manager
Executive Summary
Mission,Vision &Values
Strategic Direction
Goals, Objectives, Activities& Key Performance Indicators
Appendix: Work Plan for FY 2016-2019
1 Page
127
Message from the City Manager
February 7, 2017
Honorable Mayor Fuentes and Members of the City Council:
I am pleased to present the City of El Segundo's 2016-2019 Three-Year Strategic Plan.The plan will serve
as a roadmap of El Segundo's vision for the future through a number of goals,objectives and strategies.
With this Strategic Plan, the City will continue to work towards making El Segundo the best place to live,
work, and visit. The citizens and the business community continue to expect the City to provide a high
level of service by keeping the City safe at all times and by providing programs and services that enhance
the quality of life.
As the City implements the various projects and programs outlined in the Strategic Plan, City Staff will
continue to work with our community to build upon the partnerships we have established.
I look forward to many years of progress and important developments within our City, and extend my
personal appreciation to the Department Heads and City Staff for their hard work and cooperation while
completing this Three-Year Strategic Plan.
Respectfully,
Greg Carpenter
City Manager
128
Executive Summary
A Strategic Plan is a living document, which features a comprehensive framework that can be adjusted based on
the current needs of the community;and to ensure that the priorities set by the City Council are clear,concise, and
are being met by City staff. On a periodic basis, the City will provide updates on the progress and performance of
each goal. As such, the plan may be modified to ensure that stated goals are aligned with the needs of the
community.
Through a series of outreach efforts, the City identified key goals that will advance El Segundo as the City "Where
Big Ideas Take Off" and a hub for innovation.
1. Enhance Customer Service and Engagement
• El Segundo provides unparalleled service to internal and external customers
• El Segundo's engagement with the community ensures excellence
2. Support Community Safety&Preparedness
• El Segundo is a safe and prepared city
3. Develop as a Choice Employer&Workforce
• El Segundo is a City employer of choice and consistently hires for the future
• The El Segundo workforce is inspired,world-class, engaged—increasing stability and innovation
4. Develop Quality Infrastructure&Technology
• El Segundo's physical infrastructure supports an appealing,safe,and effective City
• El Segundo's technology supports effective,efficient,and proactive operations
5. Champion Economic Development& Fiscal Sustainability
• El Segundo promotes community engagement and economic vitality
• El Segundo approaches its work in a financially strategic and responsible way
Each of these goals has specific objectives and activities identified and outlined in order to support,implement,and
accomplish these goals. The strategies are essentially the series of steps leading to the action plans to fully and
successfully execute the completion of these goals.The Strategic Plan also incorporates an Action Plan Worksheet.
This section takes the Goals, Objectives, and Activities and assigns the responsible department and division.
129
Mission, Vision & Values
Mission — What is our purpose?
The Mission of the City of El Segundo is to "Provide a great place to live,work and visit."
This serves as the "destination"that our strategies should lead towards and provides the context for our decisions.
Vision — Where do we want to be in the future?
El Segundo has continued to be the City"Where Big Ideas Take Off" and a hub for innovation.
El Segundo residents enjoy a high quality of life as evidenced by,reduced crime, improved schools, and a sense of
vibrant community—of fun! It is a tolerant, kind and compassionate community. It is recognized as a best place to
raise a family and a center of innovation. The appeal of,working for the City is such that there are application
backlogs for jobs in the area. It has engaging, sophisticated, capitalized events that showcase tradition and match
the City's evolving demographics. We also have a robust network and service structure in place to support aging in
place.
The City has transformed. We are leading the way with innovation and environmental responsibility. With fewer
people driving cars, we have adapted our street, parking and land use plans. We have high-speed fiber optics as a
utility to support more work from home and fewer brick and mortar businesses. The downtown is vibrant with
successful businesses and day and evening pedestrian activity. The east side of town has become denser(especially
near the rail lines) including a high level of service with retail and a school to support it. While our revenue base
has shifted to changing businesses, we are financially sustainable and growing because we have capitalized on the
changes. In fact, we have more invested capital per square mile (commercial)than any other California city. All of
that said, we still have the Air Force base in part because we fought for it.
The City has also changed as a service provider. Customer service has increased. There is easy access to City
information (1-click to answer and/or a single point of entry/contact for services) and an ability to do virtually
everything online for real time access to services. Pathways for citizen and business feedback are easy and
comfortable.The City is seen as a nimble partner to businesses and residents with cutting edge infrastructure and
scalable processes/systems.At the same time, interactions are personal to keep the small town feel.
Values & Culture — How will we serve and manage our city
El Segundo Values El Segundo works to create a working culture of
• Accountability • Innovation
• Productivity • Support and recognition
• Ethics • Leadership by example
• Stewardship • Proactive action
• Service • Problem-solving—getting to yes
• Challenging ourselves
• Continuous improvement and reflection
130
Strategic Direction
Goal: Enhance Customer Service & Engagement
Goal 1(a): El Segundo provides unparalleled service to internal and external customers
R City operations are unified and integrated
o Staff know about the whole City and can:
• Problem-solve
• Offer solutions to the underlying need—even if facilitating a referral
• Anticipate the potential impact of an action on the work of others
City services are convenient,efficient and user-friendly for all residents,businesses, and visitors
• There are multiple points of entry for services,whether one-click or one-call away
• The public is educated on who to call,when, and what to expect
• It is also available as a virtual city with virtual services(i.e.,online, paperless,24/7)
• It has centralized,searchable information repositories for internal and external access
• Services are delivered pro-actively with outreach to ensure all can access them
• There is continuous improvement and innovation is encouraged across the City
Goal 1(b): El Segundo's engagement with the community ensures excellence
s The City is transparent regarding services and performance
• Communication is two-way, multi-channel,accessible to all, and targeted to specific
community segments and to specific activities/services
• Constituent expectations are aligned with service delivery
• The City engages in regular, intentional information gathering
• City communication is comprehensive and integrated
Goal: Support Community Safety & Preparedness
Goal 2: El Segundo is a safe and prepared city
The City has a proactive approach to risk and crime that is outcome focused
• All hazard mitigation and emergency services:
• Have appropriate plans and industry accreditations in place
• Are prepared to respond and pro-actively work to prevent incidents
• Respond appropriately when called upon with positive outcomes
• Are able to recover within industry standards
• El Segundo focuses metrics on prevention and positive outcomes as well as frequency and
response
• El Segundo approaches preparation and safety in a financially responsible way
Proactive communication and community engagement align perceptions of safety with reality
o Constituent perceptions of safety are aligned with service delivery
Goal: Develop as a Choice Employer & Workforce
Goal 3(a): El Segundo is a City employer of choice and consistently hires for the future
• The City has a strong culture of customer service,employee retention, and internal feedback
• The City has and inspired,engaged workforce
• The City publicly recognizes and rewards outstanding employee achievements
The City provides a competitive environment and nimble hiring/on-boarding process for its employees
o Departments are,to the extent possible, at full staffing levels
The City has a comprehensive,intentional approach to staff development,training and succession
• The City has a robust and meaningful training and development program
• The City has a Succession Planning Program
Goal 3(b): The El Segundo workforce is inspired,world-class,engaged—increasing stability and innovation
The City has a culture of innovation,trust and efficiency in which all aboard rise together
5 1 P a g
131
o The Staff rise when:
• Innovations are shared across the City
• The City comes ahead of resource competition
• Centralization and consistency is valued
• Success is celebrated
City staff enjoy mastery,autonomy and purpose in their work—pride
o El Segundo realizes that success in this area is a pre-requisite for success in its other goals
Goal: Develop Quality Infrastructure & Technology
Goal 4(a): El Segundo's physical infrastructure supports an appealing,safe,and effective City
G The City optimizes its physical resources
• The City maintains its physical assets for the safety,beauty,and function of the City
• The City improves and replaces existing assets as appropriate for efficiency
• The City engages in new initiatives that continue to move the City forward
■ The City engages in prospective thinking that allows the City to do more than keep up
Goal 4(b): El Segundo's technology supports effective,efficient, and proactive operations
N The City has an integrated focus on technology
• Align staff to support technology goals
• Ensure City employees receive appropriate training to use systems effectively
• Improve departmental synergies
The City has an effective structure to meet the technology needs of the City and its constituents
• Regularly assess technology in place and market trends in order to meet goals
• Continue to optimize systems already in use,and maintain their capabilities with timely
upgrades
The City invests in systems as necessary in order to add citizen value, provide access to information
that is easily available,engage residents in civic participation,and provide mass notification
• Increase paperless function of the City for ease of access and transparency of process
• Add citizen value(e.g.,allow for online transactions with the City across departments)
• Ensure secure,reliable, disaster resilient function and data access at all times
Goal: Champion Economic Development & Fiscal Sustainability
Goal 5(a): El Segundo promotes economic growth and vitality for businesses and the community
Implement a comprehensive economic development strategy to ensure the City encourages a vibrant
business climate that is accessible,user-friendly and welcoming to all residents and visitors
• The City promotes economic growth through a range of programs, PR, marketing and
communication strategies
• The City of El Segundo offers modern creative office developments, low tax rates,a highly-
skilled workforce,and a range of corporate office and manufacturing space in a well-planned
business community
Goal 5(b): El Segundo approaches its work in a financially strategic and responsible way
A The City will maintain a structurally balanced budget with appropriate reserve levels
o The City will provide citizens, businesses,staff, and all other stakeholders with a balanced
budget and prudent reserves
The City will maintain a stable,efficient,and transparent financial environment
o The City promotes financial transparency and accountability
6 1 P a g
132
Goals, Objectives, Activities & Key Performance
Indicators
Goal: Enhance customer Service & Engagement
1(a): El Segundo provides unparalleled service to internal and external customers
Objectives Activities Key Performance Indicators(KPIs)
City operations are ° Cross-training and cross-communication °
unified and integrated Enhance collaborative capacity Citywide(e.g., Average time to
teleconferencing) process various plan
Build a one-stop business center check reviews(P&BS)
Provide online business transactions for residents
and business community Average time to
Replace,streamline and optimize website with process film permits
mobile app and robust intranet (Finance)
• Provide a user-friendly digital file cabinet for
City services are
convenient,efficient public to access online Monthly report on
and user-friendly for Provide GIS software access to basic property Resident/Business
information and relevant documents satisfaction surveys
all residents,
businesses, and Each department will set goals for outreach and (CM)
°
visitors access
Implement year-long festivities and celebration of Turnaround time to
the City's Centennial process all City
Each department will set goals for improvement contracts(City Clerk)
° Identify areas of internal service improvement
from Human Resources ° Employee satisfaction
Amend zoning code in response to emerging surveys(H.R.) (to be
issues discovered by staff and customers developed)
1(b): El Segundo's engagement with the community ensures excellences—it understands and exceeds
customer expectations
Objectives Activities Key Performance Indicators(KPIs)
° The City is transparent Report Citywide performance indicators to City
regarding services and Council Quarterly status report
performance to City Council on the
The City engages in Assess customer satisfaction via strategic work plan
o An annual resident and business survey (Finance)
regular,intentional o Post service and event questionnaires
information gathering o Personal outreach throughout the year ° Monthly report on
Resident/Business
satisfaction surveys
(Finance)
Number of library users
M City communication is Expand use of social media as communication tool attending programs
comprehensive and L Expand use of E-newsletters as communication tool offered(Library)
integrated Provide inter-departmental tours and brief overview of
services provided Enrollment in programs
offered and event
attendance(Rec/Park)
7 1 P a
133
Goal: Support Community Safety & Preparedness
Goal 2: El Segundo is a safe and prepared city
Objectives Activities Key Performance Indicators(KPIs)
Monthly report on
Crime Statistics(P.D.)
° Monthly report on
Ensure equipment,systems and staffing remain up to Priority 1 response
date with standards and local needs(e.g., high-density times(P.D.)
construction and increased service demands, changed
The City has a crime rates,State laws and funding) Number of
proactive approach to Institute proactive plans to mitigate hazards within the members trained
annually(F.D.)
risk and crime that is City with community involvement
outcome focused Ensure redundancies are in place o
Prepare via planning,training and mock activities Average total response
Ensure ordinances are current with new/emerging time—Fire&EMS calls
risks (FD)
Number of service calls
per sworn FTEs(PD&
FD)
Proactive Citizen surveys&
Inform owners regarding retro-fit for earthquakes
communication and ° Use social media to keep community&staff informed questionnaires(CM)
community
&engaged
engagement
Goal: Develop as a Choice Employer & Workforce
Goal 3(a): El Segundo is a City employer of choice and consistently hires for the future
Objectives Activities Key Performance Indicators(KPIs)
Average time to fill
recruitments(H.R.)
^ The City has a strong k Implement an employee wellness program to enhance
culture of customer the wellbeing and morale Number of vacancies
service,employee Implement a formal Employee Recognition Program (H.R.)
retention, and internal ° Review online platforms,such as Glassdoor.com,that
feedback report on employee satisfaction and salary&benefits ° Turnover percentage
(H.R.)
The City provides a
competitive ^ ° Applicant surveys
environment and Ensure process excellence to attract qualified (H.R.) (to be
applicants
nimble hiring/on- developed)
boarding process for
its employees
° The City has a ° Train employees to effectively and efficiently perform
comprehensive,
their jobs
intentional approach Number of internal
Develop employees so they are prepared to progress
to staff development, ° in the organization&be able to fill critical vacancies promotions(H.R.)
training and
from within
succession
81 Pa
134
Goal 3(b): The El Segundo workforce is inspired,world-class,engaged—increasing stability and innovation
Objectives Activities Key Performance Indicators(KPIs)
• The City has a culture
of innovation,trust Annual Employee
and efficiency in which Each department will develop plans for advancing satisfaction surveys
all aboard rise these items (H.R.) (to be
together ° developed)
• City staff enjoy Department leaders as a group will develop plans for
mastery,autonomy
reinforcing these items
and purpose in their
work—pride
Goal: Develop Quality Infrastructure & Technology
Goal 4(a): El Segundo's physical infrastructure supports an appealing,safe,and effective City
Objectives Activities Key Performance Indicators(KPIs)
Quarterly report on
Regularly assess Citywide facility needs meet safety status of capital
improvement plan
standards and best practices
° Identify funding and commitment to future implementation (PW)
The City optimizes its infrastructure needs
physical resources ° Coordinate multi-agency CIP Monthly report on
Maintain park equipment and fixtures to meet safety number of pothole
standards and best practices repairs and sidewalk
° Enhance trimming schedule to mitigate risk repairs completed
(PW)
Goal 4(b): El Segundo's technology supports effective,efficient,and proactive operations
Objectives Activities Key Performance Indicators(KPIs)
° The City has an Improve efficiency and effectiveness of staffing and ° Status update of IS
integrated focus on leave replacement,with public safety focus master plan
technology implementation(IS)
Number of online
° The City has an transactions conducted
effective structure to from residents,
meet the technology ° Use the full potential of software businesses and
needs of the City and employees(City-
its constituents wide/Finance to
report)
The City invests in Monthly analytical
systems as necessary analysis of City website
in order to add citizen traffic: number of
value, provide access ° Each department will set paperless goals visitors(hits),what
to information that is s Each department will set value goals webpage was most
viewed, and how many
easily available,
engage residents in Wi-Fi in all critical City facilities inquiries were made
civic participation, and ° Purchase equipment and systems from community via
provide mass web tools(IS-pending
notification implementation of new
website)
9J Page
135
Goal: Champion Economic Development & Fiscal Sustainability
Goal 5(a): El Segundo promotes economic growth and vitality for businesses and the community
Objectives Activities Key Performance Indicators(KPIs)
Implement a ° Tracking of economic
comprehensive indicators and tax
economic development ° Promote business attraction and industry revenue annually(Econ
strategy to ensure the diversification. Dev)
City encourages a Business retention through proactive outreach
vibrant business 0 Enhance marketing and branding efforts through ° Business retention/
climate that is attraction/satisfaction
public relations and advertising
accessible, user- n Advocate and promote local arts surveys(Econ Dev-to
friendly and welcoming be developed)
to all residents and
visitors
Goal 5(b): El Segundo approaches its work in a financially strategic and responsible way
Objectives Activities Key Performance Indicators(KPIs]
° The City will maintain a ° Monthly OpenGov
structurally balanced Annual adoption of a balanced budget status reports on
budget with Develop revenue streams and reserve fund to keep budget versus actuals
appropriate reserve infrastructure advancing (accessed via City
levels website)(Finance)
Review and refine the budget/strategic plan process ° Quarterly status report
Develop a comprehensive master fee schedule and to City Council on the
The City will maintain a cost recovery policy to support City needs strategic work plan
° stable,efficient,and Review of Business License Tax structure progress(Finance)
transparent financial Annual review of financial policies Percent of costs
environment ° Quarterly financial status report to Community and recovered for services
Council provide(Finance)
To Annual status update on financial policies and master ° Investment policy
fee schedule compliance(Treasury)
10 1 Page
136
r_ v
o w -0
_0 m c ,; W
aj 06
cc DO a) fo O ro - v v a '^ E
ti E p Q v E E ° Y a �_ ° v —
v ai
2 to
t t m E '^ pCD '^ O n a) F— 0 u n Y O
w m C ate+ COD O u u a-+ al N CL
O E O -0 C -- , C vi a± a O
1� a C Y O w t H C CO M C 0- E a/ d
n o c .� (U C m a c o
O C - j u '^ C w v �n w LL CO Q pp LL 0
> E u " 3 E z a) m E v u c c E um
al 'ate c 9 u al .0 a! N it co :a N ,C
N E c c 3 nC F v N F 'S a)3 N a CL
C� U U O Z .0 LL H 4T- = vTj LL Z H M
G
w > v
N ro
n 1
o N O
a o
o-6 v
'ia c �
I�) ra O 'O O C C
a t ' c >Qj
c
u p fD E c in E
' N to C w p u p aJ C 4J
o m c v o v > o n
A LL C_ d n h_D C Q O a n
W L a+ m CL CL
w u u Ln C n ai 0
a aL
C O O O v w C E N v
O C N N
v 2 � — c w o f c "D D `o
N ° ai v :, c c ou ;+ oD
v1 D D i -0 V d u
7
v
'o aj
o7S
co
C u d w m > U w ` r
N � Q v c H 0 B oD `= oo. o
� "
O x y 3 c ° > �, o E n a Y
> Q u a u CL
ar
C6 7
ui T V) C
L C ` co N •E C:C as = a m �
LL
O
Oo c N o
4-J N o v ou v E C t ar c c a L
V) u > .. ns o =3 a v c v u O v
N _ ai W 3 o a`W E a c Q ti E
• v c o a O0 u c a' E ` O i s a,
\/ v T tD CO � C aJ E '� O pu .v aJ � p C Q
/\ & °D ro 3 u E a
a c c E a°i co c
• (L6 u c u CU o 3 n c v O u ° O o ai
f� co Q c v > v v v B o o c c o _ a u
4A Q c c > E u '� v c o p v v ° v c
O a) Y C ay
Q� W o o t a v a o n o o c v v 3 � °n E CF-
VI U u w u ate• Do .-� u a= o f a Y a3 W U -O -p C G
Q)
Cp 0
O
Q 4J a a, v
V Q m
OD C
•i � � al
O =3 ` O
txo
C
(n C y M
c c
N w y w w
E v
� i '�
O C
o
a
U ? �° w
(U _T
C aJ
V aJ ` y n
C �T C
N y N
6 U V 7
= O
W C7 .1 N
137
i a,
c to
IV _
Y v
Q O C N a a
00 c - C a) U O_
V q-
al i +m+ O
m a) Q N
M c CO
N E o o
Y a� E � L, r � a b a) m
Q1 Ny N 3 E u_ Iii N O •N N +�+ E d
Cp LL v j p U c j 2 0 p c u a c m I
E u u a Q 'o o a`, o f
f74! p O H w LL cc U m
L O` m Y O
a > E a)
Y i c a E Z
C
i C Ou u V N
O` 7 a) a) N O" c c m C >
CL 1 �r O E K a_+ '7 L �,,,, OJ O_ Ol
I a
f` G -C N w — c G *''
�„I a! -O c u a) L W a a) O
I a) C E x } 'C N c w V N
aJ E a +-' m a) C � OJ v Y a) N
C O � v „ c a aY) E q. E a) X >
I.I u +, v m v C w L E a) o
a ax) ±' �' ±� E v E v °
£ o a E Y > v m " E
CL •� u m Q c Q m 0 a) c •� y � � aJ
CL C N u w c c E N a a T 0-
m a a) E ._ c
N m U
�0 Q °o a>i > Q N n m ° Q E d E m a>)
V1 I a. Z D OmC w CL w Ou '� u voi u p
ra
V N h
LM v 66 3 3
Y
> > o o e as o v
X &A y n n {£ a c E Q
N 1�/1 = O N Q
LL 0 cZ) V1 ;
c
c m m m
'-I E o
+' 00 o n – o —
o n
U
Q C C (6 O
C a+ O U
x a N E v
L rl O Y V O N
U v N c O > 0 m
C ° Q N
L c_
O O LL N ai tw aL m C
+ N N 0_ C fo •5 C
VI d N c 7 '^ N
Q E C C7 N
U n
w N
U N 00
Q1 U N cu C
N Y T O Y
U O � � O a!
V m
v a E N Y^ – a ^ 3 C
n
t ro ro v v
'a rl N O c i c o
r m y v v t v
bD
V) N S T -0 O f6 O C V
LL ` N 7 •U U O fo
t T O O N
f0 �, N 41 �' ], V) -� N
V) n M n Y c n n c
L O 6 O N O N O T v O
cu 4! C N C E w C N
O v O N
0 m 0 0' u U O Z J E
i Y
A Y N w M
V) N rho E
N 7 E C t N O1
3 m o + m E
U
v g o m
OTC ec n a- T O n
Y
� � v=i U o2S vOi a N Q I
X _ L T GJ
N d W b O U v O C
_ N N
C) *� w C C u p C O
L r fo f0 C Y N 3 MC Y
Ln as 2 2 a�iY y2Q
Ln d aT+ aT+ LL 0 M-
a) U CJ V V
A
i
� _0
C w C 'O Y
L +�+ N N U N v
fo E E O ,^ O
C N
O u .m D - n O- O co c co aj
s v E ,ro v
v > v u) o c oa ' > o N m C w o Ul C o m
u u - C C N O -'j O
m
:3 2 c 'N �, v o c -0 n
U 'Y C O 7 N y C N
Y N 0 Q a o' a fo N -0 E
O al '_^ > L U m O C: O
4+ — v N v'^i o 7 Z O_ u O_ U
C� 0 fl_ Q vii a H w M w M
C E
4J
m m
b0 UD y
� C: u
W 4J ` c
Ln v C
N Y
O Op C ai
m
I
U 0 m d
L 41 G
cu U cu In _N ?
C 06
W N Y Y e T bO
d a1 a1 p al C '0 e N (0
N c v
N a ai U m E o v m :� c N o ° N 3 0
L Y a) L 7 0a 7 n O
CL o� c u ua v Y a. E E v a c -o >
Y y N ai c .c E -2 E m oa o a) m v
oo .6
c Z, x
d > n aJ O E N n1 L Q •` V as e ~
u E > e O- N L Y_ m C m
�y E u Y v 7 O fa Y 7 �' > Y O. C
N m •vYi — c v U C by 6 •++ L e 3 Uj N aJ L
al m C c aJ \ a1
N
e > Y`o m 7 E N _� E v ° > Y E 3 a
N LL C m m Q c E v, N T •�, ±± v p U1 O N v O` N U p Y `/
v ¢ p C LL '� E a a c n n m a o a N n= 7 2 `o N
z m nz ° m ¢ > v u o O n -o ¢ o w 7U 0
Y Y
m
a]
> Y p v v V L v
m c c 7 c 'T N 0
Q1 m "O = p _ L al
'p E N 06 a) N N a1 L ro �
a` -^ > v m v c N o c V) u
rl E v N m e .a v aci M. y o Z o •'^ " n acn " � v
o `Y° + � n U W o a c 0 v' :N 0 w E n o axi v o U
v E `-' a� E ° �' aui u Q " ° c _n a; m p O o
v o n c ar c n - 7 on U ai -
p c ai n'O N c: a1 a p_ v c +� 7 N U c a� v l7 Ln
v E Y °' m t7 E Q v m a c 7o v = a>i ' o o v m
v u cL
>Y �a m fa a/ 7 m u1 n a7 O U
j Q 7 a bD U C m n 'D O n 0 n a -o = p aj
Y o c ai a c p ai e y n -o o n n - -D n L v
V) 3 M m a) w > m a ¢ Q U n w m w 7 D ¢ O
N 0 Y >
C ONa N C
L fa C C w m N al Y a) d a) i O
o 7 C ` U a1 E c E ^ C E `j E p n
7 p m U oa o o� + 7 w { i co i +' n
ai ar '� a .v U t cL .c m m cL m m Q E > LL n r m n ¢ \ n
a z c > 0 n C m v n Y n x m o_ n E ° n v n cL > v n v
Q U 3 v7i U vYi v7i C D C v7i v7i D .� v7i V ii v7i ii
O
� � N Y
v in 0 Ir aj .0 c N m v p m v Q
a a I LL a c 2 'o w 66 LL a o2S LL a
N ai a a
t LL E �
c
N v
txo
Y a 3 3 N m v
aYc w v o Y ai v N > v '�-
ro m — N c u 00 •Y fo p ra e p u
aO aci 0 m u° u c a E co °c°
QJ •� 7 C O N U al O L - C 3 n1
v
U 'G O' Q t '+� a vi m �' 3 a/ 41 '> m '3 N
O Q ^ O0 N N oa - m > E ai v oo (u ° Y
N ..o L Y fa vi C Y ,Y > v u C Y v C al
7 E N N U 7 n c > 7 N \
fC Q
w >. v v o w c w a a` ua w u C
CL
Q a,
_0 m a
4 Ix
�. N O
u al
4 N m N
m O u
N _O a 0
CL
m ar
+ ar E
do > z �°,
N �+ m
E ar c 0
w N
E Q a7 .
O fY0
O
U t a,
4a Y E
I 0 (U u
Q N H
C �
f0
: O
N C7 ,1
140
C L
C �
C � Y UA
N a-I E ° aJ E 3 C
O E C 00 Y Y on U 7 ` Y m
rl N 14 al C O v > _° a1 T
Q
t O t YO � al v m O E Y Y O 0 '-i
ao E d m DD C Q O b4 E a; Y L O on u N Y
M N C Y c = O
m g E u c m 3 m CL
ri (>U do m ai ri � •Y c O ai m '� u Lon c m vpi c
N c o ' o c m o C c °' CL o ° o ° m a ai
y N 7 Q w e O1 N p L Y L a ° aJ C u L E CL E Y 7 E m C (u L O m N On
O LL >•`�' aJ E o LL m YO •c E aJ al 00 al Y vii a) m
o_ E v 3 E o u n .` p p > o v C
v E o r Cl °u t V) m o a a v E
m _
aJ O of I y• u m
° v g o
a I a v .2
O �. u C �n
w �"I y O '° N \ N
aD L v v E ,v a °
O { a1 6
Q N p C O C c c V m v'^i a n
N L u 0 I N m O m
v m U ) m C
LL +�+ E LL > CL C Y Q O
a ai ( I (U N v c m m E CU c
m ai cmi
O m C — I Y O T N !_' = N ;E
aj
-0 C t •� I Q Q O 7 H v u c M v'^i
-0 M u u u
Q N w `�' Z Z a a Ln 2 U Q v
t
6 + r- Y C
v •a Y � � p a � c m ,,, C c ° m
i `1 C .V O 4— i aJ C aJ .t al U C
'� v o Q I N '� E Y :° E •e w E v m - v E
O Q E m aJ C a t ,� — m y .*= N O 7 ° N m
al N —O "a L y al m Q Q w N U L 7 i '6 vt w Oa w CL C:ec cc E C aJ �' 7 p N 7 fa `1 C ° 7 p > O
O E of LL u .n vl 2 L L m 3 LL u V) O CD-
7" _
C
Y
y 6 al
•vi T V) Ln 'in al m `^
o `m 071 a I 2 J Y f 0
ya I O ya = ani
I U OL' i
cu C
Y N > c
cr- CL cu
p aJ V O
v
c + N
Y _0 O n v m o
o v- I� v E E v m
N = m t- U v^i w m u -p O V H N 2
of Y b0= I�� al m ° M an OxJ N N ` L al Q
{n aT+ Y N C V O L E E O �^ '+= a/ N p ° p
c a a` '� ai c L Q
y?+ 3 E oz! Lp I N 3 o m o c o o ,a E v m
I lJ p L f0 C -0 � �` u fa Y Oa f6 O Y �n Q�' Y a1 m 'C
a,- I O Q v E c ar ! n u E v Q
01 E m ° E E Y m a� +� b v m v ? E p v aOa
L, fL0 �O ! a1 E `p L Q .+7.'' bn L Y O bo
7 aY.+ .0 C u O Ul O_ O
f0 O C `o ^ p c O N o v u m n F a' t > v v
Q v 0 V v c Q 3 5 w ° m H v a m y
LCL I 4.1
N >✓ In y �o
v E
co V) I p c
A O c E
0
Q I 00.0 `.-' C ar t > o
cn O I cn aoi :t .r a i >
-O m W _ C +' N aJ
+�, O p .. 4J � w ' c ay v acid
0 w v = U v u v E Y
> u E O oo v $ E ' a+ N o
V) E y .fl c " E o a N
c ' m U a a= ar ^ M w E
w O c O m T ma m a) Lo' 3
0
m —
O o N m E o v a o Q C
U ar c fC r y Y a E m L m
>` Q `T c ° c
m _O _ v u �_ u c .
O E M ar y ar > m ar °:
CL N ° o N r ar a, r c o t c
Q (B II d u > F H w F a! m F I.
O O O O
141
0 \
\ \ \ \ /
f \ � f $
§ = §
0 \ \
0 0
/ i
— k
Qj
k > `
° o
# Bk
t E
E % f
c k k
\ � f/
E k
°3
o
o
/ E
ƒ \
o •v)
0 § 2 § U ] �
� � ■
§ � rr cu (U Qj \
� cc \ &
/ r. ,
y ts
j
\ CL CL 2
Lo L \ /
/ kt
\ §
0
/ \ ( 7
u m •CL
S o /j ' @
�
k / \= // /
\ « 20 § «
E j 0 © 3
u ± \ / R �
� °
G , R
ro ■ o
$ \ m
E / E C
LLI / 0 0 )
e E 2 \
« ` "6 (�
m
U 2 $ — § !
° m 7 � .0
m m 2b [ a
CL o O \§
@ ■ 2c /� CL
> 70 » F e cc u Z
D $ D $ 2
142
ll� = o a'
N _0 V O
Y >
01 C a) U C T f6 (p
N
a1 E C '0 O 'a -[ d C n O_
CL m. ra E N u O U U
t N o ar Y c m y a v n .-i
Y
60 Y Y n U f0 0 .� CL U al N - O -0
C c
Y a� ;° v c c v a a m o
N r6 O 'u "O 1J Y Y O O r6 aJ n C L
C N n 7 C OD O N N C on [�`! 7 fY6 O C U C v 3 N
-O t6 C t �' C t6 t0 6D .L
In LL 3 a-a0i V n "' •u m °tio v 0 v E° u c 3 t c o ai 'c
°-) +? = a>i - c c v c w `m v Q a v ra Y r6 m C,-
E
u o v 6 O v O s o ¢ v 2 ° 3 E v m
v
�
0 >
� w '-' 021
m 0 N W Z ^
f6 aD In W -O u
a = Q v o7S o a a o � v co UM
n n S " ai E r`6 c a) =o _ u
rl 0 -O U N N O u L1 r6 2 fY6 > O N Y n a1 f6 Q
O al U - L n hD V Y C
C j C CL
N J L OD d OCD"C V > C 0 > �'' C C �' E C C
a, Y v v E (, Q t + ai O a) 3 a) v 6 0
Y a tll C N L C N -O 3 al N a Y u n U Y O al 6D n C
N al a1 O C C Y V f6 fro
LL N `� U w W a1 O. m a) aJ N L m al i1 C C 6D O Y
> `Y' *' m 107 m Q .� C '� Y o aEi , ro � E m -° E 'c
v 6 a) oD + v v c v 3 n
U aCi 'p +� n QE M > > v Cl nm m 0 E � QE
6 ±
cu a � a u a V rao c v a -0 E E o o -wo v N -am
O_
Gj N Y L- Y
0 a) O O \ Q_ d \ a) v1
'7 bo a' E 0 m v Q n Y o E Y +�EL N
C y'V N O 7 n U C _ aJ M a n n n .
LL U li Q CL a u f6 V LL H u r6 0 C J N
Ln Q
N a! U
L
ti4 a i O-
C
c N v
as m a Y @ LZ
Q
Q �
(6 N
� U
C 4— vNi
V1 � N al
L t c o '0 4J > a) r6
O
CL u` fO " v "6 0 > ++3+
Q Ora. � Y N M f6 C a1 +J a1 U 4-
E V o u 4 ro 0
v E a) > c Y a N v a
b.0 3 C6 ° c c E y t atn a � v
r6
O v c
N > +
� Q N y � Y a1 N E Q U O O
u
L y N
E � v t c n
U N v u C m v r6 E � N (� Q r6 -CL a) U M O u Y 'L N al OD
F- L E c N a' v H ar W
co 0 o n� 1 c v n f6 m W bD rYa '^ +L+
CD a1 I al y 0 '� y N N Q Q N y a)
i v a c 107 -0 w E w p o 3
V) 7
t
U • • U v
7 Q
�o
N
4— al L �F I O V
O a a > a,
C C
N +_N N
N ar a O N
�-- N > a) �- N C 0 al al y
w Y ~ w 0 ar ar 0
•� aJ O L E C QJ
'y+
<.J O O N V L L 60 C
O
+T' d Q O «T+ 7 O N
p lJ O O U N U I C
41 S y L u L u
F 7 F H M r m
O N O
143
al N
7
m \ a1 al Y O (p
L m y m oo 3 ca c u
00 „ c ai c
c 0
c m o ai °G o a Y —
L w u - v) aj O N is ai Q W
F' E , Q c o
N Q O E L > m E > o E ° n
Q s E CL
ri m aai w v u 3 > v c ° '� °u ra m 5 av
Q o
^ c Q -u -0 c Q E -0 c c c v v aj
c y E o E co o � "� � E •� E E Q c E w `v
Y w v E u :° c v v m a v; c v aim c t v ya 3
N Q C of a1 yr Q: 7 Q Q
?� E a ° °° u ° ro � Q o E: o E E w 9 a) T o
— Q Q-o V) Q CO w m — V v) O m a Vl
a
a) Y V
— M In ` N u Y VI a1
m a E v a
a _v Q Y v o o °
1� VI u a1 u O u '^ u
14 m N 7 al m N LL ra 6 C y j, Q Py
l0 m u C w Q C m yr G[
�•-I > N hD a) C bB M qCj C C Q m C,
O aJ O.� w O u 7 w w m u Z)
Q Q
al .�, � U
LL Q Y C N N _Q C Q�; N C E m
3 v m ° ai m > Q
°o ami v ° 3 u o �a °; r t v u 3 ) u y u
a E u aj 3 °-' m Q 0 c m °1 a' a ai 3 `o
In m
3 v m N `- .O c v v ami E o v o '3 ^ Y
rn v Q a > 0 3 v > `0 0
O > E a) m u ° o a ai v u xx a u m o
O a w m Q Cl- 3 a m m w F m U w
ro a
`v a, u °' v
rz W a o a, v
ai a) o � c
O '3 E u a c - o
> o Q " o Q * a oa o m o m o n i u c ` N In ar Q a a oca c Q ° Q a c Q O o m o a� °c
u z E n > c ac' C rj v 5 3 0 v Of
Q _ v .� C) > Q
a, v
x w
C Q u N i ar OC
C ` W N n C m 12 U fO V) 0 Ln 0 V)CL
4-7 0 N ar " J u m J
U d L1
4
4— > h
N o a N
c a; o m
c E c
E v
u u _ Y -
•)
n m � -0 - -
bio
N> 15 v ,
v u
3 n v m
O ° � c
O N E m N H +� ai y m
? C V }
O L + m Q v u v •� u v c u
t CL ++ Q O a� oo m v u c u° v u E E
oa
U Q Qm r a m Q ._^ c o Z n v + Q m CL
V) aJ O Y pa C t u -O C m C
Q c o m „ .E c o m J O u a v aj 06 ° E �o o y c m +m- m y c
_O E > v v v E v v ,� uo aEi m LL s
O O ai � Q m > E ^_ Q Q a) Q c i
N OJ j Z) v .L a Vu) 0 3 u v Co w ¢ r n a a'
*' u
CU
d
L �
N
?_
�+- O E m u m c a c E m u r^ c 'a c
ar o d c o v o u m v c o
C � v - m ar a m - v - m v a m a..
bA > a) v) '7A u v n •N m
>� to ^ v v " � O u ^ +' (u C u
m m o
a, ° ° m m o o o °' " -
m w ? : c a C m a c C a c M a c
.0 ° as,u N N C to•u N
O v cu) aci '� m > v i� aui aa) ° f0 '�
ar c N c 'm 'w o ar c N c 'm "u o
> — F m ° m a H m ° m c
(1) O
144
T
a) v
a) UJ Y N L H
Irn m Cc o C: :3 c o v a v co
rl '~ E c — o v a) v u ro v u a): L E
I ao p a L u E 3 = c >
to '� a
o 3 p p Ol L am C-0 W V N
O p u D
a) O
m y
00 DD N n O Q +T' C 7 � N 0_ a/ � C aJ L y
N ,y, w O u a) •� al Q a) m Y a) E
n C o v c - 6 — E E a a) vY ,cc o �
I aJ N y N ,ay+ u ul 7 m m ryy p C N _ 7 v Q a w0 k
N LL a+ LL
�C L a L O E O O. a) a O 2 a al a]
o U om m O a a
E H N fa
O U C L a_T+ O V Y E ±+
al m N a E •N O al O
la Lp Vf O 0 V 11I) H O 6 N
aJ w Q � y C E c0 � Y a) •� y 3 V C a)
y O C c a m V a N Y O O C a) O
O 'n u E y O
> •a+ fa N p > = E p 41 C o -
l a d •� V V L C Ql d •C a) >. �vf U Q O EO. L
to oa Y !. _ 0 a, a v t
a) C c C N c u aJ 7 p = of a2{. > 3
C O .N a i al N O O t C Y L vi •�,
I N N 1 a) O •- '� O - n pQ � C ` Q N
LL LL E -p , to y ro O O_ p CL Wo O_ O E Y u O vi
a) a) O L '; a' a c °D a, E o u v
Y E v > 3 bo v � Y v y u Q L -0 m L m
C E o t v o 3 a' ± > ,tea a r m
O O v X L a = O al = 0a a) 4 ^ H '� ha
U l7 a` v u Q L c Q ° v l7 2 M
m
L
Q�
Q I al a a
U a. OL C- }' ya'. C
(6 u
O U v
Q E
-O ar O _w u
C .0 v
O c a) b
}; o m 0 M ° c
CL s a s Y u m
a) o w
U lB
O) O
W
a E
� a
4+ a) N a C
No m a)
t C u o
0 OJ Y u >
_ w
�n _
O i T a--+ T O +y+ _T O
C O O E O m °y' m
V u a)bo
au � a E a ai _
E
a7 9 Y
E Z
06 bn ° o Y o
L O ° v ? v
v > b
+� a a o v � �
V O O ° ¢ v
41 i
L Vf @ • r
4-+
In O O
m _0
L r U O m M y0
:3 E m E C va)i
b4 b.0 o 7 ._ y
N N a) u u E d
V) 0 m w > w >
aui ai I w . c
c v
a c t E t +• o
CL
N N
in a E > m LL'
a
> c '>
V a a) 10 N w m ICO
4J p O
� C7 C7 rl
145
\
IV ƒ E \ CL
) = U Um q
• 2 m \ o o
2 2 2 u o
N _ 0 o \ e.
R � \ - ) § «
/ / \ � \ k § \ \
0
5 -
E: % 0 2
CL) -
C U. _
�
/ e
N 3 - -
M CML
£ , E
t « ° o
� aou =
R j \ / } \ \ \ \^
CU
�. 4
V) § � � )
a § - � � { 0
§ § � } m \ { {CC CL CL \ R
2 u / 2 } § \OL
m
0.ƒ
'u
ƒ z =
. . . .
u § f $0
}
- ® ) f m 2 to
§ § U Q) \ 2 cu
« 7 m -
{ ± / /
0 %
� / \ \ - \ ) \ § /
E _ = 2
L / j ) ~ ` S \ 2 -
$ } ° C o % §
- 7 E a � 2 o m R k -
§ ) / \ 2 $ 7 - )
� J 2 A 2 I J A j } &
/ . . . . . .
0
�
\ ©
m aid -
Ln
. Q m }
w E 2 C 7 \ /
} m
f ) M § f g f
� ■ ■ 2 § � = 2 ;
�
Q � R
146
E� 00011
-
J
{j N1!`A
City of El Segundo Strategic Plan Community Survey
Q1 How effective is the local government at solving problems in the City of El Segundo?
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Completely Extremely
Ineffective Effective
Q2 Overall, do you feel the City is quick to effectively respond to requests for help from
residents/businesses?
Q3 Overall, do you feel the City's roads and sidewalks are well maintained and in good
condition?
Q4 Do you feel that the City is open and transparent in how it conducts business?
Q5 Overall, how safe do you feel in the City of El Segundo?
Q6 Overall, how responsive is El Segundo Police Department to the needs of the
community?
Q7 Overall, how responsive is El Segundo Fire Department to the needs of the
community?
Q8 Please rate your level of satisfaction with the City of El Segundo's Park & Recreation
Services:
Q9 Please rate your level of satisfaction with the City of El Segundo's Library Services;
Q10 Please rate your level of satisfaction with the City of El Segundo's Planning& Building
Safety Services:
147
Is N 0
•C E
Q11 Is the City of El Segundo business friendly?
Q12 Do you have any other comment, questions, or concerns?
148
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7,2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Unfinished Business
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action to determine how to proceed with Paolucci Selling & Martin
Communications Art ("PSM") and the City's business marketing program in light of the delayed
decision from the Fair Political Practices Commission ("FPPC") regarding whether the City can
continue to contract with PSM.
(Fiscal Impact: to be determined)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Wait for the FPPC to issue an opinion re PSM before making a decision as to whether to amend
its contract; or,
2. Proceed with a process to select a new business marketing consultant and potentially terminate
PSM's contract, and/or,
3. Authorize the City Manager in amount not to exceed $25,000 to procure business marketing
services until a decision has been made regarding PSM or until a new business marketing
consultant is under contract; and/or
4. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
FISCAL IMPACT: None
Amount Budgeted: $440,000
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s):
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: Champion Economic Development and Fiscal Sustainability
Objective: El Segundo promotes economic growth and vitality for businesses
ORIGINATED BY: Mark Hensley, City Attorney
REVIEWED BY:
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
On February 28,2014,the City Council approved a contract in the amount of$450,000 to provide
the City with business marketing services. On July 28th the City Manager increased the contract
amount by $20,000 to $470,000. On November 15, 2016, the Council was going to consider
another amendment to the contract in the amount of$440,000. At that time it was recommended
by the City Attorney that the Council should wait to take action until he had time to analyze a
potential conflict of interest by Council Member Boyles in participating in voting on the
4
149
amendment and also whether the City could legally enter into the amendment based upon Council
Member Boyles' business arrangements with PSM.
Subsequently on December 5, 2016, the City Attorney's office sent a request to the FPPC to seek
an opinion from the FPPC as to Council Member Boyle's potential conflict and whether the
Council could enter into the amendment with PSM. Generally, a FPPC opinion takes
approximately 21 business days. With the holidays falling within this 21-day period, the facts
were somewhat complex and the requested opinion sought advice not only under the Political
Reform Act but also Government Code Section 1090 et seq., the FPPC has been delayed in
responding to the City.
The Political Reform Act is the body of law that applies to whether or not Council Member Boyles
can participate in deciding whether to amend PSM's contract whereas Government Code Section
1090 is the law that governs the issue of whether the City can enter into the amendment with PSM.
Given the extended delay, some Council Members have raised concerns to the City Manager
regarding the delay in the City's marketing program caused by the delay in receiving a response
from the FPPC. The City Attorney's Office has contacted the FPPC on two occasions but the
FPPC has declined to give a date by which the City will receive a response.
The options for the Council at this point are to continue to (1) wait for a FPPC opinion until it
makes a decision on the contract amendment; (2) direct staff to undertake a process to find a new
marketing consultant, and (3) direct the City Manager to contract for interim marketing services
in an amount not to exceed$25,000 until either the FPPC makes a decision or the a new consultant
is under contract.
The agreement with PSM does provide for a 30-day cancellation period. The Council does not
have to, but could provide such termination notice at this time if its desire is to find a new
consultant. Alternatively, it could initiate the process for finding a new consultant, while leaving
PSM as an option as the City could and should receive a response from the FPPC during the process
of searching for new consultant.
The City's Economic Development Advisory Council ("EDAC") went through a request for
proposals process back in late 2013 and early 2014. If the Council so desires it could either have
EDAC go back through and review the proposals it received at that time and have EDAC propose
another firm or have EDAC go through a new request for proposal process. The Council does not
have to use EDAC for this process but since it was the process utilized before staff wanted the
Council to be aware of this fact.
150
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Continued Business
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action regarding introduction and first reading of an Ordinance
amending Title 8 of the El Segundo Municipal Code to regulate parking of oversized
vehicles, recreational vehicles, and trailers; establish a registration/permit process; and
prohibit the placement of electrical cords, cables and similar items between such vehicles
and nearby property. (Fiscal Impact: Not to exceed $4,000.00)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1.) Conduct a public hearing;
2.) Take public testimony and other evidence as presented;
3.) Introduce the proposed Ordinance amending the El Segundo Municipal Code Title 8;
4.) Provide direction to City staff regarding possible cost-recovery fees for one-time
vehicle registration, permits and/or annual handicapped permits issued under the
ordinance;
5.) Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
• Exhibit"A"—Examples of Vehicles Subject to the Proposed Ordinance
• Exhibit`B"—Proposed Ordinance
FISCAL IMPACT:
Amount Budgeted: $0
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s):
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 2. Support Community Safety and Preparedness
Objective: 1. El Segundo has a proactive approach to risk and crime
2. El Segundo has proactive community engagement so that
perceptions of safety align with reality
ORIGINATED BY: Jeff Leyman, Lieutenant b � 3G
REVIEWED BY: Mitch Tavera, Chief of Police'(
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
The parking of recreational vehicles, oversized vehicles and detached trailers on City streets has
been a source of concern and increasing complaints from El Segundo residents and business
151
owners for several years. Complaints frequently focus on the parking of these large vehicles for
extended periods of time, blocking drivers' line of sight near intersections, overnight camping and
taking up multiple on-street parking spaces. Surrounding cities have implemented oversized
vehicle ordinances, which have resulted in increased parking of these vehicles in El Segundo.
As a result, on June 7th, 2016,the City Council directed staff to further research and gather public
input on the topic. After the results of a public opinion survey and field survey were presented on
August 16th,2016,City Council directed staff to prepare a proposed Ordinance to address the issue.
A proposed ordinance was brought before City Council on October 18, 2017 for first reading and
November 1St for second reading. Due to residents' comments, City Council directed staff to hold
a community meeting for feedback and potential changes. A community meeting was held on
November 29, 2016. The proposed ordinance incorporates the public's comments from previous
hearings and the community meeting.
ANALYSIS:
State Law and the Current City Code
The El Segundo Municipal Code (ESMC) currently:
1. Limits any vehicle from parking on City streets for no more than 72 hours (ESMC § 8-5-
6(A));
2. Limits the time "any trailer, camp car or any other similar type of equipment" may be
parked on a City street to no more than 48 hours every seven days (ESMC § 8-5-6(B));
3. Disallows parking within 20 feet"of the approach to any traffic signal,boulevard stop sign
or official electric flashing device" (ESMC § 8-5-3(J));
4. Prohibits anyone from living out of a mobile home, camper, house trailer or other
recreational vehicle on any street, park, beach, square, avenue, alley, public parking lot or
public way, within the city between 10:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. (ESMC § 7-6-1);
5. Limits parking of commercial vehicles, trailers, recreational vehicles or motor homes on
any City-owned public parking lot to five hours (ESMC § 8-5B-9);
6. Allows an encroachment permit for encroachments in the public right-of-way, which
include heavy vehicles, machines, and vehicles or other property that may be associated
with an adjacent job site (ESMC Title 9, Chapter 2); and
7. Allows a "habitable vehicle" parked on private property to be occupied for residential
purposes for up to 72 hours within a 30-day period (ESMC § 15-15-6(D)).
Despite such restrictions, the current ESMC does not fully address the community's concerns
about oversized vehicles, recreational vehicles and trailers. For these reasons, the City Council
directed that staff prepare a proposed ordinance.
State law allows the City Council to prohibit or restrict parking on City streets and highways, and
may"provide for a system of permits for the purposes of exempting... disabled persons, residents
and guests of residents of residential areas." (Veh. Code § 22507.5; see also Veh. Code § 22507;
Homes on Wheels v. City of Santa Barbara (2004) 119 Cal.AppAth 1173). The proposed
ordinance fits squarely within the City's authority under state law.
152
The Prouosed Ordinance
The attached Ordinance was drafted by Police Department staff, in consultation with the City
Attorney's office. The Police Department researched and evaluated several ordinances in
surrounding cities, including Hawthorne, Hermosa Beach, Manhattan Beach, Redondo Beach and
Torrance. In addition, and after the initial oversized vehicle ordinance was postponed by Council,
a community meeting was held to address concerns from citizens effected by the proposed
ordinance.
There are several components to the modified proposed ordinance:
1. The ordinance prohibits overnight parking of oversized vehicles,recreational vehicles and
trailers (as defined) between the hours of 2 a.m. and 6 a.m. on all streets and highways
within the City. This is essential for the Police Department to manage a successful program
addressing the aforementioned concerns of citizens. The prohibition for overnight parking
of trailers includes both attached and detached trailers.
2. The ordinance establishes an Oversized Vehicle Resident Registration Program. Any
resident who owns an oversized vehicle,recreational vehicle or trailer that is parked within
the City must register their vehicle with the Police Department. When a vehicle or trailer
is registered, the Police Department will issue a sticker which must be affixed to the
registered vehicle. Importantly, rep-istration alone does not allow the registered vehicle or
trailer to park on Citv streets during overnight hours. Thus, even if a vehicle has been
registered, unless it has been issued a permit, it may not lawfully park on a City street
between the hours of 2 a.m. and 6 a.m. and would be subject to citation and towing.
3. The ordinance creates an Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit process, by which owners of
registered vehicles may apply to receive an Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit which will
allow an otherwise prohibited vehicle to park from 2:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m. for two
consecutive days (i.e., 2:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m. one day and 2:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m. the
following day). Residents may apply for and receive up to two consecutive permits at one
time, and have the option to use such permits consecutively for a total of four consecutive
days. Residents may request no more than 12 two-day Oversized Vehicle Parking Permits
per quarter and no more than 48 of such permits per calendar year. A "quarter" for
purposes of this ordinance is January through March, April through June, July through
September, and October through December of each calendar year.
4. The ordinance also creates a similar permit process for both guests staying with City
residents but who need to park their oversized vehicle, recreational vehicle or trailer
adjacent to their hosts' home. The ordinance also establishes a permit process for
handicapped residents.
5. The ordinance restricts parking of oversized vehicles, recreational vehicles and trailers
within 25 feet of an intersection. To eliminate possible safety hazards to pedestrians in the
City, the ordinance also prohibits owners from running electrical cords, cables and hoses
153
across or above sidewalks and streets from the oversized vehicle, recreational vehicle or
trailer to a nearby property.
In sum, several of the proposed Ordinance's components are depicted in the following chart:
PROPOSED OVERSIZED VEHICLE ORDINANCE
Vehicle Type Allowed on City street Allowed on City street Allowed to park
or highway between or highway between within 25 feet
6 a.m. and 2 a.m.? 2 a.m. and 6 a.m.? of an intersection
at any time?
Trailer No, unless the trailer is
Yes registered and has a No
permit
Recreational No, unless the vehicle is
Vehicle Yes registered and has a No
permit
Oversized No, unless the vehicle is
Vehicle Yes registered and has a No
permit
For examples of the vehicles that would be subject to the ordinance, please see the attached
Exhibit "A."
The Proposed Ordinance Compared with Other Cities' Ordinances
The municipalities around El Segundo have varying limits on how many permits are allowed per
year;Torrance has a maximum of ninety 24-hour permits and Hermosa Beach sets it as 32 permits.
Both Hermosa Beach and Torrance set a limit to how many permits may be used within a period
of 90 days.
It is significant to note that the municipalities around El Segundo do not give businesses the option
of using permits; the permits are for residents and guests of residents only.
Next Steps
If the City Council introduces the proposed ordinance for first reading, staff will then bring back
the ordinance for second reading. If adopted at second reading, the ordinance will take effect 30
days later. However,the Ordinance proposes an"implementation period,"which will start on the
effective date of the ordinance and will end on March 31,2017, which would allow time for City
residents to register their vehicles. As proposed,the registration requirement would commence on
April 1, 2017, and the overnight parking permit requirement would commence on April 1, 2017.
In addition, before the ordinance may be enforced, signage would need to be posted throughout
the City.
154
City staff also request that the City Council provide direction on whether they want staff to collect
fees based on the City's administrative costs in implementing the permit program. Under the
program, City staff will be:
1. Registering vehicles on a one-time basis;
2. Issuing two-day permits as needed; and
3. Issuing handicapped permits to qualified applicants on aii annual basis.
If directed by the City Council, staff will bring back a resolution amending the Fee Schedule to
impose such fees. The fees would be based on the City's estimated costs of processing the
registration and permit applications. Although staff has not yet completed the fee study, staff
estimated that the one-time registration fee per vehicle will likely range between $25.00 and
$50.00 and the daily permit fee will likely be at no cost to our residents or non-residents.
It is unknown at this time how many residents will choose to register their RV's or oversized
vehicles; however, the fee is designed to reimburse the City its costs for processing registration
applications. The ordinance may result in increased enforcement costs, which are also recouped
from the parking penalties assessed.
RECOMMENDATION:
Based on the foregoing, staff recommends that the City Council introduce the proposed ordinance
for first reading and provide direction to staff with regard to fees. In the alternative, the City
Council may discuss the proposed Ordinance and direct staff to modify the ordinance and bring it
back for further consideration at a future meeting.
155
Exhibit "A"
May not be parked on any City street or highway from
2:00 AI's - 6:00 AID unless registered and Displaying a
Valid Permit:
)3/- �:
NMI.
p
Boat Trailer
r
Camper Trailer
156
May not be parked on any City street or highway from
2:00 AM — 6:00 AM unless Registered and Displaying a
Valid Permit:
NOW
Class C Motorhome
S
l
Cg41 R
Class A Motorhome
157
May not be parked on any City street or highway from
2:00 AM — 6:00 AM unless Registered and Displaying a
Valid Permit:
Jet Ski Trailer
i�
O
.`11
4 4
�i
Motorcycle Trailer
158
Sample RV/Oversized Residential Permit
ESIDENT PERMIT
0001
May not be parked on any City street or highway from
2:00 A — 6:00 AM unless Registered and Displaying a
Valid Permit (if associated with a resident) or subject of a
City-Issued Encroachment Permit (which may be issued to
non-residents):
A
Work Trailers
159
ORDINANCE NO. 1523
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE 8 OF THE EL SEGUNDO
MUNICIPAL CODE TO CREATE OVERNIGHT PARKING LIMITS FOR
OVERSIZED VEHICLES, RECREATIONAL VEHICLES AND TRAILERS,
TO ESTABLISH A REGISTRATION AND PERMIT PROCESS AND TO
PROHIBIT THE PLACEMENT OF ELECTRICAL CORDS, HOSES,
CABLES OR OTHER SIMILAR ITEMS BETWEEN SUCH VEHICLES AND
PROPERTIES.
The City Council of the city of El Segundo does ordain as follows:
SECTION 6: The Council finds and declares as follows:
A. On June 7, 2016, the City Council directed staff to develop
options to limit or prohibit overnight parking of oversized
vehicles, recreational vehicles and trailers;
B. On August 16, 2016, the City Council held a public hearing and
considered the information provided by City staff and public
testimony regarding this Ordinance;
C. On October 18, 2016 and November 1, 2016, the City Council
considered a proposed Ordinance to address overnight
parking of oversized vehicles, recreational vehicles and
trailers; per the City Council's direction, a community meeting
was held on November 29, 2016 to solicit further input from the
public on the proposed Ordinance;
D. The parking of oversized vehicles, recreational vehicles and
trailers on City streets creates a variety of public safety and
public health problems, ranging from interference with the
normal flow of vehicle traffic, especially on narrow streets; the
creation of visual obstacles and reduction of the lines of sight
for driveways, intersections, and traffic signage, thereby
reducing sidewalk and street safety for motorists, pedestrians,
and bicyclists; to illegal dumping of garbage and waste matter
on sidewalks and streets.
E. In addition, the parking of oversized vehicles, recreational
vehicles and trailers on City streets exposes bicyclists to
greater traffic dangers as they travel around such oversized
vehicles and trailers; and fire and Emergency access is
reduced, especially on narrow streets and cul-de-sacs;
F. Further, limited availability of on-street parking is diminished
Page 1 of 13
160
due to oversized vehicles, recreational vehicles and trailers
being stored on streets; and trailers hauling debris and other
unsightly materials contribute to blight in neighborhoods.
G. In addition, detached trailers parked on certain City streets
constitute a safety hazard as some do not have an
independent braking system and could roll unexpectedly down
the street;
H. The City issues encroachment permits for work or
encroachments in the public right-of-way (ESMC Title 9,
Chapter 2); although encroachment permits would be required
for vehicles and other non-vehicular property that are
associated with work being performed at adjacent property,
and heavy vehicles or machines, the encroachment permit
process does not pertain to other oversized vehicles,
recreational vehicles or trailers;
I. The City's current parking regulations are inadequate to
address the above-referenced problems associated with the
parking of oversized vehicles, recreational vehicles and trailers
on City streets;
J. By creating a permit and registration system, the City Council
desires to strike a balance between ensuring that persons who
own oversized vehicles, recreational vehicles and trailers have
the opportunity to park their vehicles on City streets for short
periods of time, while at the same time imposing reasonable
regulations on all City streets to address the adverse impacts
described above;
K. California Vehicle Code Sections 22507 and 22507.5, and
case law such as Homes on Wheels v. City of Santa Barbara
(2004) 119 Cal.App.4th 1173, confirm the City's authority to
restrict the parking of vehicles on certain streets, during all or
certain hours of the day, including but not limited to, between
the hours of 2 a.m. and 6 a.m.;
L. The City currently prohibits any wires, pipes or conduit to be
placed in or upon any street within the City unless such wires,
pipes or conduit are permitted by an encroachment permit
issued by the City (ESMC Section 9-2-6);
M. The City Council is concerned about the potential hazards
posed by cords, hoses, cables and wires strewn on City streets
and sidewalks between Oversized Vehicles, Recreational
Page 2 of 13
161
Vehicles, and Trailers, and private residences, and desires to
prohibit such items in the public right-of-way.
SECTION 7: Section 8-1-1 of the El Segundo Municipal Code (ESMC) is amended to add
the following definitions in alphabetical order:
"Oversized Vehicle" means any vehicle, as defined by Section 670 of the California
Vehicle Code, or combination of vehicles, which exceeds twenty-two feet in length,
seven feet in width, or eight feet in height, exclusive of projecting lights or devices
allowed by Section 35109 or 35110 of the California Vehicle Code, as may be
amended. The term "Oversized Vehicle" does not include pickup trucks or sport
utility vehicles that are less than twenty-five feet in length and eighty-two inches in
height.
"Police Department" means the El Segundo Police Department.
"Recreational Vehicle" has the same meaning as Section 18010 of the Health and
Safety Code.
"Trailer" means a trailer, semitrailer, camp trailer (including tent trailers),
unmounted camper, or trailer coach as defined in Sections 242, 243, 550, 630,
635, and 636 of the California Vehicle Code, or fifth-wheel travel trailer, as defined
in Section 324 of the Vehicle Code. The term "Trailer" includes trailers that are
attached to another vehicle by means of a hitch or otherwise, and trailers that are
not attached to another vehicle (i.e., "detached" trailers).
SECTION 8: Section 8-5-6 of the ESMC is amended as follows:
A. &ovonty Two Nouro: Except as otherwise provided in this Chapter. Nno
person who owns or has possession, custody or control of any vehicle 64aa44may
park the vehicle upon any street or alley for more than a consecutive period of
seventy two (72) hours.
B-- Forty Eight i-ouro For Cortain Vol 400: FinoWt as-G*DM o pfev+dod in this
ptor, it io u f4w:Ful for any porown to part; or otand any traitor, oamp acr or
abet csr c�miler type ,
Porn, in or upon teny p blip 6treet, GOurt, driva, ahoy or �\shccr publ lare__in
*e city for mcr&-than for# -eight (19) oorseGu#ve hrv,,uo within sny Po;iod of
seven (7) d we
SECTION 9: Chapter 5, Article B of Title 8 of the ESMC is amended to add the following
new section:
"Section 8-5113-10. Cords Associated with Oversized Vehicles, Recreational
Vehicles and Trailers on Public Streets.
Page 3 of 13
162
No person may run electrical cords, extension cords, hoses, cables, wires or other
similar items across, above or on the parkway or sidewalk from a residential or
commercial property to an Oversized Vehicle, Recreational Vehicle or Trailer
parked on a public street or highway."
SECTION 10: Chapter 5 of Title 8 of the ESMC is amended by adding a new Article
G to read as follows:
"ARTICLE G. OVERSIZED VEHICLE, RECREATIONAL VEHICLE AND
TRAILER PERMIT PARKING
8-5G-1: Purpose.
This article is adopted pursuant to the City's police powers, California Constitution
article XI, section 11 and California Vehicle Code sections 22507 and 22507.5,
and any successor statute or regulation, to allow permit parking in specified areas
within the City's jurisdiction.
8-5G-2: Parking Prohibited, Exceptions.
A. No person may park or leave standing any Trailer, Recreational Vehicle or
Oversized Vehicle on any public street or highway in the City between the hours
of 2 a.m. through 6 a.m.
B. No person may park or leave standing any Trailer, Recreational Vehicle or
Oversized Vehicle on any public street or highway in the City within twenty-five
feet (25') of any intersection.
C. Exceptions. The prohibition stated in subsection A does not apply:
1. To any Trailer, Recreational Vehicle or Oversized Vehicle for which a valid
Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit has been issued and is properly
displayed, in accordance with this Article.
2. To any vehicle for which a valid Oversized Vehicle Handicap Parking Permit
has been issued and is properly displayed, in accordance with this Article.
3. To any Oversized Vehicle or Trailer for which an encroachment permit has
been duly issued by the City.
4. To any Trailers, Recreational Vehicles or Oversized Vehicles parked or left
standing as a result of a mechanical breakdown so as to allow the
performance of emergency repairs on the vehicle for a period not to exceed
twenty-four (24) hours.
5. To any commercial vehicles making pickups or delivery of goods, wares or
merchandise, or while providing services to a residence, including, but not
Page 4 of 13
163
limited to yard maintenance, pool care and maintenance, repair and
construction services.
6. To any tow trucks and similar vehicles that are in the course of providing
services.
7. To any public or utility vehicles and trailers that are in the course of providing
services.
8. To any motor coach or bus that is operated by a common carrier of
passengers for hire that is associated with a hotel in the City and is parked
adjacent to the hotel.
9. To any public emergency vehicle.
10.During any state of emergency declared by the City Council to exist within
the City of El Segundo.
8-5G-3: Oversized Vehicle Resident Registration Program.
The purpose of the Oversized Vehicle Resident Registration Program is to have
an index of all Oversized Vehicles, Recreational Vehicles and Trailers that are
owned by residents and parked within the City. The one-time registration is valid
for the life of the vehicle and is signified by a sticker that is issued by the Police
Department. Registration alone does not allow an Oversized Vehicle, Recreation
Vehicle or Trailer to park at all times on City public streets or highways. Rather,
once such a vehicle has been registered with the City, the owner may apply for
Oversized Vehicle Parking Permits pursuant to this Article.
8-5G-4: Registration of Oversized Vehicles, Recreational Vehicles or
Trailers.
A. Each person registering an Oversized Vehicle, Recreational Vehicle or
Trailer with the City must file with the Police Department a completed application
containing the following:
1. The name, address, and phone number of the registered owner of
designated Oversized Vehicle, Recreational Vehicle or Trailer;
2. The name, address, and phone number of the applicant for the permit;
3. Proof of residency, which must be current and must include the following:
California Driver's License or California Identification Card and one of the
following: Property Tax Bill or Public Utility Bill (telephone bills are not
acceptable).
4. The registration from the California Department of Motor Vehicles for the
Oversized Vehicle or Trailer that shows the Oversized Vehicle, Recreational
Vehicle or Trailer is registered to a resident of the City of El Segundo;
5. The license number, make, and model of designated Oversized Vehicle,
Page 5 of 13
164
Recreational Vehicle or Trailer; and
6. Any additional information the Police Department may require.
B. The applicant must sign the application under penalty of perjury.
C. The applicant must pay any applicable fees in an amount set by City Council
resolution.
D. The Police Chief or designee must issue an Oversized Vehicle Resident
Registration Sticker to each person who submits a completed application, pays the
registration fee set by City Council resolution, and otherwise meets the
requirements of this Article. The Registration Sticker must be issued within 10
working days from the date all requirements have been met.
E. The Oversized Vehicle Resident Registration Sticker must be displayed on
the left side of the rear bumper of the Oversized Vehicle, Recreational Vehicle or
Trailer that has been registered with the City. The sticker must be displayed in a
manner so that it is clearly visible from the street.
8-5G-5: Oversized Vehicle Parking Permits.
A. The purpose of the Oversized Vehicle Parking Permits is to give owners of
Oversized Vehicles, Recreational Vehicles and Trailers the opportunity, for a
limited time, to park the Oversized Vehicle, Recreational Vehicle or Trailer on a
public street or highway adjacent to their residence, and to allow an out-of-town
visitor who owns an Oversized Vehicle, Recreational Vehicle or Trailer to park on
a public street or highway adjacent to the residence which the out-of-town visitor
is visiting for a limited time period. For purposes of this article, the phrase"adjacent
to the residence" means as close as practicable to the residence, but no more than
400 feet from the residence.
B. A duly issued Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit only allows an otherwise
prohibited vehicle to lawfully park on a City street or highway from 2:00 a.m. to
6:00 a.m. for two consecutive days. The permit does not allow the vehicle or trailer
to be parked in an otherwise unlawful manner.
8-5G-6: Oversized Vehicle Parking Permits — Issuance.
A. Each person who seeks an Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit for an
Oversized Vehicle, Recreational Vehicle or Trailer that is currently registered with
the City must:
1. Have registered their Oversized Vehicle, Recreational Vehicle or Trailer and
permanently affixed the Oversized Vehicle Residential Sticker to their
vehicle or trailer in conformance with Section 8-5G-3 of this Article.
2. File with the Police Department a completed application form containing the
following:
Page 6 of 13
165
a. The dates for which the permit is requested;
b. The dates and duration of any and all Oversized Vehicle Parking Permits
issued to the applicant within the immediately preceding 90-day period;
c. Any additional information the Police Department may require.
3. Pay any applicable permit fee set by City Council resolution.
B. Each person who seeks an Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit for an
Oversized Vehicle, Recreational Vehicle or Trailer that is not currently registered
with the City must:
1. Be a guest of a resident of the City, and not a resident of the City.
2. File with the Police Department a completed application form containing the
following:
a. The name, address, and phone number of the registered owner of
designated Oversized Vehicle or Trailer;
b. The name, address, and phone number of the applicant for the permit;
c. The registration from the California Department of Motor Vehicles, or
equivalent agency in another state, for the Oversized Vehicle,
Recreational Vehicle or Trailer;
d. The name, address, and phone number of the resident that is being
visited;
e. The license plate number, make, and model of designated Oversized
Vehicle or Trailer;
f. The dates for which the permit is requested;
g. The dates and duration of any and all Oversized Vehicle Parking Permits
issued to the applicant during the current calendar year;
h. The dates and duration of any and all Oversized Vehicle Parking Permits
issued to the resident being visited during the current calendar year; and
i. Additional information the Police Department may require.
3. Sign the application under penalty of perjury.
4. Pay any applicable permit fee set by City Council resolution.
C. The Police Chief or designee must issue an Oversized Vehicle Parking
Permit to each person who submits a completed application, pays the registration
fee set by City Council resolution, and otherwise meets the requirements of this
Article. Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit(s) must be issued within two working
days from the date all requirements have been met.
D. Oversized Vehicle Parking Permits issued by the Police Chief or designee
must include the license plate number of the designated Oversized Vehicle,
Recreational Vehicle or Trailer, the date of issuance, and the day of its expiration.
E. Permits must be displayed in the vehicle for which it has been issued. The
permit must be affixed on the lower driver's side of the windshield or the driver's
window so that it is clearly visible from the street and from the exterior of the
vehicle. For those vehicles without windows, such as a Trailer, permits must be
Page 7 of 13
166
displayed on the side of the Trailer so that it is clearly visible from the street, which
is usually the left side of the Trailer.
8-5G-7: Oversized Vehicle Parking Permits — Duration.
A. For an Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit that is issued for a registered
vehicle pursuant to subsection A of Section 8-5G-6, the permit is valid for two
consecutive days. An Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit will allow an otherwise
prohibited vehicle to lawfully park on a City street or highway from 2:00 a.m. to
6:00 a.m. one day and 2:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m. the following day. Upon expiration of
the permit, the applicant may apply for and be granted additional Oversized
Vehicle Parking Permits if the applicant still qualifies under the conditions set forth
in this Article. An applicant may request no more than two consecutive Oversized
Vehicle Parking Permits (to allow an otherwise prohibited vehicle to lawfully park
on a City street or highway from 2:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m. for four consecutive days)
at one time. An applicant may request no more than 12 two-day Oversized Vehicle
Parking Permits per quarter. A "quarter" for purposes of this section is January
through March, April through June, July through September, and October through
December of each calendar year.
B. For an Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit that is issued for a vehicle that is
not registered pursuant to subsection B of Section 8-5G-6, the permit is valid for
two consecutive days. An Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit will allow an otherwise
prohibited vehicle to lawfully park on a City street or highway from 2:00 a.m. to 6:00
a.m. one day and 2:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m. the following day. Upon expiration of the
permit, the applicant may apply for and be granted additional Oversized Vehicle
Parking Permits if the applicant still qualifies under the conditions set forth in this
Article. The Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit must be associated with the
residence being visited. An applicant may request no more than two Oversized
Vehicle Parking Permits (to allow an otherwise prohibited vehicle to park from 2:00
a.m. to 6:00 a.m. for four consecutive days) at one time. An applicant may request
no more than 12 two-day permits per quarter and no more than 48 of such permits
per calendar year.
8-5G-8: Oversized Vehicle Handicap Parking Permits.
A. Purpose. The purpose of authorizing the issuance of Oversized Vehicle
Handicap Parking Permits is to allow a handicapped person to park a designated
Oversized Vehicle on a street/highway directly in front of(or the side of the property
if it is a corner lot) their residence.
B. Requirements. In order to be eligible to receive an Oversized Vehicle
Handicap Parking Permit, both of the following requirements must be met:
1. The applicant must be entitled to receive a handicapped placard or license
plate pursuant to the provisions of the California Vehicle Code;
Page 8 of 13
167
2. The Oversized Vehicle is the only vehicle owned by the resident and is
required to meet the daily transportation needs of the resident.
8-5G-9: Oversized Vehicle Handicap Parking Permits — Issuance.
A. Each person desiring an Oversized Vehicle Handicap Parking Permit must:
1. Have registered their Oversized Vehicle, Recreational Vehicle or Trailer
and permanently affixed the Oversized Vehicle Residential Sticker to their
vehicle in conformance with this Article.
2. File with the Police Department a completed City application form
containing the following:
a. The name, address, and phone number of the registered owner and
applicant of designated Oversized Vehicle;
b. The license number, make, and model of designated oversized
vehicle;
c. The year for which the permit is requested;
d. The years of any and all previous Oversized Vehicle Handicap
Parking Permits issued to the applicant;
e. Additional information the Police Department may require;
3. Sign the application under penalty of perjury.
B. The Police Chief or designee must issue an Oversized Vehicle Handicap
Parking Permit to each person who submits a completed application and otherwise
meets the requirements of this Article. Oversized Vehicle Handicap Parking
Permit(s) must be issued within 10 working days from the date all requirements
have been met.
C. Oversized Vehicle Handicap Parking Permits issued by the Police Chief or
designee must include the license plate number of the designated Oversized
Vehicle, the date of issuance and the day of its expiration.
D. Oversized Vehicle Handicap Permits must be issued without any fees.
E. Permits must be displayed in the vehicle for which it has been issued. The
permit must be affixed on the lower driver's side of the windshield or the driver's
window so that it is clearly visible from the street and from the exterior of the
vehicle.
8-5G-10: Oversized Vehicle Handicap Parking Permits — Duration.
Oversized Vehicle Handicap Parking Permits are valid for a period of one year, so
long as the permit holder meets the requirements of this section relating to such
permits. Permits may be renewed on an annual basis.
8-5G-11: Permit Denial.
Page 9 of 13
168
An Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit or an Oversized Vehicle Handicap Parking
Permit must be denied if the Police Chief or designee finds that:
1. The applicant or the person the applicant is visiting is not a bona fide City
resident;
2. The out-of-town visitor is not a guest of the resident;
3. Information submitted by the applicant is materially false; or
4. If the application is for an Oversized Vehicle Handicap Permit, the applicant is
not entitled to receive a handicap placard or license plate under the California
Vehicle Code; or the Oversized Vehicle is not the applicant's only vehicle.
8-5G-12: Penalties for Violations, Review Request.
A. Unless otherwise specified, any person who violates any provision in this
Article is guilty of an infraction and will be subject to citation, towing, or both.
B. Every person who displays a fraudulent, forged, altered, or counterfeit
Oversized Vehicle Parking Permit or Permit number with the intent to avoid
compliance with this Article is guilty of a misdemeanor.
C. Every person who displays a fraudulent, forged, altered, or counterfeit
Oversized Vehicle Handicap Parking Permit or Permit number with the intent to
avoid compliance with this Article is guilty of a misdemeanor.
D. Every person who displays a fraudulent, forged, altered, or counterfeit
Oversized Vehicle Resident Registration Sticker with the intent to avoid compliance
with this Article is guilty of a misdemeanor.
E. Every person who forges, alters, or counterfeits an Oversized Vehicle
Parking Permit, an Oversized Vehicle Handicap Parking Permit, or an Oversized
Vehicle Resident Registration Sticker is guilty of a misdemeanor.
F. Every person who is issued a notice of parking violation pursuant to this
Article may request review of that notice under California Vehicle Code section
40215 et seq.
8-5G-13: Application of Regulations.
A. The prohibitions in this Article apply at all times, or at those times specified,
except when it is necessary to stop a vehicle to avoid conflict with other traffic or
to comply with the directions of a police officer or official traffic control device.
B. The time limitations on standing or parking in this Article do not relieve any
person from the duty to observe other and more restrictive provisions of the
Page 10 of 13
169
California Vehicle Code or this Code prohibiting or limiting the standing or parking
of vehicles in specified places or at specified times.
C. Nothing in this Article may be construed to permit vehicle habitation on a
public street as prohibited by Section 7-6-1 of this Code."
SECTION 6: lmolementation Period: Effective Date.
A. There will be an implementation period during which the ordinance will not be
enforced. The implementation period will start on the effective date of the ordinance and
will end on March 31, 2017. The purpose of the implementation period is to give owners
of Oversized Vehicles, Recreational Vehicles and Trailers the opportunity to register their
vehicles with the City. The registration will consist of completing an application and
submitting the required supporting documentation.
B. Effective April 1, 2017, only Oversized Vehicles, Recreational Vehicles and Trailers
with a City of El Segundo Oversized Vehicle Resident Registration Sticker will be allowed
to park on any public street or highway in the City between the hours of 2 a.m. and 6 a.m.
Effective April 1, 2017, Oversized Vehicles, Recreational Vehicles and Trailers without a
City of El Segundo Resident Registration Sticker parked on a public street or highway
between the hours of 2 a.m. and 6 a.m., will be in violation of, and subject to the penalty
provisions of, this ordinance.
C. Effective April 1, 2017, no Oversized Vehicle or Recreational Vehicle will be allowed
to park on any public street or highway in the City without displaying a valid Oversized
Vehicle Parking Permit or Oversized Vehicle Handicap Parking Permit between the hours
of 2 a.m. and 6 a.m.
SECTION 7'. Environmental Review. This ordinance is exempt from environmental
review under the California Environmental Quality Act (California Public Resources Code
§§ 21000, et seq., "CEQA") and CEQA regulations (14 California Code of Regulations §§
15000, et seq.) because it consists only of minor revisions and clarifications to existing
regulations. It does not portend any new development and does not relax existing
regulatory restrictions on future development. This ordinance, therefore, does not have
the potential to cause significant effects on the environment. Consequently, it is exempt
from CEQA review under 14 Cal. Code Regs. § 15061(b)(3).
SECTION 8: Severability. If any part of this Ordinance or its application is deemed invalid
by a court of competent jurisdiction, the City Council intends that such invalidity will not
affect the effectiveness of the remaining provisions or applications and, to this end, the
provisions of this Ordinance are severable.
SECTION 9: Construction. This Ordinance must be broadly construed in order to
achieve the purposes stated in this Ordinance. It is the City Council's intent that the
provisions of this Ordinance be interpreted or implemented by the City and others in a
manner that facilitates the purposes set forth in this Ordinance.
Page 11 of 13
170
SECTION 10- Enforceability. Repeal of any provision of the El Segundo Municipal Code
does not affect any penalty, forfeiture, or liability incurred before, or preclude prosecution
and imposition of penalties for any violation occurring before, this Ordinance's effective
date. Any such repealed part will remain in full force and effect for sustaining action or
prosecuting violations occurring before the effective date of this Ordinance.
SECTION 11: The City Clerk is directed to certify the passage and adoption of this
Ordinance; cause it to be entered into the City of El Segundo's book of original
ordinances; make a note of the passage and adoption in the records of this meeting; and,
within fifteen (15) days after the passage and adoption of this Ordinance, cause it to be
published or posted in accordance with California law.
SECTION 12: This Ordinance will become effective on the thirty-first (31 st) day following
its passage and adoption.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this day of 2017.
Suzanne Fuentes, Mayor
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Mark D. Hensley, City Attorney
ATTEST:
STATE OF CALIFORNIA }
COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES } SS
CITY OF EL SEGUNDO }
I, Tracy Weaver, City Clerk of the City of El Segundo, California, do hereby certify that
the whole number of members of the City Council of said City is five; that the foregoing
Ordinance No. was duly introduced by said City Council at a regular meeting
held on the day of 2017, and was duly passed and adopted by said City
Council, approved and signed by the Mayor, and attested to by the City Clerk, all at a
regular meeting of said Council held on the day of ; 2017, and the same
was so passed and adopted by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
Page 12 of 13
171
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
Tracy Weaver, City Clerk
Page 13 of 13
172
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Reports of Committees,
Commissions & Boards
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action to receive and file the El Segundo Senior Housing Board
Corporation (Park Vista)proposed annual budget for 2017.
(Fiscal Impact: None to the General Fund)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Approve the 2017 Park Vista Annual Budget; and/or,
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
1. Park Vista 2017 Budget Worksheet
FISCAL IMPACT: None
Amount Budgeted: N/A
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): N/A
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 5b El Segundo approaches its work in a financially disciplined and
responsible way
Objective: 2 The City will maintain a stable, efficient, and transparent financial
environment
ORIGINATED BY: Liz Tran, Acting Recreation Superintendent
REVIEWED BY: Meredith Petit, Director of Recre tion and Parks
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
The El Segundo Senior Housing Board approved the 2017 Annual Budget for the Park Vista
Senior Housing apartments located at 615 East Holly Avenue. The increase in Operating
Expense is due to an anticipated increase in maintenance and utility fees. The increase Net
Operating Income is due to the completion of the loan payment.
Operating Budget Annual Comparison
2016 2017 Variance Increase/Decrease
Operating Income $ 633,084 $ 633,084 $ 0 0 %
Operating
Expense $403,050 $447,200 $ 44,150 11.0 %
Loan Payment $ 156,000 $ 0 $ 0 0 %
Net Operating Income $ 74,634 $ 186,484 $ 111,850 149.9 %
6
173
Paris Vista 2017 Budget Worksheet
Proposed 2017
2016 Jan-Sep 2016 Annualized 2016 Budget 2015 Budget 2014 Actual Budget Notes
RENT
Rent Income 460 664 30; 614 51240, 610,564 46 590 000 00, 58273659. 610 584 41110-1%vacancy fad ineld NO rent increase
Parking Income 12,47000' 16,62667' 18,00000 18,00000' 17,69792 16.000 OC
Total RENT 473,354 30, 631139 07: 626,584 48 606,000.00, 600,434 51 0763a4 4e
Lounoyincomo 3;561,50; 1,7T5,33� 4AW,90 4,400.00: 00031170 4.500.0c
&4)ense
Fire Service 2.073691 2,76519 3,000,00 3,000,001 4,748.70- 3,250.
Maintenance 62.13363: 62,844,84 70,000.00 70,00000 58,61075 100,000
Elevator service 5,516 90: 7,355 73, 9,000,00 8,000(t0: 5,65654 6.000 ,mirvel plus mai onanc0
Gardening 9,514 00; 12,685.33_ 15,000.00 12,000 00_ 11,706.60- 15,000 scum more irrigation and tree trimming
Management Fees 117,000.001 156,000.00' 156,000-00 156,000.00; 149,999.97 156,000
Security Service 000' 0 00! 0.00 0..00-; 0.00 0
Pest Control 2,350.00 3,133.33; 4,300.00 4,300.00 4,042,00- 3,500.
Insurance-Property 16,631.00! 22,17467'z 17,000..00 21,000-00,. 14,85200 17,000.
Licenses and Permits 7S.001 10000; 700.00 70000' 52500 700.0+
Electricity 12.54071; 16,720.95; 22.00000 22.00000-' 19.04628 20,000,0!_
Gas 7,63414; 10,178.65 12.000.00 12,000.00: 1046904 121000.0[_
Water 25.190.01' 33,586.66 32,000.00 30.000.00; 32.496.25: 40.000.Ot_
Tckphmc4ntcmcl 11,751.78 15,66904 9,300.00 7.700 00O
.00 7.52711: 181 .oc
Ceble/relevision 29.385.30! 39.180.40; 40,000.00 38,000.00; 36.439.02 42,000.0r--4pend"l on n @.ol conua.ot
Stale Taxes 50.00;. 6667, 000 0.00. 000- 005_
Stenographer 1400.00: 1,666-67, 2.400.00 2,400.00; 1,400.00-
Office Srpptea 676.49') 901..89; 1,750,90 1,75000 1.84054. 1,750
Uniforms O,.00j 0.00: 120D.017 2,50000; 2,32214, 1.200,.
Advertising 8 Promotion 355 79: 474..39; 500.00 500 00; 17982 500.
Entertainment 439.75 586.33+ 7200.00 2.000.00 1 2,45456 2.240. NORary Party
Bank Service Fees 56.00, 7733, 75.00 125.00' 10290 75.
Postage 205.06') 273.41' 125.W 250-00 209.66- 125-
Professional Fees 0.00; 0.00 5,600.00 7,00000. 5,00000 5.300. tin'Audi angagarr4ft fees
Total Operating Expame 304,661.35; 406,641.60; 403;040.00 401,225.00; 369,620.06: 4471200.
NtM.NdOprrann0 kown 1Ma64AA; 226,27160: M11114,06'9 211,275.63 239,96L33 1.ib,1111 ..
Other Income ;
Intemsl on Sank Ascounls 803 34_ 1,071 12; 600 00 60000. 72196 600.Or/ISwme less wdh less money in acct
Total Other In came 80334; 1,07112; 600.00 60000, 72196- 600.0c
Other Expense
Loan Principle Reduction 104,000.00{ 138,66667: 156,00040 156,00000' 156.00000' 0.0c
Other ier Expense 104,OWOO� 138,666.67 156.001DW 156.000.00, 155,00000 0.00
I
Net Other Income -103,196.661 -137,595551 .155.40000 -155.40000. -155,278..04 600.00
t
Trial I-ome 477,739.14; 636,985,52; 633.68446 613,100.00; 610,260.37 633.664.
Total Expense 408,981-35; 545,30847'1 559,050.00 557,22500' 525,62908 147200.
1
� MIN6Ytiaagta
39
174
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Committees, Commissions and Boards
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action to announce the appointments to the Arts and Culture
Advisory Committee. (Fiscal Impact: None)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Announce the appointees to the Arts and Culture Advisory Committee;
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
None
FISCAL IMPACT: Included in Adopted Budget
Amount Budgeted: $ None
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s):
ORIGINATED BY: Mishia Jennings, Executive Assistant
REVIEWED BY:
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
Committee/Commission and Board Number of Appointee(s) Term Expiration
Openings
Arts and Culture Advisory Committee 2 Jay Beynon 06/30/19—Partial Term
Dolores Me Allister 06/30/20—Full Term
7
175
x
w
f-
A
O
N
o K
> p
a w r
r
w
ui
a
�
U-
0 Y Z
LL w F
x LL
vy � O
w w w
r
O
U
G a z OU
J O Z O O
w w w
O D =1 =1
IL
LL
Y Y Y
Q w w w
LL LU
O U U U (n
z Qo O O O Z
z
oU-
m
O m
V
W O
W r
LL
0 U) ,
}Z .A V o A A V O w m m m m m C(O o
o (o A.O roa m o(0000" oo 2,
N N M m (O NAr V O V g(O(O m Q
COI M .m- n�� N a, g
rn N c m u I_
a U c w c
n 0 O m
yb L N O
C N N >
Q r
w N N J d U
Z w � O L :
o o w w l a E rz .3 `o ,
w Q� U r z O U o m a c m
~ K O w LL r W w 0 L N « O d C p
O j ¢ Q z N >
Ow m w z wr ii m E Emcom
< zzzazow 2 zw r 'w o� ° E
o 0z4a0Ow0LLm aFFScwi w wzzz y To ° w n mL $ M. - a
zo LL�rr�gz� xUZw< o ww (nQLLw F z �_ o m c `o mZ�g E A2 w I=iD (Kcr 000N �l<m �F w tr w�z z UaaZ .�uriNm 4a ❑ -O u03, u_
O r X m Z¢ Z Z U m r D O Z }LL LL W m Z H> Q
7 li F- D Iwi W 2 K Y Z w Z Z W Z d U J w f� K W OO d W W LC O O Ul N N U O
N Q 1-2 Q r r J 0 z v Q LL o w Q w r w a ¢ o a = m °' E
of W C) <��mwX " �j< iL Uit=aw0��'Wwzzo U m `o E 5 NF"i >E !3
F-
W rOw aaOwwQUQa wry�pwrwa mww n > 'm t l n m m y c M1 "
W
IQ- oi oiO���OiorQ- w�¢oi vmiaLL ¢ ¢¢OdaOwXX� m ° a=� ac
c5r(n000a0- M-T aQ Uw ir W w0 om
E O
C f0 L l0 Vi 0 3
C JO `p N C O-(0 S� P•y�
U N U O. � �7
O N U O C T E m L m
N E 666000NOOaYYY
3 - i
L m
m
J �' w o a E 0,v N c'O E t
rn
mc
m W I d o a) `m W E N W
o ¢0�aw m v N m uoi aci
�Z au
p o a 5 o o E' rnm a E 5 v v m
O O E a m c
c Lq D a"Q L
LL o
O m m
O
o u w
F Z Q W
W
a p U o O 11 II II Z B
(n U _ LL U d' LL Q m 2 6l ❑
176
CITY of EL SEG UNDO
PAYM,ENTS 13Y IRE TRANSFER
1119117 THROUGH 1129117
DesG.6.000rt
1/10/2017 Vilest Basin 1,8'19,290.54 H2O payment _—..
1/'13/2017 Manufacturers Traders 45,667.93 457 payment Vantagepoint
1/13/2017 Manufacturers g, Traders 552.31 IRA payment Vantagepoint
1/13/20'17 State of CA EFT 1,820.10 EFT Child support payment
1/13/2017 Health Comp 261.38 V�/eekly claims
1/17/2017 Nationwide NRS EFT 146,982 26 EFT 457 payment
1/'17/20'17 IRS 332,776.54 Federal 941 Deposit
1/17/2017 Employment Development 3,622.08 State SDI payment
1/17/2017 Employment Development 74,290.37 State PIT Withholding
1/17/2017 Chase Bank Debit 20,739 52 Calendar Year 2016 bank fees
1/18/20'17 Cal Pars 6,763.49 EFT Retirement Safety-Fire-PEPRA New
1/18/2017 Cal Pars 6,523.63 EFT Retirement Safety-Police-PEPRA New
1/18/2017 Cal Pars 28,281.09 EFT Retirement Misc- PEPRA New
1/18/2017 Cal Pars 96,208.10 EFT Retirement INAisc- Classic
1/18/20'17 Cal Pars 283,848.91 EFT Retirement Safety -Classic
1/20/2017 Health Comp 1,147.63 Weekly claims
1/26/2017 Unum 193.50 Long Term Care Premium
1/27/20'17 Health Camp 39.57 Weekly claims
1/27/2017 Manufacturers & Traders 21,546.48 457 payment Vantagepoint
'1/27/2017 Manufacturers &Traders 552.31 IRA payment Vantagepoint
1/27/20'17 State of CA EFT 2,394.18 EFT Child support payment
1/19/2017 Lane Donovan Golf Ptr 22,54724 Payroll Transfer
1/9/'17-1/15/17 Workers Comp Activity 24,503.43 SCRIVIA checks issued
1/16/17-1/22/17 Workers Comp Activity 78,825.26 SCRMA checks issued
1/23/17-1/29/17 Workers Comp Activity 19,408.00 SCRMA checks issued
1/2/17-1/8/17 Liability Trust - Claims 925.00 Claim checks issued
1/9/17-1/15/17 Liability Trust- Claims 120,000.00 Claim checks issued
1/16/17-1/22/17 Liability Trust- Claims 0.00 Claim checks issued
1/23/17-1/29/17 Liability Trust- Claims 132.80 Claim checks issued
'1/2/17-1/8/17 Retiree Health Insurance 0.00 Health Reimbursment checks issued
1/9/17-1/15/17 Retiree Health Insurance 0.00 Health Reimbursment checks issued
1/16/17-1/22/17 Retiree Health Insurance 0.00 Health Reimbursment checks issued
1/23/17-1/29/17 Retiree Health Insurance 0.00 Health Reimbursment checks issued
3,159,843.65
DATE OF RATIFICATION: 1130117
TOTAL PAYMENTS BY WIRE: 3,159,843,65
Certified as to the accuracy of the wire transfers by:
e'er L!'�,'L•:^i�•`r�,� r �="�, , i
Deputy C'y Treass ir>ar('ll Dat
Directo -ell � Date
City Ma ger Date
Information on actual expenditures is available in the City Treasurer's Office of the City of El Segundo.
P:\City Treasurer\U\lire Transfers\Wire Transfers 10-01-16 to 9-30-17 1 1'/ 0/20.17 1/1
SPECIAL MEETING OF THE EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 7, 2016
El Segundo Public Library
111 W. Mariposa Avenue, El Segundo, CA 90245
12:00 p.m.
(Strategic Planning Workshop No. 3)
12:00 P.M. SESSION
CALL TO ORDER — Mayor Fuentes at 12:02 PM
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE — Mayor Pro Tern Boyles
ROLL CALL
Mayor Fuentes - Present
Mayor Pro Tern Boyles - Present
Council Member Dugan - Present
Council Member Brann - Present
Council Member Pirsztuk - Present
PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS — (Related to City Business Only) — 5 minute limit per person, 30
minute limit total) None
SPECIAL ORDERS OF BUSINESS:
1. Consideration and possible action regarding the development of a specific work plan related
to the City's current strategic planning and resulting in City Council defining the City of El
Segundo's short term and long term work priorities. Receiving, filing and providing direction
regarding staff's analysis and recommendations for the specific work plan. Staff will also
present measurable metrics directly related to the work plan.
Recommendation: 1) City Council consider and discuss input regarding the specific work
plan related to Strategic Planning; and 2) alternatively, take such additional, related, action
that may be desirable.
Greg Carpenter, City Manager, introduced the item and outlined the meeting process.
Sara A Peterson, Management Consultant and facilitator, recapped the previous meetings and
stated the goals for the meeting.
The meeting was a forum for the Council and each department to discuss and ask questions
pertaining to the 2016-2019 Draft Strategic Work Plan handout (attached to this document for
reference).
Recessed at 1:14 PM
Reconvened at 1:24 PM
Continued discussion
178
The final 2016-2019 Strategic Work Plan will be approved at the December 20, 2016 City Council
Meeting. All comments and suggested edits to the Draft Strategic Plan will be emailed directly to
Joe Lillio, Finance Director and Sara A Peterson, Management Consultant and together they will
finalize the 2016-2019 Strategic Plan for the City of El Segundo.
Council requested monthly reports from each department in correlation with the Strategic Plan and
how each department is doing on 2-3 metrics from each goal area and quarterly reports green,
yellow and red lining of the Strategic Work Plan.
Attached is the meeting summary from Sara A. Peterson, Management Consultant.
ADJOURNMENT at 3:00 PM
Tracy Weaver, City Clerk
179
i
CITY OF EL SEGUNDO
Strategic Planning.
F Y 2 0 9 6 2 0
CITY OF EL SEGUNDO I CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
350 Main Street El Segundo, California (310) 524-2302
Suzanne Fuentes j
Mayor
sfuentes @elsegundo.org
Drew Boyles
- Mayor Pro Tern
dboyles @elsegundo.org
i
Michael Dugan
Council Member
v mdugan @elsegundo.org
on Brann
Council Member
dbrann @elsegundo.org -n
o
rn
Carol Pirsztuk N
Council Member 0
r cpirsztuk @elsegundo.org
I
i
r
Strategic 'Plan
2016-2019
Tab` .6 of Contents
Message from the City Manager, Greg Carpenter
Executive Summary
Part I: Mission,Vision &Values
Part II: Goals & Objectives
Part III: Work Plan for FY 2016-2019
Appendix: Draft Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
2 Page
182
Message from the City Manager
To: Honorable Mayor Fuentes and Members of City Council
I am pleased to present the City of El Segundo's 2016-2019 Three-Year Strategic Plan.The plan will serve
as a roadmap of El Segundo's vision for the future through a number of goals, objectives and strategies.
With this Strategic Plan, the City will continue to work towards making El Segundo the best place to live,
work, and play. The citizens and the business community continue to expect the City to provide a high
level of service by keeping the City safe at all times and by providing programs and services that enhance
the quality of life.
As the City implements the various projects and programs outlined in the Strategic Plan, City Staff will
continue to work with our community to build upon the partnerships we have established.
I look forward to many years of progress and important developments within our City, and extend my
personal appreciation to the Department Heads and City Staff for their hard work and cooperation while
completing this Three-Year Strategic Plan.
Respectfully,
Greg Carpenter
City Manager
183
Executive Summary
A Strategic Plan is a living document which features a comprehensive framework that can be adjusted
based on the current needs of the community; and to ensure that the priorities set by the City Council are
clear, concise, and are being met by City staff. On a periodic basis, the City will provide updates on the
progress and performance of each goal, objective, and strategy. As such, the plan may be modified to
ensure that stated goals are aligned with the needs of the community.
Through a series of outreach efforts,the City identified five key goals:
1. Enhance Customer Service and Engagement
2. Support Community Safety and Preparedness
3. Develop as a Choice Employer and Workforce
4. Develop Quality Infrastructure and Environment
5. Optimize Impact of Technology
Each of these goals have specific objectives and strategies identified and outlined in order to support,
implement, accomplish these goals.The strategies are essentially the series of steps leading to the action
plans to fully and successfully execute the completion of these goals.The Strategic Plan also incorporates
an Action Plan Worksheet. This section takes the Goals, Objectives, and Strategies and assigns the
responsible department and division.
41 Page
184
Part l : Mission, Vision & Values
Mission — What is our purpose?
The Mission of the City of El Segundo is to "Provide a great place to live, work and visit."
This serves as the "destination" that our strategies should lead towards and provides the context for our
decisions.
Vision — Where do we want to be in the future?
El Segundo residents enjoy a high quality of life as evidenced by reduced crime, improved schools, and a
sense of vibrant community—of fun! It is a tolerant, kind and compassionate community. It is recognized
as best place to raise a family and a center of innovation. The appeal of working for the City is such that
there are application backlogs for jobs in the area. It has engaging, sophisticated, capitalized events that
showcase tradition and match the City's evolving demographics. We also have a robust network and
service structure in place to support aging in place.
The City has transformed.We are leading the way with innovation and environmental responsibility. With
fewer people driving cars, we have adapted our street, parking and land use plans. We have high-speed
fiber optics as a utility to support more work from home and fewer brick and mortar businesses. The
downtown is vibrant with successful businesses and day and evening pedestrian activity. The east side of
town has become denser (especially near the rail lines) including a high level of service with retail and a
school to support it. While our revenue base has shifted to changing businesses, we are financially
sustainable and growing because we have capitalized on the changes. In fact, we have more invested
capital per square mile (commercial) than any other California city. All of that said, we still have the Air
Force base in part because we fought for it.
The City has also changed as a service provider. Customer service has increased. There is easy access to
City information (1-click to answer and/or a single point of entry/contact for services) and an ability to do
virtually everything online for real time access to services. Pathways for citizen and business feedback are
easy and comfortable. The City is seen as a nimble partner to businesses and residents with cutting edge
infrastructure and scalable processes/systems. At the same time, interactions are personal to keep the
small town feel.
Values & Culture — How will we serve and manage our city?
■ Accountability El Segundo works to create a working culture of
• Productivity • Innovation
• Ethics ■ Support and recognition
• Stewardship • Leadership by example
• Service • Proactive action
• Challenging ourselves • Problem-solving—getting to yes
• Continuous improvement and reflection
5 age
185
a,
1 >
° a, a,
E
0 0 v
v
° E o
C O p Q
m Y Y Q
u > U m 7
aJ 41 ` Z3
L i
Y I U a1 O
C ra
O _ p ro ro U1 M p
Y E
ut C U v i
V —
s E +� s
0 o aE, E u
a) O 00 w
++ Y to C O
GJ O a) 0 >
Y T — <
C >.
C �, O a
OA 6 j C
r0 ro 7 O N
Oa ai E n E
0) E CL
` O O o Q
a) a) ai io y > >
p 2 ro C ` a) Q D v
>
L (n i �, o >. a) a- u 3
Y u o C 0. c = -A E Q c
v v L
10 U f6 f6 U L) +`' m .0- C al >
L W- V) V) C O > O _Q W
C -Q +' u a CO to w i ro tDLO U i C +� `� a) ~ a) C
L N! a+ V U V) O L "Q U � O
E �' 7 a -a- ;, E a v E > � � � -
E y C m to v > O O p
u O � C U O - C N O O
aJ a) •�, O ra [0 vi C O -Q �. C a) a) v a)a (u
'y) E al aJ Y u a) O > cL i -0 Y O 0 .Q
L v� Q C � ;� E 7 u � .0 -Q a) C
aJ a� al O Q) In ro j C +-� L fa
L � C Q •�, E C O v U N r0 >. a)) 000 00 CO '� ra
Q u on , „� -Z u _ ; 3 a) c c ra o v
> n ar to o ra -0 ra +, u E w
u E N m > u ° c ro u � o 0 o v v
L E c o a) 00 u E ra —v Y E °—v,) c o bn '� '� '"P U c °C 11
O �' v v a mo E ro c 0) o + v cli :3
a) tw m o c
W C i i i C O i u ++
L v0i v0i a) Ln '> 4) W C] 0 41 a) Q w Q o �' v7 vl vl °� f0 -0 a) a) C
L
a) C Q •c m a) = f0 w N \ 7 -Q CL C a) .0 C C m N v Q a)
p + a) u ti4 r6 Ln i o > ,. °v E a) v c , O u � 3
U •> C p — O �+ da cu Q a) y u -0 -0 c cu_� w a) 06 w
CL
v +, C tin V ro ro n � o o C v '' ° ,pn o o o *' o rco E a�i o � v
CL o v c a) a) oo rB M ro a) Q) > ro E E
d Q '� •� > > v E Q o a ea aoi c v ui a v o _0 _0 t _0 o p a>i v
E c o s s v u f° c w oc w er rX Gl <C v a a a U a a rn D a
d 3 0 = 0 v 3 rco v „ . . . . . • • • ) • • . . . . . • . . . •
0 0 .0 -0 Q) o y o E �
rn s m C .� \ L00 C Q o N � C DC
ry
v� c ra ro � � � p `v c E w u a
u "M o 0 C C O � c Q ? -
C — E r M ao E
Z, c O E ate-+ j >' C O u c
a) l+ +�+ v+'i L O at+ - O al p 7 C 4 i c
u E '�n o u in > L i rn r�6 L �� 0 O
rU 4- C Y r0 Y C Q M d to M i� •C. 0' V
CL O 0 0 U O O a) C E `-
m OD > O O �, a) t �+ t' i C ` V 0 7
a) L a/ C N L C 0
Qj CU rLn 'E w c v a v m _ � a +� � c
o o E E ar a) E
ai
° ac)
bD o'n ao) ao) •� 'co L v `m 3 ) d '0 °' m v
v o C W v, Q v > O Q- rn f, c a C 3 c E s .
7 ro v a oC Z) -0 (n a -1 `n 0) C .. 3 0) m to
u O W 00 3 W
p a) 0 7 0 Q � t 0) N d 0) (A H OD OL i N
w 0 0 0 0 w 0 0 � a) 'n u +' O C s m +�+
rn V) Ln H vim- ra W C W U W aJ a+ E ur cu
V) W W W C
{A �'�•1 N M � _
W • • a •
187
c In
o ca
u G
m ro
O OD
u +
T u
*' u
C
cu
N E v
s E >
0n v
L �
> m u >
+= o E C
C N C u
C L v v _
Y m E a, _
3 o v E � C: -0
co LIO 0Ca N E °u o l) o (,• C
+ C w t > a) U- o�
m ra V aQ U Y C
in ? -O O da a) •Y O w- b4 'O C C
+' v m o c 3 � u
u °1 >_ > v _ c p Y E E E
O 1+ I Y s u U t O bn Ln O- 0 O u u
> °° a) ¢ 3 3 u co o 3 c E- ° °
C v c c E -Z v C v v a, aj oc Of
aj a) > c 'v m Q '3 ° .3 E v (D .L �' co aJ aj
C a O bO v
Ln_ Q O a Q Y °- n C N m E a-+ rYa W C 7
C }' a) V C �n 'O L a1 N bn m i O m 6 6
a1 N t -OD a 'a m N O OD bA '� 'O E w w
o 3 rco Q `° a o r °o a E v o ° o ° yo
} v ° m ai c E 'c 0- u m m C 021 m o +, u `i a
ra -6 aJ y.. — cu N 6-° V1 cu ±' in ap "0 V1 -`0 ;�, O. � m
:� u E v v E a, v Y 3 u u ;+� '� Q u o Q •c o v m u
E C o 3 0 m u Y j a u 40 L L E i v c o
Q) E m C �, m v
t! ru N ° o ro v N m (U IA m v yr + a1 O c E u m 0.'1 N
Q rn '� C c >. C Y au a) E
C L > �° E `� -0 .0 v o w Yo U m � u � o iu do > � v v a
m O YO 0 7 U +�+ 4. ° 'C 00.0 ° al N N rYa u U a! i m a1
Y Y O C u u a -0 C 0) > Q c > > ^ ra u
0 3 E o -0 Q-o E u -0 m > C c c v 'Fu cu
�- u ` c ° o r U rca arc rca U a CC Q M w n- o O o l7
� v o C 7 Q —
O- • • • • • • s e • a • • • • • • • •
L C ++ +� C
' -0 +>+
m u ..
Y *' r0 v
o C c r6 � +O 1 C o ° 0
0 0 -°
+-+ aT+ L '� 'O C U C ro c: m C O m
,v m m ° 3 c v o a E c c
-c o c LE E +� a E c
L4n d a C O T +' E Q- m N u CL w T
° Q m m
`J N yr al ++
L > Y ° Q .7 •L 0- d m ++ Q Y QJ aJ
u •� Y 0 u u Q— yl 0 m 41 m U
"a m Q Q ra al u Q O L y0„ m 'rn
C O O w Q O E L a r-
0 u m O. ++ O
ro
41 ra O- Q -0 al ra yr O 0 m aJ m of Y a Q
a a' c � a E r +J 3 m a,
O rn m v Q 0- m 0 Q O •" O c C o
f0 > a1 a1 t 4-- m U C do c >'
U rA 2 Q o Q -0 -0 '00 3 r 7 w `° O •'°
.}J •0 C C C C fC0 4, d C
L as O O O O a=A W GOO w b. N
O 0 a) a1 a! a) W •� W a) to W :�
Q 3 N In V1 In
Q W W W W W
N
O
188
c
a;
c c p aJ
ro+� E
c _0 aJ c L
.+� * u p— a c c
E u Q m
CD- c m W
O `1 t _0 C .0
a' + aJ N
> O 3 t- c
E O � 3 p
L n O u
aJ
cr Q ro F U 'Qj
Q L
Ln aJ a1 'A C ro U U
A) n Z � O
c >ai C aL N ra �O
0 > C �O Y O_
O N u m 0 bD N 3
O u ro > v)
n C - 4J O v a1
O .B O ar s aJ m
ai v O on u E
Q) o C t +� u m
Ln c n c
E aJ ac) o c ELv
O '� •� aJ p c
L
Q rya d! f'i U u aJ O
Q E u a v + v o a
r a1 L -O O u N c
!� d4 u .O ro -O > .p O
o
,E c v C ? v u m W •�
C U al m
C O N ++ iJ u aJ p' Ov C
'- CL O a = E m ai
E
aJ cr- aJ
C aJ aJ
O U aJ > .O
C O .f? 41 CA ro > N
a ai U v v 3 O t
� —w n v aJ a >
p p
u o O
0 U > v c to v E E
O aJ a1 p >,rn >_0 u O E
t C aJ
Q) tko
U U L (Ii a) -O
L v u aJ e U Q -0 0 C ' aJ p I O ,C
m E Y O C >
O L 0 � L � L O > b - E LZ n }+
o o E O a Q r° ro v r�° aJ �a p E E O
C
0- 0. O 3 � � � � F- o o a Q o
C,6 O N @ N -a c Y LJ Lp � • • • • • •
W aJ U O y ra 4-
L c a/ u m Z, >' N p >
±± pp C O to .+ 3
O y N C aJ C o OU C aJ u m E to
L ++ O- -o C VI 7 C1 aJ � a1 m = 0)
Q c •� E m ,� r'�a m E O C God C m Mo
Ln C U �j O -0 O > >; C u •� y OL y in C fu
LLJ O v m o 'a C N a) a 0 p E CL a X j aJ
L u c v y L E E a o u v c C v v
U tw aJ
U O Y �' O ° n n 3 v v o rco 1 a N a
,O Q O_ .� O_ C C .� O O 'O C N C 15 7 C u +O' two: C
E m L O ±� E o aJ w -0 y U + -
y rn p N YvLi i u N C O p .� u : O > N _ C
u m n L Vf
U �• N m rco v v m a m m + y •N m a m I m lu
L.7 N 0 vmi m S m rn L > U u m C m C m
/ln m L t t C L ^n i 0 aJ C u L m t t U
C6 �, O p o o c 0 m o o v c aJ O > pp > E E
p m � v H Urn +_ c ' m t '= w
Q C C C L C = C C m U 'E U m •� U �[
O o'n oOn u an °�° ago co on o 0 o v t 'ra t o
bo
w CL kn
o t
aJ 3 Ul V) rn ° rn C V) V)
M
w w w � w ro w w V+)
a N E ri N M
M
rO
V
189
/ k � L \
to k
CL 0 k /
o E E
u «
0 2 7 «
� f \
\ k
f /
° E 0 3 E
/ u S % 2
2 / \ /
% % # E 2
= 2 \
% : ; ` G
\ CL /
{ k
- _ \
7 C 3 § 3
/ u 2 m { g
U 0 E 2 2 _ / _ \
\ § / 2E / ` ! O : 5-
� { 7 E u & 5
M
CL 9 } : / \' �i ƒ � r
§ \ t / \ 7 2 k E
— 2 5 u m s t f
gM ro / 0 / - \ \ /ro & % #
0 � } \ ) \ ( \ /.
> § A o s T = m — ■
U.j i \ , j = E ) j \ J OL
LU
/ @ 0 3 # u
06
§ © 7 0
§ k \ = C 2 k
= ku > \ k \ }
B 2 > m
Q ;
f m EL w = :
� \ X77 \ \ f f
§ n/ / § � -
§ — > a ' _
M CL \ \ / i f
�
k e ® f § E2 { e / )
41
7 2 7 ° f > Q f
' a m � t ) 0
§ § \ / $ \ j 3 k { In
7
0 2 b \ 0 0 0 0 / \ /
> § CL \ $ $ E O
■
u — —
2 2 V-1
�
�
O
Q)
190
O a ro ai - rU
° m +' 3
m m v: m n,
H a1 m m al I m m O
m " o a) a, m e c�I
> v C •O b4 -0 u
C O m m
O ° o E c o ,` O
Y Q -0 `) m �' U T
of n E m
aJ L C
O c } c v O ro O
CL c 3 m N v u c
u •Ln L U +al+ L
C u E O m m aJ m
m
Y 3 E
v o m o f v v E ru
y. N C O -O a1 L ,U O I
Q m m L_ L C m N ° _
u w O O :Ll O O__ >
c �+ U C Q' 3 i' E--o 00
C > C m
E
> v T c T ° ` ° > m rco v In
+' !_' O T m *' O- > Q O "O .L-� C
f0 in O a1 L u C "O ° N Ou m >. Y C
rn �' m m Q C U o C C '�
Li-
CL u u +-' o a) a o Y Q E c v +
a +� Y +L Q U + p u v s w ^ v
m C L ° Q al vii +m+ y,0 m -6 v aJ .0 a1
-Tj N u °j v aj ` ° c ° " v '� m E 3 3 �a aui Z 'u .o vT
aJ m m u u '� _ ui
E � Q- u m E > v° - o (V °J o Q v°i v> " u p rca E >
Cl) o 0 0 L a, o c a' v v 3 u u 0 `F" ! c E Q a,LL
(Ij aJ m O) m U .) N m N a. C Q a1 +' m C O O '7
> v c ° c c m .� m o v u m c o E v o 'p E ° ai — ', T LET
aJ o m v m c c a) — v -0 v m ,� v m v c E — a L o
c o c + E o c .� rono v f6 v m ° o +�
Ou � •C aa) � ° •,., O of OD > C m i O m E U d -m a1 C a) N •`—^ - C
3 U aJ C — 6 m t L m
a O + m a u C n U Q LL L C 0 aJ a fu4 .m u >O C aJ Q r,
O L C a1 E v1 O •— QJ E 7 O ut 0a E i 7 L m u 0-
++ m m v a U Q o a a n a ut E
3 Q m > +T E .v a m m
m c
w a Q m v � C
o ._^ 2 '^
O a v o a` 3
i 0 .v) r y 'm v
> +� v �a
v m
0 O rn > m > C
a0+ ° U bTA v C p ° •'^ C •� Oa
M
V a a1 a1 O — ° O — C N m O C. m
U v ` 5 y m a
Q� Y C aj O in •E C bD aJ `� 'in *'' w u O O C a)
VI Q 4J U N � : i 7 C a) W U +., ra C 41 w O ° o E v^ 41 7 3 O 7 w Ln d :.
O •C Ll a s `n •*' a' a' ` N E u O 'bb
Uw o W �^ o c > O m ° °�'' Y^ O m c 3
fB --; � m o a v ` c a, a, = Y E N v
T ar — O � v In cij> � L r`o c E v -0 m u 4O-. N vv) j, Y
_ •., O aJ m
Ln Q w cc U v�T Q w rco 0 y m N N rya
N O C ° E Q m a, m oa O v' m i
O +� 0 o 0 o o 0 0 u y a+ y C. d
+-+ u v a
to
0
Q
O W ._
rO
V
191
Y
a1 z cc O O N UA
G n to-p +' a a u 'a ro
y 0 C d u N U N O m Q
a) N in Q :z: p r+ C
E E mo LL y 'a u
t C a0+ r +� ,, N O a n VVIi v _ ° y m m
� H 3 Q E a o c a a °�.' o f v ° o a E
'V1 u E L m L a = +� ++ L
o N c c a, 0 v Q ° m w yo `a c v c c '0
CL 0
N � al W O LL +J d a) t w M O al a) c J N CD
ai LL 3 E u cc c z u o ` L C .f 6. a E Y ar o v c 41 c
3
41 c a ate+ .� a co 'm +3+ N p a N '•n CL ° +3+ r+'n
a) v, c y O +- — s p C ° 3 L 7
y z rL vvi !^ w vfOi ii H �i L a U -Q a (7
aJ II
° ° 0 0 o r c
V
CL +1
o c a) $ 3
.1 ra > c v, E v, E u c u v
�° > _o Q o_ a LA E a) o rca
°
+� _v
CL In Q � 0 � � Q N CL r- � � L Q
o
E CL m u a) v u v In �' °) f° >
u _ Q v Q y
l 1i U o `� v a o y a 2 a>i v CU °n
u oc v oc a M 3 3 0
CL
LL -a o 0� o
O _ E o m o o o as
o a ra c o sa::sa .D °4 o Q ° Q Q c
W N L r 7 ra. �— C a+ Q
L
a,
QJ
O I Y
4� 'In ::'- C U 2 r/)
C N C Vl C C u m rn
m 0.
c Y a
m aw, rs) " u
s.. to L �.
co a;
0 x o c Ln
j ai c u
W c g o c .� OJ ar a) o ro
• • co N o _ o v M rra
ro p R c
c c E , o v ° 3 a u r
N L Q m E v v c ° nn �+ +' c
v � ° Q * o s ° a s D u o v
L GJ a to o a,
O ° c 'n a c cc
++ � ° o
M N N Q c 3 � v L v Q. '>. v
a. v
> E ° tea, �' o v c E v E *'
L- m rOn , c C] c a, ° L ° u CY)p 3 o N -0 c a ° " o Q�
N ai v Q a, c O o o v a) .2 c u
m n —° ° ° _ v ar ° > c
V f0 Q v v CU o � v E ° o o v
L N
ra oc 3 o a � w a 0 ° O � a u a +.. w
U O.
C C
f6 O
cN 4L rn r
W V .3 _u ai
x
is 13 u co m E
c-I O G a 'co +O+ — -a O
ca a°pi m > o m a c
O �►
192
u -6 a v
C v U bA
L 3 C +L+ >, C (U
ch -0 Lm 00 O N i w C bq U In �- Q
�' -0 fu 3 L 4r U c 3 >- u _ ro YO O M
O. ro
i -0 U Z +�+ m Ln LO (O
++ LL L �' C bo O �' Y C Y O C N
O M �n 7 ` c a1 c 06 f6 N
co 4
c c C (CO - Q 7 Q 3 bD w Q to
w 1� C Q LA ` Q n cu vO 41 C m 3
C f0 n CA
C O m v O L _ p E T ui c ro Y
O N p L C U } N bo 7 of 3 W N U C
0. } 0 C >. Q u *' p vi o_ in o_ Y E V) p
C� T fb O_ Y C 41 y N CL C f0 c
F. CL C O U 41 3 d O E O_ U 3
c O
N Q L Ln li or N U +O+ O a U ro Z) 10,31 U
N u
.O E C ` 'a0 O
CL a u v u E o c v u a) v a
D n V c +�`+ Y b0-0 s
LA lD N i N c -4 3 E +-' L `� N U o0 rl 3 41 � � 'O v=i T
a cc O O
O N +, U Q ao C bC0 CO C ^ N a Q u lD Y p
N N J O N N O` W i � U f0 r-I b0 0 6�1 d1 N "t C C tio LL fYb L a C +L+ _6 Q lrL L v 41 Y x Q!
L ` rro O Y T +L-• -N E w N C bUp .] � Q
> 0 y , � N Q- G) c c0 c c o v O ( y o f N O
V) c 5 ku z o E Lz m m d m Ln 4- N u U m 0 U
Y
N -a C N E o c EO N N
O - N b0 r0
i t �On W ,� O E N c t (O A
O cr O°c tw i p E �b c0 t
y u a s 'Q `-' v m a v a a
cc cc :3r C � O_-o > O_ o_ � 0 af6i � o_ 2
tA `�' 1� a12 � V) u0s = a
a,
E a, a,
C v41 tn � r u in u
C
m rn c ac m c
E d ° J a
r LL LL
a, L
m
cu
X I
C 41 ++ T i U N N 3
W 'a N y N } Y C m i p T u
M 0 v a _ a v c �. v o v v 'o
O I +' > ' N 4J L C bZS U 0 N T ,Yif Q
CL)M 72> L o > ti4 Vi II _ m V) v v > '
4.1.� T Ul 3 , i 'C C i N C Y Y fb .� UJ > O
m ° aui ami v .o m o a o do 3 c p c (U M
O +°+ v v c u f0t 3 � +� = v ui °J + v
cn a a 0 v ° o °1 L `� u S o o - o .0
L V c bU do N u f0 O p Y V) `� u V) O_ U V) Lq
N v v
C ` 3 E f6 C O `� v N b1 Y O f0 C C_ Q -O tOi�
C y� L i c O p O O Y Y U N N C �^ E
0 '� > tco c o_ p O .0 -p T YO Q U
in n o v u cu
0 a Y ,� $ o p c > v 3 p 3 t
vY m o u m E v E a c c c o v v " v v a
v
L v v 'o x E = W ro -a E E E c a>i u o_
V Q 3 oc w w 0 'u u m Y LL
of a Q v m Cl tA
C C
m
4A 0 M-
w . M C
o m C M O ,,, y w o E
a 3
° " N N d N C O v
`� r O CC " aCi °— n aCi o a a
to
3
O N
U' W N cn
193
� v �
�, en
O L O
O
Do (L) V
P�1I U
I_
> >_ L M
Z Y O ai
41 00 L�
O T
co 0 N f0
O m E
I
1
YI 1� 0) �••1 m en a) O
C O C N E c E t
O N O a) al
N >- ++ V) LL 7 a1 E O a U
y LL I C CC01 to U U) N a)
E L L a p I 7
4)) M ¢ aln) E E a
z1 ao }at)
a m V -O o
O a) a c a) a) 41
L v
a, v c O E cu
u
a! ,., E + c c
n o fO M u E c M ac) = u
> p -0 a, E u a E o
rl 2 0 t L L o a) E _ ai v
16 = a 0) rl a) v O a >- +
c _
Y O u
} y
N a1 ra a0+ N E o vi a) Ia N CL
U Y ro
u `p LL L c n" c o c
u V) a) o > c E ai CL
2 E
I._ c > v v u E > ❑- > Ln a—) > +ate
c G ro o
v c ro n >
v o
a u w m u o o E d` VO) -a E D n
S5 L c E ,n
Zf m CU aj O
m m a, n E a v
L R.. � ` Y L a) "N a)
7 "3 "G � 1 ++ v L •c � E ro ca � t' E
O to v
0) v tl) a E o io u v Q a
v a)
U�> Q a a Vol Q. U co 2 Ln
i CL -
E O L >
w V w Q) a] L
4-+ O +A v .0 f�0 f�a i w V a)
a+ v1 T
o = r m m 3 m
E °a a E C c. as Q c u m
_ dA 41 a kip u u
m
C
4.1 dA
y O a
LU
a
f00 u o m .E w u
' aU
_ + o v c
x E �o �I if c U a) ? a -0 O c 0.
U I
cn L 0av) Q V L L 3 o L u m t)
E aI oa`- c u u
L- E 2 u 0 + , c a)°N a+ u c u Ln o c o v U
N v ao a
E — a) o
Q � a O U L >
cu
Y a) C >• O Y t6 U E -o U OL al a YO
IA O N N E `F C O a) +f6' N c O O- N N L
O ++ a o 00 co n (o M t to c CJ
N O N x c E o Y c v E o o > v t o
O y d c �a v m 0 —y In a) c c E o u
U U Q v av OL m � a>i N v= m E vv
41 m w u w u vii o�C a ou CC
U C V L
4� C. aO+
C LU i M v =
11J .L > C m =v1 y C N O Op
C. ' 3 �i %A f7 +' )p r C 4A 0 M C
as u d
c O rl O > a) a0°i W `o t
to
d N V N 3 G) m W W i QO
O O
194
- CL
C
al _ OO" ILi,
Y U ,O 41 "0 O L hD
LA
7 �0 3 O > L C vi C C d
fa C N — 0 m cu QD E C U Y� 7 O U 'A 4J O C I
3 o 'O a) 6au•, j v m N Ln
L m O ut E C r m -0 'A +' C v, c — i--I
t c u, E v a Y v c •N ^ m
VI 0 a :3 m 0 U - O CL c U ru m U m - a1
O 0 a) m 0 >• vi X IA — L > O N 1n Y
c C4 >., a) > Ln a a) v a, a, a) — Y E a, v 'a a 0
M L U W C > > Ln t 00 m � � a OD — C Q c t
++ v, a) m Z v oa L > oA u_ a
a0i a t E o .E c o Y v o E v > v c o
E v a, m o L a L c 0 3 0 ;, m
h0 a) U U m m O d m +�+ CO Y O C j m m bz
O
to 0 v
bA m oC> a w E
aO L > N y > Cl
al C O
a L a ul u QI ' a C 0 0 o CL v, a
n c W ai 0 a 0 v 0
N L j a) v) Y a) m a) al O0 O C p Q a C N
tI m u C 3 C b y fa O O = 0 — a) In
Q) rl "a OZ( E O a) u 'Vl C '^ v, Y 3 m C '0
.be m N E - E � a j - o L) c C N CO to u, Q ho L L
a) m 0, u
v) Y O < U > C 0 N L L \ a) N C 'ha L C E Q O 'E y
w a a rz E a, Y �, u E v v a, ` o u m a
E °Y' 0 0 0 �� E v '^ 3 -0 M > a ro u I u p o
7 a) a u a) 7 0 a) a Y O C U O c O 0a •� a a)
E d 0 Q E CP cc C7 Lu _ m a Q m a Q (A a 3 a Q O L
E
u v. 'I
L L `
•� � ' nil I
0 6
n. —
0 b u aui L
4-J u 7 o v Poo" (U
N 'app c ° 'n 06 0 0 u°
c
4J O d d m cLo a u'
L
m
bD
in
E
C: 0 s
m a co
-p u v a v, a u o o +, E
LU
� � � v c m o
X y0 (U — a m m CO C 7 CO 00 C a) v
U i N C L +' u O d0 Y O O Y t U C
Y C a) U U U ut
41 ut O C a) U N C m W > m a) C In N
E 3 v, o f '> Y C Y v L L a ,°' a) C 0 vw
BUJ O •> c v E v `L° +j o m `L° �' c ,� °° o
v 1 {�/1 w E C Q_Vim• O Y 'C •> 0 ~ Iii, u •� 'Q
L u Q >. ,; - N O a c v °0D Q cu v m m v E 0
,n o a 3 a N •� o Y C c v Y m
'C v m — a) N c L C 'in v, 'In Y O O U
O y m a° c a) cu u c E -0 0 -0 o c m C: w
u C O L aJ Y m a) a a) ++ a) v, O_
X E v 4- -0 >O v N D D U c ac/ c v a c YO
7 ai v •� w o E c v Q m > m E 0 v E
V 'C N m O > a) O > 0 > c > v, m 'oa >
m 0 L c a L L v (u -0 o a 0 t v a °
U m ut bA a n Qu Q -0 U Q a
C �
t gym +' N OC O
C i 0 m rp a •0 0
LJJ 47 n +-+ �n ++ +_' C vi ++
O c O +_�+ N u N E to H
'ZI E L = C C)
) ,,, W CL v v w 4, O E u
aa
0 _( _
195
4 e
2 2 £ e
c § 6 V m
_ - $
ob 0 ' k \
� 2 ( \ § %2 $to
-0 $ 0 a) 5 2
co
, \ k \ kU
; - m E 2 V) ± e
0 F4 z CL § o
■ ) f ° «
2 % § \ ƒ V \
to _ ƒ § 2 § G ) G
E w 0 /
_ c §
§ ( 8 \
`
© ' � 0 u )
2
:E .0 E � o to B o - % \ .- E \
E 7 s § / 0 �
a & / u \ k f
/ W 0 « k { \
V) 0 \ 0 \ J $
. E
§ § D
cr
in> 2 .
w2
CL
E .
�
B i m
cu � § / A to
E § as j /
In
to
c (
LU \
c 0) $
cu / \ k
� k 2
.t 0 . E §
/ m {
§ « % m E
§ % \ \ $
F � j [ �
u k \ sf $ /
§ \ $ / \ k
c M
m 2 ■ c
in Ea -0 o
o - m J & \
M CD E - § E I w
o t § k > § m m § a
w E § 7 2 - a E 2
§ o tA o © o ° m E 2
©
3 Q a E E u % E S VA
0
� Q �
196
_ _ +� �-
C ra a) ` Q
v=
W a a _ (a C
a Q w = a C ...
ri > am-° a c Z p N C 2
ob LA
L ro bi L 'Y
OJ c v u c T ra '� o E E
00€ E o o — a u o
co 2S c on c ra s v �°
ri- a Ul O C +, '+ m ro U
n a E E ,Y O N t
vi a m +., +• m +, .
N m a
O s Q a c .� u t c 3
E - c c a s c v m a E
LL o c ro o E + E c E m
w. +F+ in C •'^ a C E a u O O ba
+ 7 op
Q c p — E Q 0 n ro c
CL O
ri U u° m m ou w u .E O a
a.,
u
a co
Y O v
O a+ u a a a + p W
a s , > Q o E o v °c° c + a o O
> E m o a a +� o a a m +, _ ro
ri CU OT O m M cu °C N pTp O rio aA N E � a! v ~ of O U
CU _ C _0 In 7 T a +� O C 'O O K m
+ Q ra c Q a p rn + a a c a T. � c 2 c ra
cu
rn C �_^ a E ro Y 4- 3 E +-• a E ._ o , ` — >
0) 'c a w a a Q c +. c O _ +� 'C a w ra a O
C N + o a +� p u a v u ro m U E ii c D u H u
LL E Y a E o a u E E Q v Q Q a a v a w o Q
ro O u L ra L E 'O w O u a aU•+ C +U•° -O +�.+ C > O +a+
T ra 3 ro ° o .a 2 m f0 � v � °A a Q-0 o Q c a � ° ro m Q
CL E Q 3 E c to ° rco > +� rco O c 'ao o °' p a a •+�
L a C a a a 6 O- •= a = a +�+ a E Q O Q .— W
O. rn � ra cc > c ca a 0 u rn Q V) Q ra Q O Q a W
LA L
�••� In L
!n
in v cr co E O a p
f0 a2S N c `F Q R E N .y,,0—
O •a p aA i U E L L a i c c O
Cl.
m v Cr � "O .a U L v O. Q a••� Q `� m O
cc � C > C �, Q Q O_ a L1 Q >- p_'} Q U
_ i a a•+ ra a O-
L - Q U of rn LL w U
LL
O T
U
u L AC a
N O o m v v a a � _ `n �
CL a s ' a n
w
41 a
L �
f6 �
O �n
OJ 06
,u in + -O Ln
L ` C _0 - cu C f6
d Y C a 0 ro -O L ra +T+
cu m-p E _ — 0 N L i O N
� s �-� o v ° T M a v u E u o
u
4J a ? a 1 c o aa) o '� � c � - � � > E L
- tw u u ro `u — a o ±
V Ln C a ra ro raj In n OD ra vi to + '�
N _ - .5;U L ol C C O T C >, C
}, a n c Q 3 c a 'L i > O a) u c
u a O_ O �, a a u i L '+� V1 O M _T
C c aca + V a C E c 'n � + Ou rua r'o a a a
L U 'a.+ 7 a +a) a) w= 7 � 0 3 L a U � N E C > ++ a
7 ra C ro fa C +' ++ LJ C W O U ,C >
co -o c N ro co .� ro o E o a 3 m E a m :+' ra
M c ra c E CL c c E no U p a u an p O
L v o E v U m (D av cc O Q Q a-
u 3 .E
O a
U -a
+.A
L m m Y
O ai rn rn
Q o ra C
Q r^ a, s O
m O ++
N o > E
a
00 u O `'
u
N 3 O Ln o CL C
c0 w
to
w O- m m
O H _
Ur W r-I
197
4 >
Y i
cu
C
7 C � E
00 - E m u m \ E E _._.
(� dD 0 L
L - 7 a v m C 0 Ou
U C CA C
0�0 in E C - "O p *,
.� Eu a � � C E m
1� al m C 'i=
pJ ri � V) ro O i CO +�
C O T - > ++ O
O N vi al al O 0 � C C C a)
U
y ur +� > m u V) E E E aEi
E p a m 'u v a, T v to
_ m
Co o °- , u v a a p a on
w 3 u Q H w Ow w E E vi a aci
Y
u
4/ Y
V L
C -p -c U 0 O
a o c c c ^ L an 3
m m O v, (u + c n
e v +� + w O 'c v v u
n v � C O C O u m u '- m c C O
'i °' a1 — a1 aJ = m �^ m p ? T w vi
�o c a E N E �' r > +� +� L -a
N :t a E 7 aJ O L C .� "a a a) Y m O i 7 C (NO vi
C } U p m O ' c m m p ,� O ra N = O •— E O
C) ai
N 3 X al 'O O > i a m
LL 7 '�^ O +O+ C '^ ri w C \ .+� '++ N 'a U O a > v C u a 'm
C C m U p u m
L C — m 'O '; N X - O ±' p 0
•+, E a O O N N O vi u m aJ m u a N '5 �' Q rOO
12 w
�1 p0 O 'c > N Q 'n O Y Q m U 'O M m N ++ O
d U w m w a D o U U a a w Ow rpo E D E 3 E m w c E
L ..... .. ..... .
vii d 0 O TO
tmi� Gl T C O C C c- N m N
u aJ
0 L L � (u m L a) a) : i p p w p a) E
O a c � v i L E E Q o � o
f6 al O E > O O N m +� Q vOi Q C Q C a! e T
L a v 0. a) s ooC ° O a o
U Q
LL-
co N O
y B +�
r t
m
O O m 'a V) .1
d a ` a 66 a
a Q d
-� 0) p
N a oc u
L. 4-
m m
V) E E p >
Q + !-
GJ 06 m a
i = m O O m c
d ±� o ao +� E
c a m c r9 n c
ami u a c a, o o E a m E
_ to c ai c + +� L .� In ou v
p u m 0 ap m *' a 00
_0 u 41 u a1 p
C 3 > 41 ±� }' m O T O O a1
fD a o o E do c u co
v1 a `u u E c ro m a > E c v
O +�
C c Ow E _0 a' v v) a) •N E o
t C a1 al C 'i E C u O Y 0
� 0 +� a1 L � m p u 01 to O � ra i m C
i v 3 E +' p °c° o ,c u a m
ruo a i 'ro a>i aci aci a- � 3 M O N
0 a w a 3 a +`� �' or O �' (v > co
U M
L m N
O rn O r-
Q m (C VI O C
Q _
t 4,
7 m Z O r 4J N fC a+
N M u C > C E u f0
O d 7
M to u £ 00 0. 4-
O inn 0 E ba M kn
w a u 00) 4, 0 3
O �
w N
198
a�i 02 o
76 c ra
oob u v "
LA E a1
3 � Q Q
L •7 aj
M (6 c Q
Y
00 C
a,
En a, v E
N ri� > _ C Q
C i p 7
r p tV v w v
ca C a s
Q U U v1
Q1
C
0
v +�
a v m .r
E v ' "
Lo o" w coo
CA Q
-01 U v
N -0 -1 v 06 D
M � ^ C
4J - En
r ro E 5
CL m
m ��
c Q a
CL
a Q 3 in Q w u
V)
m In
d
m c
0
3 '�• v
cu
M 0 a W
°J cu_ E lu
ar c
f6 oC oc � _ :3 m N a
L U Ln D .0
.......... .... ..
N O O m m
C a w a U
L m
CL
Pa-W -
t.! _•a U C
2r r w E
a) ? v
a
m c Q c v
T a a)
_ V C 6
E L v "cu m E
d 3 v .a
C ro
C i al a) 6 .
Q. O OC C9 w
0 v
t
O a m
CL
m C C N 7
N t', c
y m v+
N m G N a m t'
Q
f6 N W m i
O N
U w M
199
i -p 3 c w
o c 0 n
a, o ° E E
Qj
c c .c u r0
N' OD -a a) C a) N E 0o U1 �n Oa
N •C O p .c tc0 u o '^ N tea O O 0 ° u O
u, ri C bcA Q n ai C c 3 ra
v a1 �c _ra cO a 0 C E o 3 i C r0 s r>c a O C
U
X O
00 u aJ w > O a 5� ° O aJ i CU o
_4 0 0 N O E 7 Q p u al
a1 U E al i C E O O O
of � O_ O t Ql S > m C O a-+ '*' aJ vi
v u o rE�o v o°'n E 3 o u �, Q u > c ai rc,0 v a a� u c �c — m ^ E Z3 E °
> o v +� ° v
v a 6- 3 2 E a O ° v .E aa) a co
u
u .
d
c }
ai ° aci ai
a N V; a) v p i � o f
u cu a! — - 7 d +' vi O 'D *—' a) u
u a1 N al }, m O cu 'i u
ei Z3 vii C •`— Yn >- O a1 -0 •v � u o aJ
p a1 — — a a1 O
O N 0 ^ m O- V C C ^ Q p m 11 Q p ` a Q-
+, O u N y c .� ra to v p c0 m u ro a) u >_W to� >- c aci c E c b c u c ° + > aU— +' u ca a
O LL �° ODE +° ° v v o OD N " N u `+°
= 7 ar cu
C v7 O O 7 C a'' U in QJ
E v V) v a 3 u v Dc N
L^ o o a>i w p oc o O M c n3 ro ° ra c o
w u m u u Y u 3 a u aV E
ro
u (U � i v
t
o `
C 7
ro 6 } p pO to 0 E o E o f
p o -- ± — o
ro
m
01 O c O a-+ co ` a) ° N u N 0' 0 c0 N �" ,+� O
Q1 3 L I w u vi Q _ ♦ 2 t �n 3 H LL u i �n v1 ❑-
a•+ 7
LL 0! 4) N ro
Y Y D O ` J
LO � Q a = ru v s 2 2
o-_ ,�/Joo
A p c to u� OCD v
L O
aJ 01 Y O v >
c0 ns
0 LO c a `a °—' m ° cca u M E a `o > - 3 .
O �^ u Q v v .N a' `D v p o a) 3 3 o v v s
C 3 c + a) v u
ai w ca
W .a' o N a o v ra E Oo
E c f0 `�
ro bA +� on � a) oL o •E a) u o p c o
U a� " o a >. v '� > �' m E v E m ° E M 'N a
O v Q a, o Y c +, v v p u v y r E o ° 'c E
O 1A > C n +� U c Y c a VT' aci � a b4 v
C ns O to
ro aJ L V fa O a) C
U V II. >• aJ }, a1 U C U C ++ b0 C
o u E > a o c > t� N v E S >
y v .� .o o o .3 •c v E u ra
� L C U i aJ O_ O- j-,+ U vi (U � a) 6- , O m
0 3 i v a) o •L o -0 c � E o 0 ° v v
Q H v �, p p_ n3 a U Q co s _ u _ Q 3 _ s a o
O a _ .
N E E
L• m — c a%
Q O ro r ro oo v, t+ ,m '^ ro M
u � -O C 0 o +� C +, @ in w
ro c > ro - 3 c W i ro a 6 ro y t ro
ro t y- t W
o c a .c b o N E ax, a, 04 _ `o
�, L a, r-
.0
Y Q V 7 M C 01 to V y ro L of
ro O ro a ++ v, v
iv w m O ° E v a vii a 0 ° a in H 3
O E _
200
O_
7 C +(3) U-0
OA OA V m
00 O C O -
Q It E
y L C
N UJ C f6 pp
v > O O_ 41
00 0 O
~ T C a a2 u ro O
• of r� Al— T N O- O.
0 4J ei — U L m
t, C O U ° °_
G1 s0+ N w Q O u "O ` vi u
C
OC =O M GA O OA L +--' W
to T > T '- to ° U M M n°o
CL a v
g v U o u U O_ O cc O
a+
u
u ai
O _0 v + m
buo O T N 0 Y ° m O
C 1� u N L -O Y
U O
J v �_ v v
cu E u 'O O' C U1 : In f+ C L OA
} +' C U CA \ of W C O Q •� O ++
U O N
`~ LL .� O E ate• U N O O v ° (O VI
U v
1 ++ ° -O U1 v m N L7 2 Q pp N .y Q
1 — O U a M cl� O
Gl
aj
GJ
Ln C
C u N O L 'v
a. O N V ° O
0 c:N Y E CO CA � 00 OA
d' 6 3 = N C 'p d �
`^ 2! O a u u
on LL U LL Q a a Q m u c
c -
+.+ l6 GJ u
C: d v
a1 Q vi T
CL C a a a
O a .rr
C a+ v � ro
W ° O Y
_0 ++ 4,= ro
O {„ O c -0 a)
f0 ' m -a m
v v u a E -0 v
`
c '
CL
41 U
7 u > v > n
T y 'm +�+ C N T O
D Y�1 m m N O OA )
_ v
° m v Ln v .�
Y Y �+ U U Q u N cu
•� U N (9 C Ll �O v ~ u
O_ E C C \ �n f`0 U i cu
y N , C N (O " co
• y > � Q O Q +O+ v+'i L j,
v •?
v
Q a� 'O
C N
_O y � p
7 4-
Ln y " O
c 41
Q p > fA co
u u E
O N
C
O 0 T
7 41
fB N U _^
O tA
W ri
201
• � � Q1
> bD
cri
O U U $ 0
c i O L L 2
�+ o0 0 (O O i m _
pv o v +� N N
= t T C 0 ns
Q
to co c ra
C O � O ` Q N Y
0 T O
m N L w +' > to .0 a1 i i u C
�n a " E f6 o s .� a E o ° o -0 c co
a) E a C C ro ra a) cLO O
C Ln a ° : oo cu N a CO O Q o u o
Qa,
° } v E
v D ELL T a V a)+� v
ns
bo ^ O a Q cLo E w >
c E o V)
C 0 o ro L c 2 v D a u m m
�o 41 o N '° o LL u 3 �' a,
++ O Q L L- Q �) al U O O E
C N u o Cl- OQ E } Q n3
C a) ^ fa C L U i u CL
OJ E c ? u Q E 3 o v, E
aD as m ai v Y v o ai c 3
EL v m �; o a 0 c o v T
V) H w m K v z v>i CJ
u N
IA
fa
Q u d O +�+ v N O co
3 a N — O, Y .0 CCy,� E ++ ul �+ C E
C N Q 7 CL ro Q U >O C O al i] v O a C U Q ;0 v
oac v E Q ° v °' ° oc f6Q " a E a 3 E o a
T LL U m LL Z a a LL Q C) J Ln � 0 C � Q L �
i+
C
aJ
u as t
B O
o- a,
al G N M U LL p
>' a W)
N
tA
oc
o a o
C �G' 'O L- C
3 >— E E o o `) M a, f 0 ate'
a, u O w m o v E °1 o m 0- E N LA
0 a' Q Ln a) CC� CU o w 3 V) v L n u c
C > > u c O o v �o v o a ai a a' •1 o Q v
L) o � �+ 0 E v u � Q E
(U io Q c 0 v o c v �+ a 0 v E �_ " -0 + a bD
ro of u L i -0 � � al fa .� C O Q- C O-
p 3 m to � 3 _0 m o C aci $ E °_ v w
L aJ
♦"� > 7 •C by fC L •C N O L f0 E w bD [L fb
u O Q u_ p u al in E T N i ro
in
=
'N > Y L CU
E _ 0 3 :3 a v E u v, 3 aj Q E m E � _ a
1V O OTD H
c > o E
u p u ai
t 4j a. O C a/
a0+ W `� u 4L = in
++ a!
v r0+ G 3
tdl w a� +' w a c >
Q N
W �••i N
202
V)
v v v
E O U u ho
O` ti
C `� 7 io .O a >
a+ Ci-
ao a L- n
O L co E a, c -0 cv
4L+ Y al
a
00 v v w
,F m
p u a) u O p
c
C O 41 v
•V O N E �n al 5 bf
m y U- N vOi v 'C p '�
Ln — m E E E t m
�
J i a a) -O i
M Q Q O-
•� u
O
O O C
m
at_+ d pD u t v
c ^ v av
tko O _0 c 3 +J
c c n a) _0 v,
bD
c m — o Q c
v _
C N N C O +�_+ Lu m H GU
m LL 'o _0 u 3 -C v '3 0
L D1 of a� ,� aJ u aJ = O
L � 7
Q O u O u 2 O ,0 m 0 ai
T N x 0 u al E m a1 N N v U m U
LL Ln V) W Ln F— Of a > K - H CO in
u c
0 Ln eL+
o
u v
CL
0 6 as
0 0 CL cu
Q � a Q
+� v CL v
m occ Q c a c
a LA
� w H
C
a
cu
Ln
u m `
N C 1 cz V) C
o m 06 n
as L L a
41 y m
41
oc a M
u -
v
c °
he 06 +- O
3 v se °�' v o N -0 ov
vii u y m z = L m ? ? c c
m N LV v m u •V to m OD
O *_' 0 w a -O 4 c p C \ Q O N c
m o it O aJ N
C v 0 •� c o O M c v
u �v Q v o 'I aci m v v a
a ai a) o +' a) y ° E Ln °' m O
f"" L c L a Y '� °Q c v m u v y E c7
O u o v °D v ) E cco o v -0 o v
3 v L v o v to c n c v v E
c c °' E t •c a
_ u c a cu LL
cl ,F 0 'u m U w '� m u m � v a
r-
0
rL a O v> > -o E a vi a >
N 41
O E > r in
O 41 0 L-
in � L �
S2 cu j vii E C m +t+ - L-
++ N
a N p E v O ++ 7
O � � 41 A
M a) ,� m 4)
Ln O CL 3 N O O- E
�C1 (U O .E -v vii ° r
O %A
W M
203
a1 Y Y Y Y Y Y
L
u a1 L L
�•' 3 C C C C > U U m U U U U O O
CL LJ N w C C C C > ' }' 06
D 4 4= w a U w Ci U U d [t d U U U V J J
(2) a)
N ra m
N c \ a) 0 t' L u `1
C U U
Ln
I��/• U u c '� Q1 .� E O ++
V l C
`–° - m E m ° o v 3 v o 0
a) a) Q Q u O C 7 ro �^ = o in
C vi
u U oU a o 0 °,`' o a v ate) Q Q
c
a s m o � ° o nz -0 a, 3 E E
E E Q o o •E O a > c v v o a u o 0 0
V/ U U E e-i O i •N ate-+
L o 0 oU n3 I E o rTO °
ro
3 M u 3 ra cu .`o_ v " v v CU
O W O O c al U +� L -O a) a) C a) N N a) a) > Q 10 o vV �•• T
O ++ X N o >. C U U C a a) u u p O- C
° � O O n c I m C Y C N u C C (� EO E i O O L O O
±� +� c •c 0- L C C -0 QJ •� O •m vii a) C n3 f6 C u E p `
3 3 n3 E +� o L s Q 3 a ro u •`-° Q Q v v o v L L
O C) 0_ T E o E -0 C: 0_ E E Q o t a, u 0 3 of 0i aOi
o -4 o E o 0 O o + _0 0 n _0 T T
•� 7 7 a1 C a) •vi U U .Ln E 0 U U al r-I N • C
_0 -O o C L U o o }' 06 ^ , in a1 p O a1 a)
' v E Z, u M o r o � o o 0 _0 -0 Ln u u m v
ro 0
oo tD (D rn u) Lnn w o� w Q rn oq of D ac) a -0 Q -C O -0° o U U
W v
E
m :t2 V y
T
E `° €
_u ++ ++ �q
cu
o
O E 0 v E 0 0
L v a) u ai ',n +� 0
O Ci +� L 3 ,n u a1
O O m O Q 6 N �_ c
L > ro O E N m E i •+C_.+ U '00
L= LL N Q 2 ° � L > _ o c b
•c a a ` n7 Y CO c 3 L a) C L O
m a u s a, N E Q) a°1i +°
Q u 3 c v 0 o p y u E u E c v -0 E J
n C t
LL W C O ,,n °- 0 U a) O_ O_ m •u O L c
v v E a, ° '0 u .u' '0 a) o3 o a m m Y 3 ar -0 L
E E `^ E > — a •`L, 3 � u 0n L to U n a � 7 � 0
Y *' a Q 'n a) 0 ro of c c a1 C a1 *' u C ° 06 *' C
H a1 +' .o E a v ` c u a) =o v c E a) v u
'O a) p ra u L Q O
c c ° ° E ° > ° c Q 0n Y Q ro ° o 0
N o o 0 a`, o n3 �, o c m ca u ° *' U v �, > 0
�}� 0 0_ 0_ E v o �« 3 0 U t' _ v o c ai L O C E n3
af � +� E V E m ° ac) E u E E u a E 0°1,0 o Y Q o 0
L v N m m v c `n v c E v Y p U E _0 -0 -0
bA c LL1 -0 ° v a) v — f 6 +, ro a1 .n
ice+ a1 ->- '^ 7 vi
pip H H Q v~i w v fD E o ra L ` bca ° 3 > +� m °u n
• • C GD CD al OD GO � O ppp ° � C o i c 'N C N O d to
X E W ro t`o to O 0 C ai m C O c 7 E O T) a) 'E •E E \ u •U 7 7
t' N N O aJ Q of T a1 +� C L vi OD oD E U > 7 ai E �n CL C C
• m O� > > > v ra E > p o — 0 c v v c ° v *' a p 0
a O Q Q \ Q o' v H H Q F– E Q H W of cc fl aL o,- n 3 O a U m LL a Q Q
r U
CL
W IN
v' N
CL L a a1 T a1
� E va a
O v v c ro ro a)
++ E Q) a) 0 E ar
N 'y a1 C a) C C a a) a
O a) E O E v M -0 U E
U +� >
co a1 n3 O
U Q Q Q O_ bO o N , d
N -O E -o �O �O -0
a) O a) a)
U w E w
O .± v a) u o v u a)
Y WC L LL a Q .E E Q
204
al N 0 b
m
U L U L >`\ U L aJ ro >• >•
al -0 -0 W r0 a1 f6 �-' D a1 r0 L C L L L L O D Cr Dr cc Y Y --
0 Dc a Dc a U a 3 oc a LL r� rr- w w v= r= a a = _ = u rF- u
r-A
L O L U
c u O O
° fO m �-? o _0 ° w ar
C U1 O L U tLo
u al 'C u a) cr .- Y u C O N rC
bD
t > V) L E al tLo VV) v u CL C
\ -p O o\° Q
otS al +' rC
CL N N vi - a) o\° i C Q U pp _� N
V) Y VI Y a1 V) O 7 VI X 4- rp Y T
N > m o' -0 •� E a) O vii 7 u C Y O
L Y L � L L >• �• L a) .L (� Q ro C 'L O V)
O Y al C -a 7 Q
U rub O u 41 0 o � u v � 0 L CD u al ¢ � � �
\ Y .0 O L V) L Y C
ai a) v L " Ln o o v o v o2S °1 3 c °°1° v v u u Q E °� v v
E al ° L
c ro .� o V) •� Q c c 4- _ u u C C v c V u c
u .F a) U Y > O a1 u G1 4° N O ° N a1 c c m m F- c
41 ro a1 ? c L ro � ro ro Q Q m v C L
.O ..p al _ '0 L O Q Q N aJ ut
E ro
s c N E O 3 Y aYi s a, L a, rn m t E E o o O v m
Y
)n u, O 7 in Ln .'- E .'^ c Yn v) •'n a) O O D U L Q ut c c Q O
L L L N C p- C - �p O ?' ± U U p N N
a) 7 p r0 ro Q ?� ro OD \ o\° O O ° Q > c O > O °
Y Y CA > O 4— U Y U Y VI Y C
C 00L 0 L
O W W O T W W W 01 01 O O 00 Ln w 0 01
N M O r4 00
4— V)
O t Y )n
C O C •@ fr0
ro O u -0
E = E v
Y o E M p c
Y u
0
C
O u u u t 4 3
o
-0 F o _ 3 o m o
Y o
Y m O v - m c = O
u dD v +� Q a1 O t bD 2 CL Uo
U V)u Q m Q _> f° E D 3 oD .E •O
L " in oD Co O o - 'o .c rLo C
2 _C C O a+ f0 '� C _0 u N Y •� F- rLa
m N m C m u ¢ L N p_ Y O Y
Y Y !? •° c -0 m E 06 L^i aci
E Y c 'a.� G. N p u v 3 0 Y E
E p C -C — u c L
ro o2f c o a U o c 3 v `c o E °OL v
E " V a) Q v1 >
C vi 7 p `1 a_ ¢ ut CU
fC al p _ d 3 a d' C U o a) L L" m v w
'� o N o n u i 3 v v a>i " a
Q _ _° a m a c c V\i v Y„ a LPL * v o ° u
Y, L - m .E v � v > aaii
!E u co 0 a)u a1 L a1 ra r0 )n )n Y > L Q — r- 4— 4— iE O N ra
a - - ° m c v m (D f0 � o o o v w 0 t 3 Q c )
N E E Y p O L v L Q p c c aI aJ i , E O 3 a1 E 4— 4-
�, O C O C Q n O �, O u c c c c c p L ¢ v ar C W O O
C C a) L ut ¢ ¢
E t 0) ut v) L' pM — — = W U ra `^+ 4- 4- O rpif a1 W
E (D 3 v a>i `° �- is io a a _ � `° c 3 ` o 0 o m -0 -0
t C " C o -D ��- v 025 a, ) v E E m E c cu > 0 0 0 E E
c -0 C c o o > > > o o o m c o Ln o c 0
M ¢ w oc a v rn Y �. ¢ O O D U H Z ¢ v 0 00 01 r-I c Z Z
C • • • • • • • • • • • r • • • • Qc a • • • • •
fp C
N W
U
a
L
E
cu
cv V Q
E E O v a' (A >
m V E o Y 0
C
Q t � aci c
ai _0 a) r o c O E to
0
c y > u
Y U L/1 H rn OOC H rn
205
v
v
> > -O >, >, tip
Co O� D vii u u
06 OU OU :t N m GUJ m C C d
0 d d d d d W W u0: a G= d 4� y 4= w l0
N
N
3 O m
In ut
'O _0 C OJ
N +'
G1 w w E t Ou UO
++ ++ u N 'D O O
-a C C N a N -0 O E
Qj -a u
u u u O O m +O+ C
u ` , v M a O
p p -0 > o\°\° N 'O ~
O O L U-
0 O1 N Ol N U1 N N O C L L -j 1] L ++ O
C C C C C C E T V Q a..Q -O ut 3 �•+
LO.1 fC 2 T T E2 � vOi U O N O N w O_ o
0 E E E E E -0 -0 Q o u m v W .m O a
O �' 5; O N
00000 V u u u u u vt ut ut N O o N C
h o 0 0 0 o c"OO m m fC-O T +�.� N O E o
•� O O O O O In In V)i O
C c1 -4 -4 -1 -1 w w W CC Cr..
Ol
O_
T
OJ ++
L
>
> >`` m
L
O1 f0 U 7 -0
L o w
U v T L A
C L T T L vt O
cu m m > E O
Z) F
O N Z) 0) m
6• +' C Od
c C 00 f0 W
F O c ro O
-0 L � N ; a ' a
v *' v Y 0 rEo CL
3 _ L ti v
,w m T OL " N O c O- .
T '� O_ m U Q N Q O
7 t L cu YO C 'o
QcI .O C C u _c to
0) > O L > C
C Y T — u
C 3 ^ �c >� n
V O Fo v3, � `L° c `L° ` OU m O C C
L U ° o E " o -a
> ' U u C
d = > N '�, m > �' O C = m N
CL ai ut
C i — N L O O O O O
N u c u O Ol Q O -O w
E >
E L M L ° ° E +� +� C - .Y Fu E
CL aai T x v v 0 0 0 0 LO o o =
to l.0 W a a S u u u H n. d H Z
• • • • • • • • • • • • s r
L
N
L
� C
C H
Q LA
0
> U
4J V)
Y LL
206
City of El Segundo — Meeting Summary
November 7, 2016—Council Working Session
PARTICIPANTS
Elected Officials Appointed&Department Heads Guests
Greg Carpenter,City Manager
Suzanne Fuentes,Mayor David King,Assistant City Attorney
Drew Boyles,Mayor Pro Tern
Michael Dugan,Council Member Joseph Lillio,Finance
Carol Pirsztuk,Council Member Chief Chris Donovan,Fire Sara A.Peterson,Management Consultant
Dr.Don Brann,Council Member Martha Dijkstra,Human Resources El Segundo TV
Debra Brighton, Library Services Members of the Public
Tracy Weaver,City Clerk Sam Lee, Planning&Building Safety
Crista Binder,City Treasurer Chief Mitch Tavera, Police
Ken Berkman,Public Works
Meredith Petit, Recreation&Parks
AGENDA
Introduction
Confirm Overall Direction& Document Approach
Discuss Draft Goals,Objectives&Activities
• Are we comfortable with the direction of each?
• Are we comfortable with the components proposed for the goal areas?
• Are there any questions to answer or gaps to fill?
o What sort of performance indicators is the Council interested in seeing for each goal area?
Wrap Up& Next Steps
SUMMARY
Since this meeting was largely to work through the emerging plan document, this summary presents the broad feedback
received rather than detailed edits. Details from the discussion will be integrated into the plan document for review.
Feedback re the Overall Direction & Document
The Council expressed their appreciation for the work done to date and direction of the plan while offering the following
to guide staff in completing the document.
• Review all items to ask if we are setting the bar high enough. In doing so,set specific measurement targets.
• Review all items for active versus passive statements,and bring performance indicators into the document body.
• Roll tactics up into comprehensive strategy statements that fill the space between 50,000 feet and the day-to-
day work of the City.
Feedback re Customer Service & Engagement Goal
Again,the Council approved of the direction for this goal area with suggestions that:
• The strategies should address not only virtual customer service but also in-person for a more balanced approach.
• Both the plan and department heads in carrying it out it should embed a substantial process early on in
implementation to define the"El Segundo customer experience." Doing so will result in more intentional data
Page 1 of 3
207
collection, measurement, improvement efforts,etc. This process should include discussions about the City's
hours of business, response times, etc.
• The plan should incorporate performance indicators related to:
• Satisfaction levels for both residents and businesses;
• Understanding customer feedback(good and bad)by category;and
• Use of new systems(e.g., percent of transactions completed online versus manually).
Feedback re Safe & Prepared City Goal
Council suggestions here included the following:
• There should be a discussion of how the City will reach the community re safety and preparation, especially East
of Sepulveda, and how it will communicate/coordinate this work internally.
• The plan should incorporate performance indicators related to:
• Crime rates,
• Response times,and
• Insurance incidents and claim costs.
• The Fire Chief also mentioned the development of a disaster"readiness"score and tracking of CERT-trained
residents over time as possible performance indicators.
Feedback re Choice Employer & Work Force Goal
Council suggestions here included the following:
• Make a direct link between this goal and the first(customer service and engagement)since success for the first is
dependent upon success here.
• Make sure the strategies include a culture that nurtures improvement,innovation, and collaboration.
• The plan should incorporate performance indicators related to:
• Some form of external rating(e.g.,Glassdoor);
• Time to hire,which may vary by department because of external requirements(e.g., police);
• Promotions from within(evidence of staff development and succession planning);and
• Workers compensation and time between incidents or type of incidents.
Feedback re Infrastructure & Environment Goal
Council suggestions here included the following:
• This goal area should include a commitment to preventive maintenance,effective use of new facilities, longer-
term projections re what the City should be developing,and fiscal strategies to maintain momentum.
• The plan should incorporate performance indicators related to:
• Satisfaction levels for both residents and businesses re quality of infrastructure;
• Utilization of equipment;and
• Links to the indicators for other goals since City infrastructure is a means to arrive at other City goals.
Feedback re Technology Goal
Council suggestions here included the following:
• Ensure that the plan is not simply a series of projects and upgrades but that it is also about the integration of
technology across the City,the integration of systems with each other,and the centralization of information.
• The plan should incorporate performance indicators related to:
• Integration of online versus manual systems,and
• Perceptions of the City's use of technology given its business base.
Page 2 of 3
208
Feedback re Other Plan Elements
What is Missing?
After the Council discussed each goal as presented,they were asked:"what is missing?" In response,Council discussed
fiscal sustainability, economic development,and environmental sustainability as possible goals. They decided to amend
the infrastructure goal to include stewardship of the environment. They agreed that the plan should add a fiscal goal
focused on planning ahead,stewardship of funds,and transparency. They also felt that the economic development
elements included in the current draft should be paired with fiscal goals.
Reporting
Before closing the meeting,staff and Council discussed preliminary guidelines for reporting process toward Strategic Plan
goals. They agreed on:
• Monthly updates by goal;
• Quarterly reports assessing progress as green (on target),yellow(slowed),or red (on hold or interrupted);and
* Ongoing data transparency at the department level.
The Council reiterated that they are not interested in data for the sake of data or for creating work/reports that detract
from the goals themselves or result in mission creep. Rather they are interested in trends that will help them to make
better, more strategic decisions.
NEXT STEPS
Staff will continue work refine the plan per Council's feedback,select key performance indicators, begin planning for
reports to the City Council, and begin work on instruments to gather customer feedback.
City Council will receive a revised document for review in December.
Page 3 of 3
209
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action to award a standard Public Works Contract to Ayus and
Co., Inc. for the Fire Station 1 Men's Bathroom Improvement Project. Project No. PW 17-
08. (Fiscal Impact: $57,805)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public Works Contract in a form
approved by the City Attorney with Ayus and Co., Inc. in the amount of$52,550.00
and authorize an additional $5,255.00 for construction related contingencies,
2. Authorize to transfer $40,000 from account #301-400-8208-8706 (Seismic Early
Warning System)to account#301-400-8201-8707 (Fire Department Upgrades)
3. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
Protest Letter from R. Dependable Const Inc., dated January 26, 2017
City Response to Protest Letter, dated February 1, 2017
FISCAL IMPACT: Included in the adopted budget
Amount Budgeted: $438,426 for Various Fire Department Upgrades
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): $40,000 from 301-400-8201-8707 (Fire Dept. Upgrades)
$17,805 from 405-400-0000-6215 (Facilities Repairs &
Maintenance)
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 4 Develop Quality Infrastructure and Technology
Objective: 1 City infrastructure is well maintained
Goal: 3 Develop as a Choice Employer & Workforce
Objective: 4 The City has an inspired, engaged workforce
ORIGINATED BY: Cheryl Ebert, Senior Civil Engineer 6j
REVIEWED BY: Ken Berkman, Interim Public Works Director"
Chris Donovan,Fire Chief''
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
10
210
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
The men's bathroom in Fire Station#1's dormitory has not been upgraded since it was constructed
in the 1980's. Due to frequent plumbing issues and poor condition of the wall, floors, and shower
tiles, the bathroom improvement was identified as one of the top priorities among various fire
department upgrades. The funding for the project was anticipated to come from the adopted FY
2015-16 budget as part of the ongoing projects. However, due to other fire station upgrades
including the Fire Department Roof Replacement Project (PW 15-18) and the Kitchen
Improvement Project (PW 17-06), there is a budget shortfall of$40,000. To cover the shortfall,
staff has identified that the seismic early warning system can be eliminated since the proposed
apparatus bay doors will be upgraded from rolling doors to bi-folded doors and will provide a
quicker response time, as well as the ability to manually open the bay doors in the event of an
earthquake, thereby making the seismic early warning system unnecessary.
On December 20, 2016, the City Council adopted the plans and specification for Project No. PW
17-08, Fire Station 1 Men's Bathroom Improvement Project, and authorized staff to advertise for
receipt of construction bids. On January 24, 2017, the City Clerk received and opened four (4)
bids as follows:
1. Ayus and Co., Inc. $52,550.00
2. The Stone Collector $84,000.00
3. CTG Construction, Inc. $78,070.00
4. R Dependable Const Inc. $83,180.00
The lowest responsive and responsible bidder is Ayus and Co., Inc. (Ayus). Staff checked the
Contractor's license status and references, and found Ayus has satisfactorily met the City's
requirements and has successfully completed similar projects for other public agencies.
A protest against Ayus was received on January 30, 2017. After review of the protest in
cooperation with the City Attorney's Office and clarification from Ayus, staff concluded that Ayus
remains the lowest responsive and responsible bidder. The protest and City response letters are
attached.
Staff respectfully recommends that City Council authorize the City Manager to execute a standard
Public Works Contract in a form approved by the City Attorney with Ayus in the amount of
$52,550.00, and authorize an additional $5,255.00 for construction related contingencies.
Construction is slated to commence in April and be completed in May 2017.
211
DEPENDABLE CDNBT INC
1019w. 3wo R
- 6AN 0[RNAIIDIND. CA 9'1410
JANUARY 26,2017
CITY OF EL SEGUNDO
RE:BID PROTEST PROJECT:MEN'S BATHROOM IMPROVEMENTS
BID:PW 17-08
Bid Datel/25/2017
Pertaining to the above noted project which bid on January 25 2017,R Dependable Const.Inc.is
Protesting the bid of the apparent low bidder as being non-responsive for the following reasons.
Ayus&Co Inc.
1. Per Notice Inviting bids
Note that the Proiect is subiect to compliance manitorino and enforcement by the
California Department of Industrial Relations.Pursuant to California law, the City must
find bids faifina to comply with all applicable Labor Code requirements includinq, without
limitation, tabor Code 441725.5 and 1771.4. to be non-responsive.
Ayus&Co.Inc.subcontractor listed Caseworx Inc.License#663046 is not currently registered
with DIR at the time of bid (see Attachment A)
This makes R Dependable Const.Inc.the lowest responsible bidder
1Ct7t�P.M a IM Y'
President
212
1/26/2017 California Department of Industrial Relations-Contact DIR
ATTACHMENT A
&r Go to Search
Home Labor Law Cal/OSHA-Safety&Health Workers'Comp Self Insurance Apprenticeship Director's Office Boards
Public Works
Public Works Contractor (PWC) Registration Search
This is a listing ofcurrentand active PWC registrations pursuantto Division 2,Part7,Chapter 1(commencing with section 1720 ofthe Calffomia Labor Code.)
Enteratleastone search aiteris to displayactive registered public works contractor(s)matching your selections.
Registration Year: Current Fiscal Year 2016117 •
PWC Registration Number: example: 1234567890
Contractor Legal Name: example:ABC COMPANY Contractor License Lookup
License Number. ;663046
County: Select County •
I
Search Results
No active registered contractors to display.If the contractor name you searched for does not appear,the registration may have expired.
Fired registrations may be viewed by selecting"renew"on the registration page and searching again using the PWC Registration Number
or Contractor Legal Name.
It is also possible that the contractor's registration is active and you simply need to modify your search.The best way to search for a specific
contractor is to complete only one of the search criteria,either the PWC Registration Number or the License Number,and to leave the
Contractor Legal Name blank.
v220160101
About DIR Work with Us Learn More
Who we are Licensing,registrations,certifications&permits Site Map
DIR Divisions, Boards&Commissions Notification of activies Frequently Asked Questions
Contact DIR Public Records Act Jobs at DIR
Conditions of Use Privacy Policy Disclaimer Disability accommodation Site Help
Copyright 02015 State of California
httpsJ/efiling dir.ca.gov/PWCR/Search.acflon 213 1H
x
R S[Gu N�a�
February 1,2017
Elected oi'ficiais: R.Dependable Const. Inc.
Attn:Rosemary Padilla, President
Mayor
.Suzanne Fuentes, 1019 W. Yd Street
Drew Boyles,
M San Bernardino CA 92410
apor Pro Tmn �
Michael Dugan, Via US Mail and Email to marco(cr�.rduconstinc.corri
Council Member
Carol Pimauk,
Council Member
Dr.Don Brunn, Response to Bid Protest by R Dependable Const.Inc. for Fire Station#1 Men's
Council Mernhcr
Tracy Weaver, Bathroom Improvement Project(PW 17-08)
City Gerk
Cristo Binder,
Gly Treasurer Dear Ms. Padilla,
.appointed officials: In response to the protest letter from R Dependable Constr. Inc. for the Fire Station#1 Kitchen
Greg Carpenter, Improvement Project(PW 17-08),which had a bid opening on January 241h,2017,the City of
City Alnnnger El Segundo has investigated the protest items and has come to the following conclusions:
Alork D.If-sky,
City A norm ry
1. R Dependable Const. Inc.protests that Ayus &Co. Inc. subcontractor listed
Caseworx Inc. (license #663046) and they are not currently registered with DIR at
Department Directors: the time of bid.
Joseph lillia,
Finance
chriFire man, - Citv response: The City of El Segundo recognizes that the contractor listed in the Chif
Mayra llnustnn, "Declaration of Subcontractor's"form is not DIR registered. However, in
Interim Ilumrrn Resources
Dehrn Brighton, accordance with the bid requirements,the prime contractor,Ayus&Co.Inc. listed
Library Services
Som lee, all subconsultants and vendors that will be on the project. Ayus&Co. Inc. has
Planning and
Building.Saft, confirmed that Caseworx is a vendor and is only supplying materials for the project
Mitch ToveC and therefore is not required to be DIR registered. Ayus&Co. Inc, will be installing
Parise Chief q b Y b
Ken Berkman, the materials as part of the work.
Interim Public IVarks
Meredith Petit,
Recreation&Parks
For the reasons set forth above,the City of El Segundo does not find substantial reason to
reject Ayus&Co. Inc. bid. At the February 7th regular Council meeting,staff will recommend
that the City Council award the contract to Ayus &Co. Inc.
www.elseerrndo.ore
ivwn+.elseertlydoblls&resacans Please contact Cheryl Ebert for questions or additional information regarding this project at
cebert@.else2undo.orir or 310-524-2321. We thank you for your interest in the project and
hope that you will continue to monitor the City's website for future contracting opportunities.
Sincerely,
Ken Berkman, P.E.
Interim Public Works Director
350 Main Street, Et Segundo, California 90245-3893
Phone(390) 524-2300
214
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action to award a standard Public Works Contract to Ayus and
Co., Inc. for the Fire Station 1 Kitchen Improvements, Project No. PW 17-06. (Fiscal
Impact: $138,270.00)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public Works Contract in a form
approved by the City Attorney with Ayus and Co., Inc. in the amount of$125,700.00
and authorize an additional $12,570.00 for construction related contingencies;
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
Protest Letter from R. Dependable Const Inc., dated January 26, 2017
City Response to Protest Letter, dated February 1, 2017
FISCAL IMPACT: Included in the adopted budget
Amount Budgeted: $438,426 for Various Fire Department Upgrades
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): $100,700 from 301-400-8201-8707 (Fire Department
Upgrades)
$25,000 from 001-400-3203-4101 (Paramedic Salaries Full
Time)
$12,570 from 405-400-0000-6215 (Facilities Repairs &
Maintenance)
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 4 Develop Quality Infrastructure and Technology
Objective: 1 City infrastructure is well maintained
Goal: 3 Develop as a Choice Employer & Workforce
Objective: 4 The City has an inspired, engaged workforce
ORIGINATED BY: Cheryl Ebert, Senior Civil Engineer C�
REVIEWED BY: Ken Berkman, Interim Public Works Director
Chris Donovan, Fire Chief
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
215
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
Kitchen improvements were identified as one of the top priorities among various Fire Department
upgrades. The funding for this project was included in the adopted FY 2015-16 budget and was
carried over to the FY 2016-17 budget as part of the ongoing projects.
On December 20, 2016, the City Council adopted the plans and specifications the Project and
authorized staff to advertise for construction bids. On January 24, 2017, the City Clerk received
and opened four (4) bids as follows:
1. Ayus and Co., Inc. $125,700.00
2. The Stone Collector $155,900.00
3. CTG Construction, Inc. $229,980.00
4. R Dependable Const Inc. $144,780.00
The lowest responsive and responsible bidder is Ayus and Co., Inc. (Ayus). Staff checked the
Contractor's license status and references, and found Ayus has satisfactorily met the City's
requirements and has successfully completed similar projects for other public agencies.
A protest against Ayus was received on January 30, 2017. After review of the protest in
cooperation with the City Attorney's Office and clarification from Ayus, staff concluded that Ayus
remains the lowest responsive and responsible bidder. The protest and City response letters are
attached.
Capital improvement funds are available for various projects at Fire Station #1, including the
estimated$100,000 for the kitchen remodel,which was prepared several years ago. Due to current
construction costs and the detailed upgrade plans that were not considered when originally
estimating the project, the Fire Department recommends using the upgrades fund and salary
savings within the full-time paramedic fund for this project to make up for the shortfall.
Staff respectfully recommends that City Council authorize the City Manager to execute a standard
Public Works Contract in a form approved by the City Attorney with Ayus in the amount of
$125,700.00, and authorize an additional $12,570.00 for construction related contingencies.
Construction is slated to commence in April and be completed in May 2017.
216
DEPENDABLE CONBT INC
1019w. 3RD fT
BAN BERNARDINO,CA 92410
JANUARY 26,2017
CITY OF EL SEGUNDO
RE:BID PROTEST PROJECT:FIRE STATION#1 KITCHEN IMPROVEMENTS
BID:PW 17-06
Bid Datel/25/2017
Pertaining to the above noted project which bid on January 25 2017,R Dependable Const.Inc.is
Protesting the bid of the apparent low bidder as being non-responsive for the following reasons.
1. Per Asbestos report Section 4.1 RECOMMENTATIONS
When work is nerformed in the vicinity of an asbestos-containina material,the workers
must be informed that the material contains asbestos.Removal of an asbestos-
containino material must be performed by a licensed(Contractor's State License Board)
and registered(CallOSHA)asbestos abatement contractor under the suDervislon of a
Cal/QSHA Certified Asbestos Consultant.
Ayus&Co.Inc.does not hold license and did not list a licensed subcontractor for the removal of(ACM)
Asbestos containing material
2. Per Notice Inviting bids
Note that the Proiect is subiect to compliance monitorina and enforcement by the
California Department of Industrial Relations.Pursuant to California low, the Citv must
find bids failing to comply with all applicable Labor Cade reauirements includina,without
limitation, Labor Cade;441725.5 and 1771.4.to be non-responsive.
Ayus&Co.Inc.subcontractor listed Caseworx Inc.License#663046 is not currently registered
with DIR at the time of bid(see Attachment A)
This makes R Dependable Const.Inc.the lowest responsible bidder
Xade`ewm Pal"&
President
217
1/26/2017 California Department of Industrial Relations-Cordact DIR
ATTACHMENT "A" --ress Room i CDntactDIR i CAgov
04 Go to Search
Home Labor Law CaUOSHA-Safety&Health Workers'Comp Self Insurance Apprenticeship Director's Office Boards
Public Works
Public Works Contractor (PWC) Registration Search
This is a listing ofcumentand active PWC registrations pursuantto Division 2,Part 7,Chapter 1(commencing with section 1720 ofthe California Labor Code.)
Enteratleastone search criteria to displayactive registered public works contractor(s)matching your selections.
Registration Year Curcent Fiscal Year-2016/17 •,
PWC Registration Number: example: 1234567890
Contractor Legal Name: example:ABC COMPANY Contractor License Lookup
License Number: 1563046
County: Select County •
Reset
Search Results
No active registered contractors to display.If the contractor name you searched for does not appear,the registration may have expired.
Expired registrations may be viewed by selecting"renew"on the registration page and searching again using the PWC Registration Number
or Contractor Legal Name.
It is also possible that the contractor's registration is active and you simply need to modify your search.The best way to search for a specific
contractor is to complete only one of the search criteria,either the PWC Registration Number or the License Number,and to leave the
Contractor Legal Name blank.
v220160101
About DIR Work with Us Learn More
Who we are Licensing,registrations,certifications&permits Site Map
DIR Divisions,Boards&Commissions Notification of activies Frequently Asked Questions
Contact DIR Public Records Act Jobs at DIR
Conditions of Use Privacy Policy Disclaimer Disability accommodation Site Help
Copyrlpht®2015 State of Callfomla
https://efiling.dir.ca.gov/PWCR/Search.ac,don 218 1l1
n
1
FIR SEGUND
I•CENTEkNi l°
1917.2917
February 1,2017
Elected Officials: R.Dependable Const. Inc.
Attn: Rosemary Padilla,President
Mayor
Suzanne Fuentes, 1019 W. 31d Street
M
Drero Boyles,
San Bernardino CA 92410
Mayor Pro Tem �
Michaelnugan, Via US Mail and Email to marco a.rdoconstine.com
Council Alernber
Carol PirrJuk,
Council Member
Dr.Don Brann, Response to Bid Protest by R Dependable Const.Inc. for Fire Station#1 Kitchen
Council Member
Tram Went--, Improvement Project(PW 17-06)
Cio,Clerk
Cristo Binder,
City Treasurer Dear Ms. Padilla,
Appointed officials: In response to the protest letter from R. Dependable Constr. Inc. for the Fire Station#1 Kitchen
Greg Carpenter, Improvement Project(PW 17-06),which had a bid opening on January 24th, 2017,the City of
Cif.Manager El Segundo has investigated the protest items and has come to the following conclusions:
Mark D.lf—ky,
Ory Attorney
1. R Dependable Const. Inc.protests that Ayus&Co. Inc. does not hold a Cal/OSHA
Department Directors: license and did not list a licensed subcontractor for the removal of Asbestos
Containing Material(ACM).
Joseph lrlko,
Finance
Chris Donovan,
eChif City resnonse: On page 1-C-11 of Ayus& Co. Inc.'s bid,Enkay Engineering is listed
May-llousfon' as the subcontractor for asbestos abatement. Enkay Engineering is registered with
Interim Human Resources
Debra Brighton, the DIR(registration#1000009004, expiration 6/30/2017), has a current and valid
Library serriees
Sam Lee, contractor's license(CSLB 4509785,expiration 06/30/2017), and a current and valid
Bufldingnnd Cal/OSHA certification DOSH#054 expiration 03/08/2017 Given that Enka
Builrling.Snjety ( , p� ). y
Mitch rare c g � Y Parise hief Engineering pp will be handling g the removal of ACM Ayus &Co. Inc. is not required
q
Km Berkman, to hold a Cal/OSHA license.
Interim Rrblic Works
Meredith Petit,
Recreation&Parks
2. R Dependable Const. Inc.protests that Ayus & Co. Inc. subcontractor listed
Caseworx Inc. (license #663046) and they are not currently registered ivith DIR at
the time of bid
w iv i o.ela epi.m d o.o ri p
Ww>u.ri!�el?,►.fdanlfsrll ss:rarl City response: The City of El Segundo recognizes that the contractor listed in the
"Declaration of Subcontractor's"form is not DIR registered. However, in
accordance with the bid requirements,the prime contractor,Ayus&Co.Inc. listed
all subconsultants and vendors that will be on the project. Ayus&Co. Inc.has
confirmed that Caseworx is a vendor and is only supplying materials for the project
and therefore is not required to be DIR registered. Ayus &Co. Inc. will be installing
the materials as part of the work.
350 Main Street, El Segundo, California 90245-3813
Phone (390) 524-2300
219
1
s UNU
' ccr-xnir
For the reasons set forth above,the City of El Segundo does not find substantial reason to
reject Ayus&Co. Inc. bid. At the February 7th regular Council meeting, staff will recommend
that the City Council award the contract to Ayus&Co. Inc.
Please contact Cheryl Ebert for questions or additional information regarding this project at
cebert,else€rundo.ora or 310-524-2321. We thank you for your interest in the project and
hope that you will continue to monitor the City's website for future contracting opportunities.
Sincerely,
ten*Be*rkman,P.E.
Interim Public Works Director
350 Main Street, El Segundo, California 90245-3893
Phone (390) 524-2300
220
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action to accept as complete the Water Main Improvement
Project on Center St., Walnut Ave. and Maple Ave., Project No. PW16-02. (Fiscal
Impact: $1,527,796.80.)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Accept the Water Main Improvement Project work for Project No.16-02 as complete.
2. Authorize the City Clerk to file Notice of Completion in the County Recorder's
office.
3. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible actions related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
Notice of Completion
Project Location Map
FISCAL IMPACT: Budget Adjustment Required
Amount Budgeted: $1,750,787.00
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): 501-400-7103-8207 (Water Enterprise Fund CIP)
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 4 Quality Infrastructure and Technology
Objective: 1 The City's infrastructure is well maintained
ORIGINATED BY: Lifan Xu, City Engineer
REVIEWED BY: Ken Berkman, Interim Public Works Director-0
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager .
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
On February 2, 2016, City Council adopted plans and specifications for the Water Main
Improvement at Center St., Walnut Ave., and Maple Ave. (Project No. PW16-02, "Project") and
authorized staff to advertise for bids. A total of approximately 4,300 linear feet of water mains
and about 130 service lines and meters were scheduled for replacement at the following
locations:
Center St., from Mariposa Ave. to Imperial Ave. (built in 1934s/40s, undersized)
• Walnut Ave., from Center St. to California St. (built in 1930s)
• Maple Ave., from Center St. to California St. (built in 1930s) 12
221
On March 15, 2016, City Council awarded a standard public works contract to the lowest
responsible bidder, Ramona, Inc. for$1,388,300.00 and approved an additional $208,245.00 for
construction-related contingencies. City Council also awarded a professional services agreement
to AKM Consulting Engineers to provide construction inspection and geotechnical inspection for
the project in the amount of$144,242.00, with an additional $10,000.00 for contingencies.
Construction began on June 13, 2016 and was successfully completed by Ramona, Inc. on
December 10, 2016. All punchwork has been completed to the satisfaction of the Public Works
Department.
Staff recommends that City Council accept the work performed by Ramona, Inc. as complete and
authorize the City Clerk to file a Notice of Completion with the County Recorder's office. The
unspent budgeted amount will return to the Water Enterprise Fund for future water infrastructure
improvements.
Accounting Summary:
$1,388,300.00 Ramona, Inc. Contract Amount
—$0.00 Change Order and Contingency Utilized
+$138,728.80 AKM Construction Inspection Funds Utilized
+$768.00 Advertising for Bids in Newspaper
$1,527,396.80 Total Funds Spent
$1,750,787.00 Amount Budgeted for the project
-$1,527,796.80 Total Funds Spent
$ 222,990.20 Unspent Budgeted Amount Returned to the Water Fund
222
Recording Requested by
and When Recorded Mail To:
City Clerk, City Hall
350 Main Street
El Segundo, CA 90245
NOTICE OF COMPLETION OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECT
Project Name: Water Main Improvement at Center, Walnut, and Maple
Project No. : PW 16-02 Contract No. 4998
Notice is hereby given pursuant to State of California Civil Code Section 3093 et seq that:
1. The undersigned is an officer of the owner of the interest stated below in the property
hereinafter described.
2. The full name of the owner is: City of El Segundo
3. The full address of the owner is: City Hall, 350 Main Street, El Segundo, CA, 90245
4 The nature of the interest of the owner is: Public Facilities
5. A work of improvement on the property hereinafter described was field reviewed by the
City Engineer on December 10, 2016. The work done was: Water Main Improvement.
6. On February 7, 2017 City Council of the City of El Segundo accepted the work of this
contract as being complete and directed the recording of this Notice of Completion in the
Office of the County Recorder.
T The name of the Contractor for such work of improvement was: Ramona, Inc.
8. The property on which said work of improvement was completed is in the City of El
Segundo, County of Los Angeles, State of California, and is described as follows: Center
St. from Imperial Ave. to Mariposa Ave., Maple Ave. from Center St. to California St., and
Walnut Ave. from Center St. to California St.
9. The street address of said property is: Center St., Walnut Ave., Maple Ave. in El
Segundo, CA 90245
Dated:
Ken Berkman
Interim Public Works Director
VERIFICATION
I, the undersigned, say: I am the Director of Public Works of the City El Segundo, the declarant of the
foregoing Notice of Completion; I have read said Notice of Completion and know the contents thereof; the
same is true of my own knowledge.
I declare under penalty of perjury the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed on 2017 at El Segundo, California. 90245
Ken Berkman
Interim Public Works Director
223
_ I
l
�f
- L U
CIL
wu� --- CL
1]fI v
I
q
IF _3
E]I.....
::�� L A LZ
11 �_
I �llL L
a
_1S NMY
�30oUq�
1 IC
ci
CD
a
1 r Fl�
h 0�5 5�
- c
224
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action to 1) award a standard Public Works Contract to
Stephen Doreck Equipment Rentals, Inc. for the Water Main Improvement on Mariposa
Avenue, Project No. PW17-03; and, 2) award a standard Public Works Professional
Services Agreement to AKM Consulting Engineers for construction inspection services.
(Fiscal Impact: $750,386.13)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public Works Contract, in a form
approved by the City Attorney, with Stephen Doreck Equipment Rentals, Inc., in the
amount of$579,657.50 and approve an additional $86,948.63 for construction-related
contingencies.
2. Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public Works Professional Services
Agreement in a form as approved by the City Attorney with AKM Consulting
Engineers in the amount of $73,780 for construction inspection and geotechnical
(compaction) oversight and testing, and approve an additional $10,000 for related
contingencies.
3. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible actions related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
Location Map
FISCAL IMPACT: Included in Adopted Budget
Amount Budgeted: $3,000,000.00 (Water CIPs)
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): 501-400-7103-8206 (Water Enterprise Fund)
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 4 Quality Infrastructure and Technology
Objective: 1 The City's infrastructure is well maintained
ORIGINATED BY: Arianne Bola, Senior Engineering Associate A6
REVIEWED BY: Ken Berkman, Interim Public Works Directories
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
The City is the owner of and responsible for maintaining its water transmission and distribution
system. As part of regular annual maintenance, staff reviewed maintenance records and
identified Mariposa Avenue between Lairport and Nash Streets as one the most problematic
1
225
areas due to multiple main breaks. Many of the pipes in the City's system were installed in the
early 1920s and are undersized in comparison to modern water main standards. The age and size
of the lines, coupled with corrosion and sediment accumulation over the years, has affected the
flow rate and quality of water. This water main replacement project will eliminate poor sections
of the system, enhance the water pressure and safeguard water quality.
This work was identified and approved in FY 2016/17 Budget as part of the Capital
Improvement Program. The project consists of installing approximately 1,600 linear feet of 12-
inch water pipe along with all appurtenant valves and associated infrastructure, as well as
performing associated site work including, but not limited to, reconnecting water services,
reconnecting fire hydrants, testing, trenching, backfilling and paving.
On December 20, 2016, City Council adopted plans and specifications for the Water Main
Improvement on Mariposa Avenue (Project No. PW17-03) and authorized staff to advertise the
project for receipt of construction bids. On January 10, 2017, the City Clerk received and opened
four (4) bids as follows:
1. Stephen Doreck Equipment Rentals, Inc. $579,657.50
2. Kana Subsurface Engineering $591,000.00
3. Ramona, Inc. $774,231.00
4. Minako America Corporation dba $858,450.00
Minco Construction
The lowest responsive and responsible bidder is Stephen Doreck Equipment Rentals, Inc., whose
bid is below the engineering cost estimate of $600,000.00. Staff checked the Contractor's
license status and references, and found them to have satisfactorily completed similar projects for
other public agencies, and was satisfied with work they have done in the past for the City.
Staff has contracted with AKM Consulting Engineers for inspection and geotechnical services on
several similar projects and has found them to be highly competent and professional at providing
daily oversight and construction inspection. Staff has also verified that AKM's rates are typical
of the market for this type of inspection work.
Staff therefore respectfully recommends that City Council:
1) Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public Works Contract, in a form
approved by the City Attorney, with Stephen Doreck Equipment Rentals, Inc. in the
amount of $579,657.50 and approve an additional $86,948.63 for construction-related
contingencies.
2) Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public Works Professional Services
Agreement in a form as approved by the City Attorney with AKM Consulting Engineers
in the amount of $73,780.00 for construction inspection and geotechnical (compaction)
oversight and testing, and approve an additional $10,000.00 for related contingencies.
Construction is anticipated to commence in March and be completed in June 2017. Any
remaining funds will be returned to the Water Enterprise Fund.
226
i f,t
I ..
r-
ii }}
Gzill .
DOI_,�
a gee
11 FA
— n
227
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action to approve energy efficiency products from
Southern California Edison's Direct Install Program and installation of energy
efficient replacement equipment at the Library and Water Plant and authorize the City
Manager to execute the Southern California Edison Direct Install Program
Agreement.
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Approve the installation of energy efficiency products from Southern California
Edison's Direct Install Program at the Library and Water Plant, and authorize the City
Manager to sign the Direct Install Program Partner Authorization Forms.
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
Southern California Edison Direct Install Program Partner Authorization Form
FISCAL IMPACT: Included in Adopted Budget
Amount Budgeted: N/A
Additional Appropriation: No
Account Number(s): N/A
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 4 Quality Infrastructure and Technology
Objective: 1 The City's infrastructure is well maintained
ORIGINATED BY: Julie Hegvold, Management Analyst
Ron Fajardo, General Services Manager,.- ]
REVIEWED BY: Ken Berkman, Interim Public Works Director'
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager,
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
In 2015, the City of El Segundo participated in the Southern California Edison (SCE) Local
Government Agency Direct Install Program, which provided energy efficiency products and
installation at 1 I City facilities by SCE's approved contractor, at no cost to the City. The Direct
Install program allows the City to reduce energy costs and save money with energy upgrades that
are in line with Assembly Bill 32 (AB32) and the policies set forth to reduce Greenhouse Gas
Emissions.
14
228
At the time, the Library and the Water Plant were not eligible to upgrade to LED lighting due to
the type of ballasts that the buildings' fixtures required. However, SCE has recently unveiled
their latest Direct Install Program, which has expanded since 2015, and the LED lighting
upgrades for these two facilities can now be done.
Public Works staff and FCI Management Consultants, SCE's approved contractor, revisited the
two City facilities last month and confirmed eligibility. The LED lighting upgrades will be
provided at no cost to the City. With Council's approval, the upgrades would be scheduled
immediately, as all SCE Direct Install Program installations must be completed by
March 31, 2017.
229
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EXHIBIT
EIEDISON" 2016 Direct Install Program
Partnerships Customer Authorization Form
An EDiSON INTERNATIONAL%Company
Please review,complete,sign and submit this form authorizing an SCE-approved Consultant to perform the services outlined below.
Customer Name. c• / 'r�4`,l _ ,�, t, Service Account Name
Contact Name sr• A"tJ<' ��%� ~ Service Account Numbert:�C1
Contact Title "'J. i�f: ;c Service Address
(
Phone ✓��° L/E �'�, .f a � .Jt' CC +rr .!�� "'E
This Customer Authorization Form is entered into by the Customer listed above in connection with Southern California Edison's(SCE)Third
Party ImplementedTurnkey Program(Program).
City Manager on behalf of the City of El Segundo
{ (use'Contact Name'listed abo,v..�?,ta,=resentative of Customer,am duly authorized to sign
this Authorization on behalf of Customer.Customer hereby authorizes (Consultant)to conduct an Energy
Survey of Customer's facility and to replace and/or install energy efficiency equipment recommended by Consultant as a result of the Energy
Survey (collectively,the "Work"). Customer understands that Consultant has been pre-approved, after a competitive solicitation, by SCE
to perform the Work and that the Work will be performed at no cost. Customer agrees that all of the Work shall be subject to all terms and
conditions of this Authorization and of the Program.
Customer agrees to provide Consultant reasonable access to Customer's facility for the Work,including the Energy Survey and replacement
and/or installation of the recommended energy efficiency measures.Customer further agrees to provide SCE and Consultant(or other SCE
consultants)reasonable access to Customer's Facility for all inspections or verifications of such Work as may be required by SCE in its sole
discretion.
Customer acknowledges that SCE will provide up to$10,000 in services and equipment per Service Account for accounts with demands of
0-99 kW,or up to$15,000 per Service Account for accounts with demands of 100-199 kW.Project caps are subject to change without notice.
Program funding is limited and is available on a first-come,first-served basis until funding is depleted or the Program is terminated.
Customer must meet the following requirements to be eligible for the Program:(1)Facility site must be a nonresidential active SCE customer
and the facility must be located within SCE's service territory;(2)SCE Customers must pay the Public Purpose Programs Charge("PPP")on
the SCE electric meter where the Work is to be performed;(3)Customer certifies that Customer has not and will not receive any funds from
any other energy conservation program funded by the PPP for the same energy savings components installed under this Program;and(4)
Customer and all Work must meet all other Program requirements,terms and conditions;
Customer acknowledges that connected load at Customer's facility may increase if the Work involves replacing burned out or missing lamps.
Customer hereby agrees that SCE makes no warranty,expressed or implied,with respect to the Work,including without limitation the implied
warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose.Customer agrees to hold harmless SCE, its officers,directors,affiliates
and employees, from and against any and all liability, damages, losses, claims, demands, actions, costs, including attorneys'fees and
expenses and all court or arbitration or other dispute resolution costs,or any of them,resulting from,arising out of,or in any way directly
connected with Work performed by Consultant.Customer hereby agrees to hold the Consultant solely responsible for any and all claims,
losses,liabilities,damages and expenses,including attorneys'fees and costs,which Customer may incur as a result of the Work.Customer is
solely responsible for ownership of the equipment and services under the Program.Items installed are warranted by Consultant for one year.
Customer agrees that SCE may provide Customer's Contact information to Consultant(and other SCE consultants)for the exclusive purpose
of carrying out the Work and the Program,Customer acknowledges that Consultant has been authorized to contact Customer only with regard
to performing the Work,and that any other services,installations,improvements or equipment provided to Customer by Consultant have
not been authorized by SCE,and SCE assumes no responsibility therefore.
By signing below, I acknowledge that SCE will reimburse the installing contractor for the Work performed and that this expense will be
charged to the Partnership budget allocated to my City,County or Partnership.Partnership programs may count energy savings associated
with the Work towards their goal achievement.This initiative is limited in funding and is in conjunction with SCE's Commercial Direct Install
(01)program.All terms and conditions of the Commercial Direct Install program apply to Partnerships customers.
AGREED AND ACCEPTED:
Customer Signaturl>r-__.._ _ Date
APPROVED AS TO FORM: y F ES S ATTEST:
lxE3eY Sole rie NS
�Alvinwo M.'rM.
CRI Lighting&Electrical FESS Comprehensive Energy FCI Management Consultants CITY CLERIC
CITY ATTORNEY 1375 North Brasher Street•Anaheim,CA 92807 627 S.Lake Ave.,Suite 101!Pasadena,CA 91101 3850 E.Gilman Street•Long Beech,CA 90815
w .ralltomla-ratrofltcom http://Ie o-onergycomAndox.htm Ww Jc1m9t.com CITY OF EL SEGUNDO
Direct Install Program is funded by California ratepayers and administered by SCE under the auspices of the California Public Utilities Commission.
For further information,please contact SCE at(8001736-4777 n
White-SCE t'anan/-Vanrinr r:nLlo, —,4 r,, X02 V1-0913
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EXHIBIT
E D I S O N® 2016 Direct Install Program
Partnerships Customer Authorization Form
An EDISON INTERNATIONAL®Company
Please review,com e, sign and submit this form authorizing an SCE-approved Consultant to perform the services outlined below.
Customer Name Tai {'. 14A 4J16 t'X Service Account Name/y _)t'��!
Contact Name '�9r.fls'tk� <'�'� Service Account Number CC?/1 sr
Contact Title x t' - .f�l r Service Address ���) �r'"x r -1 Y
Phone 3.10 ` ,,.xz >I V�J'� ,�� � �N��� �rp�+,��✓
This Customer Authorization Form is entered into by the Customer listed above in connection with Southern California Edison's(SCE)Third
Party ImplementedTurnkey Program(Program),
City Manager on behalf of the City of El Sego trio
1, Y g use Contact Name'llsted ab } a_presentative of Customer,am duly authorized to sign
this Authorization on behalf of Customer.Customer hereby authorizes /V �_�� (Consultant)to conduct an Energy
Survey of Customer's facility and to replace and/or install energy efficiency equipment recommended by Consultant as a result of the Energy
Survey(collectively, the"Work's). Customer understands that Consultant has been pre-approver!, after a competitive solicitation, by SCE
to perform the Work and that the Work will be performed at no cost.Customer agrees that all of the Work shall be subject to all terms and
conditions of this Authorization and of the Programs.
Customer agrees to provide Consultant reasonable access to Customer's facility for the Work,including the Energy Survey and replacement
and/or installation of the recommended energy efficiency measures.Customer further agrees to provide SCE and Consultant(or other SCE
consultants) reasonable access to Customer's Facility for all inspections or verifications of such Work as may be required by SCE in its sole
discretion.
Customer acknowledges that SCE will provide up to$10,000 in services and equipment per Service Account for accounts with demands of
0-99 kW,or up to$15,000 per Service Account for accounts with demands of 100-199 M Project caps are subject to change without notice.
Program funding is limited and is available on a first-come,first-served basis until funding is depleted or the Program is terminated.
Customer must meet the following requirements to be eligible for the Program:(1)Facility site must be a nonresidential active SCE customer
and the facility must be located within SCE's service territory;(2)SCE Customers must pay the Public Purpose Programs Charge("PPP")on
the SCE electric meter where the Work is to be performed;(3)Customer certifies that Customer has not and will not receive any funds from
any other energy conservation program funded by the PPP for the same energy savings components installed under this Program;and(4)
Customer and all Work must meet all other Program requirements,terms and conditions;
Customer acknowledges that connected load at Customer's facility may increase if the Work involves replacing burned out or missing lamps.
Customer hereby agrees that SCE makes no warranty,expressed or implied,with respect to the Work,including without limitation the implied
warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose.Customer agrees to hold harmless SCE,its officers,directors,affiliates
and employees, from and against any and all liability, damages, losses, claims, demands, actions, costs, including attorneys' fees and
expenses and all court or arbitration or other dispute resolution costs,or any of them, resulting from,arising out of,or in any way directly
connected with Work performed by Consultant, Customer hereby agrees to hold the Consultant solely responsible for any and all claims,
losses,liabilities,damages and expenses,including attorneys'fees and costs,which Customer may incur as a result of the Work.Customer is
solely responsible for ownership of the equipment and services under the Program.Items installed are warranted by Consultantfor one year.
Customer agrees that SCE may provide Customer's contact information to Consultant(and other SCE consultants)for the exclusive purpose
of carrying out the Work and the Program.Customer acknowledges that Consultant has been authorized to contact Customer only with regard
to performing the Work,and that any other services,installations,improvements or equipment provided to Customer by Consultant have
not been authorized by SCE,and SCE assumes no responsibility therefore.
By signing below, I acknowledge that SCE will reimburse the installing contractor for the Work performed and that this expense will be
charged to the Partnership budget allocated to my City,County or Partnership.Partnership programs may count energy savings associated
with the Work towards their goal achievement.This initiative is limited in funding and is in conjunction with SCE's Commercial Direct Install
(DI)program.All terms and conditions of the Commercial Direct Install program apply to Partnerships customers.
AGREED AND ACCEPTED: City Manager on behalf of City of El Segundo
Customer Signature Date
APPROVED AS TO FORM: ATTEST:
FESS
�♦, N¢¢Gt Ulloxs
,uVrw,W W
CRI Lighting&Electrical FESS Comprehensive Energy FCI Management Consultants CITY CLERK
CITY ATTORNEY 1375 North Brasher Street•Anaheim,CA 92607 527 S.Lake Ave.,Suite 101•Pasadena,CA 91101 3860 E.Gilman Street•Long Beach,CA 90616
www.eal6omle-retroBtcom http://tese-onargy.wm/indox.htm Wv wJclmgtcom CITY OF EL SEGUNDO
Direct Install Program is funded by California ratepayers and administered by SCE under the auspices of the California Public Utilities Commission.
For further information,please contact SCE at(800)738-4777 �Q
Wbito-Cr r r..,..�.,, NI-_A —1— ., �fQR OP-V1-0913
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action regarding a request for two new ABC Licenses (Type 21 for
the sale of beer, wine and distilled spirits for off-site consumption and Type 86 for instructional
tasting) within the existing Cost Plus World Market located at Plaza El Segundo at 720 South
Sepulveda Boulevard in the Commercial Center (C-4) Zone. EA No. 1170 and AUP No. 16-13.
Applicant: Cost Plus World Market c/o Jane Baughman. (Fiscal Impact: N/A)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Receive and file this report without objecting to the issuance of the alcohol licenses.
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
1. Planning Commission Staff Report, dated January 12,
A. Administrative Use Permit Approval Letter, dated January 5,
3. 2016 Police Reporting Districts Map
4. 2016 Crime and Arrest Statistics by Reporting Districts (RD)
FISCAL IMPACT: None
Amount Budgeted: N/A
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): N/A
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: N/A
Objective: N/A
ORIGINATED BY: Gregg McClain, Planning Manager
REVIEWED BY: Sam Lee, Planning and Building Safety Directo
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
I. Background
On January 5, 2017, the Director of Planning and Building Safety approved an Administrative
Use Permit application (EA-1170 and AUP No. 16-13 for 720 S. Sepulveda Blvd.) which allows
the sale of beer, wine, and spirits for off-site consumption and on-site instructional tasting at the
existing Cost Plus World Market. The Director's decision was forwarded to the Planning
Commission on January 12, 2017, and the Planning Commission Received and Filed the
Director's decision.
is
232
In 1995, the City Council directed staff to bring all future Department of ABC licenses to it for
review. Based upon previous Council direction, staff is providing background information
regarding this application.
Under California law, once the ABC receives an application for a license, it must notify the
applicable city of the pending application. The local agency then has 30 days to review and, if
applicable, protest the issuance of the license. The grounds of a protest should relate to public
health, safety or welfare concerns. In this case, the applicant has not yet applied to ABC for the
license.
II. Analysis
The application for a license, if approved by the Department of ABC, would allow the sale of
beer, wine, and spirits for off-site consumption and on-site instructional tasting in conjunction
with the operations of the 18,205 square-foot market. The normal hours of operation are to
continue 9:00am-9:30pm Monday-Saturday and 10:00am-7:00pm Sundays. They are requesting
to extend hours for the holiday season (from Thanksgiving to New Year's) to 7:00am-11:00pm
daily. Per conditions by ABC, instructional tasting events will be limited to operating between
10:00am-9:00pm daily.
According to the most recent Crime and Arrest statistics report prepared by the Police
Department, the proposed restaurant is located in Reporting District (RD) 318. Based on the July
2016—December 2016 data reported by the Police Department, the district had a total of 47 Part
I & II crimes and 14 felony/misdemeanor arrests. This rate is 239% higher than the City's
average. The Police Department and the Planning and Building Safety Department do not object
to the issuance of Type 21 & 86 ABC Licenses for the market.
The project site is located in the Commercial Center (C-4) zone within Plaza El Segundo. The
off-site sale of alcohol at retail establishments is permitted with an Administrative Use Permit
within the C-4 zone.
ABC license review requires mandatory findings that are regulated by ABC. The City's AUP
process is separate. ABC is responsible for running a complete background check on all alcohol
license applicants, as well as conducting site inspections, before issuing any type of alcohol
license.
III. Environmental Review
The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental
Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to 14 California Code of Regulations § 15301 as a Class 1
categorical exemption (Existing Facilities). The project is a request for alcohol licenses for an
existing building. The project is not anticipated to have any significant impacts with regard to
traffic, noise, air quality or water quality.
IV. Conclusion
233
Staff recommends that the Council receive and file this report without objecting to the issuance
of a new Type 21 ABC license for the off-site sale of beer, wine, and spirits and a new Type 86
ABC license for an existing retail store at 720 S. Sepulveda, or alternatively discuss and take
another action related to this item.
234
EL SEGUNDO PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING DATE: January 12, 2016
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Director of Planning and Building Safety Decision for an Administrative Use Permit.
RECOMMENDED PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION:
1. Receive and File the Director's approval of Environmental Assessment No. EA-1170 and
Administrative Use Permit No. AUP 16-13;
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
1. Approval Letter
2. Plans
ORIGINATED BY: Russell Toler, Contract Planning Techniciansz<
REVIEWED BY: Gregg McClain, Planning Manager 190'1
APPROVED BY: Sam Lee, Director of Planning and Building Safet
The Director of Planning and Building Safety issued the following decision:
1. Approved - Environmental Assessment No. EA-1170 and Administrative Use Permit
No. AUP 16-13
Address: 720 South Sepulveda Boulevard
Applicant: Cost Plus World Market, Inc. c/o Jane Baughman
Property Owner(s): Federal Realty Investment Trust
The applicant requests the approval of an Administrative Use Permit to allow a
Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) License Type 21 (on-site sale of beer,
wine and distilled spirits for off-site consumption)and Type 86 (Instructional Tasting)within
their existing store. The applicant currently holds ABC License Type 20 (beer &wine for
off-site consumption), which was permited through AUP 06-04 in 2006. The 18,205
square-foot market is located at an existing commercial shopping center (Plaza El
Segundo) at 720 South Sepulveda Boulevard in the Commercial Center (C-4) Zone.
As approved,the hours of operation for off-site alcohol sales are limited to 9:OOam-9:30pm
Monday-Saturday and 10:00am-7:00pm Sundays, and 7:00am-11:00pm daily during the
holiday season (from Thanksgiving to New Year's). Per conditions by ABC, instructional
tasting events will be limited to operating between 10:OOam-9:00pm daily.
The Planning and Building Safety Director approved Environmental Assessment No. EA-
1170 and Administrative Adjustment No. ADJ 16-13. A detailed description of the project
and the findings for the decision are included in the attached decision letter.
1
235
Environmental Assessment
The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental
Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to 14 California Code of Regulations § 15301 as a Class 1
categorical exemption (Existing Facilities). The project is a negligible expansion of the
planned-for operation of an existing use involving alcohol sales and tastings.The property
is in an urbanized and developed area where it has adequate access and all public
services and facilities are available. Therefore, the project is not anticipated to have any
significant impacts with regard to traffic, noise, air quality or water quality.
Recommendation
Staff recommends that the Planning Commission receive and file the Director's decision.
In the alternative, any Planning Commissioner may request that an item be discussed and
a decision on the application be made by the Planning Commission instead of received
and filed.
2
236
1-
* 61 yer�"4
Planning & Building Safety Department
January 5, 2017
Elected Officials:
Suzanne Fuentes,
Mayor
Drew Boyles, Jane L. Baughman
Mayor Pro Tem 4}h
Michael Dugan, G 200 St.
CarolPlsztukember Oakland, CA 94607
Council Member
Dr.Don Brann,
Council Member
Tracy Weaver,
City Binder,,Clark
Crisis Binder, RE: Environmental Assessment No. EA-1170 and
City Treasurer Administrative Use Permit AUP No. 16-13
Appointed officials: An Administrative Use Permit request to allow ABC License Types 21
Greg Carpenter, (on-site sale of beer, wine and distilled spirits for off-site consumption)
ClfyM and 86 (Instructional Tasting) within the existing store.
Mark D.Hensleynsley,,
City Attorney
Address: 720 South Sepulveda Boulevard
Department Directors:
JosephLilffo, Dear Ms. Baughman:
Financa
Chris Donovan,
Fire
Martha a Dijkstra,
In accordance with El Segundo Municipal Code ("ESMC") Chapter 15-22,
ffro,rOn
Debra Brighton, the Planning Division has reviewed your application for the above-
Library Services
Sam Leo, referenced project and the Director of Planning and Building Safety
Planni
ngd
Building Safety p De artment has APPROVED Environmental Assessment No. EA-1170
Building
Mitch Tavera, and Administrative Use Permit No. 16-13 for the on-site sale of beer, wine
Police Chief
Ken Berkman, and distilled spirits for off-site consumption with a Type 21 ABC license, as
Interim Public Works
Meredith Petit, well as instructional tastings of alcoholic beverages with a Type 86 ABC
Recreation BParks license at 720 South Sepulveda Boulevard (Cost Plus World Market). The
following are the findings and facts in support of each finding for this
decision:
Www.elseoundo.orq FINDINGS AND FACTS IN SUPPORT OF FINDINGS:
Environmental Assessment No. EA-1170
Finding 1
The proposed project is categorically exempt from the requirements of
the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to 14
350 Main Street, El Segundo, California 90245-3813
Phone(310) 524-2380 FAX(310)322-4167
237
California Code of Regulations § 15301 as a Class 1 categorical
exemption (Existing Facilities).
Facts in Support of Finding 1
1. The project is a negligible expansion of the planned-for operation of an approved
use involving alcohol sales and tastings. The property is in an urbanized area
where there is adequate access and all public services and facilities are
available. The site is in an area that is not environmentally sensitive. Therefore,
the project is not anticipated to have any significant impacts with regard to traffic,
noise, air quality, or water quality.
Administrative Use Permit 16-13
Findinq 1
There is compatibility of the particular use on the particular site in relationship to
other existing and potential uses within the general area in which the use is
proposed to be located.
Facts in Support of Finding 1
1. The General Plan Land Use designation for the site is Commercial Center. Off-
site sale of alcohol at retail establishments is permitted in the Zone with the
approval of an Administrative Use Permit. The applicant currently holds an ABC
Type 20 license for off-site sales of beer and wine (approved by AUP 06-4). The
current request is only for a modification to the previous AUP in order to be able
to also sell distilled spirits for off-site consumption, and to allow instructional
tasting.
2. The Commercial Center (C-4) zone permits and the surrounding land uses
include similar specialty retail stores.
3. Since there is no change or physical expansion of use proposed, no additional
parking spaces are required for the request.
Findinq 2
• The proposed use is consistent and compatible with the purpose of the Zone in
which the site is located.
Facts in Support of Finding 2
1. The zoning for the site is Commercial Center (C-4). Regulations within this zone
are designed to promote and control the growth of commercial center projects
such as retail and service uses. Off-site sale of alcohol at retail establishments is
permitted in the Zone with the approval of an Administrative Use Permit.
2
238
2. The proposed use is consistent with Land Use Element Goal LU4 in that it
provides a stable tax base for the City through an expansion of a commercial
use.
3. The immediate surrounding land uses include commercial, office and industrial
uses. The proposed off-site sale of alcohol will be compatible with the
surrounding uses.
Findinq 3
The proposed location and use and the conditions under which the use would be
operated or maintained will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or
welfare, or materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity.
Facts in Support of Finding 3
1. The surrounding land uses include commercial, office and industrial uses. The
proposed sale of beer, wine, and spirits for off-site consumption is a permitted
use within the C-4 zone.
2. Types 21 and 86 Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) Licenses are
to be obtained. The applicant must abide by ABC regulations and license
restrictions.
Findinq 4
Potential impacts that could be generated by the proposed use, such as noise,
smoke, dust, fumes, vibration, odors, traffic, and hazards have been recognized
and mitigated.
Facts in Support of Finding 4
1. The on-site consumption of alcohol will be for instructional tasting only, and will
therefore not create any new impacts that would not be normally associated with
the operation of a retail store.
2. The existing hours of operation are to continue from 9:00am-9:30pm Monday-
Saturday and 10:00am-7 :00pm Sundays, with holiday season hours limited to
7:00am-11:00pm daily (from Thanksgiving to New Year's). Per conditions by
Alcoholic Beverage Control, instructional tasting events will be limited to
operating between 10:00am-9:00pm daily. The applicant must comply with
ESMC §§ 7-2-1, et seq. regarding noise and vibration.
3. The on-site tastings will be located inside the existing store and will be
constructed in accordance with all applicable codes and regulations. The project
proposes no changes to physical characteristics of the building, to parking or to
3
239
landscaping. Sufficient parking will be provided on-site in compliance with ESMC
Chapter 15-15.
Finding 5
The State Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control has issued or will issue a
license to sell alcohol to the applicant.
Facts in Support of Finding 5
1. The applicant must obtain a license from the State of California Department of
Alcoholic Beverage Control for off-site sale and consumption of alcohol (Type
No. 21) and on-site instructional tasting (Type No. 86).
DIRECTOR OF PLANNING AND BUILDING SAFETY DEPARTMENT ACTION
Based on these findings and facts in support of these findings, the Director of Planning
and Building Safety Department APPROVES the proposed project, subject to the
following conditions:
1. The hours of operation for off-site alcohol sales are limited to 9:OOam-9:30pm
Monday-Saturday, 10:00am-7:00pm Sundays, and 7:00am-11:00pm daily during
the holiday season (from Thanksgiving to New Year's). Per conditions by
Alcoholic Beverage Control, instructional tasting events will be limited to
operating between 10:00am-9:00pm daily. Any change to the hours of operation
or the hours that alcohol may be served is subject to review and approval by the
Director of Planning and Building Safety.
2. Any subsequent modification to the project as approved must be referred to the
Director of Planning and Building Safety for approval and a determination
regarding the need for Planning Commission review of the proposed
modification.
3. The applicant must obtain and maintain all licenses required by the Alcoholic
Beverage Control Act (Business & Professions Code §§ 23310 of seq.). The
applicant must obtain and maintain both Type 21 and Type 86 licenses.
4. The store must comply with ESMC §§ 7-2-1, et seq. regulating to noise and
vibration.
5. The Planning and Building Safety Department and the Police Department must
be notified of any change of ownership of the approved use in writing within 10
days of the completion of the change of ownership. A change in project
ownership may be cause to schedule a hearing before the Planning Commission
regarding the status of the administrative use permit.
6. The applicant must comply with all regulations of the Alcoholic Beverage Control
Act and the regulations promulgated by the Alcoholic Beverage Control Board
4
240
including, without limitation, the regulations set forth in 4 Cal. Code of Regs. §§
55, et seq.
7. There must be no exterior advertising of any kind or type, including advertising
directed to the exterior from within, promoting or indicating the availability of
specific alcoholic beverage products. Interior displays of alcoholic beverages
which are clearly visible to the exterior constitute a violation of this condition.
8. All employees serving alcoholic beverages to patrons must enroll in and
complete a certified training program approved by the State Department of
Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) for the responsible sales of alcohol. The
training must be offered to new employees on not less than a quarterly basis.
9. Any and all employees hired to sell alcoholic beverages must provide evidence
that they have either:
a. Completed training from the State of California Department of Alcoholic
Beverage Control (ABC), Lakewood District Office administered
Leadership and Education in Alcohol and Drugs (LEAD) Program in the
form of an ABC-issued certificate; or,
b. Completed an accepted equivalent by the ABC, Lakewood District
Office to ensure proper distribution of beer, wine and distilled spirits to
adults of legal age. If any prospective employee designated to sell
alcoholic beverages does not currently have such training, then;
c. The ABC-licensed proprietors must have confirmed with the Planning
and Building Safety Department within fifteen (15) days of the
Director's decision, or by final project approval, that a date certain has
been scheduled within the local ABC Office to complete the LEAD
course.
d. Within thirty (30) days of taking said course, the employees, or
responsible employer must deliver each required certificate showing
completion to the Police Department.
10. The licensee must have readily identifiable personnel to monitor and control the
behavior of customers inside the building premises. Staff must monitor activity
outside in the parking lot and any adjacent property under the establishment's
control to ensure the areas are generally free of people.
11. If complaints are received regarding excessive noise, parking availability, lighting,
building access, and the like associated with the sale of beer and wine, the city
may, in its discretion, take action to review the Administrative Use Permit,
including without limitation, adding conditions or revoking the permit.
12. The building must not be occupied by more persons than allowed by the
California Building Code, as adopted by the ESMC.
5
241
13. The building must comply with California Building and Fire Code requirements,
as adopted by the ESMC.
14. The Applicant agrees to indemnify and hold the City harmless from and against
any claim, action, damages, costs (including, without limitation, attorney's fees),
injuries, or liability, arising from the City's approval of Environmental Assessment
No. 1170 or Administrative Use Permit AUP No. 16-13. Should the City be
named in any suit, or should any claim be brought against it by suit or otherwise,
whether the same be groundless or not, arising out of the City approval of EA-
1170 or AUP 16-13, the Applicant agrees to defend the City (at the City's request
and with counsel satisfactory to the City) and will indemnify the City for any
judgment rendered against it or any sums paid out in settlement or otherwise. For
purposes of this section "the City" includes the City of El Segundo's elected
officials, appointed officials, officers, and employees.
6
242
By signing this document, the following officers of Cost Plus Inc. and Federal Realty
Investment Trust certify that they have read, understood, and agrees to the Project
Conditions listed in this document.
Susan E. Lattmann, Secretary, Cost Plus, Inc.
Jane L. Baughman, President, Cost Plus, Inc.
Debbie Colson, VP of Legal Operations, Federal Realty Investment Trust
Dawn Becker Executive VP, Federal Realty Investment Trust
PLANNING COMMISSION & CITY COUNCIL REVIEW PENDING
This determination is scheduled to be received and filed by the Planning Commission at
its January 12, 2016 meeting. Please be advised that this does not conclude the
review process. The City Council will determine whether or not to protest the approval
of the alcohol permit at its meeting at as of yet undetermined date.
Should you have any questions, please contact Russell Toler, Contract Planning
Technician, at (310) 524-2371.
Sincerely,
Sam Le , Director
Depart ent of Planning and Building Safety
7
243
� N W
w y 3AV SIS) w0 K C C7 H
Y O w - N z w�p ` y = wU
z a O O H
C7 - O x z I T f w u p O
z
' ,.,taolivinv
AVM. 13Na0H
a
M
LL M M C14 r
CMO
x u
O 1
3nV
is "' v0noo svlonoa 04ko
]sos
t Sadvrvo N aiolvao0
A
- N 1'wkarrao O sau LL � O .a M AVM 1VA3NUNOO,M f
.
w M issKCC Mara ir7 A31na M - W
sndWO og Q ; 1S 011Odtl
LL °w
- i$ > w! ]Irf3 fr33n0Od43n HM F:
O N O 1S HSVN
CG O T T
O -
°
V- On19 WiN3NUNOO N'LIED WY
A's
s M 0 00
a - ! is °r,la0da1V1 T .w Q Z T
w - •n 0 T ~ Q 0 M _ w
T S J W
M
> M M r. o w
_ On1a ° tla3n�d3S N ° N
_ , O tlNVIONI YNI 1S VNVIONI '0s g N - Q ��-•�s
N N M w
sIONeTH O z
is
R O �R N' N ¢w 1S VI 3i7VJ N - a
0
a 1S N VI Na0311V0: O T ser.
w ra ra
z < ? 0 - w o is o o N! o N003190 ]AV O13IOV8
< ao " 'g1s Em VOVA3N (p IAV13KRV1
PIN r
1S ' < Id31N3�J is 83LN30 !3''w I n'- y 'r
a0 MO170N110 s 00I `L W
°� is vMvw z
is aNVIA1" 00 LL
�& C*4� is x VLIV401 N is ; vilwol
3 M 1S VdaHIS tia •+° 1s tlaa31S w_LO
U 1S z ` NN3d O w U
is NN3d r >
Z ¢ n
N0013HS °
w LS SS3 40 - 15 !tlOQ13FYa
�✓!�°s 2kila
= z Lf) cc O � � �.,1S VN3UV.
a $ �
=
i T
T rb�
U
as $n dAMJn3I
¢' � is valid NVLS1
is(V ¢
`
�• y15�Dp.
T030' a < < 4• - « T 1S a MV" ty SG
F1.
a J 1S Q IOWHOW
m. ¢ a d wo !D?-n�uu
a a w w a_Ls 0N00
N �V �
-� 1S VINI aU $ 1S VIMOaI
-_ T AN ONILI" - f
} > y7 5
.S 3NNOAVA Yl -
a. is D w 1SIA 01 $
WS i A
v F o 'S S.A311Vn V
Y
4,1, v a Y 1S S,o a w 1 1S = O w
N
i ,Nti Q qZ
•�,,•• 13
L) w y
• �� +,.•
4 r• ,�.. O •y
WOO'
I m I v in -
C4 m \-
El,SEGUNDO POLICE DEPAR FNIEN"I"
REPORTED PERIOD: JANUARY- JUNE, 2016
PART I &II CRIMES AND/4FWST� BY REPORTING DISTRICT RD)
REPORTING PART I&II rct-UN r/M19b TOTAL VERAGE BY RD
DISTRICT CRIMES ARRESTS _ PERCENTAGE+/-
101 30 13 43 +115%
102 23 38 - ±90%
103 10 6 16 -20%
104 24 14 38 +90%
105 12 6 _ 18 -10%
106 3 2 5 -90%
107 49 19 68 +240%
108 11 7 18 -10%
109 8 4 12 -40%
110 5 0 5 -90%
-�
111 16 10 26 +30%
112 43 16 59 +195%
113 14 7 21 +5%
114 0 0 0 0
115 10 7 17 -15%
116 3 1 4 -80%
201 11 7 18 -10°(o
202 15 8 23 +15A6/o
203 13 8 21 +5%
204 2 2 4 -80%
205 13 8 21 +5%
206 15 6 21 +5%
207 28 13 AL---208 14 5 1 -5%
209 21 9 3 +50%
210 18 12 3 — - +50%
211 13 6 19 -5%
212 8 4 12 -40%
213 11 7 18 -10%
301 9 5 14 -30%
302 5 2 7 -65%
303 6 3 9 -55%
304 2 0 2 -90%
305 3 1 4 -80%
306 10 6 16 -20%
307 11 4 15 -25%
30
_.... ..... 8 28 15 -- 43 - - I +115% _-.._... �
309 9 2 11 -45%
310 7 3 10 -50%
311 8 2 10 -50%
312 6 0 6 -70%
313 1 0 1 -95%
314 1 1 2 -90%
315 5 1 6 -70%
316 5 = 4 9 -55%
317 4 2 6 -70%
318 56 26 82 +310%
319 40 18 58 +190%
320 8 3 11 - -45%
321 6 3 9 -55%
322 3 2 5 -75%
323 5 = 3 8 -60%
TOTALS 601 328 1.009
Number of Reporting Districts=52
Average#of Part I&II Crimes per Reporting District= 13
Average#of Felony/Misdemeanor Part I &II Crime Arrests per Reporting District=6
Average#of Crimes and Arrests per Reporting District=20
(Results from 01/01/2016 through 06/30/2016)
High Crime Area per B&P Code Section 23958.4=?20%
REEGRGSAJ PAGE 8/23/20IG
245
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action regarding authorization for the Police Department to purchase
thirty-five (35) sets of Level III+ rifle body-armor protective plates with related carriers using
Asset Forfeiture Funds. (Fiscal Impact: $37,075)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Authorize the Police Department to purchase thirty-five (35) sets of Level III+rifle body
armor protective plates with related carriers from Galls; and/or,
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
(3)Vendor quotes—Galls, U.S. Armor and First Spear/F.S.O.C. LLC
FISCAL IMPACT: $37,075
Amount Budgeted: $40,800
Additional Appropriation: $
Account Number(s): 109-400-3105-8104
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 2. Support Community Safety and Preparedness
Objectives: 1. El Segundo has a proactive approach to risk and crime
3. El Segundo approaches safety in a financially responsible way
ORIGINATED BY: Raymond Garcia, Lieutenant r..(
REVIEWED BY: Mitch Tavera, Chief of PoliceC�
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
Staff requests approval from Council to utilize existing Asset Forfeiture Funds for the purchase of
thirty-five (35) sets of Level III+ rifle body-armor protective plates with related carriers. Police
personnel currently do not have access to rifle protective body-armor, which is a vital piece of
equipment needed when responding to calls for service involving heavily armed suspects often
seen during active shooter incidents. It is Staff intent to place rifle body-armor kits in all police
vehicles so Police personnel have immediate access to this equipment as needed.
Quotes were obtained from three vendors for the proposed rifle body-armor and related carriers.
All vendors returned quotes for Level III+ rifle body-armor, which can stop rifle rounds from
5.56mm to 7.62mm, which includes the 5.56mm SS109 (green tip armor piercing round). Galls
1
246
provided the most competitive price for their Level III+ stand-alone plates with carriers. For this,
it is recommended the purchase of this protective equipment be made through Galls. If approved,
it is also recommended these rifle body-armor plates and carriers be placed on the Equipment
Replacement schedule with a five-year service life.
247
0 cc) Il- OCO M N M 1001
ct O M r- �
67 p 000 000 0O0 � O O V O
U Cc) F- L() Lj) r !r co- O r-
N
CD Q Q M `- Cl)
= M
ti Z LO 'C
LO CD
_ O r
O W
V Ct�39 � 000 C m = r
O tV N M LLB I" otS O
CL Lai LO LO N F-
L O
CU Lp`0 U Z3 LC
C 7 C () U3 Uc} U3 EA (7
2 0) U
m N Q
O O 0)
U7 C L[) LO L[) O
U Lp Cl) M CO rl-
7
a
c Y
U
co
c M 06 Q
O Y C Q C
LL _
:3 ca O O
U 4? m o
w c.)i
ca U) ca U c. '
d U 0 a
Q
c U
4 H
LL
O rn N rn N U > C N
O J >O J 0 i U
71 L N L m L ul
Z •� Oi Q CL Oi Q- O M L W
V O Q O Q
U) o a o a U a LQ
N Q N Q a) (D w
Q O J O J i
w
29 E o N (B N m `O J 10
0 a_w m U C O O > a O
ti !� N 0 10 cm CL o co
O H M m + m + o
- _
m, a
— C 0 p
o ` O Y a a
N > ' > > Uy >
W= c,, O
-ji >+ �
o
a O
w M>, N Y ^ -0 o
U U
h
Y =
O CD CO cu O m -0
2 w J M m N a CD a U co Q
`Z u
Q� > V V
rte+
~ G=1
Q V V N Y m Y
J J
C) m Y
m
G d � U') O N M O
Z
cm E L O V m N o N LO 00
m Q
0 N H j
U N
248
Ln' U. S. Armor Corporation SALES QUOTE Original
10715 Bloomfield Avenue
Sales Quote No.: 1474
U.S. A R M O R
Santa Fe Springs, CA 90670 Sales Quote Date: 12/14/16
Valid Until: 01/14/17
Customer No.: CAP—ELSE
Customer PO No.:
Page No.: Page 1 of 1
BILL TO SHIP TO
CITY EL SEGUNDO CITY EL SEGUNDO
350 MAIN STREET 350 MAIN STREET
EL SEGUNDO CA 90245 EL SEGUNDO CA 90245
USA USA
Sales Rep.: -No Sales Employee-
Contact Name: ATTN: Ship Via:
Terms: FOB:
Item Nei. Description QTY Unit Price Tota
F-3610-10X12-FC RIFLE PLATE.06 LVL III+ 1 487.00000 $487.00
STAND ALONE SPECTRA
FULL CUT 3610(10X12)
F-3610-10X12 RIFLE PLATE.06 LVL III+ 1 487.00000 $487.00
STAND ALONE SPECTRA
SHOOT CUT 3610(10X12)
F-500316-BLK TACTICAL PLATE CARRIER 1 1 122.00000 $ 122.00
RPC(500 SERIES)-BLACK
Subtotal $ 1,096.00
Shipping
Remarks: CUSTOMER PICK UP; NO FREIGHT CHARGES Tax $98.64
CA SALES TAX NOT INCLUDED Total Quote Value $1,194.64
WC L ' e-// F/2 , yu
?� Fps)
Entered By: usarmor4
Phone: 562-207-4240 Fax: 562-207-4238 E-Mail:%ustomerservice @usarmor.com Website: www.usarmor.q4�)
P r F.S.o.c. Quotation
DATE 1/5/17
803 Eucalyptus Dr QUOTATION:
El Segundo, CA 90245 VALID UNTIL 3/6/17
Phone(424)634-9573
Fax(310)640-6899
Quotation For:
El Segundo Police Department
Attn: Lt. Ray Garcia
SALES REP P.O. NUMBER SHIP DATE SHIP VIA F.O.B. POINT TERMS
Dave Passarell NET 30
QUANTITY DESCRIPTION UNIT PRICE TAXABLE? AMOUNT
35 First Spear CPC Plate Carrier Kit $ 1,129.00 $ 39,515.00
Includes (2) Paraclete 20260 Level III+ 10X12
First Spear CPC Plate Carrier
(2)M4 Speed Reload Pouches
Medical Pouch
Drag Handle
(2)"POLICE" ID Panels
SHIPPING IS INCLUDED
SUBTOTAL $ 39,515.00
TAX RATE 9.00%
SALES TAX 3,556.35
SHIPPING -
TOTAL $ 43,071.35
250
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action regarding the expansion of alcohol service to include
instructional tasting of beer, wine, and distilled spirits (Type 86 ABC License) at a grocery store
at 500 North Sepulveda Boulevard, EA No. 1169, AUP No. 16-12. The project is categorically
exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to
14 California Code of Regulations § 15301 as a Class 1 categorical exemption(Existing Facilities).
Applicant: Ralphs Grocery Company. (Fiscal Impact: N/A)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Receive and file this report for the instructional tasting of beer, wine, and distilled spirits
at an existing grocery store at 500 North Sepulveda Boulevard; and/or
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
1. Crime and Arrest Statistics by Reporting Districts (RD)
2. Police Reporting Districts Map
3. Planning and Building Safety Director Decision Letter Dated January 5, 2017
FISCAL IMPACT: None
Amount Budgeted: N/A
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): N/A
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: Champion Economic Development and Fiscal Sustainability.
Objective: Promotes economic growth and vitality for businesses and the community.
ORIGINATED BY: Gregg McClain, Planning Manager V
REVIEWED BY: Sam Lee, Planning and Building S fety Direr
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Mana 7 1
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
I. Background
In 1995, the City Council directed staff to bring all future Department of Alcoholic Beverage
Control (ABC) licenses to it for review. Based upon that direction, relevant background
information regarding this application is also provided. After the City Council considers the AUP
request, staff will advise ABC of the conclusion of the entitlement process.
17
251
On January 5,2017,the Director of Planning and Building Safety approved an Administrative Use
Permit application(EA-1169, AUP 16-12) for 500 North Sepulveda Boulevard with conditions of
approval, which allows instructional tasting of beer, wine, and distilled spirits at an existing
grocery store (Type 86). Currently, the grocery store is operating under a Type 21 ABC License
which allows for the off-site sale of alcohol. The Planning Commission received and filed the
Director's decision on January 12, 2017.
Under California law, once the Department of Alcohol Beverage Control (ABC) receives an
application for a license, it must notify the applicable local city of the pending application. The
local agency then has 30 days to review and, if applicable, protest the issuance of the license. The
grounds of a protest should relate to public health, safety or welfare concerns. In this case, the
applicant has not yet applied to ABC for the license.
II. Analysis
The application for a license, if approved by the Department of ABC, would modify an existing
AUP (EA-406 and AUP 97-1) to allow instructional tasting of alcoholic beverages at an existing
31,457 square foot grocery store. The instructional tasting of alcoholic beverages is an accessory
use to off-site sale of alcohol under AUP 97-1. No additional on-site consumption of alcohol is
authorized under this AUP. The applicant proposes the following AUP modifications:
a. Add an ABC Type 86 license to allow instructional tasting of beer, wine, and distilled
spirits to their existing Type 21 ABC License to sell the same.
b. Hours of operation for instructional tasting of alcohol to take place between 10 a.m. and 9
p.m. daily.
C. The grocery store will continue to sell alcohol between 6 a.m. and 2 a.m.
According to the most recent crime and arrest statistics report prepared by the Police Department,
the existing grocery store is located in Reporting District(RD) 308. Based on the July—December
2016 data, the district experienced 39 Part I & 11 crimes and 9 felony/misdemeanor arrests. This
represents a rate of crime 167%above the average for the entire City. The Police Department and
the Planning and Building Safety Department do not object to the issuance of the Type 86 ABC
License for the existing grocery store.
The project site is located in the General Commercial (C-3) Zone. The off-site sale of alcohol at
retail establishments requires an administrative use permit in accordance with El Segundo
Municipal Code Section 15-5C-4(A). The instructional tasting of alcohol is an authorized
accessory use to off-site sale of alcohol subject to the approval of an administrative use permit.
The permit was approved by the Director of Planning and Building Safety and the Planning
Commission with appropriate conditions attached.
ABC license review requires mandatory findings that are regulated by ABC,which is independent
of the City's AUP process. ABC is responsible for running a complete background check on all
alcohol license applicants, as well as conducting site inspections,before issuing any type of alcohol
license.
252
III. Environmental Review
The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality
Act (CEQA) pursuant to 14 California Code of Regulations § 15301 as a Class 1 categorical
exemption (Existing Facilities). The project is a request for instructional tasting of alcohol at an
existing grocery store. The approval of an administrative use permit for alcohol at the proposed
grocery store involves a negligible expansion of the existing use, which was previously used as a
restaurant.
IV. Conclusion
Staff recommends that the Council receive and file this report without objecting to the issuance of
a new Type 86 ABC license at 500 Sepulveda Boulevard or alternatively discuss and take another
action related to this item.
253
EL SEGUNDO POLICE DEPARTMENT
REPORTED PERIOD: JULY - DECEMBER, 2016
PART I &II CRIMES AND ARRESTS BY REPORTING pIST XCT (RD
REPORTING PART 1 &11 FELONY/MISD AVELGE BY RD
DISTRICT CRIMES ARRESTS TOTAL PERCENTAGE+/-
101 44 12 56 +211%
102 24 9 - - 33 _ +83%
_ 103 7 4 11 -39%
104 37 6 43 +139%
105 12 3 15 -17%
106 6 1 7 -61%
107 32 8 _ 40 +122%
108 11 6 17 -6%
109 9 0 9 -50%
110 4 1 5 -72%
111 8 4 12 -33%
112 20 8 28 +56%
113 32 3 35 1 +94%
114 0 0 0 0
115 15 5 20 +11%
116 1 0 1 1 -94%
201 11 4 15 ! -17%
202 15 4 19 +6%
203 21 - U 9 - - 30 +67%
204 6 2 8 -56%
295 10 4 14 -22%
206 16 4 20 +11%
207 29 11 40 +122%
208 23 8 31 — +72%
209__ 26 10 36 +100%
210 _ 16 6 _ 22 +22%
211 15 4 19 +6%
212 13 5 18 0%
213 11 3 14 -22%
301 8 2 10 -44%
302 12 4 16 -11%
303 3 2 5 -72%
304 5 2 7 -61%
305 8 3 11 -39%
306 10 2 12 -33%
307 12 I 4 16 -11%
308 39 9 48 +167%
309 11 5 16 -11% _
310 4 0 4 -78%
311 9 3 - 12 -33%
312 _ 6 2 8 -56%
313 0 0 0 0%
314 3 = 1 4 -78%
315 7 4 11 -39%
316 2 1 3 -83%
317 3 2 _ 5 -72%
318 47 14 ,i 61 +239%
319 11 ]_ 44
320 _ 10 4 14 -22%
321 2 1 3 -83%
322 5 2 7 -61%
323 2 1 3 -83%
TOTALS 715 223 938
Number of Reporting Districts =52
Average#of Part I& II Crimes per Reporting District=14
Average#of Felony/Misdemeanor Part I&II Crime Arrests per Reporting District=4
Average#of Crimes and Arrests per Reporting District=18
(Results from 07/0112016 through 12/31/2016) _
High Crime Area per B&P Code Section 23958.4=>20% _
RECORDS/tJ PAGE 1/19/2017
254
ID
rn w z e
LL. W 1 J y fI,1V SIS; ..;.I,�,. o rc c C7 y
0 y J Y W F WY O v E Z H
} O W O 2 W p ) x C {.7
r g q x W
uj
o
o
m M S J1,A'f\ NOIiVlAY 6
� AVM 131480H ¢ <> �
d
LL M M
LA 3AV
w
c' 1S H xSr3 r1G .g SVlonoo I • IS "10"m OON003H
N lR
sndVfVB p M l alo]vap� j
VM
N „ [pd� 1tl1k3NI1N[YJ�-
W - M M&h4NVd Lg3AV�G§ W N 131na r I LL
sndrrv3 y 3 o M yy ' 1S omcN
1S >� u.a a�it�iv� -HSVN M (� =�
< 8,
Or 1S HSVN
O M
O
M is
OA13 ,;,rZkNUN 'J ALLIEDVN
o p r
M rJ o O
¢ is 1dOd�JIV1 - ,n� N M �CD Jw M W
W h is ASIRS p p M M M o M a J
> M M r o'o W
a r x CV -
OA3B tla3A1<Ed3S N
> ftz o = m CIA3€1 tla3Al nd3S S
r
x �
¢ f�t
10 iS 'VNVIONI vg
r- 0 $ N VNo tlIONI s N
¢
f: SIONIIII m
SIONIIII O z
& 15 _7 NOIONIHSVM
w < s ��
¢ a 11S r 4 oa StlSNVN v x
z I N O a a o c14 LL
o _ _� a uJi 1S VI da3i7V3 N
a 1S ^N I VINHOJIlVo O r
w
¢ ° w o `Is a o=N 6400380 3AV'J..,Vd
of
o
z s < y 81S s tlaVA3N CD 3Atll-anvL
u ow
�• T-
T—
1S ¢ d311Vd0 1S d31N3O N a y r -
d0 M0l'VONn9 a °a w w —'
IS Q;IVIAHvyq
` 1S aNV udVIN 00 a w
+ la ' 1S O V11WOl N1S ;. Vllwol
is tldd31S + iS V8831S
LO J
U 1S NN3d 1S NN3d" z
} W } 3 O
f J � S_55311dA9 Noo HS �, 1S MIBIN rc f '"
w on zggi e > �i! -
z s LO u.: p ¢ 4r LEI 1S VN3dV- = 1
a C � r
t !4 w da sn dAlVOn31'
¢. a
1S(V ?l3dd3d Muau+d� ' IS 6 4NV1S�(:
W
O 0 > > > > r 'M Is 8 NIVWNSSF
Y
¢ < ¢ < a m kU
—_ —
4 >r - is a°olYlgfdl a �' I
wo o & oR uw m
1S R. a2iOON0
o
1
VINIdIA i 'S 1S VINIOdIA! �f SnN
l 'ir w
O °x .... 1S r ONLLIHM; .
r'IS 3NNOA }
i$ $ VASEM1 w.,q yM.
w s h LS A311 -
a < o w w I I r
v Y IS .ea. S.3119711H aa r N
g; 1S VUC7C3+, a 'S3ki lllN a 0 W �� obi
LS � �
e� Porn Z P �•
i quT1E Sr i
+fir ZQ
U) m
`---' -
A r
Planning & .wilding Safety Department
Elected Officials: January 5, 2017
Sumnne Fuentes,
Mayor Art Rodriguez &Associates
°rB"mayor P ro Tom
Maayer P ATTN: Alex Campbell
Michael Dugan, 709 East Colorado Boulevard, Suite 200
Council Member Pasadena, CA 91101
Carol Pirsztuk,
Council Member
Dr.Don
Council Member Re: 500 North Sepulveda Boulevard, Administrative Use
Tracy Weaver, Permit No. AUP 16-12
City Clerk
Crista
Chy Tr Dear Mr. Campbell:
City Treasurer
Your request to modify an administrative use permit for a restaurant
Appointed Officials: was APPROVED by the Director of Planning and Building Safety in
GrogCaMenlsr, accordance with El Segundo Municipal Code (ESMC) Chapter 15-22.
City Manager
Ma clWAtrom y The Director approved the expansion of alcohol service for instructional
tasting (ABC type 86 license) at 500 North Sepulveda Boulevard. The
Department Directors: instructional tasting of alcohol is authorized as an accessory use to off-
site sale of alcohol at a retail establishment (ABC type 21 license). This
Joseph a
Finance AUP supersedes the AUP previously issued for the subject property on
nca
Chris Don oven, May 9, 1997 (AUP 97-1). No additional on-site consumption of alcohol
Fire Chief is authorized under this AUP.
Martha D(/katra,
Human RoSaumvs
Debra Brighton, SECTION 1: Administrative Use Permit Findings:
Library Services
Sam Lee,
Planning an and Findina 1: There is compatibility of the particular use on the particular
BuildingSahry site in relationship to other existing and potential uses within the
MHcPifceChier general area in which the use is proposed to be located.
Ken Berkman,
Inforim Public Works 1. The applicant proposes to provide instructional tasting of
M�Recreation&Parks alcoholic beverages at an existing 31,457 square foot grocery
store. The grocery store is located at 500 North Sepulveda
Boulevard. The instructional tasting of alcoholic beverages is an
accessory use to off-site sale of alcohol under AUP 97-1. No
additional on-site consumption of alcohol is authorized under this
www.elsegundo.org AUP.
www.elsegundobusiness.com
256
2. The applicant proposes to provide instructional tasting of alcoholic beverages at
an existing 31,457 square foot grocery store located at 500 North Sepulveda
Boulevard. The instructional tasting is an accessory to sale of alcohol for off-site
consumption approved under AUP 97-1. No additional on-site consumption of
alcohol is authorized under this AUP.
3. The surrounding land uses include: general commercial, hotels, and restaurants.
A grocery store with instructional tasting of alcohol as an accessory use is
compatible with the surrounding uses.
4. The General Plan land use designation for the site is General Commercial. The
zoning for the site is General Commercial (C-3). Retail sales of alcohol is
permitted in the zone with the approval of an Administrative Use Permit.
5. The applicant proposes the following AUP modifications:
a. Add an ABC type 86 license to allow instructional tasting of beer, wine,
and distilled spirits to their existing type 21 license to sell the same.
b. Hours of operation for instructional tasting of alcohol to take place
between 10 a.m. and 9 p.m. daily.
C. The grocery store will continue to sell alcohol between 6 a.m. and 2 a.m.
Findinq 2: The proposed use is consistent and compatible with the purpose of the Zone
in which the site is located.
1. The zoning for the site is General Commercial (C-3). Retail is a permitted use in
this zone pursuant to ESMC §15-5C-2. Instructional tasting of alcohol is an
accessory use which requires an Administrative Use Permit pursuant to ESMC
§15-5C-4.
2. The C-3 Zone is intended to provide for the development of commercial
establishments which serve a broad cross section of the city and surrounding
area. Regulations are designed to promote and control business growth in the
context of surrounding land uses. Principal uses, therefore, include a broad
spectrum of retail and service commercial uses. The proposed use is consistent
with the purpose of the zone in that it will enhance the experience for consumers
that purchase alcohol at the grocery store. The building is currently occupied by a
major grocery retailer which serves the immediate and surrounding areas.
3. The surrounding land uses include: general commercial, a public parking lot,
offices, restaurants, and residential. A retail establishment that provides
instructional tasting of alcohol is compatible with the surrounding uses.
257
Finding 3: The proposed location and use and the conditions under which the use would
be operated or maintained will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare,
or materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity.
1. A major grocery retailer currently occupies the existing building and will continue
to operate as a grocery store.
2. The instructional tasting of alcoholic beverages will occur in a small flex" area of
approximately 25 square feet within the 31,457 square foot sales floor.
3. The hours for the instructional tasting are limited to between 10 a.m. and 9 p.m.
daily.
4. The applicant must abide by all ABC regulations and license restrictions.
Findina 4: Potential impacts that could be generated by the proposed use, such as
noise, smoke, dust, fumes, vibration, odors, traffic, and hazards have been recognized
and mitigated.
1. The instructional tasting of alcohol will not create new impacts that would not be
normally associated with the operation of a grocery store.
Finding 5: The State Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control has issued or will issue
a license to sell alcohol to the applicant.
1. The applicant maintains an active license from the State of California Department
of Alcoholic Beverage Control for off-site sale of alcohol at a retail establishment
(type 21). In addition, the applicant must obtain a separate license for
instructional tasting of alcohol at a retail establishment (type 86) before the
activity may legal commence.
SECTION 2: Environmental Assessment:After considering the above facts and
findings, the Director finds this project is categorically exempt from the requirements of
the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to 14 California Code of
Regulations §15301 as a Class 1 categorical exemption (Existing Facilities). The project
includes minor alterations to the interior of an existing building and a small expansion of
alcohol-related service.
1. The proposed project involves a negligible expansion of use since the grocery
store was previously approved to have alcohol service (off-site sale of beer, wine
and distilled spirits). The proposed expansion of alcohol service to allow for the
instructional trasting will occur in a small "flex" area of approximately 25 square
feet within the 31,457 square foot sales floor. The project involves neglible
expansion of am existing use.
3
258
DIRECTOR OF PLANNING AND BUILDING SAFETY DEPARTMENT ACTION
Based on these findings and facts in support of these findings, the Director of Planning
and Building Safety Department APPROVES the proposed project, subject to the
following conditions:
1. The approval for Environmental Assessment No. EA-1169 and Administrative
Use Permit No. AUP 16-12 supersedes the approval of EA-406 and AUP 97-1
issued on May 9, 1997.
2. The instructional tasting of alcohol is permitted only between the hours of 10 a.m.
and 9 p.m. daily. The sale of alcohol for off-site consumption is permitted only
between the hours of 6 a.m. and 2 a.m. daily. Any change to these hours is
subject to review and approval by the Director of Planning and Building Safety.
3. No additional on-site consumption is authorized at the project site.
4. Any subsequent modification to the floor plan and areas where instructional
tasting events occur must be referred to the Director of Planning and Building
Safety for approval.
5. The applicant must obtain and maintain all licenses required by the Alcoholic
Beverage Control Act (Business & Professions Code §§23000 et seq.). The
applicant must obtain and maintain types 21 and 86 licenses.
6. The grocery store operations must comply with ESMC §§7-2-1, et seq. regulating
noise.
7. The Planning and Building Safety Department and the Police Department must
be notified of any change of ownership of the approved use in writing within 10
days of the completion of the change of ownership.
8. The applicant must comply with all regulations of the Alcoholic Beverage Control
Act and the regulations promulgated by the Alcoholic Beverage Control Board
including, without limitation, the regulations set forth in 4 Cal. Code of Regs. §55,
et seq.
9. There must be no exterior advertising of any kind or type, including advertising
directed to the exterior from within, promoting or indicating the availability of
specific alcoholic beverage products. Interior displays of alcoholic beverages
which are clearly visible to the exterior constitute a violation of this condition.
10. All employees serving alcoholic beverages to patrons must enroll in and
complete a certified training program approved by the State Department of
Alcoholic Beverages Control for the responsible sales of alcohol. The training
must be offered to new employees on not less than a quarterly basis.
4
259
11. Any and all employees hired to sell alcoholic beverages must provide evidence
that they have either:
a. Completed training in ABC- administered Leadership and Education in
Alcohol and Drugs (LEAD) Program as demonstrated by an ABC-issued
certificate; or,
b. Completed an accepted equivalent by ABC to ensure proper distribution of
beer, wine and distilled spirits to adults of legal age. If any prospective
employee designated to sell alcoholic beverages does not currently have
such training, then;
C. The ABC-licensed proprietors must have confirmed with the Planning and
Building Safety Department within 15 days of the Director's decision, or by
final project approval, that a date certain is scheduled within the local ABC
Office to complete the LEAD course.
d. Within 30 days of taking said course, the employees, or responsible
employer must deliver each required certificate showing completion to the
Police Department.
12. The licensee must have readily identifiable personnel to monitor and control the
behavior of customers inside the building premises.
13. Ralphs Grocery Company and New Group — El Segundo LLC agree to indemnify
and hold the City harmless from and against any claim, action, damages, costs
(including, without limitation, attorney's fees), injuries, or liability, arising from the
City's approval of Environmental Assessment No. EA-1169 or Administrative Use
Permit No. AUP 16-12. Should the City be named in any suit, or should any
claim be brought against it by suit or otherwise, whether the same be groundless
or not, arising out of the City approval of EA-1169 or AUP 16-12, the Applicant
and the Property Owners agree to defend the City (at the City's request and with
counsel satisfactory to the City) and will indemnify the City for any judgment
rendered against it or any sums paid out in settlement or otherwise. For purposes
of this section "the City" includes the City of El Segundo's elected officials,
appointed officials, officers, and employees.
5
260
By signing this document, the applicant, Ralphs Grocery Company, c/o Steven Prough,
and the property owner, New Group— El Segundo LLC, c/o William Crigger, certify that
they read, understood, and agree to the Project Conditions listed in this document.
Ralphs Grocery Company, c/o Steven Prough, Applicant
New Group — El Segundo LLC, c/o William Crigger, Property Owner
New Group —El Segundo LLC, c/o Charals Haagen, Property Owner
6
261
PLANNING COMMISSION
This determination is scheduled to be received and filed by the Planning Commission at
its January 12, 2017 meeting. Please be advised that this does not conclude the review
process. The City Council will determine whether or not to protest the approval of the
alcohol permit at its meeting at as of yet undetermined date.
Should you have any questions, please contact Raneika Brooks, Assistant Planner, at
(310) 524-2343.
Sincerely,
m Lee, DiPPlanningand
De m of Building Safety
7
262
K J L_
z�1. �«:Sr.1--414 j - ,fsy'`yr• _.. •.
:] i`;,r y+ .._.. ry III����ORIr. .-..•�� .. r rM1 i'}.
r #. spr III �- �• ll �!' Y � �I .. •,
71 j�j 111
` � '.�r. �� •.f'I ',f a.� -pR �7'p. Gf`}.Ffl�V'-1
4 ti•_i'J y=J r
9
.y ijFjFi 11 I 1 I �,•A _
� � Tom._ r........�., • � -
',~ �.• � �"'�"+-i�. '+° .i�•?'� ''', - Vim.../� i .
rYh `"'erf•.�F•AI� ..01�- i ' r.�;'' fin. 5 k i a ctwc rs .s. .i
`��' FM.rr i .i lira ii i i i t- P •1 ... .. 'n-' ,.-� .
263
..� ` hA
=:. . -;� irk-,�K�e� y .•- � �- ':_ -�1
IY+.
�. ��,�— � • 1114�it' '� � ail .� ! ■ �.
0 '
>«����tt�11•• �
IL
al � � � �\�; -„ =Trn. r fir" �••
!
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action regarding 1) Approval of Examination Plan for Records
Technician. (Fiscal Impact: None)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Approval of Examination Plan for Records Technician.
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
FISCAL IMPACT: None
Amount Budgeted: None
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): None
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 1 Enhance Customer Service & Engagement
Objective: 1 Services are convenient, efficient and user-friendly for all residents
and businesses
ORIGINATED BY: Mayra Houston, Interim Hunan Resources Director 1 A r _
REVIEWED BY: Mayra Houston, Interim Human esources Director
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
At the November 17, 2015 Council Meeting, Council took action to reactivate the Records
Technician classification and to include in the Classification Plan. The Record Technician position
previously assigned to the City Clerk's Office was a part-time position. Examination Plans are not
required for part-time positions. Then, at the September 28, 2016 Council Meeting, Council
adopted Resolution approving the 2016-2017 Final Operating and Capital Improvement Budget
which included converting the part-time Records Technician position to full-time; therefore an
Examination Plan is necessary in order to implement the approved change.
Staff is recommending that the City Council approve the examination plan that contains the
following examination techniques and weights for the Records Technician classification.
18
265
Examination Plan
Records Technician Open Competitive or Promotional
- Written Exam Pass/Fail
- Structured Technical and
Career Preparation Interview Weighted 100%
Approval of exam plans for Merit System job classifications in all City Departments has been
required since the passage of Initiative Ordinance No. 586 in April 1962.
For departments other than Police and Fire, the plan may consist of any one or combination of
the following techniques:
1. Written;
2. Oral;
3. Demonstration; and
4. Any evaluation of education, experience, or skills or physical fitness, which fairly evaluate
the relative capacities of the applicants.
Police and Fire Departments:
The examination plan for entrance or promotional, for the Police and Fire Departments, shall
consist of a written examination and one or more of the following:
1. Oral;
2. Demonstration; and
3. Any evaluation of education certification, experience, or skills or any test of manual skills or
physical fitness, which fairly evaluates the relative capacities of the applicant.
266
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Calendar
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action regarding a request for the expansion of alcohol service (Type
47 ABC License) for a new Kona Grill restaurant located at "The Atrium at Continental Park," at
2321 East Rosecrans Avenue, Suite 1225. (Applicant: Kona Grill Inc.)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Receive and file this report without objecting to the issuance of an alcohol license for the
on-site sale of beer, wine and distilled spirits for on-site consumption at a new restaurant
2321 East Rosecrans Avenue, Suite 1225;
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
1. Crime and Arrest Statistics by Reporting Districts (RD)
2. Police Reporting Districts Map
3. Planning Commission Staff Report dated January 12, 2017, and Attachments
FISCAL IMPACT:
If approved, the proposed project will include a full-service restaurant, resulting in a nominal
increase in sales tax revenue and business license tax revenue.
Amount Budgeted: N/A
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): N/A
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: Champion Economic Development and Fiscal Sustainability.
Objective: Promotes economic growth and vitality for businesses and the community.
ORIGINATED BY: Gregg McClain, Planning Manager C0941
REVIEWED BY: Sam Lee, Planning and Building&f0ty Director
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
I. BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
On January 5, 2017, the Director of Planning and Building Safety approved an
Administrative Use Permit application (EA-1173 and AUP No. 16-14) for 2321 East
Rosecrans Avenue, Suite 1225, with conditions of approval allowing the sale of beer,
wine and distilled spirits for on-site consumption at a new Kona Grill restaurant. The
Director's decision was forwarded to the Planning Commission on January 12, 2017, and
the Planning Commission Received and Filed the Director's decision. Additionally, the
1
267
Planning Commission approved a conditional use permit for the expansion of the existing
outdoor dining area.
Under California law, once the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC)
receives an application for a license, the Department must notify the applicable local city
council, law enforcement agency and planning department. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 23987).
The city council or local agency then has 30 days to review and, if applicable, protest the
issuance of the license. The grounds of a protest, if any, should relate to public health,
safety or welfare concerns. The applicant has not yet filed its application with the
Department of ABC.
In 1995, the City Council directed staff to bring all future Department of ABC licenses to
it for review. Based upon previous Council direction, staff is providing background
information regarding this application.
II. ANALYSIS
The proposed license request, if approved by the Department of ABC, would allow the
sale of beer, wine and distilled spirits for on-site consumption in conjunction with the
operation of a 7,209 square-foot restaurant with a 2,147 square—foot outdoor dining area.
The restaurant will contain 3,453 square feet of indoor dining area. The hours for alcohol
sales will be the same as the hours the restaurant is open, which is from 11:00 a.m. to
1:00 a.m., seven days per week.
According to the most recent Crime and Arrest report prepared by the Police Department,
the proposed restaurant is located in Reporting District 319. Based on the January— June
2016 data, the district had a total of 33 Part I & II crimes and 11 felony/misdemeanor
arrests. This district is 144% higher than the City's average. The Police Department and
the Planning and Building Safety Department do not object to the issuance of the Type 47
ABC License for the new restaurant.
Kona Grill will be located at an existing tenant space previously operated by Romano's
Macaroni Grill. Restaurants are permitted in the MU-S zone in accordance with ESMC
§15-5F-2(I). The on-site sale and consumption of beer, wine and distilled spirits at a
restaurant requires the approval of an administrative use permit in accordance with
ESMC §15-5F-4(C). The outdoor dining area which is more than 200 square feet required
a conditional use permit pursuant to ESMC §15-5F-5(I).
ABC license review requires mandatory findings that are regulated by ABC. The City's
AUP process is separate. ABC is responsible for running a complete background check
on all alcohol license applicants, as well as conducting site inspections, before issuing
any type of alcohol license.
2
268
III. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
The proposed project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California
Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to 14 California Code of Regulations
§15301 as a Class 1 categorical exemption (Existing Facilities), and §15303 as a Class 3
categorical exemption (New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures). The
project includes a negligible expansion of an existing use.
IV. CONCLUSION
Planning staff recommends that Council receive and file the Director's determination
without objecting to the issuance of a Type 47 ABC license at a new restaurant at 2321
East Rosecrans Avenue, Suite 1225.
3
269
EL SEGUNDO POL[CE DLPAR'rAILNT
REPORTED PERIOD: JULY — DECEMBER, 2016
PART I &II GRIM S AND RRIISTS BY REPORTING DIST XCT RD
ll _
RtPUR i iNU PART 111 FEL YIMISD TOTAL IVERAGE BY RD
DISTRICT CRIMES ARRESTS PERCENTAGE+/-
101 44 12 56 +211%
102 24 9 33 +83%
103 7 4 11 -39%
104 37 6 43 +139%
105 12 3 15 -17%
106 6 1 7 -61%
107 32 8 40 +122%
108 11 6 17 6%
109 9 0 9 A
110 4 1 5 -72°9
111 8 4 12 -33%
112 20 8 28 +56%
113 1 32 3 3.5 +94%
114 0 0 0 0
115 15 5 20 +11%
116 1 0 1 -94%
201 11 4 15 -17%
202 15 4 19 +6%
203 21 _9 30 +67%
204 6 2 8 -56%
205 10 4 14 -22%
206 16 4 20 +11%
207 29 11 40 +122%
208 23 8 31 1 +72%
209 26 10 36 +100%
210 16 6 22 +22%
211 15 4 19 +6%
212 13 5 18 0%
213 11 3 14 -22%9
301 8 2 10 -44°�°
I 302 12 4 16 -11%
303 3 2 5 -72�°
304 5 2 7 -61%p
305 8 3 11 -39%
�0 10 2 12 -33%
30� 12 4 16 -11%
308 39 9 48 1 +167%
309 11 5 16 -11%
310 4 0 4 -78%
311 9 9 12 -33%
311 6 2 8 -56%
313 0 0 0 0% _
314 3 1 4 -78%
315 7 4 11 -39%
316 2 1 3 -83%
317 3 2 5 -72%
318 47 14 61 1 +239%
319 33 11 44 +144%
320 10 4 14 -22%
321 2 1 3 -83%
322 5 2 7 -61%
323 2 1 _ 3 -83%
TOTLL_j 715 223 938
Number of Reporting Districts=52
Average#of Part I&II Crimes per Reporting District= 14
Average#of Felony/Misdemeanor Part I&II Crime Arrests per Reporting District=4
Average#of Crimes and Arrests per Reporting District= 18
(Results from 07/01/2016 through 12/31/2016)
High Crime Area per B&P Code Section 23958.4=>20%
RE00ROS/EJ PAGE 1/19/2017
270
• I cv I m—• I a f m — — —•i
rn s I w
O w y 3nV SISI 00L4 ; a a
U) J w r w Y O o O E U)y O w o z wrc� y x °e� zu
� x v a �p O F
a
LU
m V
M Nouviny
0n19 a
�
AVM i3N80H
M a
5
Q
R °u °x r• 5 a p
3nv
1S '"isva os ` SV10n00' N a is S'dlOn00 ' OON003a
SndVMD LL p N }llaMOO -
-
C'4 .MWC Ha p - CV) M AVM avu MINoa
LL M p A.,7A9[tl5j fs-,wr,A.y�,nNJ mina T- LL
d SndRY3 r V; M /' -
�L3�} 1£ Ol10dV
1S t a ar�i mau�nuiryn
HSVN
a el • , M
M N �D
p ' r
IS HSVN
C)
o r OAl9 - 1u�SN3NI.lf;03 A11JMWY
p ,..
M 3. 0 00
a 1S 91laOdalVl' 00 r u; I r
w r 1" M
15 A$335
C C M CO) M o� M 0.uws a w
w M M r 00 J
OA19 V03Alnd3S N N ° _-
-' ¢ ° ., ^ < fJA�B Y[33n1fId3S s
0 Z r
_ to N
x
p tlNtlIONI < 10 ig %VNVIONI �� to ar
N
N w
slows ' .a
1S y NOI NIHSVM 1S .& a SIONITII O
� y 4
Z - 1S a, $ SVSNV3 im x
oN E,ryN- a w <
v 1S `� = is M at:7dllY0 N
Z iN VINaOdIIVD
iS w oN y IW03a0
w a J Wo 00 $ 3�5V OIdIaVd
U Z Q
Z 8 < o rS1S w V0VA3N r
w," 3AV*�81►V1
p is ¢j a31N30 is a31N30 i s y r
° a0 M01VONnB
s = 15 ❑dtllAaVA _z
AS ONtllAathV °tl I � u, w
•
to As p Vllwol N 1S ; Vllwol
ova av °•° is tlaa3ls d .,, J
is Mills
U
is z r. NN3d r O U
" ¢ D0f 1S NN3d r
� E. _ z � z
w
SS3ad.A0 NOOl3H5: ° 1S 5i0(I13NS °
w °
p ¢ 1S VN3'dV W _
V
r rb3 as sn dArran3
> �
ff1 _ ¢ a
ex is N a3dd3d aairla� - is 0 ONVLS
co N0
� � SP 4R
�.& 030 ¢ ¢ a _ T .v IIS NIVW N`Jl3
P
ILS 0 �Wi•1'Jikl
a w
0800NOJ�� �}�55
° 1S VINI 81A 5 $ 1S VINI°Jaln J,•, �r°,° „�
✓r tj s ca.< 9,
ONUIRM Nb
y 1 �
_ !-ILS 3NNOAtl —
°°” 15 °g �.. ...�.
07
SA3TIVA
a 0 z
Ya is [S3d:Yffl4 !' N
• ¢ 3 w § o a 0 z fin. ..� W _�sf F o
°r. 1S V{700: 31i i11H `" a it 0 W �.'�s� c�si
.e..�. O ••, u
} z ` tE ice.•'" i, p a
ss 4 a
0.
N
EL SEGUNDO PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING DATE: January 12,2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: New Business
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action regarding approval of
1. Environmental Assessment No. EA-1173;
2. Administrative Use Permit No. AUP 16-14: A modification to allow the expansion of a
previously-approved AUP for the sale of beer, wine and distilled spirits for onsite
consumption at a restaurant; and
3. Conditional Use Permit No. CUP 16-06:, A Conditional Use Permit to allow for the
expansion of an existing outdoor dining area.
The project site is at"The Atrium at Continental Park," located at 2321 East Rosecrans Avenue,
Suite 1225, in the Urban Mixed-Use South(MU-S) zone.The applicant is: Kona Grill Inc.
RECOMMENDED PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION: It is recommended that the
Planning Commission:
1. Receive and File the Director's determination approving Administrative Use Permit No.
AUP 16-14;
2. Open the public hearing, receive testimony, close the public hearing, consider the
evidence, and then adopt Resolution No. 2807 approving Environmental Assessment No.
EA-1173, and Conditional Use Permit No. CUP 16-06.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
1. Draft Planning Commission Resolution No. 2807
A. Conditions of Approval
2. Plans
3. Administrative Use Permit approval letter dated January 5,2017
ORIGINATED BY: Maria Baldernegro,Assistant Planner fXI�
REVIEWED BY: Paul Samaras, Principal Planner
REVIEWED BY: Gregg McClain,Planning Manager
APPROVED BY: Sam Lee,Director of Planning and Building Safety
I. INTRODUCTION
The proposed project is a request to modify a previously-approved Administrative Use
Permit to allow the expansion of alcohol service for a new Kona Chill restaurant, and a
Conditional Use Permit for the expansion of an existing outdoor dining area which is
greater than 200 square feet.
1
272
II. BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
Background
On October 12, 2016, applications for a Conditional Use Permit and Administrative Use
Permit were submitted to the Planning and Building Safety Department.
The project site is in the Urban Mixed Use South (MU-S) zone, and is located on the
block bounded by Douglas Street to the west, Continental Circle to the north and east,
and Rosecrans Avenue to the south. The site is surrounded by commercial offices, a
financial institution,retail,restaurants, a private gym, and a hotel.
The surrounding land uses are summarized in the following table:
SURROUNDING LAND USES
Direction Land Uses Zone
Parking Structure
North Hotel Urban Mixed Use South(MU-S)
Restaurant
East Office Urban Mixed Use South(MU-S)
Restaurant
Office
South Retail City of Manhattan Beach
Restaurants
Office
Retail
West Financial Institution Urban Mixed Use South(MU-S)
Gym
Restaurants
Discussion
Kona Grill will be located at an existing tenant space previously operated by Romano's
Macaroni Grill. The restaurant is 7,209 square feet and contains a 1,538 square-foot
outdoor dining area. The applicant proposes the sale of beer, wine, and distilled spirits for
on-site consumption for the indoor and outdoor dining areas, which requires an AUP
pursuant to ESMC § 15-5F-4(C). The restaurant will be remodeled and contain 3,453
square feet of indoor dining with 160 seats. The outdoor dining area will be expanded by
609 square feet to a total of 2,147 with 106 seats. The outdoor dining area is more than
200 square feet,which requires a CUP pursuant to ESMC § 15-517-5(1).
The proposed hours of operation for the restaurant are from 11:00 am to 1:00 am, seven
days a week. A full service menu will be available during the hours of operation of the
restaurant and no live entertainment or dancing is proposed.
2
273
The applicant will apply for a Type 47 Alcohol Beverage Control (ABC) license. A Type
47 ABC License allows for the service of beer, wine and distilled spirits in conjunction
with a bona fide eating place. The applicant must obtain the license from the California
Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control prior to serving alcohol at the restaurant.
III. ANALYSIS
Zoning consistency
The proposed restaurant, outdoor dining area and operations will be consistent with the
ESMC requirements in the MU-S Zone, including but not limited to parking, floor area
ratio, setbacks, screening and outdoor dining. The following table contains the
development standards for the MU-S zone.
Zoning Consistency
ESMC Standard Urban Mixed Use South(MU-S) Proposed
Permitted Uses Restaurants Restaurant
15-5F-5(I) Alcohol (AUP) AUP for Alcohol
Outdoor dining>20% CUP for outdoor dining
of total dining area(CUP) (38% of total dining area)
Complies
Lot Area Minimum 10,000 square feet 289,435 square feet.
15-5F-8(B) Complies
Height Maximum 175 feet 26 feet
15-5F-8(C) Complies
Setbacks Front: 20 feet and 30 feet facing Front:50'-5"to the building
15-5F-8(D) Rosecrans Avenue. (Minimum 5' and 28'-4"to the outdoor
distance for outdoor dining area.) dining area
Interior Side Yard: 20 feet Side (east): 106 feet
Street Side Yard: 20 feet Side (west): 26 feet
Rear: 5 feet Rear: 5 feet
Landscaping Setbacks and 5% of vehicle use areas Not applicable
15-517-9 and
15-2-14.
Non-dining areas: 1 space/250 sf 2,184 sf= 9 spaces
Parking Indoor dining areas: 1 space/75 sf 3,453 sf=46 spaces
15-15-6 Outdoor dining areas: 1 space/75sf 2,147 sf= 26 spaces
(200 square feet exempt) Total: 81 spaces
Complies*
* The proposed restaurant is part of a larger development where parking is shared
among multiple uses.
3
274
Parking
The site contains 272,304 square feet of office and 20,099 square feet of restaurant use
areas, both of which are permitted in the MU-S zone. The total proposed restaurant areas,
including all indoor and outdoor dining, kitchens and other usable areas is 20,708 square
feet. The overall development requires 905 spaces and 1,011 are provided, which results
in a surplus of 106 spaces. The parking breakdown for the entire site is as follows:
Parking for The Atrium at Continental Park
Use Square feet Parking Spaces
Ratio Required
Office 1`25,000 25,000 1/300 84
2nd 25,000 25,000 1/350 72
remaining 222,304 1/400 556
712
Restaurant Restrooms&
(Kona Grill) mechanical: 1,094 None 9
Non-dining: 2,184 1/250 46
Indoor dining: 3,453 1/75 26
Outdoor dining: 2,147 1/75 81
(200 sf exempt)
Restaurant Non-dining: 4,658 1 space/250 19
(Flemings Steakhouse) Indoor dining: 4,827 1 space/75 64
Outdoor dining: 1,538 1 space/75 29
(200 sf exempt) 112
Total 289,607 905
(1,011 provided)
General Plan Consistency
The General Plan Land Use Designation of the site is Urban Mixed-Use South. The
proposed project is consistent with the Goals and Policies of the General Plan as specified
in the attached Approval Letter and Resolution.
Administrative Use Permit
The project includes a request to expand service of alcohol in conjunction with a new
restaurant. The Director of Planning and Building Safety may grant an Administrative
Use Permit upon making the findings in ESMC §15-22-5. The Director made the
necessary findings to grant the AUP subject to the conditions of approval in the attached
approval letter dated January 5, 2017. Pursuant to ESMC § 15-22-7, staff recommends
that the Planning Commission receive and file the Director's determination.
Conditional Use Permit
4
275
The project includes a request to expand an existing outdoor dining area, which exceeds
200 square feet of outdoor dining area. Pursuant to El Segundo Municipal Code § 15-23-
4, the Planning Commission is authorized to grant a conditional use permit if it makes
three specific findings listed in §15-23-6(A). The required findings are: 1) The proposed
location of the conditional use permit is in accord with the objectives of the ESMC and
the purposes of the zone in which the Property is located; 2)The proposed location of the
conditional use and the conditions under which it would be operated or maintained will
not be detrimental to the public health, safety or welfare, or materially injurious to
properties or improvements in the vicinity; and 3) The proposed conditional use permit
will comply with each of the applicable provisions of Title 15. Facts in support of said
findings are outlined in the attached resolution of approval.
Staff believes that there is adequate evidence to support the three required conditional use
permit findings subject to the listed conditions of approval in the attached resolution. The
Planning Commission may consider and impose additional conditions which it deems
necessary if it demonstrates a reasonable relationship between the condition it desires to
impose and the project's impacts.
IV. INTER-DEPARTMENTAL COMMENTS
Comments from other departments were incorporated into Resolution No. 2807.
V. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
The proposed project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California
Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to 14 California Code of Regulations
§15301 as a Class 1 categorical exemption (Existing Facilities), and §15303 as a Class 3
categorical exemption (New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures). The
project includes minor alterations to an existing building, the expansion of alcohol
service for a restaurant with an outdoor dining area, and the expansion of an existing
outdoor dining area. The adoption of the Resolution approves a Conditional Use Permit
for the expansion of the existing outdoor dining area, which is a negligible expansion of
an existing use.
VI. RECOMMENDATION
Planning staff recommends that the Planning Commission Receive and File the
Director's determination approving Administrative Use Permit No. AUP 16-14, and
adopt Resolution No. 2807 approving Environmental Assessment No. EA-1173 and
Conditional Use Permit No. CUP 16-06.
5
276
RESOLUTION NO. 2807
A RESOLUTION APPROVING ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT NO.
EA-1173 FOR CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 16-06 FOR THE
EXPANSION OF AN OUTDOOR DINING AREA FOR A RESTAURANT
LOCATED AT 2321 EAST ROSECRANS AVENUE, SUITE 1225.
The Planning Commission of the City of El Segundo does resolve as follows:
SECTION 1: The Commission finds and declares that:
A. On October 17, 2016, Kona Grill Inc. filed an application for Environmental
Assessment No. EA-1173 for Conditional Use Permit No. CUP 16-06 for the
expansion of an outdoor dining area for a restaurant located at 2321 East
Rosecrans Avenue, Suite 1225;
B. The application was reviewed by the City's Planning and Building Safety
Department for, in part, consistency with the General Plan and conformity with
the El Segundo Municipal Code ("ESMC");
C. In addition, the City reviewed the project's environmental impacts under the
California Environmental Quality Act (Public Resources Code §§ 21000, et
seq., "CEQA"), the regulations promulgated thereunder (14 Cal. Code of
Regulations §§15000, et seq., the "CEQA Guidelines"), and the City's
Environmental Guidelines(City Council Resolution No. 3805, adopted March
16, 1993);
D. The Planning and Building Safety Department completed its review and
scheduled a public hearing regarding the application before this Commission
for January 12, 2017;
E. On January 5, 2017,the Director of Planning and Building Safety Department
made the required findings for the approval of an Administrative Use Permit in
accordance with ESMC §15-22-5A for the on-site sale and consumption of
alcohol at a restaurant which includes an outdoor dining area;
F. On January 12,2017,the Commission held a public hearing to receive public
testimony and other evidence regarding the application including, without
limitation, information provided to the Commission by the applicant; and
G. The Commission considered the information provided by City staff, public
testimony, and the applicant. This Resolution, and its findings, are made, in
part, based upon the evidence presented to the Commission at its January
12, 2017 public hearing including,without limitation,the staff report submitted
by the Planning and Building Safety Department.
SECTION 2: Factual Findings and Conclusions. The Commission finds that the following
facts exist:
277
A. The subject site is located in the Urban Mixed-Use South (MU-S)zone within
the Atrium at Continental Park development located at 2321 East Rosecrans
Avenue, Suite 1225. The existing development, "The Atrium at Continental
Park" contains commercial office, retail, restaurants and a hotel.
B. The subject site is developed with two 5-story buildings and a 5-story parking
structure. The site contains a total of 293,084 square feet of office and
restaurant uses with 1,011 parking spaces.
C. The site is bounded by Douglas Street to the west, Continental Circle to the
north and east, and Rosecrans Avenue to the south.
D. The proposed restaurant, Kona Grill, will be located at an existing tenant
space that was previously operated by Romano's Macaroni Grill. The existing
tenant space for the restaurant is 7,209 square feet and contains a 1,538
square-foot outdoor patio area.
E. The applicant requests a Type 47 ABC license to allow the sale of beer,wine,
and distilled spirits for on-site consumption at a new restaurant with interior
and outdoor seating for dining, which requires the approval of an
Administrative Use Permit, pursuant to ESMC § 15-5F-4(C).
F. The applicant proposes a 609 square-foot expansion to the existing outdoor
dining area, which will total 2,147 square feet, and requires 9 additional
parking spaces.A Conditional Use Permit is required for the expansion of the
outdoor dining area which exceeds 20%of the total interior dining area of the
restaurant, pursuant to ESMC § 15-5F-5(I).
G. Interior tenant improvements are proposed which will modify the existing
seating area for dining within the restaurant.The proposed interior dining area
for the restaurant will contain 160 seats and the outdoor dining area will
contain 106 seats.A combined total floor area for dining is 5,600 square feet
with 266 seats and will include alcohol service.
H. The subject site was approved with 1,011 parking spaces and 905 parking
spaces are required for the proposed project.
1. The proposed hours of operation for the restaurant are from 11:00 am to 1:00
am, seven days a week. The hours of the outdoor dining area and sale of
alcohol for on-site consumption of beer, wine and distilled spirits will be the
same as the restaurant. A full food service menu will be available during the
hours of operation of the restaurant and no live entertainment or dancing is
proposed.
SECTION 3: Environmental Assessment. The adoption of this Resolution is categorically
exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act(CEQA)pursuant
to 14 California Code of Regulations § 15301 as a Class 1 categorical exemption (Existing
2
278
Facilities), and § 15303 as a Class 3 categorical exemption (New Construction or
Conversion of Small Structures). The project includes minor alterations to an existing
building, the expansion of alcohol service for a restaurant with an outdoor dining area, and
the expansion of an existing outdoor dining area.The adoption of this Resolution approves
a Conditional Use Permit for the expansion of the existing outdoor dining area, which is a
negligible expansion of an existing use.
SECT10N 4: General Plan. The proposed project is consistent with the City's General Plan
as follows:
A. The El Segundo General Plan Land Use designation of the property is Urban
Mixed-Use South. This Land Use designation permits a mixture of office,
research and development, retail, and hotel uses.
B. The current zoning of the site is Urban Mixed Use South (MU-S) and is
consistent with the land use designation of the property. It is the intent to have
several types of uses occupy each building located in this zoning district and
the subject site contains commercial offices, restaurants with outdoor dining
areas, and parking.
C. The proposed use is consistent with Land Use Element Goal LU4 in that it
provides a stable tax base for the City through development of new
commercial uses, primarily within a mixed-use environment,without adversely
affecting the viability of Downtown.
D. The proposed use is consistent with Land Use Element Objective LU4-1 in
that it promotes the development of high quality retail facilities in proximity to
major employment centers.
E. The proposed use is consistent with Land Use Element Objective LU4-4 in
that it adds to the mixture of uses, which has the potential to maximize
economic benefit, reduce traffic impacts, and encourage pedestrian
environment.
F. Policies ED1-2.1 and ED1-2.2, both seek to promote land uses, which
improve the City's retail and commercial tax base.The proposed new outdoor
dining area and expansion of alcohol service for an existing restaurant would
contribute in generating an increase in tax revenue and would financially
benefit the City.
G. Implementation of the proposed project will meet relevant goals and policies
with regard to the Land Use Element. The project will help increase the tax
base through the proposed expansion of an existing outdoor dining area, and
the approval of alcohol service for a new restaurant without adversely
affecting the viability of downtown (Goal LU4).
H. The surrounding land uses include:commercial offices, retail, restaurants with
outdoor dining, a financial institution, a private gym, and a hotel. The
3
279
proposed expansion to the outdoor dining area will be compatible with the
surrounding uses.
SECTION 6: Conditional Use Permit Findings. After considering the above facts, the
Commission finds as follows:
A. The proposed location of the conditional use is in accord with the objectives of
the Zoning Code and the purposes of the zone in which the site is located.
The zoning designation of the property is Urban Mixed Use South(MU-S). This
zoning district allows outdoor dining areas which exceed 200 square feet or
20% of the indoor dining area with the approval of a conditional use permit,
pursuant to ESMC § 15-5F-5(I). This zoning district permits a mixture of
commercial offices, research and development, retail, restaurant and hotel
uses. The tenant space for the proposed restaurant is currently vacant and
within the Atrium Continental Park development. The tenant space was
previously used as a restaurant and contains an outdoor dining area. The
proposed outdoor dining area expansion is appropriate for this site.The site is
located in an area that is surrounded by commercial offices, retail, restaurants
with outdoor dining, a financial institution, a private gym, a hotel, and is in
accord with the objectives of the zoning district in which the site is located.
B. That the proposed location of the conditional use and the conditions under
which it would be operated or maintained will not be detrimental to the public
health, safety or welfare, or materially injurious to properties or improvements
in the vicinity.
The proposed outdoor dining area expansion is adjacent to the restaurant and
is located on the southeast side of the existing patio. The site is surrounded
by commercial offices, retail, restaurants with outdoor dining, a financial
institution, a private gym, and a hotel. Outdoor dining activities are not
anticipated to be detrimental to adjacent businesses and no residential uses
are located in the immediate vicinity. The proposed outdoor dining area
expansion is subject to the conditions listed in the attached Exhibit A. The
proposed location of the project under the conditions in which it will be
operated will not be detrimental to the public health, safety or welfare, or
materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity.
C. That the proposed conditional use will comply with each of the applicable
provisions of this Chapter.
The proposed conditional use complies with the applicable provisions of
ESMC Chapters 15-23 and 15-27 since proper notice was provided and
proper hearing was conducted on January 12, 2017. In addition, proper
hearing decision and records will be complied with, and the required findings
will be considered. The proposed project meets all of the current ESMC
requirements.
4
280
SECTION 7: Approval. Subject to the conditions listed on the attached Exhibit°A,"which
are incorporated into this Resolution by reference, the Planning Commission approves
Environmental Assessment No. EA-1173 and Conditional Use Permit No. CUP 16-03.
SECTION 8: Reliance On Record. Each and every one of the findings and determination in
this Resolution are based on the competent and substantial evidence, both oral and written,
contained in the entire record relating to the project. The findings and determinations
constitute the independent findings and determinations of the Planning Commission in all
respects and are fully and completely supported by substantial evidence in the record as a
whole.
SECTION 9: Limitations. The Planning Commission's analysis and evaluation of the project
is based on information available at the time of the decision. It is inevitable that in evaluating
a project that absolute and perfect knowledge of all possible aspects of the project will not
exist. In all instances, best efforts have been made to form accurate assumptions.
SECTION 10: This Resolution will remain effective unless superseded by a subsequent
resolution.
SECTION 11: The Commission Secretary is directed to mail a copy of this Resolution to
Kona Grill Inc. and Continental Atrium Corporation, and to any other person requesting a
copy.
SECTION 12: This Resolution may be appealed within ten (10) calendar days after its
adoption. All appeals must be in writing and filed with the City Clerk within this time period.
Failure to file a timely written appeal will constitute a waiver of any right of appeal.
5
281
SECTION 13- Except as provided in Section 12, this Resolution is the Commission's final
decision and will become effective immediately upon adoption.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 12th day of January, 2017.
Ryan Baldino, Chair
City of El Segundo Planning Commission
ATTEST:
Sam Lee, Secretary
Baldino -
Newman -
Nicol -
Nisley -
Wingate -
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Mark D. Hensley, City Attorney
By:
David King, Assistant City Attorney
6
282
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 2807
Exhibit A
CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
In addition to all applicable provisions of the El Segundo Municipal Code ("ESMC"),
Continental Atrium Corporation agrees to comply with the following provisions as conditions
for the City of El Segundo's approval of Environmental Assessment No. EA-1173 and
Conditional Use Permit No. 16-06 ("Project Conditions"):
Zonina Conditions
1. This approval is for the project as shown on the plans reviewed and approved by the
Planning Commission on file. Before the City issues a building permit, the applicant
must submit plans, showing that the project substantially complies with the plans and
conditions of approval on file with the Planning and Building Safety Department. Any
subsequent modification must be referred to the Planning and Building Safety
Director for a determination regarding the need for Planning Commission review and
approval of the proposed modification.
2. The outdoor dining area will be limited to 2,147 square and must comply with all
requirements of ESMC § 15-2-16.
3. The hours of operation for the restaurant and sale of alcoholic beverages for on-site
consumption will be limited to 11:00 am to 1:00 am, seven days a week. A full
service menu will be required during the hours of operation of the restaurant. Any
change to the hours of operation or the hours that alcohol may be served is subject
to review and approval by the Director of Planning and Building Safety.
4. No live entertainment is permitted at the restaurant or the outdoor dining area.
5. Pursuant to ESMC §15-23-11(13)(1), this conditional use permit expires 24 months
after its approval if the use does not commence or construction does not commence
under a valid building permit. The City is not responsible for informing the applicant
regarding a pending CUP expiration.
Building Safety Conditions
6. Before the City issues building permits, the applicant must obtain Los Angeles
County Health Department approval.
7. Before the City issues building permits the applicant must comply with all applicable
building codes.
8. Before the City issues building permits the applicant must comply with all access,
ingress and egress, and walkway widths pursuant to a report completed by a
Certified Access Specialist (CASp) as determined by the City Building Official.
7
283
Fire Der)artment Conditions.
9. The applicant must comply with applicable California Fire Code requirements and El
Segundo Fire Department regulations.
Public Works Department Conditions
10. The project must comply with the latest NPDES requirements and must provide Best
Management Practices (BMP's) for sediment control, construction material control
and erosion control.
Miscellaneous Conditions
11. Kona Grill Inc. and Continental Atrium Corporation agree to indemnify and hold the
City harmless from and against any claim, action, damages, costs(including,without
limitation, attorney's fees), injuries, or liability, arising from the City's approval of
Environmental Assessment No. EA-1173 and Conditional Use Permit No. CUP 16-
06. Should the City be named in any suit, or should any claim be brought against it
by suit or otherwise, whether the same be groundless or not, arising out of the City
approval of Environmental Assessment No. EA-1173 and Conditional Use Permit No.
CUP 16-06,the Applicant and Property Owner agree to defend the City(at the City's
request and with counsel satisfactory to the City) and will indemnify the City for any
judgment rendered against it or any sums paid out in settlement or otherwise. For
purposes of this section"the City"includes the City of El Segundo's elected officials,
appointed officials, officers, and employees.
By signing this document, Kona Grill Inc. and Continental Atrium Corporation certify that
they have read, understood, and agree to the Project Conditions listed in this document.
Christi Hing, Treasurer and Secretary (Applicant)
Kona Grill Inc., an Arizona Corporation
Alex J. Rose, Vice President-Development (Property Owner)
Continental Atrium Corporation, a California limited liability company
{If Corporation or similar entity,needs two officer signatures or evidence that one signature binds the
company)
8 284
•
Planning & Building Safety Department
January 5, 2017
Jason Smith
Landshark Development Services Group
Elected Officials: 1641 W. Collins Avenue
Suzanne Fuentes, Orange, CA 92867
Mayor
Drew Boyles,
Mich el DuganTem RE: Environmental Assessment No. EA-1173 for Administrative Use Permit
Council PintzMember
No. AUP 16-14.
Carol P/rsztuk,
Council Member
Dr.Don Brann,
Council Member
Tracy Weavereaver,, Address: 2321 East Rosecrans Avenue, Suite 1225, g El Segundo, CA 90245
City Clerk
Crisis Binder,
City Treasurer Dear Mr. Smith:
Appointed officials: Your request to modify a previously-approved administrative use permit for a
Grogcarpente, restaurant was APPROVED by the Director of Planning and Building Safety
City Manager
Mark D.Hensley, Department in accordance with El Segundo Municipal Code("ESMC") Chapter
C1tyAttomey 15-22. The Director approved the expansion of alcohol service for on-site sale
and consumption of alcohol (beer, wine, and distilled spirits)for the indoor and
Department Directors: outdoor dining area of a restaurant located at 2321 East Rosecrans Avenue,
JosephUlla, Suite 1225.
Finance
Chris Donovan,
Fire Chief
I/ksfra
Martha D , SECTION 1: Administrative Use Permit Findings:
human Resources
Debra Brighton, The following are the facts in support of each finding for this decision:
Ubrary Services
Sam Lee,
Planning& Finding 1
Building safety
Mitch Tavern,
FW1"Chief
KenB°,h-1 There is compatibility of the particular use on the particular site in
tn[uNm Public Works
MeredithPetll, relationship to other existing and potential uses within the general area in
Recreation&Parks
which the use is proposed to be located.
Facts in Support of Finding 1
www.elseaundo.ora 1. The applicant proposes the expansion of on-site sale and consumption of
alcohol (beer, wine, and distilled spirits) for the interior and outdoor dining
area of a new restaurant (Kona Grill).
2. The proposed restaurant is 7,209 square feet and the interior floor area for
dining is 3,453 square feet will contain 160 seats. The existing outdoor
dining area is 1,538 square feet and will be expanded by 609 square feet
bringing the patio to 2,147 square feet containing 106 seats for dining.
350 Main Street, El Segundo, California 90245-3813
Phone(310)524-2380 FAX(310)322-4167 285
3. The surrounding land uses include: commercial office, retail, restaurants with
outdoor dining, a financial institution, a private gym, and a hotel. Other existing
restaurants and uses in the general area sell alcohol for onsite consumption. The
proposed alcohol service for the interior and outdoor dining area of the restaurant
will be compatible with the surrounding uses.
4. The proposed hours of operation for the restaurant are from 11:00 am to 1:00 am,
seven days a week. Alcohol service is proposed during the same hours as those
of the restaurant. A full food service menu will be available during the hours of
operation of the restaurant and no live entertainment or dancing is proposed. The
proposed hours for alcohol service at the restaurant are not anticipated to be
detrimental to adjacent businesses, and no residential uses are located in the
vicinity.
5. Alcohol service for the proposed outdoor dining area expansion for the new
restaurant, requires an Administrative Use Permit in accordance with ESMC § 15-
5F-4C and 15-22-5A. The restaurant must also obtain and maintain the State of
California Beverage Control (ABC) Type 47 license in accordance with ESMC§15-
22-5B.
6. The minimum number of required parking spaces for the restaurant and outdoor
dining area is 81 parking spaces.The proposed project at the Atrium at Continental
Park development is required a total of 905 parking spaces, a total of 1,011 parking
spaces are provided, and 106 surplus spaces are available at the site.
7. The property contains an existing restaurant which will be remodeled for a new
occupant. The applicant proposes modifications to the existing AUP (EA-605 and
AUP 02-03). The proposed expansion of alcohol service for a new restaurant is a
minor modification to an existing approved use.
Finding 2
■ The proposed use is consistent and compatible with the purpose of the Zone in
which the site is located.
Facts in Support of Finding 2
1. The General Plan Land Use designation for the site is Urban Mixed-Use South.
2. The Urban-Mixed-Use South Land Use permits a mixture of office, research and
development, retail, and hotel uses.
3. The Urban Mixed Use South (MU-S) zone is established to provide area(s)where
a mixture of compatible offices, research and development, retail, and hotel uses
can locate and develop in a mutually beneficial manner. It is the intent to have
several types of uses occupy each building located in this zoning district.
2
286
4. The subject site contains office, restaurants, parking and is consistent with the
intent of the zone and land use designation of the property.
5. The proposed restaurant use is permitted in the Urban Mixed Use South (MU-S)
zone, pursuant to ESMC § 15-5F-2(I).
6. Outdoor dining areas are permitted accessory uses in the Urban Mixed Use South
(MU-S) zone, pursuant to ESMC § 15-5F-3(A).
7. The proposed outdoor dining area expansion exceeds 20% of the total interior
dining area of the restaurant, and requires the approval of a Conditional Use
Permit, pursuant to ESMC § 15-5F-5(I).
8. The proposed expansion of alcohol service(sale of alcohol for on-site consumption
at a restaurant) to the additional outdoor dining area, requires an Administrative
Use Permit in accordance with ESMC § 15-5F-4C.
9. The proposed use is consistent with the purpose of the zone in that the building
contains a mix of uses and the ground floor of the building contains a restaurant.
Finding 3
The proposed location and use and the conditions under which the use would be
operated or maintained will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or
welfare, or materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity.
Facts in Support of Finding 3
1. Alcohol service is proposed at an existing restaurant which was previously
approved to operate with a Type 47 ABC License. Interior tenant improvements
are proposed which will modify the existing seating area for dining within the
restaurant and the outdoor dining area will be expanded by 609 square feet. The
restaurant will include 3,453 square feet of indoor dining area and 1,538 square
feet of outdoor dining area. The on-site consumption of alcohol is proposed for the
interior and the outdoor dining area of the restaurant. Minimal changes are
proposed to the landscaping facing Rosecrans and Continental Circle. Sufficient
parking will be provided on-site for the restaurant and the expansion of the outdoor
dining area in compliance with ESMC Chapter 15-15.
2. The surrounding land uses include: commercial offices, retail, restaurants with
outdoor dining, a financial institution, a private gym, and a hotel.
3. The proposed hours of operation to serve alcohol will be the same as the
restaurant from 11:00 am to 1:00 am, seven days a week. No live entertainment is
3
287
proposed. The proposed use is subject to certain conditions outlined in this
approval letter.
4. Because the location of the proposed restaurant is surrounded by commercial uses
with no residential uses adjacent to the site, the proposed on-site consumption of
alcohol will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare, or materially
injurious to properties or the immediate vicinity of the property.
Finding 4
Potential impacts that could be generated by the proposed use, such as noise,
smoke, dust, fumes, vibration, odors, traffic, and hazards have been recognized
and mitigated.
Facts in Support of Finding 4
1. The restaurant was previously-approved to serve beer, wine and distilled spirits for
onsite consumption. The proposed expansion of on-site sale and consumption of
alcohol will not create any new impacts that would not be normally associated with
the operation of a restaurant.
2. The proposed hours of operation and alcohol sales are limited to 11:00 am to 1:00
am, seven days a week. The applicant must comply with ESMC §§ 7-2-1, et seq.
regarding noise and vibration.
3. The proposed hours of operation and alcohol service for a restaurant within a
commercial district will help minimize impacts on surrounding uses.
4. In addition to complying with the requirements of the City of El Segundo and the
State of California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control the restaurant is
subject to County Health Department regulations that address and monitor impacts
of fumes and odors.
Finding 5
■ The State Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control has issued or will issue a
license to sell alcohol to the applicant.
Facts in Support of Finding 5
1. The applicant must obtain a license from the State of California Department of
Alcoholic Beverage Control for on-site sale and consumption of alcohol for
restaurants (Type 47).
SECTION 2: Environmental Assessment: After considering the above facts and findings,
the Director finds this project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the
4
288
California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to 14 California Code of
Regulations § 15301 as a Class 1 categorical exemption (Existing Facilities) and § 15303
as a Class 3 categorical exemption (New Construction or Conversion of Small
Structures). The project includes minor alterations to the interior of an existing building,
the expansion of an existing outdoor dining area, and the expansion of alcohol service for
a new restaurant tenant at the site.
1. The proposed project involves a negligible expansion of use since the restaurant
was previously approved to have alcohol service (sale of beer, wine and distilled
spirits for onsite consumption)for the existing interior and outdoor dining area.The
proposed expansion of alcohol service to the outdoor dining area that will be
increased in size by 609 square feet is negligible. The project is not anticipated to
have any significant impacts with regard to traffic, noise, air quality, or water
quality, and the proposed project will not result in any changes to the land use or
density.
DIRECTOR OF PLANNING AND BUILDING SAFETY DEPARTMENT ACTION
Based on these findings and facts in support of these findings, the Director of Planning
and Building Safety Department APPROVES the proposed project, subject to the
following conditions:
1. The City's approval of EA-1173, AUP 16-14 and CUP 16-06 supersedes the prior
approvals granted by EA-605 and AUP 02-03.
2. The hours of operation for the indoor and outdoor dining area of the restaurant,
including the sale of alcohol for on-site consumption is limited to 11:00 am to 1:00
am, seven days a week. A full service menu must be available during the hours
of operation for the indoor and outdoor dining area of the restaurant. Any change
to the hours of operation or the hours that alcohol may be served is subject to
review and approval by the Director of Planning and Building Safety.
3. The seating for the restaurant is limited to 3,453 square feet of indoor dining, and
2,147 square feet of outdoor dining. The restaurant will contain a combined total
5,600 square feet for dining with 266 seats.
4. Any subsequent modification to the floor plan and areas where alcohol will be
served and consumed must be referred to the Director of Planning and Building
Safety for approval and a determination regarding the need for Planning
Commission review of the proposed modification.
5. The applicant must obtain and maintain all licenses required by the Alcoholic
Beverage Control Act (Business & Professions Code §§ 23000 of seq.). The
applicant must obtain and maintain a Type 47 license.
5
289
6. The restaurant operations must comply with ESMC §§ 7-2-1, et seq. regulating
noise and vibration.
7. The Planning and Building Safety Department and the Police Department must be
notified of any change of ownership of the approved use in writing within 10 days
of the completion of the change of ownership. A change in project ownership may
be cause to schedule a hearing before the Planning Commission regarding the
status of the administrative use permit.
& The applicant must comply with all regulations of the Alcoholic Beverage Control
Act and the regulations promulgated by the Alcoholic Beverage Control Board
including, without limitation,the regulations set forth in 4 Cal. Code of Regs. §§ 55,
et seq.
9. There must be no exterior advertising of any kind or type, including advertising
directed to the exterior from within, promoting or indicating the availability of
specific alcoholic beverage products. Interior displays of alcoholic beverages
which are clearly visible to the exterior constitute a violation of this condition.
10. All employees serving alcoholic beverages to patrons must enroll in and complete
a certified training program approved by the State Department of Alcoholic
Beverages Control (ABC) for the responsible sales of alcohol. The training must
be offered to new employees on not less than a quarterly basis.
11. Any and all employees hired to sell alcoholic beverages must provide evidence
that they have either:
a. Completed training from the State of California Department of Alcoholic
Beverage Control (ABC), Lakewood District Office administered
Leadership and Education in Alcohol and Drugs (LEAD) Program in the
form of an ABC-issued certificate; or,
b. Completed an accepted equivalent by the ABC, Lakewood District Office
to ensure proper distribution of beer, wine and distilled spirits to adults
of legal age. If any prospective employee designated to sell alcoholic
beverages does not currently have such training, then;
c. The ABC-licensed proprietors must have confirmed with the Planning
and Building Safety Department within fifteen (15) days of the Director's
decision, or by final project approval, that a date certain has been
scheduled within the local ABC Office to complete the LEAD course.
d. Within thirty (30) days of taking said course, the employees, or
responsible employer must deliver each required certificate showing
completion to the Police Department.
6
290
12. The licensee must have readily identifiable personnel to monitor and control the
behavior of customers inside the building premises. Staff must monitor activity
outside in the parking lot and any adjacent property under the establishment's
control to ensure the areas are generally free of people.
13. If complaints are received regarding excessive noise, parking availability, lighting,
building access, and the like associated with the sale of beer, wine, and distilled
spirits for on-site consumption, the city may, in its discretion, take action to review
the Administrative Use Permit, including without limitation, adding conditions or
revoking the permit.
14. The building and any outdoor seating must comply with California Building and Fire
Code requirements, as adopted by the ESMC.
15. The Applicant and the Property Owners agree to indemnify and hold the City
harmless from and against any claim, action, damages, costs (including, without
limitation, attorney's fees), injuries, or liability, arising from the City's approval of
Environmental Assessment No. EA-1173 or Administrative Use Permit No. AUP
16-14. Should the City be named in any suit, or should any claim be brought
against it by suit or otherwise, whether the same be groundless or not, arising out
of the City approval of EA-1173 or AUP 16-14, the Applicant and the Property
Owners agree to defend the City (at the City's request and with counsel
satisfactory to the City) and will indemnify the City for any judgment rendered
against it or any sums paid out in settlement or otherwise. For purposes of this
section "the City" includes the City of El Segundo's elected officials, appointed
officials, officers, and employees.
7
291
PLANNING COMMISSION
This determination is scheduled to be received and filed by the Planning Commission at
its January 12, 2017 meeting. Please be advised that this does not conclude the review
process. The City Council will determine whether or not to protest the approval of the
alcohol license at its meeting on February 7, 2017.
Should you have any questions, please contact Assistant Planner Maria Baldenegro at
(310) 524-2341.
SinceYnt
CSamctor
Planning an d Building Safety
By signing this document, the applicant Christi Hing, and the property owner, Alex J.
Rose, certify that they read, understood, and agree to the Project Conditions listed in this
document.
Christi Hing, Secretary and CFO (Applicant)
Kona Sushi Inc., an Arizona Corporation
Alex J. Rose, Senior Vice President— Development (Property Owner)
Continental Atrium Corporation
s
292
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action to award a standard Public Works Contract to Cinbad
Industry Inc., in a form approved by the City Attorney, for construction of the Police
Department Kitchen Remodel, Project No. PW 17-07 (Fiscal Impact: $38,148.00)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public Works Contract in a form
approved by the City Attorney with Cinbad Industry Inc. in the amount of$34,680.00
and authorize an additional $3,468 for construction related contingencies.
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
None
FISCAL IMPACT: Included in Adopted Budget
Amount Budgeted: $300,000 for Various Police Department Upgrades
Additional Appropriation: No
Account Number(s): 301-400-8201-8708
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 4 Develop Quality Infrastructure and Technology
Objective: 1 City infrastructure is well maintained
Goal: 3 Develop as a Choice Employer & Workforce
Objective: 4 The City has an inspired, engaged workforce
ORIGINATED BY: Orlando Rodriguez, Senior Civil Engineer 42
REVIEWED BY: Ken Berkman, Interim Public Works Dire is y
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
The kitchen and break room in the Police Department has not been upgraded since it was
constructed in the 1950's. Given the poor condition of the existing floor tiles, kitchen cabinets,
fixtures and plumbing,the police kitchen remodel was identified as one of the top priorities among
various Police Department upgrades. In addition to this work, modifications will be made to
ensure the kitchen is in compliance with the latest Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
requirements. The modifications include installing the countertop and sink at the required ADA
heights.
20
0
293
The funding for the project was included in the adopted FY 2015-16 budget and was carried over
to the FY 2016-17 budget as part of the ongoing projects.
Prior to the project being advertised, staff hired an environmental consultant to conduct asbestos
and lead sample testing in various locations in the kitchen given the age of the facility. The results
of the sample testing have shown that a small sample of materials contain asbestos. Asbestos
abatement will be performed during the construction of the kitchen remodel.
On December 20, 2016, Council approved the complete set of plans and specifications for the
project and authorized staff to advertise the project for construction bids. On January 24, 2017,
the City Clerk received and opened 8 bids, as follows:
1. Cinbad Industry Inc. $34,680.00
2. Ayus & Co., Inc. $38,450.00
3. CTG Construction, Inc. $41,500.00
4. Corral Construction& Development Inc. $43,979.75
5. The Stone Collector $52,875.00
6. New Art Construction $54,200.00
7. R Dependable Const Inc. $58,765.00
8. CC Layne & Sons, Inc. $67,935.00
The lowest responsive and responsible bidder is Cinbad Industry Inc. Staff checked the
Contractor's references and license status and found that Cinbad Industry Inc. has satisfactorily
completed similar projects for other public agencies and its license is in good standing.
Therefore, staff respectfully recommends City Council authorize the City Manager to execute a
standard Public Works Contract in a form approved by the City Attorney with Cinbad Industry
Inc. in the amount of $34,680.00 and authorize an additional $3,468 for construction related
contingencies. The project is slated to commence in March and be completed in April 2017.
294
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA ITEM STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Receive and file an informational report on the Transient Occupancy Tax(T.O.T.)revenue to the City
and the impact of Measure B. (Fiscal Impact: $0)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Receive and file an informational report on the Transient Occupancy Tax (T.O.T.) revenue
to the City and the impact of Measure B.
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
None
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 5(b) Champion Economic Development and Fiscal Sustainability:
El Segundo approaches its work in a financially disciplined and
responsible way
Objective: 2 The City will maintain a stable, efficient, and transparent financial
environment
FISCAL IMPACT: $ (0)
Amount Budgeted: $0
Additional Appropriation: N/A
PREPARED BY: Joseph Lillio, Finance Director /
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
BACKGROUND & DISCUSSION:
On April 12,2016 a proposed change in the City of El Segundo's T.O.T.rate appeared on the ballot as
"Measure B."Measure B gave registered voters the opportunity to approve or disapprove a rate increase
in the T.O.T. from 8%to 12%. The Measure passed with a 71.8% approval from voters.
Measure B was expected to raise an additional$3,200,000 in annual revenue for El Segundo's General
Fund. The revenue comes from hotel visitors.
The T.O.T.revenue in FY 2013-14 was approximately$6.0 million. The T.O.T.revenue in FY 2014-15
was approximately$5.4 million. This decrease, compared to the prior year,was due to the remodeling
of the Hacienda Hotel. 21
295
The T.O.T. budget for FY 2015-16 was $6.1 million. The City ended up receiving $7.6 million
(unaudited)for FY 2015-16. The increase of unaudited actuals to budget was mainly due to passage of
Measure B that took effect as of June 1, 2016. The proposed T.O.T. budget for FY 2016-17 is $9.6
million. During the 1St quarter of the current year, we received approximately $1.8 million in T.O.T.
revenue.
The T.O.T. revenue received in October is for September activity (hotel stays). Following generally
accepted accounting principles, the revenue received in October is accrued back to September (prior
fiscal year). Therefore the$1.8 million for the 1St quarter of FY 2016-17 represents only two months of
revenue,which is in line with the total annual budget projection of$9.6 million.
T.O.T. Revenue
$10,000,000
$9,000,000
$8,000,000
$7,000,000
$6,000,000
$5,000,000
$4,000,000
$3,000,000
$2,000,000
$1,000,000
$0 r
FY 2013-14 FY 2014-15 FY 2015-16 FY 2015-16 FY 2016-17 FY 2016-17 1st
Adopted Budget Unaudited Budget Q.Actuals
T.O.T.Revenue
The full 1 St quarter financial report will be presented to Council on February 21.
296
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action to award a standard Public Works Contract to Corral
Construction & Development Inc., in a form approved by the City Attorney, for
construction of the Police Department Men's Locker Room Improvements, Project No.
PW 15-10. (Fiscal Impact: $64,898.00)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public Works Contract in a form
approved by the City Attorney with Corral Construction & Development Inc. in the
amount of$58,998.00 and authorize an additional $5,900.00 for construction related
contingencies,
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
None.
FISCAL IMPACT: Included in the adopted budget
Amount Budgeted: $300,000 for Various Police Department Upgrades
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): 301-400-8201-8708
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 4 Develop Quality Infrastructure and Technology
Objective: 1 City infrastructure is well maintained
Goal: 3 Develop as a Choice Employer& Workforce
Objective: 4 The City has an inspired, engaged workforce
ORIGINATED BY: Orlando Rodriguez, Senior Civil Engineer E(L
REVIEWED BY: Ken Berkman, Interim Public Works Directs
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager r,
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
The Men's Locker Room improvements were identified as one of the top priorities among various
Police Department. The funding for this project was included in the adopted FY 2015-16 budget
and was carried over to the FY 2016-17 budget as part of the ongoing projects.
22
297
On December 6, 2016, Council approved the complete set of plans and specifications for the
project and authorized staff to advertise the project for receipt of construction bids. On January 3,
2017, the City Clerk received and opened two (2) bids, as follows:
1. Corral Construction& Development Inc. $58,998.00
2. Cinbad Industry Inc. $59,950.00
The lowest responsive and responsible bidder is Corral Construction & Development Inc. Staff
checked the Contractor's license status and references, and found Corral Construction &
Development Inc. has satisfactorily met the City's requirements and has successfully completed
similar projects for other public agencies. Therefore, staff respectfully recommends that City
Council authorize the City Manager to execute a standard Public Works Contract in a form
approved by the City Attorney with Corral Construction & Development Inc. in the amount of
$58,998 and authorize an additional $5,900 for construction related contingencies.
Construction is slated to commence in March and be completed in May 2017.
298
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: Consent Agenda
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action authorizing the City Manager to execute an amendment to the
Professional Services Agreement with NCM Engineering Corp. for preliminary roadway and
railroad design work for the Park Place Extension Project. (Fiscal Impact: $0 to General Fund;
Reimbursement Grant up to $735,000 and Property Owner Deposit of$150,000)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Authorize the City Manager to execute an amendment to the Professional Services
Agreement with NCM Engineering Corp. in a form approved by the City Attorney in the
amount of $49,146.00;
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
NCM Engineering Corp. Scope of Services
FISCAL IMPACT: Included in Adopted Budget
Amount Budgeted: $0 [Reimbursement from Grant and Property Owner
Deposit]
Additional Appropriation:No
Account Number(s): 301-107-0000-0107
ORIGINATED BY: Ken Berkman, Interim Public Works Directorr?V
REVIEWED BY: Ken Berkman, Interim Public Works Director W
CA
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manage•
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
In 2008, the City secured a federal earmark of$750,000 to initiate design concepts and evaluate
the possible extension of Park Place between Nash Street and Sepulveda Blvd. On March 20,
2013 the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) approved the encumbrance and the
California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) issued a Notice to Proceed (E-76) for
preliminary design work for extending Park Place. Total available funds for the project include
the earmark ($750,000 less Caltrans' $15,000 administration fee) plus the 20% match
requirement ($150,000), for a total of$885,000. The match funds are being provided by Federal
Realty Investment Trust (Street Retail, Inc.) through a separate reimbursement agreement with
the City.
A Request for Proposals (RFP) for the preliminary roadway and railroad design work for the
Park Place Extension Project (Project) was released in Spring 2013; NCM was selected to
2:3
299
provide the preliminary design services, and has successfully provided those services in
advancement of the Project since that time.
In concert with the development of the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR), the initial
scope of work included:
1. Evaluating three preliminary design alternatives (one above grade crossing and two
below grade crossings;
2. Compiling data on the feasibility of each design alternative based on, among other things,
on the railroads' willingness to relocation (railroad alignment studies), topographical site
limitations, geotechnical considerations, structural feasibility, utility relocation, right-of-
way considerations, environmental considerations and cost.
3. Progressing through conceptual design and probably cost estimates for the one preferred
alternative. The conceptual design will include:
a. Initial site assessment
b. Roadway plans
c. Traffic and signal lighting plans
d. Rail plans
e. Grading plans
f. Drainage plans
g. Utility relocation plans
h. Structural plans
i. Right of way requirements
Since the award of the contract, there have been two (2) amendments. The first one was
procedural in nature to include Federal Contact Requirements, the second was to extend the
agreement to September 30, 2015. No other terms and conditions were revised.
This third agreement will extend the agreement to February 28, 2018 and provide an additional
$49,146.00 to allow NCM to continue working on the Project in concert with the (D)EIR phase,
providing critical right-of-way analysis and coordination with the railroads and utilities, and
ultimately draft Memorandums of Understanding with those key stakeholders, as well as
ensuring a smooth transition into the design phase.
300
Park Place Extension Project M
Engineering& Design Services
SCOPE OF SERVICES PM SUPPORT
✓ Protection or potential relocation of utilities
PROJECT MANAGEMENT SUPPORT DURING within railroad right of way under railroad
ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENT PHASE license agreements
✓ Fundamental construction sequencing
1.0 Review Existing Documents/Info ✓ Maintenance Access
The NCM team will review any additional documents,
reports,and studies prepared during the environmental Obtaining pertinent information from the
phase. railroad to develop design documents
✓ Project schedule
✓ Environmental reports prepared by Michael
Baker Task 1.1 Deliverables:
Task L 0 Deliverables:
✓ Meeting Attendance and Minutes as applicable
✓ Existing Document Review Summary ✓ Draft MOUs(3)
Memorandum ✓ Draft C&M Agreement
1.1 Railroad Coordination 1.2 Utility Relocation Coordination
Coordinate with the Union Pacific Railroad(UPRR), Coordinate with Plains All American,West Basin
BNSF Railway Company(BNSF)and Chevron through Municipal Water District and ExxonMobil through the
the environmental phase with the goal of obtaining environmental phase with the goal of obtaining
consensus on the plan of action for each of the consensus on the plan of action for each of the
alternatives under consideration. Begin the coordination alternatives under consideration for environmental
process of the C&M Agreement with the UPRR and clearance. Prepare MOU for the each agency with the
BNSF. For UPRR,BNSF and Chevron prepare City as a road map for final design once a preferred
Memorandum of Understanding(MOU)for the City as a alternative is selected. The team will utilize the support
road map for final design once a preferred alternative is of William Johns of Utility Coordinating Inc. for our
selected. Coordination with the CPUC will not begin utility coordination efforts. The key items to coordinate
until the project is in the final design stage. The CPUC with the utility companies include:
Application for an Order to Construct cannot be
submitted until after an environmental document has ✓ Existing Utility Operations and impacts to
been certified and the project design is at a stage where Utility Companies during construction
the project is well defined—typically 65%design Task 1.2 Deliverables:
complete. ✓ Meeting Minutes Attendance and as applicable
The team will utilize the support of Larry Long of ✓ Draft MOUs(3)
Wilson and Company for our railroad coordination
efforts. The key items to coordinate with the railroads
1.3 Right of Way Coordination
include:
Based on the alternatives being evaluated for the
✓ Existing Rail Operations and impacts to Rail environmental phase,develop a comparative strategy for
Operations during construction R/W acquisition for alternatives under consideration
✓ Potential impacts to Rail served customers under the environmental phase.
✓ Temporary and permanent horizontal and Task 1.3 Deliverables:
vertical clearances proposed from the existing ✓ Preliminary Project Right of Way Strategy
tracks
✓ Bridge overhead clearance
✓ Changes in drainage
301
Exhibit— Page 1
NCM Enqineerinq Coma.
COST PROPOSAL
Project: Park Place Extension Project Management Support
Client: City of El Segundo Consultant: NCM Engineering Corp
350 Main Street 22362 Gilberto
Suite 125
El Segundo, CA 90245 Rancho Santa Margarita, CA 92688
ATTN: Lifan Xu, PE ATTN: William Nascimento, PE, SE
City Engineer
Project No. OHL_1301
Element: Project Management Support Prepared by: WN
Date: January 3, 2017
Proposed Services:
Provide On Call Project Management Support to City Engineer to coordinate with the railroads,Chevron,
utility companies,and analyze right of way acquistion to assist in advancing the project
William Nascimento and Mark Gonzalez(the PSR PM and PE)of NCM shall primarily lead coodination on behalf
of the City with support by other NCM staff and subconsultants as appropriate.
OH Multiplier for Design Build Proposal: 273%
Manhour Estimate: Man Direct Billing Labor
Hours Rate Rate Cost
1 Project Manager 36 95.00 259.16 9,330
2 Senior Project/Bridge Engineer 100 75.00 204.60 20,460
3 Project/Bridge Engineer 65.00 177.32
4 Design Engineer 53.00 144.58
5 Assistant Engineer 42.00 114.58
6 QC 85.00 231.88
7 Senior CAD Operator 48.00 130.94
8 CAD Operator 41.00 111.85
9 Clerical/Administrative 30.00 81.84
Total Cost+Fee 136 $29,790 (A)
Other Direct Costs:
Other Direct Costs (Billed at actual cost with receipts)
1 Reproduction
2 Copying $480
3 Plotting
4 Transportation/Travel $1,327
5 Special Deliveries $50
6 Computer
7 Subconsultants $17,500
Subtotal- ODC $19,357 (B)
Total Proposed Fee
Total Amount $49,146 (C)=(A+B)
302
Exhibit_ Page 2
NCM Engineering Corp.
COST PROPOSAL
Project: Park Place Extension Project Management Support
Client: City of El Segundo Date: January 3,2017
Element: Project Management Support Proj:OHL_1301
Labor Hours by Classif catior
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Total Subtotal
PM Sr. PE PE DE Asst QC Sr.CAD CAD Clr Subs Hours
W O N W W W 'r N
(D M iD UD W W W co
D) O f� V O .
W) O 1+ (7 (2 _ W
N N N
(A (A fA 69 f9 to K)
TASKSJSUBTASKS
f
Enciineerinci Services
1 Coordination 36 100 -� 136 $29.790
2
3 — —�
4
5
6 T
�-
7
—T..
9
Total 36 100 136 $29,789.76
303
Exhibit— Page 4
NCM Engineering Corp.
COST PROPOSAL
Project: Park Place Extension Project Management Support
Client: City of El Segundo Date: January 3, 201
Element: Project Management Support Proj: OHL_1301
Ref# Descri tion Unit Amount Cost/Unit Total
1 Reproduction/Plotting
Number of Drawings(Half Size) Ea
Size of Drawings(Half Size) 1 5 Sq Ft
Size of Drawirgp(Full Size) 6 Sq Ft
Bluelines(Full Size) Sets Sq Ft 0.15 /Sq Ft
Xerox(Full Size) Sets Sq Ft 0.50 /Sq Ft
Sepia transparency(Full Size) Sets Sq Ft 080 /Sq Ft
Contact Mylars(Full Size) Sets Sq Ft 1 90 /Sq Ft
Vellums(Full Size) Sets Sq Ft 0.95 /Sq Ft
Subtotal(1)
2 Copying/Binding
Reports 20 Ea 200 Sheets 0.12 /Sheet 480
Calculations Ea Sheets 0.12 /Sheet
Specifications Ea Sheets 0.12 /Sheet
Half Size Drawings Sets Sheets 0.45 /Sheet
Binding(Reports) Ea Tot 2.5 Ea
Subtotal(2) $480.00
3 lotting
Plotting(Half Size) Sets Sheets 5.75 /Sheet
Plotting(Full Size) Sets Sheets 6.50 /Sheet
J
Subtotal (3)
4 Transportation/Travel
Flight Persons Trips EA 418 EA/Round Ti
Rental Car 1 Day(s) EA Trip 5 Trips Total 45 EA Day 225
Hotel/Per Diem Days 150 EA Day
Personal Car(Mileage) 120 Miles Round Trip 17 Trip 0.540 $/mile 1,102
J Subtotal(4) $1,326.60
5 Special Deliveries
Express Mail 2 Deliveries 1 Ea 25 $/EA 50
Special Delivery Ea Ea 55
J Subtotal(5) $50.00
6 Computer Costs
Engineering Design Hr 8
CAD Hr 24
] Subtotal (6)
7 Subconsultants
Wilson&Co LS 7,500
Overland Pacific LS 5,000
Utility Coordinating, Inc. LS 5,000
1 bliototal{Sub ) $17,500
Total(1 through 6) $19,356.60
304
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: New Business
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action to adopt a resolution to implement the honorary memorialization
of Lairport Street as Carl Jacobson Drive. (Fiscal Impact: None)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Adopt the attached Resolution implementing the honorary memorialization of Lairport Street
as "Carl Jacobson Drive" effective April 3, 2017; and/or,
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
1. Resolution
2. Map
FISCAL IMPACT: None
Amount Budgeted: $0
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): N/A
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 4 Develop Quality Infrastructure and Environment
Objective: 1 City infrastructure is well maintained
ORIGINATED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
REVIEWED BY: Ken Berkman, Director of Public Works
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager IQ
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
At the City Council meeting on January 24, 2017, Mayor Fuentes requested an agenda item to
consider the dedication of Lairport Street as "Carl Jacobson Drive" in honor of the significant
contributions made by the former El Segundo Councilmember and Mayor. This action will
provide a lasting tribute to Mr. Jacobson,who served on City Council with dedication and integrity
from 1984 to 2016, including two terms as Mayor from 1988-1996 and 2012-2013.
The street is especially appropriate because it is home to the Automobile Driving Museum where
Mr. Jacobson shares his time, leadership and passion for historic automobiles.
4
305
ADiDlicable Code and Policy
Streets and Highways Code (SHC) Section 5026 provides that City Council may, by resolution,
change the name of any street located within the City. The recommended street dedication and
street name modification is the type of action covered by SHC Section 5026.
The City's current Facilities Naming Policy does not specifically apply to street names.
Accordingly,if it so decides with the adoption of the attached Resolution,the Council may directly
take action to dedicate Lairport Street as "Carl Jacobsen Street" in his honor.
This street is approximately 1,100 feet in length, and is fronted by 10 properties from Mariposa to
Maple Avenues. In order to minimize any impact on residents and business, the name Lairport
Street will also be retained; businesses will not need to change stationary or other items bearing a
Lairport Street address, although they may do so should they desire. Additionally, the U.S. Postal
Service will recognize both street names and no notice of change of address will be required to be
filed with the Postal Service.
Street signs along the affected portion will bear the new name as well as the honorary name to
minimize any confusion on the part of drivers. The cost of the new signs is estimated to be
approximately $2,000 and can be provided within the existing Public Works Repairs and
Maintenance Budget.
306
RESOLUTION NO:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF EL
SEGUNDO DEDICATING LAIRPORT STREET AS CARL JACOBSON
DRIVE
The City Council of the City of El Segundo does resolve as follows:
SECTION 1 The City Council finds and declares that:
A Carl Jacobson was elected to the City Council in 1984 and served with dedication
and integrity through 2016, including two terms as Mayor from 1988 to 1996 and
2012 to 2013;
B During Carl Jacobsen's service to the City of El Segundo, he diligently and
passionately represented the City's interests, including leading the City through
both prosperous and difficult times; always looking out for the best interests of the
City's residents and businesses; maintaining the City's financial stability; being
actively involved in monitoring activities at the Los Angeles International Airport
and working diligently to limit their impacts on the City;
C Carl Jacobson's accomplishments and service to the City of El Segundo and the
region warrant significant and lasting tribute; and,
D The Streets and Highways Code Section 5026 provides that the City Council
may, by resolution, change the name of any street located in the City of El
Segundo.
SECTION 2 The Council of the City of El Segundo, California hereby resolves
that the street currently named Lairport Street is hereby dedicated as "Carl Jacobson
Drive" in his honor.
SECTION 3 The City Clerk is directed to certify the adoption of this Resolution, record
this Resolution in the book of the City's original resolutions, file a certified copy of this
Resolution with the Board of Supervisors and the County Surveyor of the County of Los
Angeles, and make a minute of the adoption of the Resolution in the City Council's
records and the minutes of this meeting.
-1
307
SECTION 4 This Resolution will become effective April 3, 2017 and will remain unless
repealed or superseded.
PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED this 7th day of February 2017.
Suzanne Fuentes, Mayor
ATTEST:
Tracy Weaver, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Mark D. Hensley, City Attorney
-2
308
CERTIFICATION
STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ) SS
CITY OF EL SEGUNDO )
I, Tracy Weaver, City Clerk of the City of El Segundo, California, do hereby certify that the whole
number of members of the City Council of said City is five; that the foregoing Resolution No.
was duly passed, approved and adopted by said City Council at a regular meeting held on the 7th
day of February, 2017, approved and signed by the Mayor, and attested to by the City Clerk, by the
following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
WITNESS MY HAND THE OFFICIAL SEAL OF SAID CITY this 24th day of January, 2017.
Tracy Weaver, City Clerk
of the City of El Segundo,
California
-3
309
1 L-j' OAl9 NOUVIAV I I I L
ui
3d
L
I �
N IL z
cn
a pod ile
�+ _ tlnl�y0nznd�s _
� ti C�C m �C
J
PCCC 0 o C
upoil C; _
E:
I -;LS Z33Sk3� �� •� L
CL
LHEEI
C iB
C B LE
P7 M=4=4 O
OC1S NIVW ��Is
L
IF� ma HED
d IBB y
B LL
0
6
l 7 r5..
O N
310
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7,2017
AGENDA ITEM STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: New Business
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Receive and file an informational report on the fiscal impact to the City from the change to the
CalPERS discount rate. (Fiscal Impact: $0 for FY 2016-17)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Receive and file information regarding the reduction to the CalPERS discount rate and the
resulting fiscal impact to the City.
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
None
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 5(b) Champion Economic Development and Fiscal Sustainability:
El Segundo approaches its work in a financially disciplined and
responsible way
Objective: 2 The City will maintain a stable, efficient, and transparent financial
environment
FISCAL IMPACT: $ (0)
Amount Budgeted: $0
Additional Appropriation: N/A
PREPARED BY: Joseph Lillio, Finance Director
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
BACKGROUND & DISCUSSION:
At the December 21, 2016, CalPERS Board (the "Board") meeting, it was approved by the Board to
lower the CalPERS discount rate assumption. The discount rate, or long-term rate of return, was
adjusted from 7.5%to 7.0%. This adjustment will be phased in over a three year period. The result of
this Board action is an increase of public agency employee contribution costs beginning in Fiscal Year
(FY) 2018-19.
The phase-in of the discount rate change approved by the Board for the next three years is as follows:
Valuation Date FY for Required Contribution Discount Rate
June 30, 2016 2018-19 7.375%
June 30, 2017 2019-20 7.25%
June 30, 2018 2020-21 7.00%
:;�15
Lowering the discount rate means the City's plan will see an increase in both the normal cost(the cost
of pension benefits accruing in one year for active members)and the accrued liabilities(the future cost
of pension benefits). These increases to the normal cost and accrued liabilities will result in higher
required employer contributions beginning in FY 2018-19.
The increase in costs to the City are detailed by fiscal year in Table 1. The increase costs are identified
by Public Safety and Miscellaneous groups. As detailed in Table 1, the impacts of the discount rate
change will be an annual increase to the Public Safety Group of $2.5 million by FY 2022-23 and
$980,000 to the Misc. Group. Currently,there are 238 active full-time equivalents(FTEs). The Public
Safety Group has 95 FTEs and the Misc. Group has 143 FTEs.However,the numbers in Table assume
all budgeted positions will be filled at a total of 274 FTEs.
Table 1: Annual increase to the City's Ca1PERS pension contributions
Fiscal Impact of the CaIPERS Discount Rate Change to the City by Fiscal Year
FY 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23
Public Safety $0 $0 $293,773 $630,191 $1,506,984 $1,993,955 $2,515,549
Misc.Staff $0 $0 $121,869 $262,670 $613,454 $789,788 $979,207
Total $0 $0 $415,642 $892,860 $2,120,438 $2,783,743 $3,494,756
In the current fiscal year, the City is budgeted to pay about $10.6 million in employer contributions.
Using the new discount rate of 7.0%, it is anticipated the City will pay $19.4 million in employer
contributions by FY 2022-23.This is an increase of$3.5 million compared to keeping the discount rate
unchanged. The below graph(graph 1) depicts the total annual employer contributions by the City to
the Ca1PERS pension plan before the discount rate change and after implementation of the rate change.
This is a drastic change from the current year projected$10.6 million compared to the adjusted amount
of$19.4 million by FY 2022-23.
As displayed in the above table and the below graph, the City will begin to experience additional
pension contributions from the discount rate change beginning in FY 2018-19.
312
Graph 1: Total annual Ca1PERS pension contributions by the City
$25,000,000
$20,000,000
V)
Or
$15,000,000
�i
0
i° $10,000,000
rmf
n
$5,000,000
V
$0
2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23
7.5%Discount Rate $10,596,497 $11,269,657 $12,422,183 $13,642,946 $14,379,473 $15,227,620 $15,929,139
°7.004 Discount Rate $10,596,497 $11,269,657 $12,837,825 $14,535,806 $16,499,911 $18,011,363 $19,423,895
Per a Ca1PERS news release on January 19, "the benefits of reducing the discount rate include:
Strengthening long-term sustainability of the fund
Y Reducing negative cash flows; additional contributions will help to offset the cost to pay
pensions
Reducing the long-term probability of funded ratios falling below undesirable levels
• Improving the likelihood of Ca1PERS investments earning our assumed rate of return
• Reducing the risk of contribution increases in the future from volatile investment markets".
In April 2013, the Ca1PERS Board approved new amortization and smoothing policies that were
aimed at returning the System to fully funded status within 30 years. The current reduction of the
discount rate more accurately reflects the average Ca1PERS portfolio returns and achieves the
Board's policy goal of 100% funded (fully funded) by the year 2043. Fully funded is a pension plan
that has sufficient assets needed to provide for all accrued (future) benefits. A fully funded pension
plan is one that has the financial stability to make current and future benefits payments to pensioners.
The plan depends on returns on its investments to achieve stability.
During the last two years, June 30, 2016 and 2015, the portfolio returns have been 0.8% and 2.4%.
Currently,the City's Public Safety pension is funded at 65.7%and the Miscellaneous group is funded at
75%.
The Ca1PERS Board is contemplating further changes that may be required to further mitigate risks.
Additional steps that could be taken to further mitigate funding risks include:
• Margins for conservatism: This could be accomplished by either further lowering the
discount rate or by changing other actuarial assumptions to include additional conservatism.
313
• Systematic De-risking: This would involve changing the asset allocation gradually over time
to lower investment risk and reduce the funding risks outlined in the report.
• Flexible De-risking: This would involve changing the asset allocation but only when good
investment returns permit this to occur without increasing employer rates beyond their
expected levels.
• Multiple Asset Allocation Choices: This would involve providing employers with the ability
to choose from a range of asset allocations (e.g. high,medium and low risk). This option has
been requested by a number of employers.
• Risk Sharing Options: While the Board does not have the ability to change the benefit
structure or member contribution rates, the level of risk could be reduced by either benefit
design or various forms of employee/employer cost sharing. This would require legislative
changes.
The total Ca1PERS portfolio for all participants is$307.2 billion as of January 27,2017.This is funded
through contributions from employers,contributions from employees,and investment earnings.Graph 2
breaks down the percentage of the funding sources.
Graph 2 - CalPERS Pension Funding Sources
13%
❑ Investment
earnings
® CaIPERS
Employers
62% ❑ CaIPERS
Members
Conclusion
The City will need to address these forthcoming pension increases during the FY 2017-18 strategic
planning and budget study sessions. In order for the City to proactively address this issue, remain
fiscally sustainable, and financially prudent, it is likely that any effective plan will require a multi-
faceted approach that combines a number of different elements: reviewing reserve levels to offset
increases of financial uncertainty, discussion of revenue enhancements, expenditure reductions, and
policy discussions involving solutions to mitigate the City's liability.
314
EL SEGUNDO CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 7, 2017
AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA HEADING: New Business
AGENDA DESCRIPTION:
Consideration and possible action to direct staff to carry out the necessary actions to change the
name of Sepulveda Blvd. to Pacific Coast Highway in the City of El Segundo.
(Fiscal Impact: None)
RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION:
1. Direct staff to carry out the necessary actions to change the name of Sepulveda Blvd.to Pacific
Coast Highway in the City of El Segundo;
2. Alternatively, discuss and take other possible action related to this item.
ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
April 13, 2015 letter to the Mayor of Manhattan Beach from the Mayor of El Segundo
FISCAL IMPACT: None
Amount Budgeted: $0
Additional Appropriation: N/A
Account Number(s): N/A
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Goal: 4 Develop Quality Infrastructure and Environment
Objective: 1 City infrastructure is well maintained
ORIGINATED BY: Ken Berkman, Interim Director of Public Works 1-4�
REVIEWED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manager
APPROVED BY: Greg Carpenter, City Manage
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:
In the fall of 2013, staff was directed to investigate what would be required by the California
Department of Transportation(Caltrans)in order to change the name of Sepulveda Blvd.to Pacific
Coast Highway. Caltrans first confirmed that changing the street name is feasible since Sepulveda
Blvd. is already officially designated as Highway 1 (i.e.,Pacific Coast Highway)by the California
State Legislature, the governing body that oversees naming of the State's highway system.
Caltrans also indicated that the City would need to take several preliminary steps, including
conducting outreach to and receiving support from a majority of affected property/business owners
(due to the name/address change), approving the request for a name change through a City Council
formal action(e.g.,resolution of support) and submitting a formal request to Caltrans. The agency
also indicated that submitting a request in concert with Manhattan Beach would be desirable for
consistency purposes.
6
315
Staff presented an overview of the qualifying criteria at a joint City Council/Economic
Development Advisory Committee (EDAC) meeting held on October 23, 2013. At that meeting
staff was directed to bring the item back to the full City Council for consideration and direction.
On November 19, 2013 staff was given direction to proceed with a preliminary survey to gage
support among businesses and property owners along the Sepulveda corridor and to reach out to
Manhattan Beach to determine whether it is interested participating with El Segundo in a joint
application to Caltrans. In the spring of 2014, staff sent out 509 survey mailers to businesses and
property owners, and set up a Survey Monkey website for respondents to utilize in lieu of returning
the surveys. Staff also hosted a community workshop on May 6, 2014, whereupon only three
organizations attended. In all, 86 survey responses were received, representing a 17% response
rate. Their responses are listed in the following table:
Blvd.Sepulveda
SLrc n9ky Somewhat No on amp-hat Strongly
ft rev ofisagree Agme g<r
Survey Monkey 6 1 0 2 9
Survey Card 30 2 12 3 21
Total'(86) 36 3 12 5 30
Response 42% 3% 14% 6% 35%
Among the respondents, four were property owners, 73 were business owners, five were property
managers and four declined to state their category.
Survey information was presented to the joint City Council/EDAC Committee in the summer of
2014, but no formal action was taken or recommendation given at that time; however, this
information was brought to Council again on March 3, 2015. At that meeting, staff presented the
possible next steps, including:
1. Expanding survey efforts to ensure that a majority of property owners are reached and
support the name change, as required by Caltrans. Detailed outreach to achieve a high
response rate will require additional support beyond the City resources currently available.
2. Working with the post office to gather specific information about the lead time needed for
implementation.
3. Submitting a formal request to Caltrans with a resolution of support adopted by City
Council.
4. Establishing an implementation schedule and conducting detailed outreach to business
owners about the pending name change.
5. Coordinating signage installation.
At that time, staff estimated that process to take approximately 12-18 months to complete given
the lead time businesses were expected to need to ensure that costs and impacts to them are
minimized. The post office allows for up to 18 months of transition time when street names are
changed, which will help businesses minimize costs in planning for the transition. According to
the Minutes, the Council directed staff to reach out to the city of Manhattan Beach to understand
their opinion on the possible name change and bring the item back. Attached is the only follow
up action found in Public Works files—a letter from Mayor Fuentes to Mayor Powell of Manhattan
Beach.
316
Office of the Mayor
April 13,2015
Elected Metals:
Suzann ROMM
arrr .oa Wayne Powell,Mayor
�PM r� City of Manhattan Beach
Dam Canm#Nembar 1400 Highland Ave.
NWft
or. Manhattan Beach,CA 90266
cowrcaAfomber
rrwyWo*�vr, Re: Renaming Sepulveda Blvd.to Pacific Coast$ighway
cry crrx
crier.ska*r,
CAY rF*JWU °' Dear Mayor Powell,
Appointed Officials: I hope 2015 finds you well. E1 Segundo reached out to Manhattan Beach just over one year ago regarding
C-V c.wwwar, your City's interest in formally redesignating the southern segment of Sepulveda Blvd.as Pacific Coast
UN*a+ r Highway(PCH). As you know,Sepulveda Blvd."shares"its designation with Pacific Coast Highway
cxynaorrr r from LAX southward through Manhattan Beach until it reaches Hermosa Beach, where the street is
recognized as PCH again.
Depart`Aent Directors: CalTrans indicated the name change is possible because,starting at LAX,Sepulveda Blvd.is already
n.00nh cry designated as Highway 1 (i.e,Pacific Coast Hwy)by the California State Legislature. In order to request
KeWrrSnft the name change, El Segundo was directed to take several preliminary steps, including 1)conducting
motwofkIft outreach to and receiving support from the majority of affected property owners who will be affected by
o e m&V"iO/C' this change,2)approving the name change request through a City Council formal action(e.g.,resolution
SW c� sd� of support)and 3)submitting a formal request to Caltrans for processing. The agency also indicated,
although not required,submitting a partnership request with Manhattan Beach is desirable for consistency
~r.,.r; purposes because Hermosa Beach and Redondo Beach already designated their street segments as Pacific
SAWbeffib r'Os0'KO—uUm Coast Highway.
Pu6b wcxra
RWMSMM A P.rr. El Segundo's City Council has not voted to approve the highway's name change.
El Segundo and CalTrans both recognize having a Sepulveda Blvd.`island"in the middle ofa continuous
PCH segment is not ideal and could be confusing to locals and visitors. As we consider aname change,it
wrwiw.elseaunda.arq is important for El Segundo to understand the level of interest from Manhattan Beach.
Please let us know if there is anything we can do or provide to Manhattan Beach that will assist with your
consideration of this matter. We look forward to hearing from you.
Sr
y
Suzann h�rentes,Mayor
City of El Segundo
cc: Mark Danaj,City Manager
350 Maki Sbee4 El Segundo, Callibmia 90245-3813
Phone(310)524.2302 FAX(310)322-7137
317
