2006-06-22 PC MinutesMINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING
OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION
OF THE CITY OF EL SEGUNDO, CALIFORNIA
JUNE 22, 2006
Chairman Kretzmer called the regular meeting of the El Segundo CALL TO ORDER
Planning Commission to order at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber of
the City of El Segundo City Hall, 350 Main Street, El Segundo,
California.
Director Jurjis led the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
PRESENT: FELLHAUER, KRETZMER, ROTOLO, WAGNER
ABSENT: FRICK
Chairman Kretzmer presented the Consent Calendar.
None.
Commissioner Wagner moved, seconded by Commissioner Fellhauer,
to approve the June 8, 2006, Minutes as submitted. Motion passed 4-0.
None.
PLEDGE TO FLAG
ROLL CALL
CONSENT
CALENDAR
CALL ITEMS
FROM CONSENT
CALENDAR
MOTION
PUBLIC
COMMUNICATIONS
Director Jurjis explained that the Commission had been provided WRITTEN
amended Municipal Code Section pages for Item H-2, replacement COMMUNICATIONS
Page Nos. 7, 10 and 13.
Chairman Kretzmer presented Item H-2, Environmental Assessment No. PUBLIC HEARINGS,
715 and Zone Text Amendment No. (ZTA) 06-6. Address: Citywide. NEW BUSINESS,
Applicant: City of El Segundo. Property Owner: Various. EA NO. 715 and
ZTA NO. 06-6
Planning Manager Christensen presented the staff report and the
recommendation to adopt Resolution No. 2603, recommending that the A ZTA to amend El
City Council adopt the proposed Zone Text Amendment. Segundo Municipal
Code Chapter 15-18
Planning Manager Christensen noted for Commissioner Wagner that the regulating the time,
high school marquee LED sign is not regulated under this code because place, and manner
it is located on school property; and she explained that these new that signs are
provisions would establish regulations for any future LED signage. erected and
El Segundo Planning Commission Minutes
June 22, 2006
Page 1 of 4
Commissioner Wagner stated that the proposed changeable copy every constructed within
15 minutes is too long, suggesting that every 15 seconds would be more the City's
appropriate. jurisdiction.
Commissioner Rotolo asked for additional input on the proposal for
allowing temporary directional real estate signs.
Assistant City Attorney Berger explained that the proposed real estate
sign section brings the code into conformance with state law; and noted
that directional signage placed on private property would need the
owner's consent.
Commissioner Wagner expressed his belief that monument signs should
be much lower than the proposed 25-foot high, suggesting a maximum
height of 6 to 8 feet for monument signs.
Chairman Kretzmer noted his desire for signs to be consistent with the
zones wherein these businesses are located, suggesting that additional
language would be appropriate to indicate specific zones have their own
standards for signage.
Planning Manager Christensen advised that the Downtown Specific Plan
has its own standards for signage, which is extremely restrictive when
compared to other zones in the City.
Assistant City Attorney Berger explained that If there is a conflict
between a specific plan and the municipal code, the specific plan would
apply to a specific zone, that the specific plans or development
agreement would regulate the signs in those areas.
Chairman Kretzmer noted his opposition to allowing monument signage
that is any higher than it is wide, suggesting additional verbiage may be
appropriate to limit signage proportion.
Addressing the Commission's concern to limit the size of monument
signs, Director Jurjis suggested amending the ground/monument sign
definition to limit the height to 6 feet, with a base not to exceed 6 feet.
Assistant City Attorney Berger advised that the proposed Section 15-18-
8-D would need to be amended to reflect that change.
Chairman Kretzmer concurred with Commissioner Wagner's comment
regarding the proposed 15-minute limitation on the changeable copy.
It was the consensus of the Commission that 15-minute changeable
El Segundo Planning Commission Minutes
June 22, 2006
Page 2 of 4
copy is excessive, that it should be closer to every 15 seconds.
Chairman Kretzmer questioned if the City has research data to support
staffs assertion that animated signs can affect traffic patterns, produce
light nuisances and affect the public health and safety.
Planning Manager Christensen advised that staff did not conduct any
studies, but noted that a lot of traffic safety analysis has been done on
these matters.
Chairman Kretzmer expressed his belief that when these blanket type
statements are made, staff should cite some research reference to
support their claims.
Assistant City Attorney Berger stated that the footnote to his comment is
this is a legislative determination, which can be different with each city;
and noted it can be supported if challenged.
Planning Manager Christensen stated in response to an inquiry from
Commissioner Fellhauer that the LED section has specific language that
addresses orientation of these signs away from residential properties.
Chairman Kretzmer opened the public hearing. There being no input,
Chairman Kretzmer closed the public hearing.
Commissioner Wagner moved, seconded by Commissioner Fellhauer, MOTION
to concur with staff's recommendation; moved that changeable copy be
permitted every 15 seconds; that the monument signs be no more than
6 feet high; and moved to adopt Resolution No. 2603. Passed 4-0.
None.
Director Jurjis announced that he has taken a job in the private sector
and noted his pleasure in working with this Commission.
None.
None.
The Planning Commissioners commended Director Jurjis for his hard
work and wished him well in his future endeavors.
PUBLIC HEARINGS
CONTINUED
BUSINESS
REPORT FROM
DIRECTOR
PUBLIC
COMMUNICATIONS
OTHER BUSINESS
PLANNING
COMMISSIONERS'
COMMENTS
El Segundo Planning Commission Minutes
June 22, 2006
Page 3 of 4
Chairman Kretzmer wished everyone a safe and fun 4t" of JUly
celebration.
The meeting adjourned at 8:11 p.m.
PASSED AND APPROVED ON THIS 27th DAY OF U Y, 20
eimone Jurjis, Secretary of Mi e K etzmer,r,alifornia
rman of
the Planning Commission the Pla ning Cosion
and Director of Planning and City of El Segun
Building Safety
El Segundo Planning Commission Minutes
June 22, 2006
Page 4 of 4
ADJOURNMENT